1 Dec 2000, 02:20 UTC
WPTF Friday Life is Just One Beefy Burrito
- From
- Gary Ackerman foothill@lmi.net
- Date
- Thu, 30 Nov 2000 18:20:00 -0800 (PST)
? THE FRIDAY BURRITO "42.7 percent of all statistics are made up on the spot." We're back.? We're live.? We're living.? Actually, we are still in limbo land.? As of yet, no prez elect.? The week was typical by California standards.? The utilities filed their plans to raise rates over the next five years, the consumer advocates held a press conference to kick off their holy war against electric restructuring, a class action suit was filed for $4 billion against the generators and the utilities, gas prices hovered between $18 and $20/mmcf on day trading, the Secretary of Energy spat on FERC regarding the remedies proposed to fix the alleged dysfunctional California market, and the Governor announced his options for curing what ails us.? I think that pretty well covers it.? It was just another week in paradise. I was on KRON TV last week for a couple of 10-second sound bites.? Chomp, chomp.? That is what was distilled from fifty minutes of taping.? It was a learning experience for me, more so than it was for the general viewing public.? The station did an investigative report on California's restructured power industry, and the slant was fairly predictable, although it could have been far worse.? Two moms on my son's hockey team told me they saw the clips on TV, and I used these ladies as my unbiased (?) sample to gather some opinions.? There are about twenty families on my son's team, so that means (using testimonial math) that about ten percent of the Bay Area watched the news piece.? One mom said she saw me, really didn't listen to what the news was covering, but that she recognized me. I'm sure that her experience, less the recognition, applies easily to half or more of the viewing public. The second mom, who I have known for many years, asked me, "So, who is doing the gouging?"? This from a person who is well educated, very involved with the community, and is part of a routine family (he says) of husband, wife, three kids, and a dog. Alas, I realized, the battle for California's power market will not rest nor be resolved in chaotic meetings at the ISO or AB1890 working groups.? The war will be won or lost based on public opinion.? Will Californians support the continuation of electric restructuring?? I don't know if they will, but I am not at all surprised that the vast majority of people do not understand the issues.? As an industry, we have a long, long way to go in educating the public.? And I have tremendous doubt that we are going to cough up the necessary money to publicly demonstrate a positive image on power restructuring.? Nancy Day wrote me last week; "You and your associates must 'prove' to the policy-makers and the public that, in the long run, competitive markets are always better than command and control regulation.? How do you do that?? You hire a PR firm ( and you get them to help you shape your messages to a variety of audiences." Shape a message.? I know that some of you folks think you are doing that now.? I disagree.? Individually or collectively we have not made even a small dent in the public image for our cause.? There is some name recognition, to be sure. The paid TV ads for Enron, and Southern have made those company names more familiar.? Green Mountain Energy has done a good job of getting its name out, too.? But that is hardly the point.? As an industry of private interests, we are kaput on the PR side. Imagine this.? Imagine Joe Montana, four-time Superbowl wining quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers standing next to the Lombardi Trophy, talking into the camera.? He smiles, and says, "Hi. I'm Joe Montana.? I believe in competition."? A few side clips, some simple explanations how competition is going to more quickly bring prices into line with expectations, and back to Joe.? We can also do some follow on ads with Jerry Rice, and Jim Plunket (two-time Superbowl QB for the Oakland Raiders), thereby making a connection with different factions of California's ethnic and racial makeup.? That is what I call PR.? Touching the soul of the public with simple messages from credible, well-known, likeable people. I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts. Here is what is on this week's leftover turkey menu Things in the People's Republic of California ?@@@ Oh when the comments, come marching in( ?@@@ ISO Super Peak Market books first transaction ?@@@ Consumers Rattle the Saber for a Ballot Initiative ?@@@ All Injured Parties form a line to the left( ?@@@ The Governor's Plan Odds & Ends (_!_) ? ? Things in the People's Republic of California ?@@@ Oh when the comments, come marching in ( My mailman is becoming increasingly ticked off at me because the tonnage of FERC comments coming to my address weighing four, or five pounds per delivery.? He's a mailman, not a pediatrician.? He is leaving small hints of his displeasure, such as dropping my mail in the middle of the driveway, or delivering the goodies to my neighbor's house.? Most of the copies received, I confess, go into the trash bin without a second thought. I don't even break the gummy seal on most.? I check the sender's name, and decide if the fortune inside the envelope might be worth a read.? I always open the envelopes from the CPUC, the Electric Oversight Board, and Steptoe & Johnson (SCE's counsel for really important filings).? These filings are the most entertaining of the lot. The holiday weekend gave me some time to read a selection of comments submitted to FERC regarding the Commission's November 1 Order. I don't know whether I should laugh or cry at some of these pleadings.? The comments I read from some of my favorite sectors of California's power industry are so childish that I wonder if it is a joke.? Or is the joke on us?? Take for example, the CPUC's comments.? The first 52 pages are more or less what you would expect:? refund our money, change this hearing from a paper hearing to a full-blown evidentiary hearing, request a rehearing, the CPUC should get copies of everything the MSC and DMA publish at the same time FERC gets them, FERC got the soft price-cap issues and just about everything else wrong, the State has jurisdiction, etc.? The CPUC claims that there is insufficient evidence to support the FERC's conclusions. Since the CPUC also lacks sufficient evidence (because the generators and power marketers will not comply with the CPUC's data requests), then, well, what the heck, we need a lengthy hearing with evidence and cross-examination of witnesses.? This line of reasoning sounds very much like the Florida vote recount litigation, but I don't want to go there. Here is the real kicker.? If you go to page 52 of the CPUC's comments, there is the signature block of the CPUC attorneys, dated November 21.? The next page begins with the "Separate Statement of Commissioners Duque, Neeper, and Bilas".? I did a double take on the title, not understanding, at first, that the first 52 pages were never adopted by the CPUC by vote.? Our politically hypercorrect couple, Ms. Lynch and Mr. Wood forced it in. What do the three Republican Commissioners say?? "We find much to support in FERC's Market Order, and are filing this statement to insure that FERC has access to our full thinking concerning the technical aspects of the wholesale market, which are not the principal focus of the Commission's filing."? I remain astounded that, in essence, the CPUC has two replies.? One that lambastes the FERC Order, and another that encourages the Order with some modifications.? For example, the evil part of the CPUC commentary shakes a finger at FERC for ordering elimination of the requirement for the UDCs to buy all power through the PX.? That, says the attorneys, is a violation of jurisdiction, and you federal people should stay off of our lawn. The trio of? Duque, Neeper, and Bilas (DNB) say, "While the state maintains jurisdiction, we are willing to cede to FERC temporary jurisdiction over this matter."? Which of the two responses sounds more cooperative to you?? I wonder (he asks) why the CPUC comments never came to a vote?? Sounds to me like the CPUC comments a la DNB would have passed 3-2, quite nicely, thank you.? But those days are long gone. The CPUC expert witness testimony appended to the CPUC comments includes the direct testimony of Michael Scheible, a supervisor of the California Air Resources Board staff responsible for energy issues including electricity.? This is a person who was part of the development of the RECLAIM program of tradable emission credits utilized in the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD).? Here is what Mr. Scheible testifies.? "The average price paid for a NOx RTC went from $1 a pound in January 2000, to $4 in June, to $20 in October 2000."? What is he talking about?? He took the year-to-date expenditures on NOx credits, and divided the total by the number of traded RECLAIM Trading Credits (RTC).? He used the average value, not the marginal or incremental price!? NOx credits are today trading in the $40 to $50 per pound range. But he doesn't stop there.? He takes another leap at the impact of the RTC prices on electricity prices.? "( RECLAIM affects only thermal power generating units in the SCAQMD.? These units account for about 20 percent of the power generating capacity in the State( Thus, the market price of RTCs was a factor for only a relatively small percentage of the State's generation capacity in 2000".? Markets? What are markets?? This is the basis upon which the State hopes to persuade FERC that the markets are not working because one cost factor only affects 20% of the State's capacity.? Okay, it is your turn.? Do you want to laugh, or cry? I reviewed one of the UDC proposals, PG&E.? PG&E's comments included three expert witness affidavits that in total were about one inch thick.? PG&E asks the FERC to replace the $150/MWh soft cap with a cost-based load differentiated cap; pay as bid for bids accepted over the load differentiated cap; force in-state generators to bid into the California PX before seeking to participate in other markets; penalize both load and generation if either does not sufficiently participate in forward markets; and return to cost-of-service ratemaking in California for an interim period.? In their proposed relief for electricity prices realized after October 2, 2000, PG&E requests a waiver of the payment provisions of the ISO and PX Tariffs, requests that the utility only be required to pay based on 1999 levels, and that after refund claims are adjudicated, PG&E will pay the extra amounts that may be ordered. Shakespeare couldn't have said it any better.? To sleep.? To sleep, perchance to dream. Things in the People's Republic of California ?@@@ ISO Super Peak Market books first transaction Ziad Alaywan of the ISO talked with me today during my attendance at the ISO Governing Board meeting.? He had a sad face as he told me, "We made our first transaction using the Super Peak Market instead of issuing an out-of-market (OOM) order.? It was for 100 MW."? Grand, says I.? Why the long face?? He was disheartened because the accepted bid was higher than the price cap of $250.? I said to my man Ziad that bids either above or below the price cap are not a reason to be upset.? What do you want the bidders to do, I asked?? He confessed that it troubles him when all the offers are above the cap, but, nevertheless, he is going to maintain the request for bids every day for the remainder of December. In case you haven't seen the form of the ISO request for bids, it is dispatched via e-mail, and looks like this: ? For operating day XXXXXX, 2000 the CAISO will be participating in its "Seasonal Super Peak Day of Market" via the Automated Power Exchange? (APX). This Market will close at 0915(.? Purchase may be made during this time for the peak hours of 1700 through 1900. It is the intent of the CAISO to reduce the amount of Out-Of-Market purchase for XXXXXX, 2000 through this "Seasonal Super Peak Day of Market". I encourage marketers and generators to look closely at this market in which to post offers.? The Super Peak Market is the best hope we have to bring order to the otherwise somewhat chaotic method by which the ISO operators go hunting for out-of-market energy.? I told Ziad that the more the ISO accesses the Super Peak Market, the more offers he is likely to see, and the more competition there will be to bring prices down.? Markets do not develop overnight.? I don't think offers below the cap are either unlikely or illogical.? Anyone disagree? Things in the People's Republic of California ?@@@ Consumers Rattle the Saber for a Ballot Initiative I told you it was going to occur.? Harvey Rosenfield, President of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights (FTCR), a consumer watchdog group, held a press conference last Tuesday to announce the kick off of a campaign to influence the Governor and the State Legislature to enact measures that will reverse the progress of electric competition, or face? on the November 2002 ballot (no butterflies) an initiative to achieve the same.? He tried this tactic two years ago when he launched Proposition 9.? It failed, but the in-state utilities spent $42 million in advertising to educate the public regarding the ills of old-time religion. ? The alleged purpose of the proposal/ballot initiative it to protect California consumers and small businesses against higher electricity bills. Rosenfield submitted a concept draft of their proposal to the Governor and Legislature that you can review on the web site http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/utilities/pr/pr000842.php3 ? ? FTCR's Key Points of Reform: ? requires refunds to San Diego customers of excessive electricity charges through a windfall profits tax on profiteering power generators; requires oversight of electricity rates by the Public Utilities Commission (PUC); institutes an integrated resource planning process to address future energy needs; creates a state power authority to ensure the fulfillment California's energy needs, promote conservation, and construct and operate power plants, transmission and distribution facilities; facilitates the authority of local and state government to exercise the power of eminent domain if necessary; and creates strong accountability mechanisms for state agencies. The advocates expressed doubt concerning whether state officials were willing to defy the powerful energy lobbies. And they warned elected officials against another bailout of the utility companies at the expense of taxpayers and consumers. If there is any part of the proposal I like, then it is the organization asked the Governor and legislators to refuse any campaign contributions from utility or power companies during the consideration of legislative proposals.?? According to Rosenfield, "(history shows that whenever elected officials must choose between the interests of the private utility/power companies and protecting the public interest, they will choose to protect the utility and energy companies. That is how we got into this mess. Whether the public officials currently in office are willing to do so -- especially in the? midst of a ratepayer revolt -- remains an open question. " You know, windfall profit tax aside, the more I read the proposal, the more I am intrigued.? The proposal boxes in the utilities, and you can easily expect that the utilities will come slugging back in two directions, simultaneously.? First, the utilities will slug back with the bankruptcy argument if they are stuck with the under-collection risk.? Second, the utilities will step up their accusations against the generators for "gouging."? The opportunities for schizophrenic behavior will be legion, because the utilities are less and less the largest sources of earnings for their corporate holding companies. Stay tuned.? It promises to be interesting. Things in the People's Republic of California ?@@@ All Injured Parties form a line to the left ( In the Chinese calendar, it is the Year of the Lawyer.? When I first heard about the $4 billion class action suit against the generators and utilities in California, I wanted to make a public statement to express my outrage.? However, I was too busy handing out free cigarette samples to school age children. Between endless squabbles over presidential vote counting, and pot shots at the restructured electric system in California, it always seems the lawyers come out ahead.? You know what I am saying?? Our litigation bills for WPTF in October almost hit $100,000, a new monthly high. So, what is this class action suit all about?? You can read the suit as filed on the web site of the filing attorneys at http://www.krausekalfayan.com/reliant.htm However, here is a summary. In the Superior court of the State of California for the county of San Diego?? a suit has been filed on behalf of Pamela R. Gordon in a class action complaint for violations of California business and professions code, and antitrust and unfair business practices.? The defendants are? Reliant Energy, Inc.; Southern Company; NRG Energy; Dynegy, Inc.; AES Corporation; Williams Energy; Duke Energy North America; And Does 1 Through 100, Inclusive, ? FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION: Violation of Sections 16720 and 16726 of the California Business and Professions Code Trust In Restraint of Trade or Commerce in Violation of the Antitrust Act SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION: For Violations of the Unfair Trade Practices Act Based Upon Violations of the Antitrust Act THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION: For Violations of the Unfair Trade Practices Act Based Upon Defendants' Unfair Business Acts and Practices FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION: Violations of the Consumers Legal Remedies Act FIFTH CAUSE OF ACTION:? Unconscionability It is that fifth cause of action that has me wondering.? Were we not conscious during this whole episode, with the possible exception of SDG&E when they didn't hedge their summer energy procurement? This is what the suit claims.? That, ? Defendants charged rates for wholesale electricity that were unconscionable given their cost of production, the newly emergent markets for that product, and the consumers' need for electrical power. Defendants' rates were inherently excessive, invalid and unconscionable, particularly in light of the deceptive and manipulative practices they used to inflate the market prices and the vital need consumers and businesses have for electrical power. Defendants' unconscionable prices were passed through to Plaintiff and the majority of the Class in the retail electricity rates charged by SDG&E and thereby directly damaged Plaintiff and the Class. Things in the People's Republic of California ?@@@ The Governor's Plan Well, we have had quite a week, haven't we?? Top it off with this.? Today, Governor Davis of California will float his proposals for fixing the California electricity market.? It is reassuring to know that so many people are rushing in to fix our problems. Here is what Jason Leopold of the Dow Jones Newswire reported about the Gov's draft plan.? It will include options to: ? Develop a state power authority to build power plants and own and operate transmission systems Eliminate the California Independent System Operator Extend the freeze on retail electricity rates Require utilities to retain existing generation and to build new power plants Consider re-asserting state authority over the operation, maintenance and safety practices of all in-state generating facilities for public health and safety purposes Authorize utilities to purchase the majority of their power in forward markets Pressure the FERC to implement a regional price cap on wholesale energy that varies by time of day and year Lobby for refunds for "unjust and unreasonable" rates. We will have a more detailed report on the proposals next week, assuming we survive that long. Odds & Ends (_!_) Jim Kritikson sent me an e-mail that has 54 different thought-provoking sayings, such as the by-line header at the top of today's Burrito. The one I selected is among my favorites.? Every week I will rotate a new by-line from the list Jim provided me, thereby lengthening the pure joy these morsels bring, rather than blowing the whole wad in one Burrito. Speaking of learning new things, I mentioned in the introduction that my experience being interviewed on TV gave me a world of insight into the phrases and words that get through the media filter.? I am becoming a student of the sound bite, as any reader of these Burritos will attest.? I am compiling a list of key words that either work, or don't work when talking with the media or the press.? For example, if you are talking to a reporter and you say, "The day-ahead ancillary service markets are too illiquid and the price is highly variable," then you will not only strike out with the media people, but you will go to the back of the sound-bite class.? On the other hand, if you say something like, "Of course they are gouging," then I can assure you they will take your bite to print or video. I have developed a simple chart of words and phrases either to embrace, or to avoid when addressing members of the press, the public, or when mingling with people at holiday cocktail parties with whom your spouse works, but you can't stand. There are In-words (they are good), and Out-words (to be avoided like the plague).? Feel free to add to the list as you learn new terms. In-words: 1. generator 2. manipulate 3. gouging 4. market power 5. demand response 6. consumer rights 7. under-collection 8. excess profits 9. abuse 10. utilities 11. competition 12. withholding Out-words 1. default provider 2. markets 3. high price 4. ancillary services 5. penny loafers 6. Eric 7. scarcity 8. interruptible customer 9. stakeholder 10. outages 11. investments 12. Burrito Now, here is how you utilize the system I have invented.? You pick three numbers, randomly.? Let's take today's hourly electric price, say, $249/MWH.? So, the numbers are 2, 4, and 9.? You can select any three numbers, it really doesn't matter.? So, for example, if you want to create a quotable quote, then you take the words (2) Manipulate, (4) Market Power, and (9) Abuse, and put them in a sentence; e.g., "The abuse of market power is an attempt to manipulate price."? See how easy that was?? The press will eat it up. Try it the Out-wordily way.? Using the same three numbers, select the words (2) Markets, (4) Ancillary Service, and (9) Stakeholder.? You might get, "The Ancillary Service markets are designed by stakeholders."? Dry as bone, and essentially useless.? Suitable for ISO Governing Board public comment, but you'll never be a press maven.? Keep a copy of these words in your wallet or purse.? It could save your life, or the life of an innocent consumer (see, I did it again). As the political rhetoric heats up, we, being soldiers of fortune, must be prepared at any moment to whip out the handy quote sheet necessary to calm the jittery nerves of the masses, lest there be a ratepayer revolt. As if we didn't have enough problems in California, the rest of the nation is in something of a fix.? This week, Dan Douglass sent us a classic piece to humor our weary bones.? This makes the phrase "Turning back the hands of the clock" seem a bit larger than life. =================== NOTICE OF REVOCATION OF INDEPENDENCE ? To the citizens of the United States of America: In the light of your failure to elect a President of the USA and thus to govern yourselves,? we hereby give notice of the revocation of your independence, effective today. Her Sovereign Majesty Queen Elizabeth II will resume monarchical duties over all states, commonwealths and other territories, except Utah, which she does not fancy. Your new Prime Minister (The Rt. Hon.? Tony Blair, MP for the 97.85% of you who have until now been unaware that there is a world outside your borders) will appoint a minister for America without the need for further elections. Congress and the Senate will be disbanded. A questionnaire will be circulated next year to determine whether any of you noticed. To aid in the transition to a British Crown Dependency, the following rules are introduced with immediate effect: ? 1. You should look up "revocation" in the Oxford English Dictionary.? Then look up "aluminium." Check the pronunciation guide. You will be amazed at just how wrongly you have been pronouncing it. Generally, you should raise your vocabulary to acceptable levels. Look up "vocabulary."? Using the same twenty-seven words interspersed with filler noises such as "like" and "you know" is an unacceptable and inefficient form of communication. Look up "interspersed." ? 2. There is no such thing as "US English." We will let Microsoft know on your behalf. ? 3. You should learn to distinguish the English and Australian accents.? It really isn't that hard. ? 4. Hollywood will be required occasionally to cast English actors as the good guys. ? 5. You should relearn your original national anthem, "God Save The Queen," but only after fully carrying out Task 1. We would not want you to get confused and give up half way through. ? 6. You should stop playing American "football." There is only one kind of football. What you refer to as American "football" is not a very good game. The 2.15% of you who are aware that there is a world outside your borders may have noticed that no one else plays "American" football. You will no longer be allowed to play it, and should instead play proper football. Initially, it would be best if you played with the girls. It is a difficult game. Those of you brave enough will, in time, be allowed to play rugby (which is similar to American "football", but does not involve stopping for a rest every twenty seconds or wearing full kevlar body armour like nancies). We are hoping to get together at least a US rugby sevens side by 2005. ? 7. You should declare war on Quebec and France, using nuclear weapons if they give you any merde. The 97.85% of you who were not aware that there is a world outside your borders should count yourselves lucky. The Russians have never been the bad guys. "Merde" is French for "s--t." ? 8. July 4th is no longer a public holiday. November 8th will be a new national holiday, but only in England. It will be called "Indecisive Day." ? 9. All American cars are hereby banned. They are crap and it is for your own good. When we show you German cars, you will understand what we mean. ? 10. Please tell us who killed JFK. It's been driving us crazy. ? Thank you for your cooperation. ========================= You are very welcome.? Have a great weekend, y'all. gba ?