16 Oct 2000, 10:36 UTC
Reliant Energy: Splitting Business in Two to Maximize Shareholder Value
- From
- Steven J Kean steven.kean@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 16 Oct 2000 03:36:00 -0700 (PDT)
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Steven J Kean/NA/Enron on 10/16/2000 10:39 AM ----- "IssueAlert" <IssueAlert@scientech.com> 10/12/2000 06:56 AM To: cc: Subject: Reliant Energy: Splitting Business in Two to Maximize Shareholder Value http://www.consultrci.com ************************************************************************ El Paso Global Networks plans to spend up to $2 billion in the next few years on telecom acquisitions. Find out more about SCIENTECH'S Telecommunications InfoGrid at: http://www.consultrci.com ************************************************************************ =============================================================== SCIENTECH IssueAlert, October 12, 2000 Reliant Energy: Splitting Business in Two to Maximize Shareholder Value By: Will McNamara, Director, Electric Industry Analysis =============================================================== Reliant Energy announced the top-level executives for the two companies that will emerge from its planned separation into two stand-alone, publicly separated companies. Steve Letbetter will serve as chairman and CEO of the unregulated company. David McClanahan has been named president and CEO of the regulated company, which will be created at the time of the business separation. In July, Reliant Energy announced plans to separate into two publicly traded companies in order to separate its unregulated businesses from its regulated businesses. Following regulatory approval, the company plans an initial public offering (IPO) of approximately 20 percent of the common stock of its unregulated operations by early 2001. ANALYSIS: In June 1999, Texas adopted legislation to allow retail competition beginning on Jan. 1, 2002, for the majority of customers within the state. Senate Bill 7 mandated that utilities in the state construct firewalls between their operating companies. In other words, Texas utilities must have separate companies*with separate financial records*for energy services, distribution, generation, etc. In Texas, incumbent utilities must establish affiliated retail units that will serve customers who do not switch, but these units must be completely separate from the T&D operation of the incumbent utility. At first, Reliant Energy resisted this mandate and lobbied to keep its operations under one company. Thus, it was somewhat of a surprise when Reliant announced in July that not only would it be splitting into two publicly traded companies, but also that it would be issuing an IPO for the unregulated side of its operations. Currently, as one company with both regulated and unregulated operations, Reliant (NYSE: REI) is trading at about $45 13/16 (at market close on 10/11). Reliant has declined to make any projections about pricing of the IPO of its unregulated businesses, which it expects to issue in early 2001, until it submits an S1 filing with the SEC later this year. Reliant expects the IPO to be followed by a distribution to shareholders of the remaining stock of the unregulated company (within 12 months of the IPO). Reliant's motivations to divide itself into two companies are pretty straightforward. On one hand, the company is simply complying with the regulatory mandates of Texas. Yet, more importantly, Reliant is turning the mandate into a financial opportunity by establishing two public companies with dramatically different risk / reward profiles. The unregulated side will include such businesses as power generation, marketing and trading, telecom, and the European operations. The regulated side will include the businesses related to electricity and natural-gas distribution as well as the company's U.S. interstate pipelines. Reliant is a company that is seeking to maximize the opportunities that deregulation is offering, both in the United States and internationally. As an international energy delivery and energy services company, Reliant makes about $15 billion in annual revenue and has assets totaling $30 billion. The company's wholesale energy trading and marketing business is arguably within the top five (definitely within the top 10) in the United States, supported by its nearly 27,000 MW of power generation assets. As the company continues to transform itself from a traditional utility into an aggressive energy services company, it recognizes that its traditional investors have tended to be fairly risk averse, preferring to invest in the regulated activities of a conservative utility company. As Reliant attempts to penetrate new competitive markets, it intends to make itself an appealing investment opportunity for investors who are more "growth oriented and tolerant of risk," (as described by Letbetter). The most practical way to maximize shareholder interest and boost stock value is for Reliant to bifurcate its operations, offering two options for capital investment. It's a trend that is becoming more common in the energy industry, especially with regard to high-risk ventures. For instance, Southern Company just closed the IPO of its aggressive subsidiary Southern Energy (NYSE: SOE) on Oct. 3. Southern Energy, a global energy company, has become one of Southern Company's primary moneymakers (in the second-quarter alone, the subsidiary reported $93 million in earnings). When the IPO of Southern Energy closed, it brought total gross proceeds and a concurrent securities of approximately $1.81 billion to its parent. Southern Energy's current stock price is running at $29 1/8 (at market close on 10/11). The IPO price of Southern Energy on 9/27 was $22. Another example is Northern States Power (now part of Xcel Energy since it merged with New Century Energies), which this June spun off a portion of its NRG Energy subsidiary, an independent power producer. (See IssueAlert from 10/2/00 for more information). In addition, the trend is visible in other industries as well. AT&T recently announced its plans to spin off its customer long-distance business to shareholders. However, even though the financial rewards of such an IPO are enticing, there are possible downsides to such a move as well. Moody's raised serious concerns about Reliant's announcement in particular. Specifically, Moody's says that Reliant's regulated unit could be left with heavy debt loads after the structural split, which would hurt its own quality and bond ratings. Moody's has put both Reliant Energy Inc. and at least two of its subsidiaries on watch for possible downgrade from their Baa 1 status. Reliant remains on watch for possible downgrade as of Oct. 11. Another risk is that as more spin offs of non-generation units become commonplace, they may lose their appeal on Wall Street. The average first-day gain for similar energy IPOs was 43 percent in the third quarter, compared to 96.5 percent in the first quarter, perhaps indicating that Wall Street is already becoming less enamored with this strategy. Yet, these risks aren't dissuading Reliant from moving forward with its plan. As the company retains but moves beyond its traditional electricity and natural-gas distribution businesses, Reliant's focus is to expand its current business portfolio. By splitting its two operations in two, Reliant can separate its vastly different regulated and unregulated cultures. The companies require totally different management approaches, one based more in regulatory relations and the other driven by entrepreneurial spirit. The freedom Reliant gains from spinning off its operations into two separate businesses*one high risk, one low risk*appears to make this a smart move, at least for now. ============================================================== Discover a world of utilities information in our new e-zine, SourceBook Online. Get a free SourceBook Weekly article at: http://www.consultrci.com/web/rciweb.nsf/Web+Pages/SBEntrance.html =============================================================== SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products including e-commerce and telecom in the electric utility industry. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly at: http://www.consultrci.com/web/infostore.nsf/Products/IssueAlert Sincerely, Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis wmcnamara@scientech.com =============================================================== Feedback regarding SCIENTECH's IssueAlert should be sent to wmcnamara@scientech.com =============================================================== SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are compiled based on independent analysis by SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy and telecommunications issues. Copyright 2000. SCIENTECH, Inc. If you do not wish to receive any further IssueAlerts from SCIENTECH, please reply to this message and in the body of the email type "remove."