25 May 2000, 16:40 UTC
Weyerhaeuser Company Limited ISDA
- From
- Carol St Clair carol.clair@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 25 May 2000 09:40:00 -0700 (PDT)
Snady: Here is what our internal counsel in Canada is recommending. Carol St. Clair EB 3892 713-853-3989 (Phone) 713-646-3393 (Fax)
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Carol St Clair/HOU/ECT on 05/25/2000 04:39 PM -----
Mark Powell\CAL\ECT
Sent by: Mark Powell
05/25/2000 02:25 PM
To: Carol St Clair/HOU/ECT@ECT
cc: Peter Keohane/CAL/ECT@ECT, Greg Johnston/CAL/ECT@ECT
Subject: Weyerhaeuser Company Limited ISDA
Hi Carol,
Peter has asked me to respond to your inquiry as to whether or not we can
agree to the request of Weyerhaeuser Company Limited ("WCL") in order to
replace the existing securities representations (as found near the bottom of
this e-mail) in the ISDA to:
"It is a Qualified Party within the meaning of the Ontario Securities
Commission, Rule 91-505 Over-the-Counter Derivatives."
From my perspective, there are four main reasons why this amendment would not
be appropriate. They are as follows:
1. Proposed Rule 91-504 - Over-The-Counter Derivatives ("91-504") and the
corresponding companion policy have yet to be formally adopted. At this
time, 91-504 is merely a proposal. In addition to checking the Ontario
Securities Commission ("OSC") website, I have contacted the lawyer who first
brought the "securities representation" issue to our attention and he has
confirmed that 91-504 is not yet in place and there have been no recent
announcements by the OSC with respect to an anticipated timeline for such
adoption.
2. Even though the WCL may trade through an office in Toronto, any trade
with Enron Canada Corp. ("Enron Canada") is likely to be considered a "trade
within Alberta" under Alberta securities law (due to the fact that the head
office and the mind and management of Enron Canada are in Alberta). As a
result, it is important that we get representations which address Alberta
securities law.
3. In a similar vein to point number 2 above, a "trade" can take place in a
number of jurisdictions depending upon the particular facts of the trade.
Although it may seem unlikely, it is possible that trades could possibly be
made in jurisdictions other than Alberta and Ontario. With the exception of
British Columbia, I am not aware of other provinces of Canada adopting
similar "blanket orders", "policies" or "rules" with respect to this issue.
However, it is usually Ontario, Alberta and British Columbia which are at the
forefront of Canadian securities law development (with the remaining
jurisdictions eventually following the leaders). I expect that, once 91-504
is in place, we will see some movement from the remaining jurisdictions.
Regardless, it would seem prudent to leave the reference to British Columbia
in place at this time.
4. I think it is worthwhile to have the parties to the ISDA acknowledge the
fact that a transaction under the ISDA will constitute an "OTC Derivative"
(and thus, have the applicable prospectus and registration exemptions
potentially available to them). I can think of no reason why it would be
beneficial to either party to remove this representation.
With respect to our physical agreements, we have addressed points 1, 2 and 3
above (as well as the fact that the exemptions we are relying upon are
provided by blanket orders and policies {as opposed to the Securities Act
(Alberta), Securities Act (British Columbia) or Securities Act (Ontario)} and
are, thus, more likely to be {and more easily} amended) with the following
clause:
"(i) each Transaction shall constitute a &commodity contract8 or an &OTC
derivative8 or such other similar term as defined pursuant to the securities
legislation in force in Alberta or British Columbia or pursuant to the
securities legislation of any other jurisdictions having application to the
Transaction, and (ii) it is a &Qualified Party8 within the meaning of
paragraph 9.1 of Alberta Securities Commission Order Doc.#394043 and
paragraph 1.1 of the British Columbia Securities Commission Blanket Order
BOR#91-501, in either case, as amended, restated, replaced or re-enacted from
time to time, and pursuant to any equivalent order or other enactment made
pursuant to the securities laws of Alberta, British Columbia or any other
jurisdictions having application to the Transaction;"
I understand that similar language has not been adopted in the ISDA due to
the "open-ended" nature of the above-mentioned clause. If we want to refer
to 91-504 and only to the blanket orders and policies currently in place, I
would suggest that we amend the existing clause, which states:
Canadian Securities Acts. (i) Each Transaction shall constitute an &OTC
Derivative8 as defined in the Securities Act (Alberta) and the Securities Act
(British Columbia) which have application to such Transaction and (ii) it is
a &Qualified Party8 within the meaning of paragraph 9.1 of Alberta Securities
Commission Order Doc#394043 and/or paragraph 1.1 of the British Columbia
Securities Commission Blanket Order BOR#91-501(BC), as in effect on the date
hereof.
to:
Canadian Securities Legislation. (i) Each Transaction shall constitute an
"OTC derivative" within the meaning of paragraph 4 of Alberta Securities
Commission Order Doc#394043 ("ASC 394043"), paragraph 1.1 of British Columbia
Securities Commission Blanket Order BOR#91-501(BC) ("BCSC 91-501") and/or
paragraph 1.1 of [proposed] Ontario Securities Commission Rule 91-504 )
Over-The-Counter Derivatives [as published by the Ontario Securities
Commission on January 7, 2000] ("[Proposed] OSC 91-504"), as applicable to
such Transaction, (ii) it is a "Qualified Party" within the meaning of
paragraph 9.1 of ASC 394043 and/or paragraph 1.1 of BCSC 91-501, as in effect
on the date hereof, and (iii) it is a "qualified party" within the meaning of
paragraph 1.1 of [Proposed] OSC 91-504.
Once 91-504 is formally adopted by the OSC, the bold and square bracketed
language above should be deleted and you may want to amend the ISDAs which
were drafted using such language. Similarly, if there are amendments to the
Alberta or British Columbia orders or a province (other than Ontario, Alberta
or British Columbia) which could possibly have/claim some jurisdiction with
respect to a transaction under the ISDA issues a similar order or policy, you
may want to amend the clause (and possibly, the pre-existing ISDAs).
I hope this discussion is useful for you. If you have any questions, please
do not hesitate to give me a call. I can be reached directly at (403)
974-6708.
Mark.