29 Nov 2000, 09:50 UTC
FW: Sempra Gas Transmission OII PHC
- From
- Brian Cherry bkc7@pge.com
- Date
- Wed, 29 Nov 2000 01:50:00 -0800 (PST)
FYI. Thought you might be interested. Perhaps next week we can do coffee.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> -----Original Message----- > From: Cherry, Brian > Sent: Tuesday, November 28, 2000 6:43 PM > To: Andrew Niven; Benjamin Campbell; Dan McLafferty; Dan Thomas; David > Anderson; Dede Hapner; Dennis Gee; Donald Petersen; Frank Lindh; G > Jefferson; Geoffrey Bellenger; George Clavier; J Reidenbach; Jerry Miller; > John Armato; John Clarke; Kevin Ernst; Kirk Johnson; Les Buchner; Les > Guliasi; Lisa Lieu; Lise Jordan; Mark Huffman; Michael Katz; Neha Patel; > Patrick Golden; Paul Sivley; Randall Litteneker; Ray Williams; Richard > Hall; Rodney Boschee; Sandra Burns; Sandy Dickinson; Shaun Halverson; > Shelly Malekos; Stuart Tartaglia; Todd Arnett; Trista Berkovitz > Subject: Sempra Gas Transmission OII PHC > > Earlier today, a PHC was held in the Sempra Gas Transmission OII > (I.00-11-002). ALJ Bushy and Assigned Commissioner Bilas presided over > the hearing and 40 appearances were entered into the record. The OII is > focused on Sempra, SoCalGas, and SDG&E's gas transmission planning > practices in general and the recent curtailments of gas deliveries in > SDG&E's service territory. > > Parties argued for segmenting the proceeding into two phases: Phase 1, > which would deal with SDG&E's Rule 14 curtailment priority and is expected > to be resolved through a settlement in the near term (by January 2001) > with SDG&E's electric generation customers, and Phase 2, which will deal > with longer-term issues of reliability and system infrastructure planning > and development. > > As for the Phase 1 issues, Duke, Dynegy and SDG&E are to reply to > discovery requests by December 15 and present a status report or > resolution of Rule 14 matters to the ALJ on or before January 19. In an > effort at compromise, PG&E NEG (Otay Mesa) proposed a "Double Pro Rata > Gas Curtailment" plan for parties to consider. Under this plan, EG's > (excepting cogenerators) would be curtailed on a pro rata basis within the > EG class based upon scheduled EG demand. This would be classified as a > Step 1 allocation. In the event this Step 1 allocation to an individual > EG is such that it is unable to satisfy its RMR obligations under the gas > allocated under Step 1 (assuming it has been called upon by the ISO > pursuant to the terms of the RMR contract), then an additional quantity > of gas will be made available to that plant on a pro rata basis from the > remaining EG plants. PG&E NEG was the only one to offer a formalized > proposal and I have copies of the proposal for those who are interested. > > The Phase II issues look to be much more contentious and are likely to > involve significant discovery issues. The parties pointed out to the ALJ > that comments filed by SDG&E and SoCalGas on the OII and in > representations made in the courtroom today failed to include Sempra or > its pipeline affiliate as a respondent. They also noted that many of the > issues they were concerned with dealt specifically with communications > between Sempra and its affiliates. The ALJ noted that "good form required > a respondent to cooperate and appear" . Sempra argued that SDG&E and > SoCalGas were the only entities owning and operating gas transmission and > distribution facilities in California, not the parent or the pipeline > company. ALJ Bushy ended this discussion quickly and noted that Sempra > was a respondent and should enter an appearance and the Sempra attorney > reluctantly agreed. > > More important were the comments of Commissioner Bilas. Bilas noted that > the recent gas curtailments in southern California, combined with the > electricity crisis and high winter gas prices, were creating headaches for > everyone. He stated that parties need to come to grips with the dynamic > political climate and needed to find, "..legitimate economic > solutions...not let this become a political football". This certainly > appears to be consistent with his current thinking as evidenced by his > caution in moving forward with the southern California Comprehensive > Settlement as stated in the CSA PD. > > Parties are requested to file PHC statements for the second PHC, currently > scheduled for sometime the week of the January 22. The PHC statements > need to include an issue discussion and a proposed schedule. ALJ Bushy > ordered discovery to commence immediately.