17 May 2001, 08:44 UTC
RE: INSURANCE EXHIBIT FORTURBINE PURCHASE AGREEMENT- Paul call please.
- From
- Paul E Parrish paul.parrish@enron.com
- To
- John G Rigby
- Cc
- David Marshall, James L Bouillion, Kay Mann, Scott Dieball, Sheila Tweed, cflourno@jwortham.com, rward@jwortham.com
- Bcc
- David Marshall, James L Bouillion, Kay Mann, Scott Dieball, Sheila Tweed, cflourno@jwortham.com, rward@jwortham.com
- Date
- Thu, 17 May 2001 01:44:00 -0700 (PDT)
John: The call is set up for tomorrow [Friday] 4 pm your time [London]/ 10am my time [Houston] to discuss this. David Way will be in a meeting just prior to this time so we wanted to give him time to get back to his office. The broker,s concern is that if this contract is to apply to a variety of 7FA, s with various rating, etc., the underwriter could view them differently and require subrogation rights on some of them. We need to understand how this contract language will be used to purchase what equipment before insurance language can be suggested. Paul
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Rigby, John Sent: Thursday, May 17, 2001 5:45 AM To: Parrish, Paul E. Cc: Marshall, David; Bouillion, James L.; Mann, Kay; Dieball, Scott; Tweed, Sheila Subject: Re: INSURANCE EXHIBIT FORTURBINE PURCHASE AGREEMENT- Paul call please. Paul- when will your review of the language be complete. This language has been given to outside counsel to incorporate in the world hunger standard. Please keep in mind that in this case the contracting party is a vendor whose job is manufacture the equipment and deliver it to the site, the vendor is not involved in the construction other than providing technical direction of installation. Paul- we need to talk- I thought I heard that the 7FA' are not considered new technology. I need to hear this from you, David and Wortham before opening up the subject of collateral damage and allowing the insurer to subrogate. I do not understand your comment on your naming the vendor as an additional insured. We are doing so in the case of Arcos. What we are doing in Arcos is making the vendor responsible under its warranty obligations for colleteral damage. I need to have a very clear understanding of what we can and cannot do it the case of GE 7FA units. Deviating from the past practice on 7FA's where there is not a new technology issue will be a painful and expensive ordeal. I can be reached in London via Scott Dieball's cell phone 713-504-2742. Please call. Paul E Parrish/ENRON@enronXgate 05/16/2001 03:56 PM To: John G Rigby/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Scott Dieball/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENt cc: Sheila Tweed/HOU/ECT@ECT, Kay Mann/Corp/Enron@Enron, David Marshall/ENRON@enronXgate, James L Bouillion/ENRON@enronXgate Subject: INSURANCE EXHIBIT FORTURBINE PURCHASE AGREEMENT John: The changes I suggested on the watercraft wording are still being reviewed for completeness. I think what I gave you will work for most situations where the watercraft is incidental to the work or is far removed from our being involved [contractor to sub to sub contractor] but it does not address every situation that we could be involved in. We may need to expand our wording accordingly. Likewise, your question on giving to the turbine venders the waiver of subrogation and additional insured is an even bigger concern. You are asking us to obligate ourselves in providing waiver and additional insured status to GE which we cannot do. As you know, we went many years with providing turbine venders protection under the insurance because the market was soft and underwriters agreed to it. Now they balk at giving it because of the losses they have incurred and we cannot predict what they will agree to. It does not matter if the machines are proto-type or not, there is a good chance right now that they will not agree to insuring the vender. Everyone says it only takes money and in many cases we could probably include venders on the insurance but I cannot recommend committing to it in a long term contract ) we have to arrange the insurance at the time we need it in order to determine if it is available. If you need to have some language in the agreement, I would recommend that we not give the waive and additional insured to GE or any vender. When we need the insurance and begin placing it, we can then determine if the underwriter will cover the vender and ask for a price reduction from GE to move their risk to the underwriter. I am sorry I cannot make this easier but that is the nature of the insurance beast. Paul