13 Jun 2001, 16:58 UTC
GS and gas/power documentation
- From
- Ruth Ainslie @ENRON rainslie@isda.org
- Date
- Wed, 13 Jun 2001 09:58:41 -0700 (PDT)
These are (Unedited) notes from the following (lengthy) telephone call: **************************************************************************** ***************************************************************** James and Bernadette of Goldman just called to ask where we are specifically on gas (more difficult) and power (way ahead) documentation in Europe. They think now is the right time for ISDA to address this issue. Many counterparts are still only in physical markets. They feel strongly that there is much groundwork to be done and clearly to be done now. Financial institutions are not dealing with "trading" arm or mindset, BP, Shell, etc. European regs will not be completed until 2005. Although there's momentum for changing the documentation now, the traditional players (many of whom are NOT ISDA members) are "locked into" terms. James/Bernadette's idea is to meet now with Katia/John/Richard T and Rita of RWE and start talking now. They emphasize starting from the energy markets, not the financial markets so the market players are NOT turned off. The market players extrapolate from their physical days - (according to GS, many may get a carve out from FSA for capital requirements so there is no real need for netting agreements). Further there is skepticism about the terms of dealing in financial markets (and physical terms are where trading often takes place). James points put the GTMA is less netting than in the iSDA and there is a large and troubling acceptance issue for ISDA-style documentation. Bernadette points out certain provisions are too burdensome, such as the Confidentiality Provisions. Bernadette mentions EFA's questionnaire. Both James/Bernadette are hopeful that the fix is in the bridge. The energy companies want a physical contract (e.g. GMTA) but will do financials under ISDA They say fixing the bridge is the first step toward a one-size-fits-all ISDA-type master and some are already amenable. This avoids fighting every battle in every market. They see a 3-4 year period perhaps before there's buy-in on the importance of netting. Also very significant: Bernadette suggests that ISDA spend time with key players in physical markets (BP), whether or not they are members and educate. **************************************************************************** ***************************************************************** Katia, could you call James (7774-0022) or Bernadette (7774-1691) re this and offer several time slots. They believe Rita's involvement is critical as well and of course the appropriate lawyers representing ISDA. Mark and Stacy, we should add include this topic to the NA Energy call we are planning. Regards, Ruth