5 Jan 2001, 13:15 UTC
POWER POINTS:For The Record, Price Cap Follies Of 2000
- From
- Greg.Blue@dynegy.com greg.blue@dynegy.com
- To
-
Tom Ross, smara@enron.com, stephanie-newell@reliantenergy.com, rllamkin@seiworldwide.com, rwhyde@duke-energy.com, jackp@calpine.com, paula.hall-collins@williams.com, Kelli Norton, rmcnally@mcnallytemple.com, Marty Wilson, lale@dynegy.com, kvellandi@pstrategies.com
and 48 more
kent.palmerton@williams.com, Katie Kaplan, Kassandra Gough, Karen Edson, Julee Malinowski-Ball, john_h_stout@reliantenergy.com, Joe Ronan, Jeff Dasovich, Jean Munoz, smutny@iepa.com, GTBL@dynegy.com, curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com, Robert Weisenmiller, Carolyn A Baker, andy brown, Andy Brown, dkk@eslawfirm.com, john.g.larrea@williams.com, 104525.3473@compuserve.com, BRBarkovich, bcarnahan@scppa.org, cmkehrein@ems-ca.com, dank@edf.org, dfreem@ladwp.com, dug@cpuc.ca.gov, dxh4@pge.com, estrategy@mindspring.com, fieldejr@sce.com, jpope@siliconvalleypower.com, kbjoha@aol.com, Mike Florio, mwoods@chrm.com, pfarnold@bpa.gov, pspan18988@aol.com, rachel@cleanpower.org, stacey.kusters@powerex.com, roscoesa@pg.com, steve_ponder@fpl.com, twinter@caiso.com, timothydanielhay@aol.com, tingwer@smud.org, vpatel@water.ca.gov, V. John White, wiseco@pacbell.net, wreed@sempra.com, Chuck Cole, askaff@energy-law-group.com, joseph.lyons@asm.ca.gov - Date
- Fri, 5 Jan 2001 05:15:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Greg Blue/HOU/Dynegy on 01/05/2001 03:10 PM --------------------------- "Golden, Mark" <Mark.Golden@dowjones.com> on 01/05/2001 01:27:25 PM To: "Pergher, Gunther" <Gunther.Pergher@dowjones.com> cc: Subject: POWER POINTS:For The Record, Price Cap Follies Of 2000 POWER POINTS:For The Record, Price Cap Follies Of 2000 By Mark Golden A Dow Jones Newswires Column NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--Significant facts in the California electricity crisis of 2000 have been lost in the high-pitched political response to a genuine economic problem. That's too bad, because some of the lost truths are humorous, others are enlightening. The year began with California State Senator Steve Peace, who was one of the chief architects of the state's 1996 deregulation law, boasting that California had fooled merchant power companies into paying too much for the power plants they bought from the state's utilities. The deregulation law was "a bet that most of the industry nationwide would misperceive what we were doing and overbid on the power plants," said Peace, as reported by Intelligence Press in January. "When the California legislature entered the debate on electricity competition," Peace went on to say in January, "the assumption was that you had to accept some level of compromise on reliability. But what is fundamentally different in what we did, compared to the national debate, is that we said absolutely, categorically you cannot compromise reliability. We led with reliability." Now, of course, this view of things is laughable. By late June even, Peace was foaming at the mouth before the California Independent System Operator about the new power plant owners and how they were gouging the state. He demanded - and eventually got - the ISO board of governors to cut their price cap to $250 a megawatt-hour from $750/MWh. For the record, the ISO's lower price cap was a complete failure. Not only didn't the price cap protect the state's utilities from financial ruin, it contributed to their losses. During the week of Dec. 4, when western U.S. wholesale power markets were well above $250/MWh, the ISO staff was buying massive amounts of juice at an average price of $700/MWh in "out-of-market" purchases that were allowed under the price cap rule, but not publicly reported. The ISO staff was allowed to make these out-of-market purchases only from utilities outside of California. So California's independent power producers were selling to out-of-state utilities for about $400-$500/MWh, and the utilities were selling power back to the ISO for up to $1,100/MWh. Some Northwest utilities even started buying power from the plants PG&E Corp. (PCG) and Edison International's (EIX) Southern California Edison still own through in the California Power Exchange's day-ahead market at $250/MWh, and then selling it back to the utilities through the ISO's real-time market at $700/MWh. That was pretty cheeky, but market participants always take advantage of stupid rules if they can make a big profit. At this point, the ISO asked the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for permission to dispense with its failed price cap and move to the FERC-recommended "soft" price cap, which requires only that sellers document costs that justify power sold for more than $150/MWh. On Dec. 8, the FERC approved the emergency measure. Prices fell, but one would never know that listening to the California Public Utilities Commission. "The elimination of wholesale electricity price caps by FERC on December 8 as confirmed by its order on December 15 and the resulting five-fold increase in wholesale electricity prices has expanded the crisis," the CPUC said in its rate-case ruling Thursday. This is false, and the CPUC staff knows it. The CPUC wants to blame the FERC for the crisis, because the FERC has said that the CPUC is to blame for discouraging PG&E and Southern California Edison from purchasing power on a long-term basis. What Sen. Peace lacks in perception, the CPUC lacks in integrity. The highest price in the four-year history of western electricity markets was recorded the morning of Dec. 8, about 12 hours before the FERC killed the price cap. Power for Monday at the mid-Columbia River hub traded over-the-counter Friday morning at a high $4,400/MWh, because a cold front was expected to arrive over the weekend. The lowest prices paid in the Northwest that day were $3,000/MWh. The cold front never fully materialized. As a result, the California Power Exchange, which trades Monday power on Sunday rather than Friday as the over-the-counter market does, priced Monday, Dec. 11 power at $654.22/MWh. This was above the old price cap of $250/MWh, but not bad considering where other western utilities had been trading Monday power two days earlier. When the CPUC and California Gov. Gray Davis talk about "a five-fold increase" in prices after the FERC lifted the price cap, they are talking about the CalPX's clearing price index of $1,407.07 on Dec. 13. But the CalPX went on record later calling that clearing price "meaningless." It was the result of a computer problem instituting the new "soft" price cap rules. No electricity was bought or sold at that price in California that day, and hours later the prices were refigured at $250-$310/MWh. The over-the-counter market had drifted down to $450-$500/MWh in the Northwest and to $320-$350/MWh in the Southwest. And prices have been drifting down ever since. Northwest power traded Friday at $135-$155/MWh and Southwest power traded at $121-$130/MWh. Generators are coming back on line from fall maintenance, and the weather is warmer than expected. Pretty fundamental stuff, but Steve Peace, the CPUC and Gov. Davis are still convinced they can simply dictate prices. Sure. And Alan Greenspan can save the Nasdaq. -By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604; mark.golden@dowjones.com (END) Dow Jones Newswires 05-01-01 1845GMT(AP-DJ-01-05-01 1845GMT)