24 Oct 2001, 13:34 UTC
FW: Oct. 24 -- BNA, Inc. Daily Labor Report
- From
- Sylvia Hu sylvia.hu@enron.com
- To
- Felecia Acevedo, Cole Brown, Michelle Cash, bonne.castellano@enron.com, Rick Johnson, Lizzette Palmer, gilda.parker@enron.com, Kriste Sullivan, scott.walker@enron.com, Bonnie White
- Date
- Wed, 24 Oct 2001 06:34:30 -0700 (PDT)
User ID: enrondlr PW: bnaweb22
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: "BNA Highlights" <bhighlig@bna.com>@ENRON
Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2001 11:12 PM
To: BNA Highlights
Subject: Oct. 24 -- BNA, Inc. Daily Labor Report
______________________________
DAILY LABOR REPORT
Highlights & Table of Contents
October 24, 2001
______________________________
ISSN 1522-5968
Registered Web subscribers can access the full text of these
articles by using the URL link supplied.
Information about becoming a subscriber or signing up for a
FREE Web trial is available at http://web.bna.com or call
BNA Customer Relations at 1-800-372-1033, Mon. - Fri. 8:30
am - 7:00 pm (ET).
__________
HIGHLIGHTS
__________
RYAN'S STEAK HOUSES' ARBITRATION PACT UNENFORCEABLE, APPEALS
COURT FINDS
The Seventh Circuit finds unenforceable an agreement
employees hired by Ryan's Family Steak House in Indiana were
required to sign with an arbitration service. The
obligations of Employment Dispute Services Inc. are so vague
and general that the agreement is unenforceable, the court
rules ("Penn v. Ryan's Family Steak Houses Inc., "7th Cir.,
No. 00-2355, 10/17/01).
Judge Diane P. Wood finds the contract between Ryan's food
server Craig Penn and EDS was "hopelessly vague and
uncertain as to the obligation EDS has undertaken" and that
EDS "could fulfill its promise by providing Penn and Ryan's
with a coin toss." Finding the contract unenforceable, the
court affirms a district court's denial of Ryan's motion to
compel arbitration of Penn's claims of disability harassment
and retaliation.
Penn worked as a food server at a Ryan's in Fort Wayne,
Ind., from 1996 until 1998 when he was fired. He filed a
suit under the Americans with Disabilities Act charging that
Ryan's maintained a hostile work environment and that he was
fired for complaining about harassment. When Penn was
initially hired by Ryan's, he was required to sign a
contract with EDS to have EDS provide an arbitration forum
for all employment-related disputes with Ryan's. Relying on
Indiana law, the court says the contract between EDS and
Penn lacked mutuality of obligation and contained only an
"unascertainable, illusory promise" by EDS while placing
significant obligations on the employee. . . . Page AA-1,
Text E-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w3p3w5_
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k1m5_
COURT LIMITS SEX BIAS CLASS ACTION AGAINST BOEING TO SEATTLE
AREA
A federal judge in Washington state certifies a class of
some 30,000 female Boeing Co. employees who allege they were
discriminated against in job assignments, promotions,
training, retention, and bonuses ("Beck v. Boeing Co., "W.D.
Wash., No. C00-301P, 10/19/01).
The class of hourly employees--represented by the
International Association of Machinists--and nonexecutive,
salaried employees are employed at facilities in the Puget
Sound area of Washington. The plaintiffs had originally
sought to represent 42,000 workers nationwide, including
employees in St. Louis, Wichita, Kan., and Long Beach,
Calif., but Judge Pechman of the U.S. District Court for the
Western District of Washington limits the class to improve
manageability, calling the sweep of the proposed class
"immense."
Boeing has been the subject of two other class actions
alleging bias by African American and Asian American
employees. In 1999, a court awarded $14.2 million to the
black plaintiffs, and the second suit is still pending. . .
. Page A-2
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h9t2_
NLRB RULES 2-1 ILLEGAL CONFIDENTIALITY RULE REQUIRES NEW
ELECTION
Freund Baking Co.'s maintenance of a personnel handbook
provision illegally barring employees from discussing wages,
hours, and other terms and conditions of employment requires
setting aside a representation election, National Labor
Relations Board rules 2-1 ("Freund Baking Co., "336 N.L.R.B.
No. 75, 10/1/01 [released 10/22/01]). Ordering that a third
election be held in the longrunning case, Members Truesdale
and Walsh agree with a hearing officer that employees could
reasonably interpret the confidentiality provision "as
prohibiting them from discussing their wages and working
conditions with a union, as well as with others outside of
the company." Going one step farther than the hearing
officer, the board finds the provision could reasonably be
construed as prohibiting workers from discussing terms and
conditions of employment with other employees.
Chairman Hurtgen agrees the handbook rule is illegal.
However, Hurtgen, finding no evidence that the rule was used
to punish employees' protected activities, asserts that
maintenance of the rule did not merit setting aside the
election. Local 119 of the Bakery, Confectionery, and
Tobacco Workers lost the second election by a 30-3 vote. . .
. Page A-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h2j7_
SIXTH CIRCUIT FINDS TVA NUCLEAR SECURITY WORKERS NOT EXEMPT
FROM FLSA
The Tennessee Valley Authority willfully violated the Fair
Labor Standards Act by denying overtime pay to 20 former
nuclear power security employees, the Sixth Circuit rules
("Ale v. TVA, "6th Cir., No. 99-6642, 10/17/01). Despite
having some supervisory duties, the workers could not be
fairly characterized as bona fide executive and
administrative employees exempt from the overtime
requirements of FLSA, the court decides.
The 20 former employees, who alleged TVA had eliminated
their right to overtime compensation, had worked in site
security offices at TVA's Watts Bar and Sequoyah nuclear
power plants. Regardless of TVA's position descriptions and
other paperwork, the employees' actual duties did not
support the exempt classification, the appeals court says.
"The words 'in charge' are not a magical incantation that
render an employee a bona fide executive regardless of his
actual duties," the appeals court adds. . . . Page A-3
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h2t3_
DRIVER TAKING ANTI-SEIZURE MEDICINE NOT 'QUALIFIED' UNDER
ADA, COURT SAYS
A commercial truck driver who was terminated after his
employer discovered he was taking anti-seizure medication
and had a history of "seizures, fits, convulsions or
fainting" has no claim under the Americans with Disabilities
Act because he was not "qualified" for the job, the Tenth
Circuit decides ("Tate v. Farmland Industries Inc.", 10th
Cir., No. 99-6329, 10/10/01). The court says even if Charles
Tate could show he had a disability under the ADA, he could
not meet a Farmland Industries Inc. job requirement of
compliance with Department of Transportation certification
criteria. "We hesitate to second-guess a legitimate business
judgment on the part of DOT and its covered employers as to
the necessary qualifications of CMV operators," Judge
Baldock writes.
In dissent, Judge Briscoe argues Farmland admitted in
pretrial discovery that Tate was "qualified" as a truck
driver, and the company should not be allowed to argue the
contrary without withdrawing its earlier admission. Tate
should be able to pursue his claim because Farmland regarded
him as disabled and violated the ADA by firing him based on
that perception, Brisco adds. . . . Page A-4
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4v9w7_
________________
ALSO IN THE NEWS
________________
EMPLOYMENT: As the labor market weakened nationally during
September, several states registered unemployment rates
above the national average of 4.9 percent, the Bureau of
Labor Statistics reports. Three states and the District of
Columbia showed jobless rates of 6 percent or higher. . . .
Page D-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5e8n6_
FMLA: A worker wrongfully fired and reinstated with back pay
by an arbitrator, then fired again two days later after
taking a day off to visit his sick father, did not qualify
for FMLA leave because he had not worked for at least 1,250
hours in the preceding 12 months, a magistrate judge rules.
. . . Page A-8, Text E-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k7q8_
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5g5w4_
TELECOMMUTING: One in five U.S. employees participates in
some form of teleworking arrangement, and the vast majority
of these teleworkers are more satisfied with their jobs,
more productive, and more loyal to their employers than are
office workers, according the International Telework
Association and Council. . . . Page A-9
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k0j1_
____
TEXT
____
FMLA: U.S. District Court for the District of Maine's
decision in "Plumley v. Southern Container Inc". . . . Page
E-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5g5w4_
ARBITRATION: Seventh Circuit decision in" Penn v. Ryan's
Family Steak Houses Inc. ". . . Page E-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k1m5_
_________________
TABLE OF CONTENTS
_________________
LEADING THE NEWS
ARBITRATION
Seventh Circuit finds unenforceable an agreement
employees hired by Ryan's Family Steak House in Indiana
were required to sign with arbitration service . . . Page
AA-1, Text E-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w3p3w5_
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k1m5_
____
NEWS
____
DISABILITIES
Commercial truck driver terminated after employer
discovered his use of anti-seizure medication and his
seizure history has no ADA claim because he was not
"qualified" for job, Tenth Circuit decides . . . Page A-4
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4v9w7_
DISCRIMINATION
Federal judge in Washington state certifies class of
30,000 female Boeing Co. employees who allege job
discrimination . . . Page A-2
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h9t2_
ECONOMIC OUTLOOK
Demand across broad spectrum of goods and services fell
for first time since 1990-1991 recession during third
quarter of 2001, according to National Association for
Business Economics . . . Page A-11
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5m7d8_
EMPLOYMENT
House plans vote on broad economic stimulus bill (H.R.
3090) that includes provisions allowing states to expand
unemployment insurance benefits and provide health care
coverage for unemployed individuals . . . Page A-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5m4a5_
ERISA
Illinois Department of Labor is barred by ERISA from
investigating wage claims filed by former Hamilton
Sundstrand Corp. employees seeking severance pay under
ERISA-governed plan, federal district court rules . . .
Page A-8
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5e0u8_
FARM WORKERS
Labor Department extends review period for proposed rule
to modify fee structure for H-2A labor certification
applications . . . Page A-14
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5f9q3_
FLSA
Tennessee Valley Authority willfully violated Fair Labor
Standards Act by denying overtime pay to 20 former
nuclear power security employees, Sixth Circuit rules . .
. Page A-3
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h2t3_
FMLA
Worker wrongfully fired and reinstated by arbitrator,
then fired again two days later after taking time off to
visit his sick father, did not work requisite number of
hours to qualify for Family and Medical Leave Act
coverage, federal district judge says . . . Page A-8,
Text E-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k7q8_
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5g5w4_
INTERNATIONAL LABOR
European Parliament deputies approve legislation
establishing European Union-wide employee rights to
information and consultation . . . Page A-5
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5d7c0_
MANUFACTURING
Negotiators for General Dynamics Land Systems and UAW
reach tentative agreement for new four-year contract . .
. Page A-13
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5c0r4_
Workers at Maytag's Middle Amana, Iowa, plant reject new
contract offer and continue strike against household
appliance maker . . . Page A-7
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4t0t7_
NATIONAL ORIGIN
Federal judge in Maine preliminarily certifies settlement
class of Hispanic farm workers at DeCoster egg processing
company, paving way for distribution of $6 million
settlement of discrimination and fraud claims . . . Page
A-6
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4w6w6_
PENSIONS
Survey finds 80 percent of eligible employees have
balances in tax code Section 401(k) plan . . . Page A-6
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4k8r3_
REPRESENTATION ELECTIONS
Freund Baking Co.'s maintenance of personnel handbook
provision illegally barring employees from discussing
wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of
employment requires setting aside representation
election, NLRB rules 2-1 . . . Page A-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h2j7_
STEEL
U.S. Trade Representative Zoellick signals that his
support for import relief for U.S. steel industry hinges
on whether industry takes steps to restructure . . . Page
A-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k7h5_
TELECOMMUTING
Survey says one in five U.S. employees participates in
some form of teleworking arrangement . . . Page A-9
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k0j1_
TRADE
World Trade Organization Director-General Moore says
fourth ministerial conference scheduled for Doha, Qatar,
will go ahead as planned barring major adverse
developments in region . . . Page A-13
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5f5w5_
TRANSPORTATION
Citing job losses in aviation industry, transportation
union leaders urge Congress to move promptly on
legislation to extend worker relief programs . . . Page
A-12
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5n8m1_
WORKFORCE REDUCTIONS
Copper producer Phelps Dodge Corp. will lay off 1,500
U.S. employees . . . Page A-13
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5f9n7_
CWA says it has been notified by AT&T Corp. of plans to
lay off 2,400 union-represented workers . . . Page A-13
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h3h7_
New York-based insurance firm MetLife Inc. will cut just
under 1,900 U.S. jobs in ongoing effort to reduce costs .
. . Page A-13
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5b9y4_
_____________
ECONOMIC NEWS
_____________
EMPLOYMENT
As labor market weakened nationally during September,
several states registered unemployment rates above
national average of 4.9 percent, according to Labor
Department's Bureau of Labor Statistics . . . Page D-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5e8n6_
____
TEXT
____
ARBITRATION
Seventh Circuit decision in "Penn v. Ryan's Family Steak
Houses Inc." . . . Page E-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k1m5_
FMLA
U.S. District Court for the District of Maine's decision
in "Plumley v. Southern Container Inc." . . . Page E-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5g5w4_
______________
TABLE OF CASES
______________
Ale v. TVA (6th Cir.) . . . Page A-3
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h2t3_
Beck v. Boeing Co. (W.D. Wash.) . . . Page A-2
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h9t2_
Freund Baking Co. (N.L.R.B.) . . . Page A-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5h2j7_
Hamilton Sundstrand Corp. v. Healey (N.D. Ill.) . . . Page
A-8
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5e0u8_
Penn v. Ryan's Family Steak Houses Inc. (7th Cir.) . . .
Page AA-1, Text E-10
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w3p3w5_
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k1m5_
Plumley v. Southern Container Inc. (D. Me.) . . . Page A-8,
Text E-1
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5k7q8_
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w5g5w4_
Ramirez v. DeCoster d/b/a DeCoster Egg Farm (D. Me.) . . .
Page A-6
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4w6w6_
Tate v. Farmland Indus. Inc. (10th Cir.) . . . Page A-4
http://pubs.bna.com/ip/BNA/dlr.nsf/id/a0a4w4v9w7_
__________
Daily Labor Report (ISSN 1522-5968) Highlights are
published daily by The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc.,
1231 25th St., NW, Washington, DC 20037.
For account information and changes, contact
1-800-372-1033 (M-F, 8:30 am-7:00 pm ET)
To request retransmission or to order a copy of the
summarized article, contact 1-800-452-7773 or e-mail
bnaplus@bna.com.
For copyright guidelines, go to
http://www.bna.com/corp/copyright.
Copyright (c) 2001 by The Bureau of National Affairs,
Inc. Washington, D.C. 20037. Use of this service is
subject to the terms and conditions of the license
agreement with BNA. Unauthorized access or distribution
is prohibited.