27 Sep 2000, 14:42 UTC
FERC COMMISSIONERS PLEDGE TO ADDRESS CALIFORNIA'S POWER MARKET PROBLEMS
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
- filuntz@aol.com, Elizabeth A. VanDersarl, Nicholas O'Day, Mike Dahlke, Jennifer Rudolph, c.thompson@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Wed, 27 Sep 2000 07:42:00 -0700 (PDT)
FERC COMMISSIONERS PLEDGE TO ADDRESS CALIFORNIA'S POWER MARKET PROBLEMS DURING AND AFTER EMOTIONAL HEARINGS; SAN DIEGO ELECTRICITY CONSUMERS EXPRESS THEIR FRUSTRATIONS 09/20/2000 Foster Electric Report Page 2 (c) Copyright 2000, Foster Associates, Inc. Two days of hearings in San Diego, Calif. on the causes of this summer's significant electricity price increases in Southern California and other problems with California's competitive markets revealed much hand wringing and finger pointing, but the answer to the question of whether and how the market should be fixed proved elusive. Nevertheless, all four FERC Commissioners attending the hearings agreed that the Commission needs to be part of the solution. Commenting on his impressions of the discussions earlier in the week, Chairman James Hoecker conceded at the Commission's regular Sept. 14 meeting that "it will not be sufficient simply to sprinkle deregulation dust on the old monopoly cost-of-service environment." There will be no "magical" solution to the problems, he added. The causes are complex and involve both wholesale and retail service and state and federal regulatory responsibilities. Nevertheless, Hoecker said that FERC now has a better understanding of the plight of the inhabitants of Southern California and is cognizant of the sentiment of everyone that the Commission "should not study the issue to death." Accordingly, he said that FERC would work with the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), the state attorney general's office and the governor to do what is necessary with respect to wholesale electric market design and to maintain California as an attractive market for investment. "High prices, market uncertainty, and a long transition to competition, in my view, are not sustainable," Hoecker added, but he discouraged the apparently spreading view of some parties that "this is the beginning of the end for competitive electricity markets. I personally reject that notion not just as a matter of policy but as a practical matter." He predicted that fixing the problems will simply take a lot of hard work. The other commissioners similarly proclaimed their continuing commitment to the development of competitive electricity markets. Commissioner Linda Breathitt said incentives exist to act as soon as possible. Proclaiming that wholesale prices in California markets have not been just and reasonable, Commissioner William Massey said that authorities should focus on how to provide short-term relief while exploring the requisite long-term changes to the market structure. Commissioner Curt Hebert Jr. stressed the need to regard the implications on a wider scope beyond California. California's symptoms reflect a "systemic problem" that can be rectified, not a competitive problem per se, Hebert insisted. The first San Diego hearing was convened by the House Commerce energy and power subcommittee on Sept. 11, and California's House members appearing were quick to argue that generators were the main culprits behind prices that were as much as three times what they were last year. The generators "are playing games," asserted Rep. Bob Filner (D-Calif.). "They are robbing people of their livelihoods, even threatening to murder people's businesses. That's criminal to me." Besides Filner, other House members attending the hearing were all Republicans: subcommittee chairman Joe Barton (Texas), Brian Bilbray (Calif.), Randy Cunnigham (Calif.), Duncan Hunter (Calif.), Ron Packard (Calif.) and John Shadegg (Ariz.) California Representatives Filner, Hunter and Bilbray all called on FERC to roll back the wholesale rates being charged to San Diego's electricity consumers. Bilbray and Hunter also said they would support a bill (H.R. 5131) introduced by Filner (see related article, this REPORT) that would set the price for wholesale power sold in the Western Systems Coordinating Council region after June 1, 2000, at no more than the average price for the preceding three years, and would require refunds to ultimate consumers. While skeptical about the need to order refunds, Hoecker said that the Commission would take a new look at the issue. His preliminary view is that California's high prices result primarily from a critical imbalance of supply and demand, exacerbated by the wholesale market rules and structure. Once again, Hoecker called for enactment of federal restructuring legislation to reduce the uncertainty associated with deregulation, which may be inhibiting investment in new generation and transmission capacity. "Such legislation should address the need for comparable and open access to transmission facilities, regional transmission organizations, mandatory reliability rules, and tools for remedying market power," he told the panel. Currently, Hoecker said that California's market woes reveal FERC's lack of the necessary tools to address market power effectively. George Sladoje, president and CEO of the California Power Exchange (CA-PX), said one of the main culprits in California's electric market woes was generators abandoning the CA-PX's day-ahead market in favor of the California Independent System Operator's (CA-ISO's) more lucrative real-time market. "The shift of demand from the day-ahead market to the real-time market exacerbated price volatility and contributed to the crisis atmosphere, and it has been the most dominant cause of the significant supply reduction in the day-ahead market," Sladoje said in written testimony. He added that prices in markets outside California were more attractive to generators seeking long-term contracts, leaving California buyers at the mercy of the real-time markets in the face of increased demand and decreased supply. "To give some perspective to this condition, at times this summer the CA-ISO real-time market expanded to include as much as 20-30 percent of the total energy volumes, although it was designed as a balancing market that would handle no more than about 2 percent," Sladoje added. In defense of the generators, Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers, blamed the problems on the lack of retail competition combined with a shortfall in generation. Executives from Enron Corp. and Reliant Energy faulted the state for requiring California's three investor-owned utilities to purchase all their electricity from the PX and for limiting their ability to hedge price risks by entering into long-term fixed-price contracts. On Sept. 12 FERC held a hearing of its own in San Diego as part of its ongoing investigation (EL00-95) into California's wholesale electricity markets (see REPORT No.199, pg.3). To open the hearing, Hoecker acknowledged that "San Diego customers are hurting. Competition is about choice, and these folks don't have choice." However, he also cautioned that federal intervention is at least six weeks away because he is reluctant to act before a Commission staff report on California's electricity market is completed on Nov. 1. "The Commission will correct any market flaws or unlawful behaviors to the extent it has authority to do so," Hoecker said in prepared testimony for the House hearing held a day earlier. "However, the Commission is still investigating these markets. When we have a sufficient record of market conditions, the Commission will take further action to address problems to the full extent of our jurisdiction." Hoecker's written testimony also lamented that FERC may lack the tools it needs to address market power. While FERC can attach market power mitigation measures to approvals of utilities' mergers or other corporate transactions, he noted that this remedy does not address market power already built into current commercial and operational arrangements. While the Commission also can deny or revoke authorization for market-based wholesale rates, reimposing cost-based rates would do "little or nothing to promote efficiency or competition," Hoecker stated. "And, in California where generation plants have recently been sold at well above book value, cost-based rates may not represent a real reduction." Commissioner Massey, however, believes that FERC has enough information to act now to mitigate what he believes are unjust and unreasonable wholesale power rates being charged in California. "Based on the records of proceedings at the Commission this summer, I believe that there are sufficient indications that California wholesale markets are not producing prices that are just and reasonable," Massey insisted in his written testimony. "For example, California wholesale electricity costs for June 29 of this year were seven times what they were for the same date in 1999 ($340 million vs. $45 million) even though energy usage was only about 3 percent more. During the month of June 2000, the total cost of electricity (energy and ancillary services combined) charged to the California market was nearly half of California's total electricity cost for all of 1999. . . . I would also note that the California Public Utilities Commission states that every analysis of the California markets since their opening has found substantial exercises of market power. I believe that there are serious flaws in the California wholesale markets." "I am concerned that this summer's events are causing a crisis of confidence in California wholesale electricity markets that threaten to erode the political consensus necessary to sustain a market-based approach to regulation, not just in California but across the country," Massey added in his often-repeated concerns. "The Commission must act forcefully and decisively to reassure market participants, policymakers and consumers that jurisdictional wholesale markets will produce consumer benefits and just and reasonable rates." The Commission's strongest advocate for open and free electricity markets, Commissioner Hebert's written testimony cautioned against labeling the current situation as simply a "California" or "summer of 2000" problem. "Rather, the problems that are now confronting Southern California represent a manifestation of larger, deeper problems that may confront other portions of the country in later months and years," he insisted. The problem, Hebert acknowledged, is that easy fixes do not exist. According to Hebert, "Rebates, refunds, and emergency releases may offer some relief right now. However, these short-term bandages do nothing to mask the larger problem that surely will reemerge next summer and future summers until something is done to address the true, underlying nature of the problem. At bottom, the situation in Southern California demonstrates that the federal government -- in particular, FERC -- can and should do much more to promote energy supply, energy delivery, and utility innovation. . . . There is no comprehensive energy strategy. Decisions are made on an expedient, ad hoc basis, with little regard for long-term impacts. And policies made in one energy sector (electricity, natural gas, oil, etc.) fail to take into account their impact on other sectors. What is needed is a new form of thinking. Most regulators claim to support competition, but their decisions belie their stated intentions. What regulators need to do is to demonstrate the courage of their convictions by allowing competition actually to operate -- by trusting that markets will make appropriate allocative decisions. Regulatory policies that claim to help consumers by inhibiting the operation of market forces -- such as through price controls -- actually work to their detriment." Hebert's also pointed his finger at (1) SDG&E for failing to employ adequate risk management tools, (2) the CA-ISO "for lacking the incentives and accountability to make difficult decisions necessary for the transition to competition" while compromising its independence by bowing to political pressure, (3) the CPUC for policies "that fail to allow for the timely siting and construction of badly-needed generation" and for ignoring performance-based incentives, and (4) FERC for "sending inconsistent signals to energy suppliers" and granting too much deference to the CA-ISO, Finally, Commissioner Breathitt's prepared testimony stressed the need for federal and state officials to work together in exploring solutions since both have jurisdiction over different aspects of California's electricity markets.