4 Oct 2000, 12:51 UTC
Cal-ISO seeks forward contracting authority
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Wed, 4 Oct 2000 05:51:00 -0700 (PDT)
Cal-ISO seeks forward contracting authority 09/20/2000 Generation Week (c) Copyright 2000 Pasha Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The California Independent System Operator (Cal-ISO) "most reluctantly" asked FERC last week to approve tariff amendments that would allow the system operator to obtain forward contracts. Further, in an effort to discourage utilities from leaning on the ISO for power, The ISO wants to allocate the costs of those contracts to scheduling coordinators whose forward schedules do not reflect their actual real-time demands. The allocation of those costs would be proportional to the sizes of the deviations. This would be a change from the current system, in which energy purchasing to balance load is spread among all market participants. "Fairness, as well as providing appropriate economic incentives to scheduling coordinators to align their forward and real-time schedules, dictates this allocation," the Cal-ISO's filing states. Recently, Cal-ISO President and CEO Terry Winter had unsuccessfully sought approval from the ISO Board of Governors to approve an amendment to the ISO's tariff to require scheduling coordinators to include at least 90% of actual loads, with generation and imports sufficient to balance their schedules, in final day-ahead schedules, and 95% of actual load in final hour-ahead schedules. Scheduling coordinators would have had to bear the costs of the ISO's out-of-market power purchases to balance the load. Coordinators would have been allocated the costs of those arrangements in proportion to the deviations of their actual real-time loads from their scheduled loads (GW 8/30). The ISO is asking for authority to enter into forward contracts without first soliciting bids because a formal bid process would take too long in a fast-moving market. FERC has directed the ISO to enter into forward contracts as a means of better assuring that load requirements are met. FERC expressed its concern in an order refusing San Diego Gas & Electric's request for a cap of indefinite duration on energy sold in the California Power Exchange. FERC ordered "the ISO to immediately institute a more forward approach to procuring the resources necessary to reliably operate the grid." The ISO said it is in total agreement with FERC's observation that a reasonable supply portfolio would make use of forward contracting as a hedge against price volatility. The ISO noted that the grid operator and FERC are in agreement that fulfillment of forward contracting is a responsibility that best resides with load-serving utilities. "Unfortunately, and for reasons not at all apparent to the ISO, the utilities thus far have been denied that authority," the Cal-ISO filing stated, noting the decision to empower the utilities rests California Public Utilities Commission. The ISO said it is applying for the tools to enter into forward contracts, but expressed hope that load-serving entities would "receive and exercise the authority to discharge a responsibility that more properly is theirs." The ISO said it doesn't want to be placed in the position as a competing market player. "The ISO continues to believe that its market activities should be constrained to an absolute minimum and that, most particularly, it should not be competing against load-serving entities for the energy needed to satisfy load that is reasonably predictable," the Cal-ISO said. The Cal-ISO wants forward contracting authority because the grid operator needs to buy increasing amounts of power at the last minute to balance supply and load on the grid. The ISO has been scrambling through real-time and ancillary services markets to find this balancing power. Originally, the California market system was set up so that utilities would buy most of the state's power needs through the California Power Exchange's (Cal-PX) day-ahead market. State regulators have not given utilities authority to do extensive forward contracting outside the Cal-PX, and utilities have been increasingly inclined to under schedule their actual needs in the Cal-PX and lean on the ISO to provide the balance of the power for their customers. Saying that underscheduling of load continues to be a problem and cautioning that unseasonably warm days occur in the fall, the ISO asked FERC to waive the typical 60-day notice required for tariff amendments and allow the changes to take effect immediately. "What the ISO seeks are the tools necessary to enable it to contract if available forward commitments appear reasonable," the system operator's filing says. The ISO said it does not believe other, related FERC orders require it to forward contract.