27 Nov 2000, 08:22 UTC
Re: Environmental Concerns about Emergency Programs
- From
- owner-nyiso_tech_exchange@lists.thebiz.net owner-nyiso_tech_exchange@lists.thebiz.net
- Date
- Mon, 27 Nov 2000 00:22:00 -0800 (PST)
Mark, Thanks very much for your observations in response to my environmental memo. I think I understand some of your concerns about the role of the ISO in general and, in particular, with regard to conservation programs. There are several ways in which I think the NYISO is inextricably involved with energy efficiency: The current competitive market the NYISO is overseeing is quite simply not working when it comes to demand or load responding to prices. Supply or generators are responding to price*imperfectly, but there is significant response. So we have "half a market." We should be seeking to put demand on a par with supply*treating load equally with generation. We are moving in the direction of facilitating that, but with basically all consumers on flat or average rates, and with almost all LSEs (the regulated distribution companies) able to pass along their energy costs, there is little basis for responding to high prices even when we have the software mechanisms in place to do so. Someone needs to find a way to have consumers confronting real prices*or at least paying a risk premium for not having to do so. Someone needs to find a way to have LSEs have a financial incentive to keep prices down*they don,t now. One way LSEs could do so would be to encourage their (fixed price) customers, through incentives, to reduce their use when prices are high. Environmentally, there is a lot at stake in getting the market to work right, and the ISO plays a major role in that, even when it is not its immediate responsibility. The emergency measures the ISO is considering have very significant environmental impacts. Small diesel generators may be needed to avoid the significant social costs of outages. One environmental concern here is that such generators be restricted to emergency conditions, and not become a new breed of economic peak clippers. And also, it seems reasonable that the emergency program "clean up after itself" by having offsets or mitigation associated with it. Actual demand reductions are a preferable alternative since they do not have health and environmental impacts*and help lower market prices at the same time. I don,t mean to suggest that the NYISO is responsible for all of the issues raised here*clearly the PSC, DEC, NYSERDA and others have very important roles. I think the NYISO needs to work with these other agencies to get competition to work more or less right, and pull down prices and protect the environment at the same time. Sorry if I have fallen into the trap of repeating myself(at length. Thanks for your comments. Larry