26 Jun 2000, 14:58 UTC
CERA Western Markets July Forecast
- From
- Lorna Brennan lorna.brennan@enron.com
- To
- Steven Harris, Jeffery Fawcett, Lorraine Lindberg, Kevin Hyatt, Christine Stokes, TK Lohman, Michelle Lokay, Lindy Donoho, Lee Huber, Susan M Scott, eileen.peebles@enron.com, Vernon Mercaldo
- Date
- Mon, 26 Jun 2000 07:58:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Lorna Brennan/ET&S/Enron on 06/26/2000 02:53 PM --------------------------- webmaster@cera.com on 06/23/2000 10:27:33 PM To: Lorna.Brennan@enron.com cc: Subject: New Peaks, New Prices - CERA Alert ********************************************************************** CERA Alert: Sent Fri, June 23, 2000 ********************************************************************** Title: New Peaks, New Prices Author: Zenker, Moritzburke, Snyder E-Mail Category: Alert Product Line: Western Energy , URL: http://www.cera.com/cfm/track/eprofile.cfm?u=5526&m=1247 , In the West, July typically marks the start of the summer cooling season, which, along with waning hydroelectric energy production and the more frequent use of gas-fired generators to meet demand, causes steadily rising power prices. CERA expects the West to be the only region in North America with a year-over-year increase in peak electricity demand. Power prices already established new record highs in June, suggesting that as demand reaches its peak during the coming summer months western power markets will continue to experience increased volatility compared with last year's levels. The convergence of natural gas prices that are much higher than last year's levels, growing demand for power, and reduced hydroelectric energy production when compared with levels in 1999 is pushing up western power prices. Merchant and other gas-fired generators will be pressed into service, experiencing their strongest utilization rates since the drought year of 1994. Greater utilization of gas-fired generators within the West has supported western differentials and contributed to high gas prices throughout North America. Western gas prices should continue to be strong, boosted by continuing increases in regional gas demand for power generation and pressure across North America to inject gas into storage in anticipation of summer power loads. The main drivers of higher power and gas prices when compared with year-earlier levels will be * Peak WSCC load season. Summer weather will drive loads to the year's coincident peak, which is most likely to occur during the July/August period but could arrive any time during the June through October air-conditioning season. CERA expects demand growth of 3.1 percent in the third quarter compared with levels in 1999, which will push Western Systems Coordinating Council (WSCC) coincident peak demand levels to 2.7 percent over 1999 levels. * Waning hydroelectric output. Hydroelectric production is on its normal downward seasonal slide. This resource decline is more visible when compared with the 1999 hydro season, which was both abundant and prolonged. * High utilization rates for gas-fired generators. Growing demand for electricity, coupled with a declining availability of hydroelectric energy, will drive utilization rates of gas-fired power plants to their highest levels since the drought year of 1994. * Higher fuel prices. Western gas prices have remained at $1.00-$1.50 per MMBtu above 1999 levels. Growing year-over-year gas demand for power generation is providing much of the price pressure in western markets. These higher gas prices provide a boost to both on-peak and off-peak power prices of between $10 and $15 per megawatt-hour (MWh). Regional Power Market Drivers Power markets in the West are poised to break records for demand, peak load, and gas-fired plant utilization and, as a result, power prices. A return to normal summer weather coupled with growing demand for power will push demand for electricity up by 5,274 gigawatt-hours (GWh) in the US West for the third quarter compared with 1999 levels, or almost 2,400 megawatts (MW) on average (see Table 1). This growth in the demand for electricity will also drive peak loads to new highs. CERA expects the 1999 WSCC coincident peak to be exceeded by 2.7 percent, climbing to nearly 119,000 MW. As was demonstrated by the mild summer of 1999, deviations from normal weather could boost or thwart this peak demand growth figure. Two key factors will significantly reduce third quarter hydroelectric production levels compared with 1999 levels. * First, CERA expects West-wide total season hydroelectric production in 2000 of roughly 100 percent of historical average levels, substantially lower than the approximately 120 percent of average in 1999. * Second, runoff was prolonged in 1999, serving to push a substantial portion of the hydroelectric production into the summer period (see Figure 1). On average, CERA expects these factors will remove 9,187 GWh, or almost 4,200 average megawatts (aMW), from the western resource base compared with 1999 levels. Exacerbating this decline, refilling of reservoirs and flow restrictions to assist fish migration will cause periodic but significant curtailments in power production at key Pacific Northwest hydroelectric facilities. Natural gas-fired facilities will be called upon to supply most of the expected increase in demand, while also replacing hydroelectric resources as they continue to decline. This will push average annual utilization rates of gas-fired combined cycle, steam, and cogeneration plants to approximately 38 percent in 2000--levels not experienced since the 41 percent annual average utilization rate in 1994, a year marked by drought and warmer-than-normal summer weather. Utilization rates for these facilities will also surge past 1999 levels, especially this summer. CERA anticipates a West-wide third quarter utilization rate of 59 percent for these facilities under normal summer weather conditions, compared with 46 percent for the same period of 1999. This level of utilization will certainly establish gas-fired generation as the floor to power prices during the third quarter, during not only the on-peak demand period but the off-peak as well. With natural gas prices at $1.00-$1.50 per MMBtu higher than 1999 levels, power prices are boosted by $10-$15 per MWh owing to fuel price increases alone. With supply tightness already evident in western power markets, the stage is set for increased price volatility compared with 1999 levels as episodes of hot weather require increased utilization of less-efficient generators throughout this summer. Pacific Northwest The water supply forecast for the Columbia River remains near average but has dropped a couple percentage points from last month. Flows are expected to remain at roughly 96 percent of average through September on the Lower Columbia and 103 percent of average on the Upper Columbia. Conditions overall are still sufficient to be considered average. This return to normal conditions in the Pacific Northwest should produce hydroelectric output nearly 2,700 GWh (18 percent) lower than last year for July and 8,405 GWh lower for the third quarter as a whole (see Table 2). The region's load growth coupled with lower hydro supply will continue to elevate power prices in the Pacific Northwest relative to 1999 levels. Tighter supply conditions in California and the Southwest will attract energy exports from the Pacific Northwest, preserving a differential between the Pacific Northwest and California of about $1 per MWh on average. Price differentials between the Pacific Northwest and California have varied dramatically recently, with the north at times rising above those to the south owing to local demand and hydroelectric constraints caused by reservoir filling operations. Since the end of May, volatility in both markets has pushed the difference between daily on-peak prices at COB and those in California from a premium of $120 per MWh to a discount of $55 per MWh within a few days. CERA expects that over the long run, California markets will clear at a premium as the summer progresses, but the differential will vary widely, with episodes of Pacific Northwest power pricing at a premium to those in California. California Despite below-average precipitation and snowpack this year, California reservoir storage levels throughout the state are higher than normal, ranging between 108 and 166 percent of average for the state's primary runoff regions. Under these conditions hydroelectric output should be roughly 4 percent (363 GWh) below last year's levels for the third quarter (see Table 2). With a return to normal weather conditions relative to third quarter 1999, cooling demand this summer will increase most in California, where weather was nearly 30 percent cooler than average last year. Recent day-ahead power prices in California have drawn attention to the West as the highest-cost market (if only temporarily) in North America. Record high temperatures and unscheduled unit outages produced new day-ahead price records, with power prices on June 15 at $457 per MWh in the day-ahead on-peak market and real-time hourly prices at the market cap of $750 per MWh. Increased utilization of gas-fired generation and daily gas prices of around $5 per MMBtu (burner-tip in Southern California) have kept daily average off-peak prices between $40 and $80 per MWh. Notably, these higher price have occurred during periods when roughly 1,800 MW more coal-fire generation was available in the West compared with the same period in 1999. CERA expects prices to continue to respond to the tight capacity environment this summer. Rockies and Southwest During summer 1999, the Rockies/Southwest was the only region to experience above-average cooling demand, suggesting that normal weather should bring only moderate demand growth of less than 1 percent (see Table 3). However, growing energy demand in neighboring regions and a large transmission transfer capability will pull energy from the Rockies/Southwest region when excess capacity is available, ensuring that prices in the region will remain tightly connected to price levels in other parts of the West. Palo Verde prices have generally kept pace with other western markets, while maintaining their characteristic premium to the California Power Exchange during spring and early summer. CERA expects Southwest prices to strengthen relative to California when summer weather periodically shifts the locus of demand to the Southwest. However, California prices will maintain a premium on average to those in the Southwest, as the effects of the state's tight supply situation translates to higher prices than those in either the Southwest or Pacific Northwest. Regional Gas Market Drivers Under continuing pressure to inject gas into storage in the face of declining supply and increasing gas demand for power generation, gas prices at the Henry Hub are expected to average $4.45 per MMBtu in July. The strong demand for gas for power generation will keep differentials strong in the southern half of the West. In the Rockies, pipeline constraints will keep differentials wide. The heightened call on gas demand for power generation, driven by the declining hydroelectric generation and increasing power loads, is expected to drive demand increases of 1.6 Bcf per day relative to July 1999 and 660 MMcf per day relative to June 2000 demand levels. Gas demand for power generation is expected to reach a monthly average record level of 4.9 Bcf per day in July (see Tables 4 and 5). These increases will result in declines in western storage injection rates and in exports from the West. Both Permian and San Juan supplies will be pulled increasingly toward the West Coast during July. Low storage inventories and needed increases in injections are driving North American gas pricing. The West is the one US region actually running a storage surplus, but the recent heat waves and associated pull on gas supplies have eroded that surplus, particularly in California (see Table 6). Given the expected increases in gas demand, the western surplus should continue its decline. This decline and very high demand will reinforce the volatility in differentials already evident this summer. California Because of the early hot weather in the West and strong gas demand for power generation, Topock prices have been extremely high and volatile. So far this month, Topock has averaged over $0.30 per MMBtu above the Henry Hub. Flows on El Paso and Transwestern into California increased by over 300 million cubic feet (MMcf) per day during June relative to May averages, and flows are expected to continue to climb by an additional 400 MMcf per day during July. PGT continues to run near capacity (see Table 7). At the same time, the storage levels within California look likely to fall below last year's levels sometime during the month. This intense demand pressure--California demand should increase by nearly 500 MMcf per day in July relative to June--will keep utilization rates on import pipelines high and sustain Topock differentials. CERA expects the Topock to Henry Hub differential to average $0.30 per MMBtu during July (see Table 8). This high differential will likely persist through the summer, with differentials rising above $0.50 per MMBtu during West Coast heat waves. Southwest San Juan price differentials have been volatile, narrowing during periods of very high western demand. However, a very high utilization rate on pipeline capacity into California has widened the Topock-San Juan differential, and that wide gap is expected to persist. On average, San Juan differentials to the Henry Hub are expected to narrow from current levels as southwestern demand increases with western temperatures. Demand in the Southwest is expected to climb from 1.4 Bcf per day in June to 1.5 Bcf per day in July. This increased call on regional supplies and an expected strengthening in Permian prices should result in an average San Juan differential to the Henry Hub of $0.18 per MMBtu. In the Permian Basin, prices are expected to strengthen as Texas power demand climbs. Combined with the pull on supplies from the West, Permian differentials should narrow from their current levels of $0.20 per MMBtu to below $0.10 per MMBtu. Pacific Northwest Strong June hydroelectric output has limited the call on gas supplies in the Pacific Northwest so far this summer, but as hydroelectric output decreases in June and July, gas demand will increase dramatically. CERA expects an increase of nearly 200 MMcf per day during July relative to June levels. The limited demand so far has meant differentials between Malin and the Henry Hub of as much as $0.30 per MMBtu and Topock to Malin differentials of over $0.60 per MMBtu. The Malin to Henry Hub differential has narrowed slightly to around $0.20 per MMBtu. It should continue to strengthen with growth in regional demand and average $0.00 per MMBtu during July. Rocky Mountains Regional gas supply within the Rocky Mountains continues to increase, bolstered by continuing growth in the Powder River Basin. This April, exports out of the Rockies reached 3.2 Bcf per day, a record high. Although there is excess pipeline capacity out of the region into the Southwest on the Transcolorado and Northwest pipelines, high utilization rates have widened Rockies differentials with the rest of the West. In particular, Rockies to San Juan differentials have averaged nearly $0.25 per MMBtu for June after pricing close to parity earlier in the year. That gap should persist through the summer, as gas-fired generation climbs across the rest of the West. Demand is expected to average the same level in July as in June in the Rocky Mountains, where coal limits gas's gains in power generation. CERA expects prices within the Rockies to gather some support from increasing power loads in the Pacific Northwest, as well as from stronger differentials in the San Juan Basin. On average, Rockies differentials to the Henry Hub are expected to average $0.52 per MMBtu during July. In response to the increasing supplies flowing out of the Powder River Basin and the increasing pipeline capacity utilization on export pipelines, Trailblazer has announced an open season for two possible options to extend and expand the 500 mile pipeline from Wyoming into Nebraska. Although timing and volumes have yet to be announced, the additional capacity could prevent serious bottlenecks from developing out of the region, which CERA would expect by 2002 without capacity additions. **end** Follow URL for PDF version of this Monthly Briefing with associated graphic and tables. Please note: Should the above URL not work, please use the following: http://www.cera.com/client/ce/alt/062300_17/ce_alt_062300_17_ab.html ********************************************************************** Account Changes To edit your personal account information, including your e-mail address, etc. go to: http://eprofile.cera.com/cfm/edit/account.cfm This electronic message and attachments, if any, contain information from Cambridge Energy Research Associates, Inc. (CERA) which is confidential and may be privileged. Unauthorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this message or any attachments, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited. Terms of Use: http://www.cera.com/tos.html Questions/Comments: webmaster@cera.com Copyright 2000. Cambridge Energy Research Associates