21 Dec 2001, 16:40 UTC
Fw: Talking Points
- From
- Eric Gadd eric.gadd@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 21 Dec 2001 08:40:51 -0800 (PST)
Here's the talking points for ANNGTC. -------------------------- Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld (www.BlackBerry.net)
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: Coughlin, Michelle <Michelle.Coughlin@Williams.Com>
To: 'Brad D. Reese' <bdreese@duke-energy.com>
CC: 'andrew.ilnycky@foothillspipe.com' <andrew.ilnycky@foothillspipe.com>; Bob Bissett <BBissett@wei.org>; Reinecke, Bryan <Bryan.Reinecke@ENRON.com>; 'Bruce Scott' <BScott@wei.org>; 'byron.wright@elpaso.com' <byron.wright@elpaso.com>; Carlton, Cavan C <Cavan.C.Carlton@Williams.com>; 'dave.vandriel@neg.pge.com' <dave.vandriel@neg.pge.com>; 'donna_friesen@transcanada.com' <donna_friesen@transcanada.com>; 'dpentzien@nisource.com' <dpentzien@nisource.com>; Gadd, Eric <Eric.Gadd@ENRON.com>; 'jay.holm@elpaso.com' <jay.holm@elpaso.com>; Moore, Jim C <Jim.C.Moore@Williams.com>; 'john.ellwood@foothillspipe.com' <john.ellwood@foothillspipe.com>; John Taylor <JTaylor@wei.org>; 'lauri.newton@neg.pge.com' <lauri.newton@neg.pge.com>; Moench, Mark C <Mark.C.Moench@Williams.com>; 'marty.heeg@foothillspipe.com' <marty.heeg@foothillspipe.com>; Murray Birch <mbirch@wei.org>; Thomas, Peter C <Peter.C.Thomas@Williams.com>; 'peter.lund@neg.pge.com' <peter.lund@neg.pge.com>; Hill, Robert <Robert.Hill@ENRON.com>; 'rob.cohen@foothillspipe.com' <rob.cohen@foothillspipe.com>; 'skschroeder@duke-energy.com' <skschroeder@duke-energy.com>; 'spatrick@sempra.com' <spatrick@sempra.com>; 'tony_palmer@transcanada.com' <tony_palmer@transcanada.com>; 'vincent_lee@transcanada.com' <vincent_lee@transcanada.com>; 'wpurcell@sempra-intl.com' <wpurcell@sempra-intl.com>; 'rocco.ciancio@foothillspipe.com' <rocco.ciancio@foothillspipe.com>
Sent: Fri Dec 21 10:09:53 2001
Subject: Talking Points
Brad - I could not agree with you more. We do not want to negotiate this in the public arena. I felt the stories in the Calgary Herald, National Post were unfortunate in timing and substance.
As per your suggestion I have eliminated the last 2 bullets and attached the talking points here. The last bullet in the revised talking points was devised to take media pressure off of both us and the Producers. There has been an incredible amount of political hay being made with this project and it has realized an inordinate amount of media attention. We need to give the media (only if asked or questioned - not to be released) some reasonable expectations for time frames. In any discussions we have with government bodies or if questioned by media representatives we need to make it very clear we cannot discuss the terms of the proposal at this time and help them understand that the Producers will have only received an executive summary and the meeting in January will be the first glance at a large complex proposal and is intended to be the beginning of a process. Outlining this timeframe clearly stating there will be no immediate results from either receiving the proposal or the early January meeting will hopefully set the media and government minds at rest that there is no story here for a while so no need to dig further. Normally a timeframe and a process is a better answer than no comment.
Please let me know if you have any other concerns or would like to see additional revisions.
-----Original Message-----
From: Brad D. Reese [mailto:bdreese@duke-energy.com]
Sent: Friday, December 21, 2001 5:27 AM
To: Coughlin, Michelle
Cc: 'andrew.ilnycky@foothillspipe.com'; Bob Bissett;
'bryan.reinecke@enron.com'; 'Bruce Scott'; 'byron.wright@elpaso.com';
Carlton, Cavan C; 'dave.vandriel@neg.pge.com';
'donna_friesen@transcanada.com'; 'dpentzien@nisource.com';
'eric.gadd@enron.com'; 'jay.holm@elpaso.com'; Moore, Jim C;
'john.ellwood@foothillspipe.com'; John Taylor;
'lauri.newton@neg.pge.com'; Moench, Mark C;
'marty.heeg@foothillspipe.com'; Murray Birch; Coughlin, Michelle;
Thomas, Peter C; 'peter.lund@neg.pge.com'; 'robert.hill@enron.com';
'rob.cohen@foothillspipe.com'; 'skschroeder@duke-energy.com';
'spatrick@sempra.com'; 'tony_palmer@transcanada.com';
'vincent_lee@transcanada.com'; 'wpurcell@sempra-intl.com'
Subject: RE: ANGTS Commercial Proposal - Executive Summary - Dec. 20
Versi on
Michelle - - my comments are very much based on the impact of comments as
seen recently in TCPL's Calgary Herald article followed by the "scaled down
pipeline" article published by the Petroleum News Alaska:
I firmly believe the less said in public before jan 8 discussions with
producers the better off we are - we do not want to negotiate this deal
in public.
I'd prefer to keep advertisements down to a minimum and keep to the
staight and narrow for now; hence,
collapse the third and fourth bullets into one very concise bullet
indicating a proposal being sent before year end to be followed up by a
meeting in early Jan - I would not say anything further about whats in
the proposal nor the attributes.
Again, in the less said the better mode - I'd delete the last two
bullets.
I appreciate Tony's email on Mr. Kvisle's comments and timing and can
understand how these types of things occur. It indicates to me we need to
keep to a very tight script in all discussions (media and politicians
alike) until we make meaningful progress with the customer, hence my desire
to keep the talking points as brief as possible so we have the most
integrity with producers. I'll defer to the collective wisdom of the group
since I have no real editorial comments on your talking points - my real
comment is policy-wise to keep them as brief as possible; i.e. all we
really need to say right now is we're going to be meeting with producers in
early jan on a pipeline proposal. Thanks
"Coughlin, Michelle"
<Michelle.Coughlin@Wil To: "'Bruce Scott'" <BScott@wei.org>,
liams.Com> "'spatrick@sempra.com'" <spatrick@sempra.com>,
"'wpurcell@sempra-intl.com'"
12/20/01 04:56 PM <wpurcell@sempra-intl.com>,
"'eric.gadd@enron.com'" <eric.gadd@enron.com>,
"'robert.hill@enron.com'"
<robert.hill@enron.com>,
"'skschroeder@duke-energy.com'"
<skschroeder@duke-energy.com>,
"'bdreese@duke-energy.com'"
<bdreese@duke-energy.com>,
"'byron.wright@elpaso.com'"
<byron.wright@elpaso.com>,
"'jay.holm@elpaso.com'" <jay.holm@elpaso.com>,
"Moore, Jim C" <Jim.C.Moore@Williams.Com>,
"Carlton, Cavan C"
<Cavan.C.Carlton@Williams.Com>, "Thomas, Peter C"
<Peter.C.Thomas@Williams.Com>, "Moench, Mark C"
<Mark.C.Moench@Williams.Com>,
"'dave.vandriel@neg.pge.com'"
<dave.vandriel@neg.pge.com>,
"'peter.lund@neg.pge.com'"
<peter.lund@neg.pge.com>,
"'lauri.newton@neg.pge.com'"
<lauri.newton@neg.pge.com>,
"'bryan.reinecke@enron.com'"
<bryan.reinecke@enron.com>,
"'dpentzien@nisource.com'"
<dpentzien@nisource.com>,
"'marty.heeg@foothillspipe.com'"
<marty.heeg@foothillspipe.com>,
"'andrew.ilnycky@foothillspipe.com'"
<andrew.ilnycky@foothillspipe.com>,
"'rob.cohen@foothillspipe.com'"
<rob.cohen@foothillspipe.com>,
"'john.ellwood@foothillspipe.com'"
<john.ellwood@foothillspipe.com>,
"'tony_palmer@transcanada.com'"
<tony_palmer@transcanada.com>,
"'donna_friesen@transcanada.com'"
<donna_friesen@transcanada.com>,
"'vincent_lee@transcanada.com'"
<vincent_lee@transcanada.com>, Murray Birch
<mbirch@wei.org>, Bob Bissett <BBissett@wei.org>,
John Taylor <JTaylor@wei.org>, "Coughlin,
Michelle" <Michelle.Coughlin@Williams.Com>
cc:
Subject: RE: ANGTS Commercial Proposal -
Executive Summary - Dec. 20 Versi on
Attached are the talking points we discussed - I have not put in any
details of the proposal. Please send me back any comments.
-----Original Message-----
From: Bruce Scott [mailto:BScott@wei.org]
Sent: Thursday, December 20, 2001 9:47 AM
To: 'spatrick@sempra.com'; 'wpurcell@sempra-intl.com';
'eric.gadd@enron.com'; 'robert.hill@enron.com';
'skschroeder@duke-energy.com'; 'bdreese@duke-energy.com';
'byron.wright@elpaso.com'; 'jay.holm@elpaso.com';
'jim.c.moore@williams.com'; 'cavan.c.carlton@williams.com';
'peter.c.thomas@williams.com'; 'mark.c.moench@williams.com';
'dave.vandriel@neg.pge.com'; 'peter.lund@neg.pge.com';
'lauri.newton@neg.pge.com'; 'bryan.reinecke@enron.com';
'dpentzien@nisource.com'; 'marty.heeg@foothillspipe.com';
'andrew.ilnycky@foothillspipe.com'; 'rob.cohen@foothillspipe.com';
'john.ellwood@foothillspipe.com'; 'tony_palmer@transcanada.com';
'donna_friesen@transcanada.com'; 'vincent_lee@transcanada.com'; Murray
Birch; Bob Bissett; John Taylor; 'michelle.coughlin@williams.com'
Subject: ANGTS Commercial Proposal - Executive Summary - Dec. 20 Version
Attached is the latest draft of the covering letter and executive summary,
reflecting yesterday's discussion and subsequent edits and changes by
Cavan,
Dave, Michelle and myself. I have left a few comments/questions imbedded
in
this draft (in bold italics) to make sure we don't miss any details in the
last-minute rush. Please provide me with your final comments on both of
these documents by 3:00 p.m. Mountain time today. If you need to talk to
me, please call my cell at 403-862-0706. Thanks.
<<ANGTS_Letter_Dec19.doc>> <<ANGTS_Proposal_Dec19.doc>>
Bruce Scott
Office: 403-699-1415
Cell: 403-862-0706
(See attached file: Talking PointsANGTS .doc)