29 Sep 2000, 16:45 UTC
Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: As Power Prices Rise, Businesses In Ore. Seek to Delay ...
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Fri, 29 Sep 2000 09:45:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Miyung Buster/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on 09/29/2000 04:44 PM ----- djcustomclips@djinteractive.com 09/27/2000 02:17 AM Please respond to nobody To: 86464@WCTOPICS.djnr.com cc: Subject: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: As Power Prices Rise, Businesses In Ore. Seek to Delay ... The Wall Street Journal THE WALL STREET JOURNAL / NORTHWEST As Power Prices Rise, Businesses In Ore. Seek to Delay Deregulation By Rob Eure ? 09/27/2000 The Wall Street Journal (Copyright (c) 2000, Dow Jones&Company, Inc.) A year ago, Oregon's big businesses encouraged the state Legislature to deregulate the electricity market. Now the corporate lobby is working with state regulators to effectively put the law on hold. When the businesses asked for deregulation, they thought it would save them money: If the market was opened to competition, they reasoned, they could use their high demand as a bargaining chip and get better rates on power. But electricity prices skyrocketed this summer, and now businesses face the prospect of buying power that's much pricier than historical norms. So, some big commercial consumers have asked the state Public Utilities Commission for help. The PUC, which is writing the rules implementing the law, says it is considering modifying the rules to allow companies to keep buying power at essentially the old, regulated rates until market prices come down. "We still favor deregulation, but we need a smooth transition," says Ken Cannon, executive director of Industrial Customers of Northwest Utilities, a Portland-based trade group. Indeed, executives with major companies predict doom if the law -- ordering the biggest users of electricity to shop on the open market for power, giving up their access to regulated rates -- is put into action. "If deregulation is instituted next October, it will devastate commerce and industry in Oregon," says Dan Williamson, an energy consultant for Portland-based Pope&Talbot Inc., a pulp and lumber company that is a member of the Industrial Customers of Northwest Utilities, a Portland-based trade group of 40 large industrial-power users that lobbied heavily for the deregulation. The PUC's rule proposal wouldn't change the date of deregulation; it would still go into service on Oct. 1, 2001, and mandate that major power consumers -- essentially, the bulk of Oregon's businesses -- buy on the open market. Small companies and residential customers will be able to continue to buy power from their current, regulated suppliers. Instead, the proposal would work this way: The big power users affected by the law would enter into contracts of varying length -- six months, a quarter or a year -- with their current, regulated providers. The users would pay higher rates tied to free-market prices, but then -- through a complicated accounting process -- the providers would give them credits that would, effectively, bring the rates down to the current regulated rates. When the contracts were up, the users could either jump into the free market or renew their contracts with regulated providers, if market rates were still too high. In theory, that "should leave our rates at about the same level, if we do it right," says Julie Brandis, a lobbyist with the Salem-based Associated Oregon Industries, the state's largest business lobby with 18,000 members. Ms. Brandis says she expects that most businesses in the state will back the stopgap plan and remain with their incumbent utilities next October. She says AOI still believes "deregulation is the right way to go, but the higher prices are a concern. We think we need a bridge of some sort for the short term." Randy Dahlgren, director of pricing for Portland General Electric, a unit of Houston-based Enron Corp. and Oregon's largest utility with 730,000 customers, says the utility understands the need for the stopgap measure. "We're working on a [pricing plan] now that should be similar to the regulated rate," he says. Regulators have asked the state's private utilities to submit their proposals by next month, and Mr. Dahlgren says that's just in time. "We need to start planning for our power purchases as soon as possible," he says. Deregulation seemed a fine idea to many until earlier this year, when wholesale prices spiked to $200 a megawatt in June from $25 a megawatt in April. Now, commercial customers say that, as they talk to suppliers about buying electricity starting in October 2001, they're being told prices will be in the neighborhood of $60 a megawatt -- 140% more than they're paying now under the fixed-rate, regulated contracts they have with providers overseen by the Oregon PUC. "That's more than most businesses can afford to pay," says Mr. Williamson of Pope&Talbot. Deregulation proponents in the Legislature say they recognize power users are in a tough spot, but aren't sure deferring the inevitable is the right course, as any delay in creating a fully open power market in Oregon, where marketers vie to sell electricity, will delay the kind of competition that could ultimately bring prices down. "The idea was that by sending the large users into the market, they would create demand and that would cultivate the market," says Senate Majority Leader Gene Derfler, a Salem Republican and the major architect of the deregulation law. "The sooner we get to that point, the sooner I think we have the economic incentives in place to develop more power generation" to reduce the rates. Still, Sen. Derfler says he would prefer delay of a few months over legislation that would change the law's effective date. "I certainly hope that we can leave the deregulation bill alone in the coming session," he says. More than just the law's timing is coming under pressure. The Building Owners and Management Association of Portland, whose members own or operate 500,000 square feet of commercial property in the city, recently asked the PUC to exempt some smaller users of electricity who fear they aren't big enough to wield sufficient buying power in the open market. Under the law, any commercial consumer that uses more than 30 kilowatts in any given hour must quit buying from its regulated provider and go shopping; the association wants the cutoff to be 500 kilowatts. Ann Fisher, a Portland lawyer for the association, says that the summer price spikes proved "there is a big risk to deregulation. If the people who want to jump in to deregulation are wrong, we are going to be in a world of hurt." PUC Commissioner Roger Hamilton says raising the threshold might leave so few industries shopping for power that it would thwart the creation of a competitive market. But he adds that the commission will consider the request. Mr. Cannon of the industry group thinks the delay is a reasonable step, but he doesn't think it really delays the state's deregulation. "It's worth remembering that if the market for electricity goes up and stays there, sooner or later, we will all be paying a higher price, with or without deregulation," he says. Folder Name: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 99 ______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClipsor contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.comor by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones &Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved