18 Sep 2001, 01:06 UTC
ISO Navigator Alert: NERTO Report Issued by ALJ Young
- From
- Aaron Breidenbaugh aaron@global2000.net
- Date
- Mon, 17 Sep 2001 18:06:53 -0700 (PDT)
Aaron Breidenbaugh <aaron@global2000.net> writes to the NYISO_TECH_EXCHANGE Discussion List: Greetings, FERC ALJ Young has issued his eagerly anticipated report on Northeast RTO formation. Subscribers may obtain a copy of the report, business plan, and appendices here: http://www.iso-navigator.com/NERTO_Business_Plan_Final.pdf Judge Young recommends the appointment of settlement judges for the post-mediation "going forward" process and refrains from advocating any particular governance structure or stakeholder processes apart from tallying the number of stakeholder supporters for each. Over the objections of the largest group of stakeholders, including PJM, as well as virtually all generators and marketers, the Judge advocates Option 1-M concerning market design issues. He cites with favor its incorporation of "best practices" from NYISO and ISO-NE and criticizing Option 3-M's failure to identify best practices, "let alone implement them". Option 1-M is the option favored by NYISO and ISO-NE and anticipates end-state implementation by Q3 2004. It is described in Appendix B of the Business Plan. The Judge implies in his criticism of the very aggressive Option 3-M that some of its supporters at least "would sacrifice optimal RTO market benefits in the long term to exploit more immediate economic opportunity in a sprint". He also notes that "PJM was unwilling during the mediation to concede that any practice pre-identified by another ISO in fact constituted a best practice." The following statement is especially noteworthy: "I left the mediation confident that the PJM paradigm will prove a more than adequate platform for the Northeastern RTO- provided it incorporates essential best elements from the other ISOs, and provided further that impatience, haste and greed are not permitted to drive RTO implementation at the expense of sound policy." Although he takes no position on whether the RTO CEO or Board members should have to resign their current positions, the Judge does advocate a an RTO-dedicated staff that does not work for the existing ISOs. He also acknowledged the fact that the mediation process "decidedly disadvantaged" smaller, newer entities, and that the Commission needs to address this problem in the post-mediation process. The report notes the technical difficulties likely to be faced in scaling up the PJM platform to the entire Northeast and the vagaries of NY and NE: "None of the software experts whom I consulted believes the Northeastern RTO will require an entirely new software system. Neither does any of them believe that any currently-employed software is capable of managing a system as large and complex as the RTO. The Northeastern RTO will constitute the largest energy market in the world. The complexity of the technology it will take to implement and administer that market is staggering. I learned during the course of the mediation that the complexity of electric system management software is second only to that of the banking industry. I also learned that there are very, very few vendors who design such software, and those vendors have a tremendous economic incentive to overestimate their/their software's capabilities to secure such lucrative contracts. Once entrenched, moreover, it would be exceedingly difficult and expensive to switch vendors in the event the original software proved inadequate. And that would be the least of the problems. Accordingly, it is my strong recommendation that independent, non-vendor, experts be involved in the technology assessment from the outset. These experts should be involved in both the IT and applications technologies assessments, and should be required to demonstrate that they have no financial interest whatsoever in the outcomes of those assessments. This will assure that the RTO has the advantage of continuing and unbiased expert opinions with respect to software provider representations and capabilities throughout the assessment process and beyond." (Left unstated was the fact that PJM itself is the software vendor of the PJM platform.) The ALJ strongly advocates that the Commission preclude comments on the Report or, alternatively, that if comments are allowed, replies should be permitted. Aaron (Copies of this email are being circulated to the TIE list as a public service.)