6 Dec 2000, 08:20 UTC
Re: Proposed Agenda for 12/7/00 Meeting @ 0830
- From
- Wayne Gardner wayne.gardner@enron.com
- Cc
-
Angie Buis, Ban Sharma, beth.wapner@enron.com, Bill White, Cynthia Harkness, Donald Lassere, James Ginty, Jan Haizmann, Jane Wilson, Jeff Dasovich, Kristin Albrecht, Lara Leibman
and 7 more
Michael Grimes, Michelle Hicks, Mike Dahlke, Rajen Shah, Richard Anderson, Robbi Rossi, Sue Nord - Bcc
-
Angie Buis, Ban Sharma, beth.wapner@enron.com, Bill White, Cynthia Harkness, Donald Lassere, James Ginty, Jan Haizmann, Jane Wilson, Jeff Dasovich, Kristin Albrecht, Lara Leibman
and 7 more
Michael Grimes, Michelle Hicks, Mike Dahlke, Rajen Shah, Richard Anderson, Robbi Rossi, Sue Nord - Date
- Wed, 6 Dec 2000 00:20:00 -0800 (PST)
David, We should specifically address the Singapore licensing issue in our discussion of point two and three. As for Korea, given that the group has assigned it a fairly low priority, we have not been able to review your note. I would be happy to stay on after the meeting to discuss the issues. Alternatively, I'd be willing to arrange a separate conference call if you would give me a range of times that you would be available. W. Wayne Gardner Enron Broadband Services 1400 Smith Street Houston, TX 77002-7361 Phone: 713 853 3547 Fax: 713 646 2532 David Merrill@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 06/12/2000 05:47 To: Wayne Gardner/Enron Communications@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS@ENRON cc: Donald Lassere/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Sue Nord/NA/Enron@Enron, Michelle Hicks/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Cynthia Harkness/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Lara Leibman/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Jan Haizmann/LON/ECT@ECT@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS@ENRON, Rajen Shah/LON/ECT@ECT@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS@ENRON, Richard Anderson/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, James Ginty/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Beth Wapner/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Robbi Rossi/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Ban Sharma/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Jane Wilson/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@ENRON, Mike Dahlke/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Michael Grimes/AP/Enron@Enron, Bill White/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Kristin Albrecht/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON, Angie Buis/Enron Communications@Enron Communications@ENRON Subject: Re: Proposed Agenda for 12/7/00 Meeting @ 0830 Wayne - to remind, there are two operational issues that had been on the agenda that keep getting deferred : the Singapore license entity and a regulatory issue in Korea. The deferral of the Singapore one defers our license application and our timeline for Singapore. I told the commercial team we hoped to deal with it in this week's call, but that even then the license would slip to January, with Singapore processing time. So we need to try to decide the entity this week or next, either in this call, or by e-mail, or in a separate call - - whatever is the most efficient way. Otherwise with the holidays we may lose an additional month. What is the best mechanism to decide this? In Singapore, if we can see our way clear to go with the already established entity, of course that would be simpler, but I defer to the group's judgment. For the Korea question, perhaps all we need to do is agree to ask Kim and Chang to look at it (including mine and Jan Haizman's and Jae-Moo Lee's thoughts) and give us their advice. If legal authorizes that I can get some material worked up to send. I will be on the Thursday call from the beginning unless I am in the air in which case I will join around 60-90 minutes into the call. Thanks. To: Donald Lassere/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Sue Nord/NA/Enron@Enron, Michelle Hicks/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Cynthia Harkness/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Lara Leibman/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Jan Haizmann/LON/ECT@ECT, Rajen Shah/LON/ECT@ECT, Richard Anderson/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, James Ginty/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Beth Wapner/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, David Merrill/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Robbi Rossi/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Ban Sharma/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Jane Wilson/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@ENRON, Mike Dahlke/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Michael Grimes/AP/Enron@Enron, Bill White/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Kristin Albrecht/Enron Communications@Enron Communications cc: Angie Buis/Enron Communications@Enron Communications Subject: Proposed Agenda for 12/7/00 Meeting @ 0830 1. Review attached note to confirm that we are restricted to one option (the "Regulatory Structure") from a regulatory standpoint with respect to the trading of Japanese bandwidth. 2. Determine whether there are similar restrictions in SIngapore or Hong Kong requiring us to adopt a similar Regulatory Structure. 3. Review the tax costs and risks arising from the Regulatory Structure and describe the steps that must be taken to manage the tax risks. 4. Given the foregoing, determine what specific steps are necessary to implement the Regulatory Structure and manage the concomitant tax, legal, accounting, and credit risks. 5. Review what steps, if any, are necessary to permit bandwidth trading by the US (and UK?) trading desks of bandwidth terminating in Australia. 6. Time permitting, determine whether regulatory considerations require that we adopt a structure similar to the Regulatory Structure in Mexico, Brazil, or Argentina. 7. Time permitting, review what steps, if any, are necessary to permit bandwidth trading by the US (and the UK?) trading desks of bandwidth terminating in Canada. Questions and comments are invited. Thanks. W. Wayne Gardner Enron Broadband Services 1400 Smith Street Houston, TX 77002-7361 Phone: 713 853 3547 Fax: 713 646 2532
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Wayne Gardner/Enron Communications on 05/12/2000 08:28
-----
Wayne Gardner
17/11/2000 18:12
To: Sue Nord/NA/Enron
cc: James Ginty/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Donald
Lassere/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, David
Merrill/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
Subject: Japan Trading
Dear Sue,
Because of the important role of Japan in the trading business of EBS, I want
to make sure I understand very clearly our regulatory options. For the sake
of simplicity, I limit the discussion below to trading of segments between
Japan and the US on the grounds that the Japanese principles that apply to
any other trading of international segments would be identical. The
discussion is further limited to the purchase of IPLCs because that is the
standard form of telecom capacity available for purchase out of Japan.
Finally, based on input from Regulatory, the discussion assumes that the
purchased IPLCs are divided into half-circuits. The Japan half-circuit
terminates in Japan and in the middle of the Pacific. The US half-circuit
terminates in the middle of the Pacific (picking up where the Japan
half-circuit terminates) and in the US.
I. Our only option from a regulatory standpoint:
We understand that the only option from a regulatory prespective is as
follows: EBS Networks YK ("YK") purchases the Japan half-circuits because it
has an ST2 license and switch in Japan through which it will route ALL
trades. EBS Trading L.P. ("Trading") purchases the US half-circuits only.
Each of Trading and YK can resell their respective half-circuits in the form
of capacity under the EBS Master Services Agreement (the "Master") to others,
who may be resellers or end-users.
II. Tax consequences of structuring trades in accordance with this option:
At best, the tax consequences of the foregoing are that half of the earnings
on Japan to US trading will be subject to 42% immediate Japan income tax
(with no ability to defer the cash payment of tax with Enron's US tax loss
carryforward). In addition there may be significant exposure to US income
tax (we are in the midst of quantifying this risk and evaluating potential
ways around it) which would incrementally increase the effective income tax
rate to 62%. If instead Trading undertook all the Trading activity,
virtually all of the earnings of Japan to US trading would be subject to a
single rate of US income tax (35%) and the payment of such tax could be
deferred for a significant period of time due to Enron's large US tax loss
carryforward.
III. The following options have been ruled out by Regulatory for the
following reasons:
Unworkable Option 1:
Trading does not acquire an ST2 license. Trading buys US and Japan
half-circuits directly and resells them in the form of capacity under the
Master to others, who may be resellers or end-users.
This option is illegal from a regulatory standpoint even though YK has an ST2
license. Japanese telecom regs provide that a reseller of Japanese IPLC
capacity must hold an ST2 license directly. In other words, the regulations
provide that no affiliate of the YK licensee may resell IPLCs unless that
affiliate itself acquires a license. Moreover, Trading cannot claim that it
is not engaged in resale activities that require an ST2 license. Japanese
telecom regulations treat the resale of capacity under the Master as a resale
of the underlying IPLC.
Unworkable Option 2:
Trading does not acquire an ST2 license. YK purchases the Japan
half-circuits. Trading purchases the US half-circuits. YK then resells the
Japan half-circuits to Trading. Trading then resells the entire circuits
under the Master to others, who may be resellers or end-users.
For the reasons set forth under Option 1, this option is illegal from a
regulatory standpoint, even if the sale from the YK to Trading and the
subsequent resale by Trading occur in tandem one immediately after the other.
Unworkable Option 3:
EBS Trading L.P. forms a wholly-owned US special purpose vehicle ("SPV")
which obtains an ST2 license. SPV executes a cost-plus contract with EBS
Networks YK. The cost-plus contract provides that SPV has the right to use
and control the telecom equipment owned by EBS Networks YK in exchange for
periodic payments based on the cost of the equipment. SPV buys entire
circuits and resells them in the form of capacity under the Master to others,
who may be resellers or end-users.
This option is illegal from a regulatory standpoint because SPV does not own
or lease the equipment through which it trades capacity. Even if it were
legal from a regulatory standpoint, this option is NOT workable because the
companies that control the Japanese capacity market would sell only to a
licensed Japanese company.
Unworkable Option 4:
EBS Trading L.P. forms a wholly-owned US special purpose vehicle ("SPV")
which obtains an ST2 license. SPV establishes a local branch in Japan and
controls a nominal amount of the telecom equipment in Japan through which the
SPV's Japanese trading is switched or routed. SPV buys Japan to US full
circuit IPLCs and resells them in the form of capacity under the Master Sales
Agreement.
This option is illegal from a regulatory standpoint because SPV does not own
or lease ALL the equipment through which it trades capacity. Even if it were
legal from a regulatory standpoint, this option is NOT workable because the
companies that control the Japanese capacity market would sell only to a
licensed Japanese company.
Unworkable Option 5:
EBS Trading L.P. forms a wholly-owned US special purpose vehicle ("SPV")
which obtains an ST2 license. SPV establishes a local branch in Japan and
controls ALL of the telecom equipment in Japan through which the SPV's
Japanese trading is switched or routed. SPV buys Japan to US full circuit
IPLCs and resells them in the form of capacity under the Master Sales
Agreement.
Although perfectly legal from a regulatory standpoint, this option is NOT
workable because the companies that control the Japanese capacity market
would sell only to a licensed Japanese company. This also creates a tax
problem in that Japan would treat the SPV as having a Japanese permanent
establishment subject to Japanese income tax on the earnings attributed to it.
Please confirm, clarify where ambiguous, or correct where inaccurate. Due to
the extremely tax inefficient results of what appears to be our only option,
we need to be absolutely certain that our understanding is correct. Is it
clear that there are no other options here?
Thanks.
W. Wayne Gardner
Enron Broadband Services
1400 Smith Street
Houston, TX 77002-7361
Phone: 713 853 3547
Fax: 713 646 2532