3 May 2001, 12:50 UTC
Attachment to Curricular Review Task Force Report 3
- From
- Deborah K. Davis dkdavis@monm.edu
- Cc
- raj@monm.edu, don@monm.edu, george@monm.edu, jackiec@monm.edu, marybeth@monm.edu, rgiese@monm.edu (Dick and Sandy Giese)@ENRON, Valentine, Richard" @ENRON
- Bcc
- raj@monm.edu, don@monm.edu, george@monm.edu, jackiec@monm.edu, marybeth@monm.edu, rgiese@monm.edu (Dick and Sandy Giese)@ENRON, Valentine, Richard" @ENRON
- Date
- Thu, 3 May 2001 05:50:00 -0700 (PDT)
A Summary of the Written Comments from our Members and A Couple of Faculty Members General Education Structure: The four-year program with its existing rubric-scheme seems to make sense, as long as it is an integrated, coherent and distinctive program. The relation between the general education and majors needs to be examined and an authoritative body should be charged with the responsibility of continuously reviewing all programs and the curriculum. There is a suggestion that Sophomore and Junior level Seminars should be introduced. According to our catalog (p. 16), the requirements of a Monmouth College degree involves: 1. Four years of academic work earning at least 124 semester hours. 2. Completion of Freshman Seminar 3. Completion of a major program, and 4. Completion of the five components of the general education program: Language, The Physical Universe and its Life Forms, Beauty and Meaning in the Works of Art, Human Societies, and Issues and Ideas. One comment is that the present rubric scheme is woefully inadequate to the understanding of the Self for which we need to address metaphysical issues, epistemological questions, and issues of God, spirit and man. Freshman Seminar Monmouth College introduced this course in the early eighties and several schools have added similar courses to their curriculum in subsequent years. There seems to be a strong commitment among the faculty and administration to continue to develop and teach this course. The following are some of the comments and suggestions: 1. It is very resource intensive, is trying to do too many things in one semester, and is quite regimented in its organization and delivery. Instructors need some flexibility after establishment of clear, limited and common goals for the course. 2. We should commit more resources to this venture and a greater proportion of senior faculty should teach this course. 3. More stipends and/or release times are needed for the faculty to continue the development of this course and to provide shadowing experience to new faculty members who are interested in teaching it. Language This component generally makes sense - keep, strengthen and change it. There is a suggestion to reduce the foreign language requirement and to introduce more courses on foreign cultures and traditions. There is an almost universal agreement that our graduates need more experience in writing, in its several forms, composition, creative writing, technical writing etc. We think our task force needs to examine carefully (possibly with a consultant) the concept of Awriting across the curriculum@ and find ways of incorporating it in our academic program. There is also a suggestion that we should require composition courses at the Junior and Senior levels. Beauty and Meaning in the Works of Art This component seems to work well. There is a call for a wider range of choice of courses in this rubric. Perhaps, we should consider some courses on aesthetics. Physical Universe and its Life Forms This component also seems to be working well. The assessment of this rubric last semester did not call for any radical changes. The Assessment Committee is satisfied with the goals, concept and delivery of this component. Some questions were raised on the understanding of the scientific method by our students. Scientific literacy is very important in this technological age. Do students understand the relation between science and technology? There is a call for courses on History or Philosophy of Science and Science & Society offered by HT folks. Human Societies There is much dissatisfaction with the menu of courses offered beyond Comparative Societies. This smorgasbord of courses can be replaced by a slate of 5 to 7 courses, with multiple sections, which address spirituality in different ways. Another suggestion is to limit this menu to a set of Introduction to Social Sciences courses and to make Comparative Societies value-based. It should be noted that our assessment program indicates that our fifth purpose of exploring Athe spiritual dimension of human existence and the relationship between faith and knowledge@ is not being addressed by our academic curriculum. Issues and Ideas This course is supposed to provide the culminating experience in our general education program. It seems to be working well. Can we develop some common goals for the 15 to 20 courses offered under this rubric? Should we go back to the two-course Systems of Thought and Belief mode? Majors We should plan to review all the current majors. We should strive to provide a state of the art emphasis in most majors (eg. Molecular Biology, Computational Dimension in Natural Sciences, Media Concentration, Public Relations, Sports Management etc.) According to AAC&U, there is a Amuddle in the middle@ in most major programs. Is there coherence and integration within the disciplines? How do the majors relate to the general education? We are expected to make recommendations for adding, modifying, and eliminating course offerings and programs. May be, when more majors become attractive and cutting edge, they will stem the tide towards Business and Education! Further Suggestions 1. There is wide support for introducing a Quantitative Reasoning requirement in our curriculum. There is a relevant article in our red folder. We may have to look at Abest practices@ in peer institutions and work with a regional consultant to see how this can be implemented. 2. How do we educate our students to make value-based decisions in this fast-changing and complex world? Many schools have introduced Ethical Inquiry/Moral Reasoning requirement in their curriculum. There are two relevant articles in our red folder. Again, we may want to look at Abest practices@ in peer institutions or work with a regional consultant to see how this can be implemented. 3. We need to introduce course requirements under the broad category of Internationalization, Globalization and Cultural Diversity in our curriculum. 4. Do we need to develop courses that explicitly deal with Modes of Inquiry, Critical Thinking, Logical Reasoning, Problem Solving etc.? Other General Considerations Related to Curricular Review 1. The six questions Dean Arnold has raised on the articulation of our curricular goals, understanding the needs of our students and the world they are entering into and the allocation of resources. 2. The implications of the Teagle grant - Adoing nothing is not a viable option@ and if we come up with strong initiatives, management support may be forthcoming. 3. Simplify the process for curricular initiatives, streamline the budget process and review our style of management. 4. There is no ongoing support for Instruction Technology and our current policies and procedures continue to frustrate folks, especially some of our newer faculty. 5. Our semester schedule is anathema to aims of a serious, liberal arts education: the semester system breeds fragmentation, superficiality, freneticism, hyperactivity and resentment. 5. We need to continue to address the work load issue.