7 Nov 2000, 13:12 UTC
CPUC Transmission OII
- From
- Daniel Douglass douglass@arterhadden.com
- To
- barbara_klemstine@apsc.com, bob_anderson@apses.com, dcazalet@apx.com, billr@calpine.com, jackp@calpine.com, glwaas@calpx.com, ken_czarnecki@calpx.com, Carolyn A Baker, rjhickok@duke-energy.com, GTBL@dynegy.com, kewh@dynegy.com, rpelote@energy.twc.com
- Date
- Tue, 7 Nov 2000 05:12:00 -0800 (PST)
The CPUC has commenced, "an investigation of the state's transmission and electric generation system reliability pursuant to AB 970."? The OII will also look into, "utility acquisition of new peaking generation reosurces for Summer 2001 and beyond."? The OII notes that the state currently has a, "mismatch between supply and demand statewide and in specific geographic areas."? An appendix to the OII lists various system upgrades which may require improvements.? The investigation, "will examine the most cost-effective ways of easing transmission constraints and associated generation shortfalls, both in the short term and the longer term." ? The OII notes the ISO's RFP for 2,00 MW of peaking capacity, complains that the terms of such deals are to be kept confidential until the contracts are signed, and concludes that,?"contract terms that offer project proponents market prices plus full capacity costs appear exorbitant, especially if, as we understand, the ISO's contracts do not commit the power to be available to serve the state's interests."? The OII challenges ISO's authority, "to plan, solicit and pay for construction of new power plants across the state, absent some substantial involvement of agencies that represent the state's interests."? In other words, as noted in an article?from today's Electricity Daily (excerpted below), we now have a "turf war" between the CPUC and ISO. ? The Commission has classified the investigation as a ratesetting proceeding and ordered the three?utilities to file a cost/benefit analysis on new transmission upgrades as well as their own ability to build new peaking generation for next summer. Their responses are due Nov. 22.? ISO and other interested parties have until December 20 to files analyses and comments on the utilities' November 22 filings.? WPTF should discuss this new OII at its meeting on the 14th to decide if it wishes to become involved.? Please let me know if you want a copy of the OII.? ? Dan ? The following is excerpted from the 11/7 issue of Electricity Daily: ? Turf War Breaks Out Between CPUC and ISO "In opening an investigation last week into California's transmission system reliability, the California Public Utilities Commission has started a turf war with the California Independent System Operator. Until now, Cal-ISO had the unquestioned authority to keep the lights on, but the CPUC now asks, "At what price?" and questions whether Cal-ISO has siting authority for a slew of transmission upgrades to be built by utilities to hasten more power into the state's strained system. The CPUC has authority over utilities, but Cal-ISO is the agency that is approving transmission upgrades to be built by utilities and complementary new generation to be built by market forces to hook into that transmission. Although the CPUC has not stepped fully into the new generation siting process -- so far, a procedure that has been up to Cal-ISO and the California Energy Commission -- it does use the transmission inquisition as a foundation to question both transmission and generation projects."