4 Jun 2001, 09:39 UTC
IEP News: 6/3-6/4
- From
- Jean Munoz jmunoz@mcnallytemple.com
- To
-
Andy Brown, andy brown, Carolyn A Baker, rescalante@riobravo-gm.com, Robert Weisenmiller, curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com, dean.nistetter@dynegy.com, dkk@eslawfirm.com, GTBL@dynegy.com, smutny@iepa.com, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Ronan
and 69 more
john.g.larrea@williams.com, Julee Malinowski-Ball, Kassandra Gough, kent.palmerton@williams.com, lale@dynegy.com, mmoretti@mccabeandcompany.net, Marty Wilson, rmcnally@mcnallytemple.com, nam.nguyen@powersrc.com, Kelli Norton, paula.hall-collins@williams.com, jackp@calpine.com, rwhyde@duke-energy.com, Roger Pelote, stephanie-newell@reliantenergy.com, smara@enron.com, Tom Ross, tcwillia@duke-energy.com, alex.sugaoka@uaecorp.com, william_carlson@wastemanagement.com, billw@calpine.com, bellery@spi-ind.com, bob.gates@enron.com, cody.carter@williams.com, curt.hatton@gen.pge.com, David Parquet, dean_gosselin@fpl.com, fernley.doug@epenergy.com, dnelsen@gwfpower.com, ed.tomeo@uaecorp.com, eileenk@calpine.com, eric.eisenman@gen.pge.com, frank.derosa@gen.pge.com, frazier_blaylock@ogden-energy.com, hap_boyd@enron.com, jack.hawks@gen.pge.com, elliottsa@earthlink.net, jgreco@caithnessenergy.com, jweisgall@aol.com, ccastillo@riobravo-gm.com, kellyl@enxco.com, khoffman@caithnessenergy.com, kfickett@usgen.com, Lynn.A.Lednicky@dynegy.com, marty_mcfadden@ogden-energy.com, paula_soos@ogden-energy.com, rjhickok@duke-energy.com, rskoebbe@powerworksinc.com, rllamkin@seiworldwide.com, ain@worldnet.att.net, siliff@riobravo-gm.com, steve_ponder@fpl.com, twetzel@thermoecotek.com, wfhall2@duke-energy.com, trusso@mcnallytemple.com, sadlersa@earthlink.net, mstultz@epsa.org, rtemple@mcnallytemple.com, Tracy Fairchild, megan.beiser@edelman.com, deborah.fiorito@dynegy.com, Lynne Church, Katie Kaplan, Thomas McMorrow, suzy.l.rodriguez@dynegy.com, ppitts@wiredworld1.com, mnobili@cal-lobby.com, sscsus@aol.com, kvellandi@pstrategies.com - Date
- Mon, 4 Jun 2001 02:39:00 -0700 (PDT)
Wall Street Journal, June 4, 2001, California Companies Combine, To Influence Power Regulation, By ????? ???MITCHEL BENSON Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL Wall Street Journal, June 4, 2001, Energy Commission, California, Clash Over Power-Grid Control ???By REBECCA SMITH Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL Business Wire, June 4, 2001, Monday, 09:11 AM Eastern Time, 307 words, ????Tired of Constantly Changing Energy Prices? NewPower Offers California ????Natural Gas Consumers A Two-Year, Locked-In Rate, PURCHASE, N.Y., June 4, ????2001 United Press International, June 4, 2001, Monday, 08:23 AM Eastern Time, ????GENERAL NEWS, 3236 words, What U.S. newspapers are saying CNN, CNN SUNDAY 16:00, June 3, 2001; Sunday, 5:19 PM Eastern Time, ????Transcript # 01060307V36, INTERVIEW, News; Domestic, 816 words, Are Price ????Caps a Solution for California's Energy Woes?, Barbara Shook, Stephen ????Frazier The Gazette (Montreal), June 4, 2001 Monday, 802 words, Dim policies in ????California, P.J. O'ROURKE Los Angeles Times, June 4, 2001 Monday, Home Edition, Page 2, 1700 words, ????Los Angeles; ; An Illuminating Look Several Light-Years Back; Utility ????Players Bat Cleanup, PATT MORRISON, TIMES STAFF WRITER The San Francisco Chronicle, JUNE 4, 2001, MONDAY,, FINAL EDITION, NEWS;, ????Pg. A1, 581 words, Electricity usage shrinks by 11%; ???State's consumers ????beat goal set by governor, Keay Davidson The San Francisco Chronicle, JUNE 4, 2001, MONDAY,, FINAL EDITION, NEWS;, ????Pg. A1, 1092 words, Eliminating night games may seem like a bright idea, but ????. . .; ???Baseball is balking, Erin Hallissy The San Francisco Chronicle, JUNE 4, 2001, MONDAY,, FINAL EDITION, ????EDITORIAL;, Pg. A19;, 682 words, Gloom today, glut tomorrow, Carolyn ????Lochhead The Washington Times, June 04, 2001, Monday, Final Edition, PART A; ????COMMENTARY; Pg. A14, 805 words, Shedding light on Bush's energy plan, Charli ????Coon The Associated Press State & Local Wire, June 4, 2001, Monday, BC cycle, ????12:09 AM Eastern Time, State and Regional, 745 words, Developments in ????California's energy crisis The Associated Press State & Local Wire, June 3, 2001, Sunday, BC cycle, ????State and Regional, 839 words, Critics say FERC ignored California's ????deregulation flaws, FOLSOM, Calif. The Charlotte Observer, June 3, 2001, Sunday, STATE AND REGIONAL NEWS, ????K1149, 1806 words, Duke Energy rates spike in emergency, By Stella M. ????Hopkins and Peter Wallsten Contra Costa Times, June 3, 2001, Sunday, STATE AND REGIONAL NEWS, K1314, ????653 words, Judge refuses to override PUC over PG&E bankruptcy, By Matt ????Sebastian Contra Costa Times, June 3, 2001, Sunday, STATE AND REGIONAL NEWS, K1316, ????731 words, Gloomy electricity supply forecast in June may have been ????optimistic, By Mike Taugher and Rick Jurgens Los Angeles Times, June 3, 2001 Sunday, Home Edition, Page 3, 915 words, ????Los Angeles; ; Key Figures Trade Views of Energy Picture; Forum: Most of the ????12 discussing crisis agree only on blaming federal regulators. They find no ????consensus on a solution., JOE MOZINGO, TIMES STAFF WRITER Los Angeles Times, June 3, 2001 Sunday, Home Edition, Page 1, 828 words, ????Thanks for Your Concern, Wall Street, PETER H. KING, SAN FRANCISCO Los Angeles Times, June 3, 2001 Sunday, Home Edition, Page 1, 4230 words, ????The Nation; THE ENERGY CRISIS; Watchdogs Take a Hit in State's Power Ills; ????Energy: Ex-federal officials say oversight of California's deregulation ????suffered due to a push for free-market competition., JUDY PASTERNAK, ALAN C. ????MILLER, TIMES STAFF WRITERS, WASHINGTON The New York Times, June 3, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final, Section 4; ????Page 18; Column 5; Week in Review Desk, 788 words, The Nation; Econ 101: ????It's Right and It's Wrong, By MICHAEL M. WEINSTEIN; Michael M. Weinstein is ????a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. The New York Times, June 3, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final, Section 4; ????Page 17; Column 1; Editorial Desk, 739 words, Reckonings; Watt Price ????Ideology?, By PAUL KRUGMAN The New York Times, June 3, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final, Section 1; ????Page 37; Column 1; Metropolitan Desk, 1065 words, One Developer's Power ????Solution: Build a Plant at the Office, By CHARLES V. BAGLI The Orange County Register, June 3, 2001, Sunday, DOMESTIC NEWS, K1495, 757 ????words, California may have already spent energy money it plans to borrow, By ????Hanh Kim Quach Sacramento Bee, June 3, 2001, Sunday, Pg. A3;, 491 words, State heeds call ????to conserve energy Californians trimmed their use of electricity by 11 ????percent in May., Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau Sacramento Bee, June 3, 2001, Sunday, Pg. L4;, 625 words, Lone shining ????light State power authority a future market tool San Jose Mercury News, June 3, 2001, Sunday, DOMESTIC NEWS, K1534, 2242 ????words, U.S. approved California's power-deregulation plan despite flaws, By ????Eric Nalder and Mark Gladstone The San Francisco Chronicle, JUNE 3, 2001, SUNDAY,, FINAL EDITION, NEWS;, ????Pg. A1, 2344 words, Cutting a deal on the environment; ???Activists accused ????of favoring cash over mission at Moss Landing, Scott Winokur, Christian ????Berthelsen The San Francisco Chronicle, JUNE 3, 2001, SUNDAY,, FINAL EDITION, ????EDITORIAL;, Pg. C6;, 554 words, Draw a line in the sand, Debra J. Saunders The Seattle Times, June 3, 2001, Sunday, Sunday Edition, ROP ZONE; News;, ????Pg. A1, 1633 words, the energy crisis: ground zero In Stockton, Calif., ????where a long, hot summer looms, keeping the power on seems an easy trade for ????saving the salmon in the Northwest, Lynda V. Mapes; Seattle Times staff ????reporter, Stockton, Calif. The Associated Press, June 2, 2001, Saturday, BC cycle, Washington Dateline ????, 249 words, Democrat calls on Bush to cap energy prices in radio address, ????WASHINGTON June 4, 2001 ???? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ California Companies Combine To Influence Power Regulation By MITCHEL BENSON Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL SACRAMENTO, Calif. -- Some big hitters in California's business community, angered by the pace and direction of the state government's efforts to solve the energy crisis, are launching a massive coalition aimed at boosting their influence on legislative and regulatory actions. In fact, the new business group, tentatively named the Coalition for Energy Action, is gearing up just as lawmakers here are desperately scrambling to promote the latest in a series of so far unsuccessful plans to save the financially crippled Southern California Edison Co. from bankruptcy. A primary component of this latest proposal: big business -- large energy users -- would pay nearly $3.1 billion of the utility's $3.5 billion in unpaid wholesale electric bills. That is just one reason why an unexpectedly large crowd of 60 representatives of high-tech, agriculture, manufacturing, oil and natural-gas, construction and most every other economic sector gathered here last week at the headquarters of the California Chamber of Commerce for the coalition's first organizational meeting. Chamber President Allan Zaremberg, who is leading the effort, has in the past organized effective business coalitions to oppose increased managed-health-care costs, restrictions on diesel fuel and efforts to re-regulate the state's electricity market. Mr. Zaremberg and others say their latest gambit is spurred by two main concerns: Gov. Gray Davis, the legislature and the state Public Utilities Commission are taking a worryingly scattershot approach to the state's energy pricing and supply-and-demand problems, even as the state's economy continues to deteriorate; and if and when policy makers do offer solutions, the business community worries it will be left paying a disproportionate share of the tab. "I understand the politics here, I understand the worry," says Jack Stewart, president of the 800-member California Manufacturers and Technology Association and one of the meeting attendees. "But sometimes you have to look a little bit beyond that, because the next step will be closing down plants, laying off workers and moving production out of California." While the coalition is just now getting off the ground, Mr. Zaremberg and others already are working with a pair of political and public-relations consulting firms. Those firms, in turn, recently conducted several focus groups in Northern and Southern California, in preparation for the May 31 meeting. After a positive reception, the consultants are now discussing a range of options for the coalition that could range from scheduling one-on-one meetings between coalition members and public officials to spending several hundred thousand dollars on a newspaper advertising campaign. Consumer activists say they find it ironic that many of the business interests who fought for the state's electricity deregulation plan in 1996 are now considering spending big bucks to seek protection from it. "The big business lobbyists bought the politicians and propelled deregulation through the legislature, and now they're upset because the politicians aren't paying attention to them anymore," says Harvey Rosenfield, president of the nonprofit Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. "Because now, the politicians are more worried about the voters." Indeed, the business community feels it is being taken advantage of. As evidence, Mr. Stewart and others point to the PUC's decision last month to boost electricity rates for customers of the Pacific Gas & Electric Co. unit of PG&E Corp. and the Southern California Edison unit of Edison International. The PUC decision estimates that more than 60% of residential customers -- those who are deemed low-income or who use relatively small amounts of electricity -- will see no increase. Yet many small business and industrial customers will face rate increases of 37% to 50%, while some businesses could see their monthly bills jump by much more. Just last week, lawmakers began circulating their latest proposal to rescue Southern California Edison from possible bankruptcy, now that it appears an agreement reached between the governor and the utility earlier this year has gained no traction in the legislature, which must approve the pact. Among other things, the latest approach calls on Southern California Edison's 3,600 largest electricity users to pay nearly $3.1 billion of the total $3.5 billion that the utility owes in unpaid wholesale-power purchases. The large consumers would pay that debt off through a surcharge on their electric rates over an estimated 20 years. Under the proposal, lawmakers say, large consumers also will be permitted to buy directly from generators. As a result, the lawmakers argue, the overall electricity costs to large consumers actually will be less than under the new PUC rate increases. But the business community remains skeptical. The Chamber's Mr. Zaremberg says the approach "doesn't send conservation signals to the residential community, and that should be paramount." Moreover, he is concerned that "the attitude of public-policy officials [is] that business consumers have to subsidize residential users." Write to Mitchel Benson at mitchel.benson@wsj.com ?? June 4, 2001 ???? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Energy Commission, California Clash Over Power-Grid Control By REBECCA SMITH Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL As California politicians wade deeper into the energy crisis, the state's electric-grid operator appears headed toward a showdown with federal energy regulators over whether its board is independent enough. The California Independent System Operator Friday bowed to pressure from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and submitted its qualifications to continue as a federally sanctioned grid operator. But the tardy filing is almost certain to be challenged by federal regulators and market participants because the ISO's governance structure has strayed from a "bedrock requirement" that it be "independent of control by any market participant." The market participant casting the long shadow is the state of California. Since January, when the state of California began buying huge sums of electricity on behalf of its nearly broke utilities, the ISO has been under pressure to give state officials preferential treatment and unique access to market-sensitive information. Its chief operations officer, paid $245,000 a year according to the most recent IRS filing, is on indefinite loan to the governor's office where he is working as an energy adviser. This politicization of the ISO is significant because the organization's purpose is to run a market for power needed to keep the electric system in balance and to give buyers and sellers impartial access to the power lines on which they depend to move electricity. Unlike other commodities, electricity can't be stored. Transactions, therefore, depend completely on instantaneous access to the electric superhighway of high-voltage lines. The FERC worries that a loss of political independence by the ISO will further degrade the state's already dysfunctional energy market. The FERC hasn't formally accused the ISO of acting improperly, but it is clear that a wall between the state and the ISO that once was solid has become permeable. Last month, the ISO notified the FERC that the state of California had asserted "it must have access to the ISO control room floor" and "nonpublic information" as a "necessary condition" of continuing to buy power, even though such preferential access violates ISO rules. But without the state to back power purchases -- it has spent nearly $8 billion on electricity since January -- the ISO's market would collapse and blackouts and chaos likely would ensue. The governance issue, which may appear esoteric, actually cuts to the heart of the power crisis in California. State officials feel they have ceded too much control to the FERC, which they accuse of shirking its duty to protect consumers. As a consequence, the state has forced its way into the inner workings of the formerly arcane ISO, a public-benefit corporation formed three years ago amid California's push to deregulate its electricity market. In January, the state legislature authorized the governor to eject a FERC-approved board of directors and hand pick his own five-member ISO board. The state attorney general ordered old board members to resign or face personal fines of $5,000. Currently, one ISO board member is a former member of the governor's staff, while another, on the governor's behalf, negotiated the proposed purchase of utility transmission assets by the state, all the while serving as chairman of the supposedly independent board. The ISO's chairman says changes in the board structure have made the ISO more answerable to the citizenry and "efficient." Michael Kahn, who is a San Francisco attorney, added that the governance structure had to change to reflect the fact that "we're in a state of emergency." In its filing Friday, the ISO took the position that the tighter relationship between the ISO's board and the state doesn't violate the FERC's requirement that ISO boards be free of control by market participants. Even though the state has been "required to provide financial support," the ISO asserts, this "participation does not make ... the State a market participant." Many market watchers scoff at that contention. "Inevitably, this will lead to a showdown," said N. Beth Emery, former general counsel of the ISO and now an energy attorney for Ballard, Spahr, Andrews & Ingersoll in Washington, D.C. "Clearly, the ISO is in violation of the independence requirement." But the FERC doesn't have many tools for enforcing its vision of autonomy. That may explain why it has failed to intervene. It can order the ISO to make board changes, for instance. But if it refuses, there may not be much the FERC can do except threaten to rescind the ISO's operating tariffs. That, of course, is the opposite of what the FERC wants to do, which is encourage creation of multistate grid organizations free of any political favoritism. But California's angry isolationism appears to be growing. Gov. Gray Davis said the ISO's filing ensured the state will "maintain control of our own energy destiny and not be subject to the whims of federal regulators or the interests of other states." To date, the FERC has been steadfast in its resolve to make regional grid operators independent organizations, free of control of utilities and power marketers. It has rejected other grid-operator proposals because it felt utilities that owned the power lines were attempting to retain too much control. But Order 2000, the landmark decision issued in December 1999 that promoted the creation of independent grid runners throughout the nation, never contemplated a state government assuming such a huge role in a market as has occurred in California. If anything, that role is likely to increase. Not only is the state of California the biggest power buyer in the nation now, but it has formed a power authority that intends to build and operate generating plants. In addition, Mr. Davis is promoting a plan to buy the transmission systems of the state's investor-owned utilities. As such, a new vertically integrated utility is forming that could be larger than any the nation has seen since the "power trusts" of the 1930s were broken apart by Congress. It is rife with conflicts of interest. The ISO's drift has created a fissure in the solid support it enjoyed from the state's big utilities that transferred control of their transmission systems to the ISO in 1998. PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric Co. unit, which is in bankruptcy proceedings, declined to join the ISO filing, which was supported by Edison International's Southern California Edison unit and Sempra Energy's San Diego Gas & Electric Co. unit. PG&E said in a separate grid-plan filing that it would prefer the ISO join a multistate grid organization. It expressed reservations about the independence of the current board. Opposition to the state's influence is becoming more vocal. The Electric Power Supply Association, a trade group representing power producers, warned FERC last month that the ISO has become "a partisan advocate for the State of California" and sought FERC intervention to defend the rights of all market interests. Write to Rebecca Smith at rebecca.smith@wsj.com. Copyright 2001 Business Wire, Inc. Business Wire ??????????????????June 4, 2001, Monday 09:11 AM Eastern Time DISTRIBUTION: Business Editors LENGTH: 307 words HEADLINE: Tired of Constantly Changing Energy Prices? NewPower Offers California Natural Gas Consumers A Two-Year, Locked-In Rate DATELINE: PURCHASE, N.Y., June 4, 2001 BODY: ??The New Power Company(TM), a subsidiary of NewPower Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:NPW), the first national residential and small business energy provider, today announced that it has begun offering consumers in northern California a two-year, fixed-price natural gas contract. Consumers in Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s service territory can lock in a low fixed rate for the entire two years. ??"NewPower is enormously pleased to provide California consumers, who've been buffeted by volatile energy prices, with a stable, gas contract," said H. Eugene Lockhart, The New Power Company's president and chief executive officer. "Smart energy shoppers in California will join the 600,000-plus customers we now serve in 19 markets." ??With today's announcement, natural gas from The New Power Company is available in the following PG&E counties: ??Alameda, Amador, Butte, Calaveras, Colusa, Contra Costa, Fresno, Glenn, Humboldt, Kern, Kings, Madera, Marin, Mendocino, Merced, Monterey, Napa, Nevada, Placer, Sacramento, San Benito, San Bernardino, San Francisco, San Joaquin, San Luis Obispo, San Mateo, Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, Shasta, Solano, Sonoma, Stanislaus, Sutter, Tehama, Trinity, Yolo, Yuba ??Consumers who need additional information or who want to sign up with NewPower can visit the Company's Web site at www.newpower.com or call 866/402-3949. ??About NewPower Holdings, Inc. ??NewPower Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:NPW), through its subsidiary, The New Power Company, www.newpower.com, is the first national provider of electricity and natural gas to residential and small commercial customers in the United States. The Company offers consumers in restructured retail energy markets competitive energy prices, pricing choices, improved customer service and other innovative products, services and incentives. ??SOURCE: The New Power Company ? LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ??????????????????????????????2 of 143 DOCUMENTS ????????????????????????????Copyright 2001 U.P.I. ??????????????????????????United Press International ??????????????????June 4, 2001, Monday 08:23 AM Eastern Time SECTION: GENERAL NEWS LENGTH: 3236 words HEADLINE: What U.S. newspapers are saying BODY: ??Compiled by United Press International ??New York Times ??Faced with resistance from Moscow, objections among NATO allies and opposition from Democrats about to assume control of the Senate, the Bush administration needs to reassess its missile defense plans and scale them back to a realistic level. The kinds of ambitious systems that Bush advisers have described are not technologically or politically attainable today. Clinging to these outsized concepts can only damage American diplomatic interests and delay the development of more modest and feasible missile defenses that could enhance the nation's security. ??Long-range missiles now being developed by North Korea, Iraq and Iran pose a legitimate security concern. The Pentagon should target its missile defense efforts on meeting that specific threat. There is a good chance that a system designed to achieve that limited purpose could be made palatable to Russia and America's European allies and, once tested and proved to be technologically reliable, win funding from Congress. ??Russia's thousands of intercontinental ballistic missiles could easily overwhelm any defensive shield the United States could build today. Moscow's real concern is that if the restraints built into the 1972 Antiballistic Missile Treaty are abandoned, America might one day be able to develop more advanced technologies that could blunt the effectiveness of Russia's strategic missile force and leave it vulnerable to attack. It is unrealistic to expect Moscow to agree to such open-ended development. But the Kremlin has signaled that it might be willing to contemplate a more limited defensive system bound by mutually agreed restrictions. ??The Bush administration seems to recognize that an agreement with Russia on missile defenses would help dispel European and Congressional misgivings. In recent weeks, Washington has made constructive proposals for cooperation with Moscow on related issues like early-warning radar and tactical missile defenses. But the administration has not yet addressed Russia's core concerns. ??There is ample time to pursue further diplomacy with Moscow before any defensive system is built. Carl Levin, the Michigan Democrat who is soon to become chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, has rightly stated that whatever technology the Pentagon decides on must be thoroughly tested and shown to be reliable before funds are appropriated for construction. But some increased financing would be justified over the next few years for expanded research and testing. ??That would allow the Pentagon to explore sea-based systems designed to shoot down missiles soon after they are launched, as well as refining the land-based approach pursued by the Clinton administration that is designed to intercept enemy warheads in mid-flight. Both technologies hold some promise of successful development. But neither is yet far enough advanced to justify construction of a system within the next several years, a step that would breach the ABM treaty. Space-based interceptors are a bad idea. As the country most dependent on satellites for reconnaissance and communications, America has the most to lose if space becomes a potential battlefield. ??The time needed for further testing and research should be used to try to negotiate a deal with Moscow. The administration also ought to consult further with its NATO allies and begin serious discussions with China. Beijing understandably worries that an American missile shield could undermine the credibility of its small force of long- range missiles and require it to build many more. ??A narrowly targeted, technologically reliable missile defense is desirable and may be possible to develop. To produce such a system, the Bush administration must set aside its exaggerated expectations and commit itself to a program of careful testing and patient diplomacy. ??0- ??Christian Science Monitor ??Living as he does among many wolves of war, the kind who would send a suicide bomber to a Tel Aviv night club to kill young Israelis, Palestine leader Yasser Arafat made a bold gesture on Saturday. He ordered a cease-fire. ??Such an order -- unusual for him -- assumes a lot. It assumes the chairman of the Palestine Authority has the power to carry it out. It assumes Mr. Arafat spoke from the heart rather than from international pressure or a fear that he might be the next Palestinian official assassinated by Israel. (Israel holds him "responsible" for Friday's bombing that killed 20 people and injured 90.) ??Maybe, though, one could assume Arafat has finally seen the futility of eight months of an increasingly violent uprising that's spinning toward wider war, with no conceivable endgame. ??And on that slim hope -- that maybe Arafat is finally sticking his neck out -- many nations have gone into diplomatic overdrive to push Israel and Arafat to again engage each other in making trade-offs needed for peace. ??Arafat's order included resuming patrols by Palestinian security forces at points of friction, such as Israeli checkpoints. But so far he has not ordered the arrests of known militants that he freed from jail when the current intifada began last fall. Without that, an Israeli military reprisal is assumed, only re-escalating the conflict. ??For a decade, the peace process has hung on an assumption that this one man is willing to make sacrifices and has the power to do so. Both have been in doubt recently. ??If Arafat isn't able to end attacks on Israelis, then it may be time to try other ways of bringing about peace without him. Perhaps the United States and Europe can broaden their approach and reach the Palestinian people directly. ??The days when one man could deliver peace - Anwar Sadat, Yitzhak Rabin, King Hussein - may be over in the Middle East. Flows of information, money, and weapons now spread so far and so fast that those seeking peace must deal more with public opinion. Encircling the wolves with hearts of peace may be the only way. ??0- ??Washington Post ??The recently approved tax bill, among other goodies, grants a tax break to savings that can be used to send children to private elementary and secondary schools. It's an expansion of what was formerly a college savings program and allows contributions of as much as $2,000 a year to education accounts whose earnings accumulate tax free. Some school-choice proponents hail the provision as a first step toward vouchers. If so, it's an odd first step, because it does little to help the families who most need financial help. Where Congress should be going on vouchers is toward a pilot program that would focus on helping poor children stuck in failing schools. ??The House generously granted the middle and upper-middle class tuition tax break as part of the tax bill but rejected vouchers when it passed its version of an education reform bill. Now the Senate is expected to take up the issue when it returns to work this week. One proposed amendment, offered by GOP Sen. John McCain, would create a four-year test voucher program for low-income students in the worst-performing D.C. schools. District officials weren't consulted and are uniformly opposed to vouchers. Staffers say Sen. McCain is reacting to persistent low achievement by D.C. students. That's a valid concern, but singling out the District in this fashion is an affront to home rule. ??Sen. Judd Gregg, R-N.H., has a better idea. He would create a pilot program for which interested systems -- as many as 10 cities and three states -- could apply. It would make vouchers available to low-income children in schools that have been failing for three years. It allows participating districts to set the vouchers' value, holding out the chance that some students might get enough money to actually meet the cost of private tuition. It provides for an outside evaluation of students' performance and the effect on the public schools involved. This experiment might help some individual students trapped in failing public schools while also providing useful data to inform the long-running debate about vouchers' potential effects. ??Opponents argue that any available federal money should be spent on the public system. It's true that the president's proposed budget falls short of what will be needed to carry out the initiatives in the education bill. Offering vouchers does not take away the obligation to improve troubled public schools. But it's also true that too many students pay dearly, and for the rest of their lives, because they have no alternative to a failing public school. Congress should be willing to explore what might come of giving more choices to some of those low-income students. D.C. officials, given the chance to make their own decision, should be willing to explore that option as well. ??0- ??Omaha World-Herald ??Homosexuals in Nebraska could be forgiven for wondering if there's an agenda by some in the state to marginalize them. ??Last year, a statewide referendum added to the state constitution a prohibition against state recognition of civil unions or domestic partnerships, although there was no known move afoot to allow such formalizing of relationships. ??Now a legislatively sustained veto by Gov. Mike Johanns has choked off an attempt to provide them legal protection against discrimination in renting or buying homes. ??Housing bias against gays in Nebraska is, as far as we can tell, rare. Yet that's not exactly the point. Johanns said he opposes creating "a special classification" based on sexual orientation. Yet the stroke of his pen effectively did just that. Today, anyone who follows the legislature knows that the state had an opportunity to ban such discrimination. It had the opportunity and refused. ??Of course the legal situation is unchanged. But a subtext exists that did not exist before. Defeat of the legislation called attention to the fact that some types of discrimination in housing are not prohibited by state law - discrimination not only on the basis of sexual orientation but also on the basis of religion, sex, family status and disability (although federal law, in some cases, applies). State law prohibits discrimination based upon race, color, national origin or ethnic group. ??This is one of those cases in which refusing to take action makes a statement all its own. And the statement for gays and lesbians is extremely negative. ??Actually, Johanns didn't exactly refer to sexual orientation. He offered as accepted fact what in reality is a hotly disputed contention: that homosexuality is about "sexual choices." There's a substantial body of scientific evidence that says sexual orientation is, in fact, inborn -- not, perhaps, up there with eye color, but nonetheless a strong predisposition rooted in people's genetic coding. ??Johanns is not obliged to accept such research as fact, but somewhere in the discussion he ought to be candid enough to admit that honest minds have disagreed and do disagree on the matter. (Food for thought: Given the amount of grief society often gives gays, if homosexuality is a choice, why does anyone choose it?) ??Interestingly, the two groups that presumably could be most affected by such legislation were for it, or at least neutral. The Nebraska Real Estate Commission and Nebraska Board of Realtors said they had no objection to the amendment, since they basically don't engage in such bias. And their observation just underscores common sense: Realtors are in business to sell property, not shoo people away from it. (The amendment wouldn't have affected landlords or other non-license-holders who may rent or sell property.) ??The real agenda seems to be that Johanns and other opponents of this measure are content to let gays (whose sexual relationships are not prohibited in Nebraska) get the cold shoulder in certain aspects of day-to-day life. Foes of the just-vetoed measure, notably including Family First and the Nebraska Family Council, say they'll continue to fight against other legislation that contains protections or concessions for homosexuals. ??Our interpretation is that gays and lesbians want to be quietly left alone like everybody else. They seek no special privileges. They just want to be accepted for what they are. But on such points, Governor Johanns becomes Governor No. A pity. ??0- ??Sacramento Bee ??Years from now, when California looks back on this expensive failure of electricity competition, one bright light will shine from this dark moment in history. That was the decision by the California Legislature and Gov. Gray Davis to create a California public power authority. ??Recycling the rhetoric of decades past, when utility monopolies and holding companies fought the creation of municipal utilities, critics today see public power as an unwelcome, inefficient intruder into the free market system. ??But public power's role isn't to replace that market. It is to make sure that it behaves. Californians can adjust to price gyrations for things such as airline tickets and cherries. Electricity, however, is too vital a commodity, and without regulation and competitive policy, the electricity market, as Californians have so painfully learned, is too easily gamed. ??There is now a brief window to contemplate how this state public power authority can stay one step ahead of market manipulation. The governor has signed the authorizing legislation, but the authority won't officially exist for another two months. Once in operation, its potential is enormous. ??As financial capital, the Legislature has authorized it to sell up to $5 billion worth of bonds to build new power plants to create electricity to be sold at cost. As human capital, the governor will likely tap the wisest old owl in the public power trade, David Freeman. Having already run the public power agencies of the Tennessee Valley, the state of New York, Sacramento and Los Angeles, Freeman brings experience that likely will never be duplicated. ??Freeman's strategy is to ensure that California races to turn a shortage of electricity into a surplus of about 15 percent. Private generators are busy building new plants and applying to build others. Yet at some point these companies may conclude it is not in their interests to compete so vigorously against each other. They feast on shortage and volatility. That's where a vigilant public authority can provide supply to keep the market balanced. ??An ideal partner in generating ventures would be the existing cities that run their own power authorities. The Sacramento Municipal Utility District, for example, is looking to build a generating plant fired by natural gas at the site of the former nuclear plant, Rancho Seco. By partnering with the state authority, SMUD could build a larger plant. The state could sell the surplus at cost. SMUD could get even more reliable power. ??With its surplus, the state may wish to direct some to new municipal districts. Customers in several communities are mulling whether to create their own municipal power agencies as a way to avoid the volatility of the deregulated world. Davis, San Francisco, Fresno and other communities are in various stages of this exploration. This very threat of competition keeps down the charges of both the private utilities and the generators. ??The cheapest power of all is that which California doesn't have to buy. The power authority's greatest contribution to California may end up being on the demand side of the electricity equation. It is ideally suited to lead future conservation and efficiency initiatives. Lowering demand lowers the price for the power that Californians do have to buy, whether their utility is public or private. ??"We will be masters of our own destiny," says Freeman. The history of public power's vital role in the market place suggests that Freeman is right about the future. LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ??????????????????????????????5 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????Content and programming copyright 2001 Cable News Network ?????????????Transcribed under license by Federal Document Clearing ?????????????House, Inc. Formatting copyright 2001 Federal Document ??????????Clearing House, Inc. All rights reserved. No quotes from the ??????????materials contained herein may be used in any media without ???????????attribution to Cable News Network. This transcript may not ???????????????????????be copied or resold in any media. ?????????????????????????????????????CNN ????????????????????????????SHOW: CNN SUNDAY 16:00 ??????????????????June 3, 2001; Sunday 5:19 PM Eastern Time ???????????????????????????Transcript # 01060307V36 SHOW-TYPE: INTERVIEW SECTION: News; Domestic LENGTH: 816 words HEADLINE: ?Are Price Caps a Solution for California's Energy Woes? GUESTS: ?Barbara Shook BYLINE: ?Stephen Frazier HIGHLIGHT: ?As the U.S. deals with energy woes, there has been heated rhetoric over price controls for power. ?But could they, in fact, make a difference. BODY: ??THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY BE UPDATED. ??STEPHEN FRAZIER, CNN ANCHOR: As the U.S. deals with energy woes, there has been heated rhetoric over price controls for power. ?But could they, in fact, make a difference. ?Barbara Shook joins us now from Houston to help answer that question. ?Mrs. Shook is the Houston bureau chief for the Energy Intelligence Group. ??Mrs. Shook, welcome, thanks for joining us. ??BARBARA SHOOK, ENERGY INTELLIGENCE GROUP: Thank you, Stephen. It's good to be working with you again. ??FRAZIER: Let's talk a little bit about what happened the last time we tried price controls, remember, in '79 or so when we had an energy crisis stretching on. ?What do you think happened then to the price of energy? ??SHOOK: The price of energy was held artificially low in that period of time. They actually started during 1971 under the Nixon administration, and price caps sent false signals to consumers, and they don't encourage consumers to conserve or to find alternative sources of energy. ??FRAZIER: So, historically, we had just what the president said in comments in week that they didn't improve -- they didn't reduce demand and they didn't increase supply, in his words. ??SHOOK: Very true. ?I would have to agree with the president on that. ??FRAZIER: So, there's a historic precedent for that which proves it. ?Why, then, such a call for price caps? ?Even now, Governor Gray Davis in California saying he's going to sue the federal government for those caps. ??SHOOK: I don't understand where the governor's reasoning is on this issue because price caps, as we have already pointed out, have not worked in the past. What the people are doing is trying to avoid paying the cost that they have tried to avoid for all these years but not building additional plants. ?If they had had the additional facilities in place, it might have cost them a little bit more in the short run, but now it's going to cost them a whole lot more. ??FRAZIER: Of course, in your experience, the resistance to building new plants is more sort of a not in my backyard process kind of in California, isn't that it? ??SHOOK: Well, in California, it's gone beyond the not in my backyard, or NIMBY, syndrome. ?You can describe Californians' attitude as either BANANAS, for build absolutely nothing here anybody, or NOPE, not on planet Earth. ??FRAZIER: So, as result, then, they have kind of a patchwork of half deregulation and half forces that are not market forces at all, and it's something of their own doing, as the federal government likes to point out. ??SHOOK: Yes, it is. ?The plan that is in place right now was formulated in 1996 by a coalition of Republicans and Democrats. ?You had a Democratic state assembly, you had a Republican executive branch under Governor Wilson. ?So, it's -- you can't make this a partisan issue. ?Both sides are at fault. ??FRAZIER: Now, you have spoken earlier this week with a newly- appointed member of the Federal Energy Resource Commission, Pat Wood. What were his thoughts on what's going to happen, how to resolve this crisis? ??SHOOK: Commissioner Wood has chaired the Texas Public Utilities Commission, and done a very successful job. ?What he said to me that he was going to recommend to California was first, discuss the number of plants that will be coming on in the near future. ?They will have additional plants that start up this summer, and then more in 2002. ??That will bring the price down just because of the expectation of additional supply. ?It will certainly mitigate more price spikes and it should bring the price down. ?He also recommended that the state do whatever possible to improve the creditworthiness of all the electricity buyers out there. ??In California, the consumers are being charged a penalty, if you will, in the cost of their electricity because of the credit problems, just as somebody who has a bad credit rating pays a higher interest rate on a home or car. ??And finally, Commissioner Wood recommended that the folks in California just turn down the rhetoric and start addressing the issues as adults, and stop making this just a finger-pointing game. ??FRAZIER: Right, in 25 words or less, because we're running out of time, did he think they are doing anything right there? ??SHOOK: He thinks that the fact they are building plants and expediting process and are expanding their gas pipelines and are going to expand some of their electricity transmission systems are steps in the right direction. ??FRAZIER: Right, that new Path 15. ?Well, Barbara Shook from the Energy Intelligence Group, once again, we're grateful for your insights. ?Thanks for joining us on a Sunday night. ??SHOOK: Thanks for having me. TO ORDER A VIDEO OF THIS TRANSCRIPT, PLEASE CALL 800-CNN-NEWS OR USE OUR SECURE ONLINE ORDER FORM LOCATED AT www.fdch.com LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????11 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????????????Copyright 2001 Southam Inc. ????????????????????????????The Gazette (Montreal) ??????????????????????June 4, 2001 Monday FINAL EDITION SECTION: EDITORIAL / OP-ED, Pg. B3 LENGTH: 802 words HEADLINE: Dim policies in California BYLINE: P.J. O'ROURKE SOURCE: Knight Ridder BODY: ??California is in the midst of an enormous stupidity crisis. Californians have been sitting in the dark because they didn't turn the lights on. ??They say they're short of electricity. Yes, they are. Between 1988 and 1998, California's electricity consumption increased by 15 per cent. Meanwhile, California's capacity to generate electricity shrank by 5 per cent, even as the state hesitated to build new power lines to tap into neighbouring states' power supplies. ??Californians didn't want dams across their rivers, derricks on their ocean, power lines across their borders or fossil-fuel smoke in their sky. These might interfere with all the smart things Californians do, such as hang-gliding. California was going to rely on so-called negawatts: dramatic power conservation. (But California regulators put price controls on electricity that lowered prices, and even Californians weren't dumb enough to skip a bargain.) And California was going to rely on alternative-power generation. With all the puffery from Silicon Valley dot.com start-ups, wind farms wouldn't be a problem. But it turns out that alternative power generation is an alternative, mostly, to generating power. ??U.S. President George W. Bush was wrong to extend executive orders requiring out-of-state utilities to supply power to California. And everyone is wrong to listen to Californians whine about electricity deregulation. ??Never Deregulated ??There never was any deregulation. The California Public Utilities Commission merely changed its regulations, which apparently weren't stupid enough to meet Golden State standards. Under California's 1996 reregulation plan, electric companies sold their generating plants and became distributors. They were required to buy their power on the wholesale spot market and forbidden to enter into any long-term power-supply contracts. Retail electricity prices were lowered by 10 per cent and frozen at the new rate until March 2002. ??This is like requiring A&P to sell you porterhouse at $2 a pound, no matter what the price of beef on the hoof. Imagine how many steaks there would be, and how many supermarkets. ??La-la Land, however, is a state of mind as well as a state of the Union. The world is full of mental Californians who, despite a century of socialist catastrophes, are willing to blame the free market for things like the California energy crisis. ??The critics of economic liberty are right: the free market did cause California's energy crisis. Hooray. Capitalism is doing its job. The critics are right without knowing what they're talking about. The free market isn't a means "to provide for people's basic needs." It doesn't come in or out of political fashion. The free market is a precise measurement of voluntary price settings. ??Free Market Was Ignored ??Californians devised a system of electricity sales that ignored every dimension of the free market. (Interesting that the Information Economy is centred in a place that's immune to information.) The free market is a yardstick, and Californians got smacked with it. Mideast oil jitters, cold weather, natural-gas price spikes and the plain unpredictable freedom of the free market caused wholesale electricity costs to rise and California utilities to go $12 billion into the red. ??California Governor Gray Davis responded with the full force of bikini-beach brain. In a Jan. 8 speech to the state legislature, Davis proposed creating a state agency to buy generating plants and build new ones. He threatened to expropriate power generators and transmission grids. He called for laws to allow criminal prosecution of wholesale suppliers that withheld electricity from California markets. And he said the state's universities and community colleges would build co-generating plants and become energy independent. (With gas produced by the cafeteria food?) Davis sounded like Joseph Stalin with the IQ of Keanu Reeves. "Everyone should understand that there are other, more drastic measures that I am prepared to take if I have to," Davis declaimed. ??"Take" is the key word. Grabby Californians tried to regulate themselves into some cheap electricity. Hoggish California power companies went along because the state-imposed retail-price ceiling was also a retail-price floor. According to the Los Angeles Times, during the first 28 months of the scheme, Pacific Gas and Electric and California Edison made $20 billion from the legally required mark-up between wholesale and retail electric prices. ??It would be wrong to call Californians stupid. They're sleazy, too. ??- P.J. O'Rourke is H.L. Mencken Research Fellow at the Cato Institute and foreign-affairs desk chief for Rolling Stone. This op-ed is adapted from an article published in the latest edition of the Cato magazine Regulation. TYPE: Business LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????12 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????June 4, 2001 Monday ?Home Edition SECTION: California; Part 2; Page 2; Metro Desk LENGTH: 1700 words HEADLINE: Los Angeles; ; An Illuminating Look Several Light-Years Back; Utility Players Bat Cleanup BYLINE: PATT MORRISON, TIMES STAFF WRITER BODY: ??In the years between 1994 and 2000, California's three little pigs--its investor-owned utilities and/or their parent companies--spent $51.6 million on political campaigns. Most of it, about $39 million, was spent beating back Proposition 9, which if you don't remember (and who can?) would have thrown deregulation into reverse. ??An additional $18.6 million was shelled out for six years of lobbying the governor, the Legislature and state agencies. The point-six part of that was spent by Pacific Gas & Electric .tin the first quarter of this year, even as PG&E was prepping itself to file for bankruptcy protection and make a bid for a bailout. ??The study by the nonprofit Center for Public Integrity found that way over half a million went to the campaigns of three leading politicians, all of whom have said the dough did not influence them: $171,000 to then-Gov. Pete Wilson, who signed deregulation into law; $212,186 to state Sen. Jim Brulte, the Rancho Cucamonga Republican whose name topped the author list on the deregulation law; and $268,135 to the campaign causes of state Sen. Steve Peace, the El Cajon Democrat held up as the Frank Lloyd Wright of deregulation (Wright's houses always looked fabulous but didn't always function ideally). ??The utilities are, of course, PG&E, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas and Electric: the one that's filed for bankruptcy protection, the one that may want to, and the one that's still carrying a torch, a lighted one. ??All Moneyed Up and Nowhere to Go ??OK, everybody: s-l-o-w-l-y take one step back. ??Now that it looks like Newport Beach Republican Chris Cox won't be taking off his congressional neckties in exchange for a black robe on a federal bench, anyone who had been angling to run for his seat had better make other plans. ??This means you, Mark C. Johnson. ??With Cox staying put--his odds of surviving confirmation in a newly Democratic Senate were shriveling anyway--Johnson has the million and a half for a campaign, and nothing to spend it on. ??Johnson is co-founder of Republicans for a New Majority, a bunch of people with a bunch of money to spend on moderate GOP candidates. He won't run against Fullerton Republican Rep. Ed Royce, or against Orange County's solitary congressional Democrat, Loretta Sanchez. But reapportionment might open up a new congressional district, or rejigger the one that now belongs to surfin' Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, who expected to collect big at his $1,000-per Arnold Schwarzenegger fund-raiser over the weekend. ??Think the Balkans are complicated? Look behind the Orange Curtain. "Things," said Johnson circumspectly, "may turn out to be a lot more convoluted than any of us are expecting." ??Walt Yes, Al No ??Disney plus Navy equals "Pearl Harbor" the movie. The U.S. Navy gave Disney unprecedented access, and Disney made script changes per the Navy. ??But actor Ben Affleck, aboard the carrier Constellation off San Diego on Sept. 13, filming scenes involving Gen. Jimmy Doolittle's raid on Tokyo, took a break from films for . . . politics. Surrounded by sailors, he began making a commercial on behalf of Vice President Al Gore's presidential campaign. Cut! Cut! Military property is off limits for political purposes, sailor! A Navy lieutenant stuck a hand in front of the camera--and it wasn't a salute. ??Biting the Hand That . . . ??Barely a month ago, the Congressional Hispanic Caucus gave a pass to Rep. Maxine Waters, saying it wants to elect more Latino politicians but not at the expense of simpatico non-Latinos like Waters, whose South-Central Los Angeles district has a huge Latino population. ??But in comments last week about Antonio Villaraigosa, the man running to be Los Angeles' first Latino mayor in more than a century, the African American member of Congress (who endorsed Villaraigosa's opponent, Jim Hahn), demanded, "Who is Antonio Villaraigosa? Where did he really come from? How much time has he spent in public service? . . . We need to know these things." ??For the record, Villaraigosa has spent six years not exactly hiding in the Legislature, including nearly two years as Assembly speaker, and years more as a community activist. He comes from L.A. Waters was born in St. Louis. ??The Man in Tartan Returns? ??It's the question all of Sacramento is asking: With state Sen. Tom McClintock considering another run at the state controller's job, will "Cousin Angus" be back? ??In ads for his 1994 campaign, which he lost to Kathleen Connell, the Thousand Oaks Republican tapped his Scottish roots to conjure the kilted cousin, who bragged in an accent as dense as highland heather that Cousin Tom is a true skinflint Scot, "tighter than a bullfrog's behind." Has anyone called the Scottish Anti-Defamation League? ??But Cousin Angus, says McClintock, "is so angry about the energy situation he may be running himself--for governor." ??A Little Rice, A Lot of Oil ??The few, the proud, the California Republicans are desperately trying to flush some big-name candidates out of the undergrowth, and the latest quail to emerge is Condoleezza Rice, President Bush's national security advisor and a former Stanford provost. ??The Capitol Hill newspaper Roll Call says state party Chairman Shawn Steele is talking her up to run against Sen. Barbara Boxer: "There's a long list of quality, top-flight Republicans emerging to run against Boxer [pregame big talk, there], and Rice would be among those ideal candidates." ??Besides saying "Condi loves" California, Rice's office demurred, with the usual "no plans" quote that always leaves some running room. ??With gas above $2 a gallon in the state, maybe now is not the right moment for Rice, who sat on the Chevron board and has a 150,000-ton oil tanker named after her. ??Quick Hits ??At an Irvine fund-raiser, former GOP Assembly Speaker Curt Pringle drummed up $15,000 for a Democratic former colleague, L.A. mayoral candidate Antonio Villaraigosa, whom Pringle called "an honorable guy." . . . Amid the talk of outgoing L.A. Mayor Richard Riordan running for governor on the Republican side, records show Riordan donated $12,500 to Davis' campaign on March 2, 2000, which his wife matched a day later. . . . Two dogs, each kitted out in Hahn or Villaraigosa political trinkets, met nose to nose in Venice to urge the candidates to support a canine beach in Los Angeles, which has none. ??Word Perfect ??"What do you want from me, a quote that I'm going to raise taxes? That will kill me when I run for president in New Hampshire." ??State Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, to reporters asking whether he'd raise taxes to plug the holes left in the budget by the energy crisis. ??Columnist Patt Morrison's e-mail address is patt.morrison@latimes.com. This week's contributors include Nick Anderson, Mark Z. Barabak, Dan Morain, Jean O. Pasco, Tony Perry, Margaret Talev and Jenifer Warren. GRAPHIC: PHOTO: Numbers Game: Mayor Richard Riordan welcomed President Bush to the World Affairs Council luncheon in Los Angeles last week by noting that he arrived "during stressful times" . . . meaning the NBA playoffs. (The mayor has been working on his comedic timing with his pals at the Friars Club.) He presented Bush with a pair of Shaquille O'Neal's shoes that could seat four, and a Lakers jersey, he said proudly, bearing the number 43 (it's right next to Bush's right hand), as in the 43rd president--except the jersey bore the number 34. Cut--propman! Was that a Bush-dyslexia joke or just a slip of the mayor's alphanumeric tongue? PHOTOGRAPHER: BRIAN WALSKI / Los Angeles Times LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????13 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ?????????????????????JUNE 4, 2001, MONDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: NEWS; Pg. A1 LENGTH: 581 words HEADLINE: Electricity usage shrinks by 11%; State's consumers beat goal set by governor SOURCE: Chronicle Staff Writer BYLINE: Keay Davidson BODY: By turning off lamps, turning up thermostats and buying energy-efficient light bulbs, the people of California helped reduce the state's electricity consumption last month 11 percent below the May 2000 level, more than was expected, Davis administration officials said yesterday. ???The "fairly remarkable" response to the governor's appeal for energy conservation came not only from business but from ordinary electric customers: "If you go into any hardware store, people are buying new lighting facilities. . . . It's truly a tribute to the people of California who are doing this," said Steve Larson, executive director of the California Energy Commission, in a conference call with news reporters. ???In May, the state consumed 18,616,485 megawatt hours of electricity, a drop of 2,289,362 megawatt hours or 11 percent from May 2000, said Gov. Davis' press secretary, Steve Maviglio. ???The governor called for a 10 percent reduction in May, whereas his energy advisers forecast that only 7 would be achieved, Maviglio noted. ???In the news conference, officials also said: ???-- The state signed nine new contracts in May with out-of-state power sources to boost Caliornia's available megawattage by 900 megawatts. Presently, that makes a total of 36 contracts with out-of-state energy sources. ???-- The price of electric power in May was 45 percent below the January amount, thanks to market fluctuations. ???Prices "are much more stable today -- things are really coming together," said Ray Hart of the Department of Water Resources. ???-- An unknown number of rolling blackouts are ahead as the state enters energy-hungry summertime. "Who knows?" Larson replied when asked by a reporter to forecast the likely number of blackouts. ???"It's the job of the state to look under every rock for every megawatt possible," Larson said. "During the month of May, we did a pretty good job." ???All in all, Maviglio concurred, it's "very good news for this month." ???"Californians exceeded the governor's expectations," Maviglio added in a post-conference interview with The Chronicle, "and it's critical to note all this (energy conservation) was voluntary. . . . If this is a harbinger of the summer, it's good news." ???During the news conference, a reporter from another publication asked for comment on Chronicle reports that certain energy providers deliberately throttled their available supply early in the crisis. ???While declining to discuss the newspaper's charge in detail, Hart replied: "What we do know -- I do not have specific information -- (is) the amount of forced outages were more than double the norm, and that's never happened (before). And (the forced outages were) up to four times (normal) some days. That is extraordinary, in itself, (and) that really makes you wonder whether there was (power) idling that was intentional." ???Officials also discussed the Davis administration's push to negotiate power purchases at reasonable prices from municipal utilities. They vaguely hinted at legal action if the state doesn't get what it wants, namely reasonably priced power from such sources. ???Negotiations with the utilities are continuing, said Dick Sklar, energy adviser to the governor. "I think the first step is to see if we can get people (at the municipalities) to act in a reasonable way before (we start) talking about punitive action. . . . The state has weapons I hope we never have to go (toward using)."E-mail Keay Davidson at kdavidson@sfchronicle.com LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????14 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ?????????????????????JUNE 4, 2001, MONDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: NEWS; Pg. A1 LENGTH: 1092 words HEADLINE: Eliminating night games may seem like a bright idea, but . . .; Baseball is balking SOURCE: Chronicle Staff Writer BYLINE: Erin Hallissy BODY: It's the way baseball was meant to be played, some say: under a summer sun instead of huge banks of lights. ???Now, some power misers are joining baseball purists by complaining about all those games played at night, saying they're as wasteful as leaving the air conditioning running when no one's home. ???From the small minor-league parks in places like Vacaville to games played in the state's five major-league ballparks, all those light banks could be shut down, all those power-using concession stands and scoreboards and illuminated billboards could be turned off. ???"It is my contention that we had better start seeing all five major league baseball teams, and many of the other sports activities at all levels of competition, being rescheduled to the daytime," said Blaine Nicol, who wrote to The Chronicle advocating the change. ???"It can be done," said Ed Moose, owner of Moose's restaurant in San Francisco and a fan of day baseball games. "It only takes a fiat by the president of the United States or the governor or the Legislature to say that this is what we have to do to get through a crisis. A lot depends on how important we say this is. Is it more important that we start a ballgame at 7:15 p.m. than at 12:30?" ???MOST LIKE SCHEDULE AS IS ???But energy crisis or no, don't look for baseball to move its night games to daytime. The leagues don't want it, the teams don't want it, the players don't want it and many of the fans don't want it, either. ???"Baseball during the day -- it's fabulous," Hillary Lassetter said before an Oakland A's night game last week. "But I can't get there." ???Like thousands of other fans, the 31-year-old Los Gatos woman works during the day. Lassetter, who has been going to games with her father since she was in first grade, works at a San Jose construction office, and her job isn't flexible enough to let her go out for an afternoon of baseball. ???Teams at all levels of baseball say they can't change the schedule this late in the season. It isn't just that many fans who have already bought tickets wouldn't be able to go to day games -- television contracts, player contracts and stadium leases wouldn't allow it. In some cases, even the weather wouldn't allow it. ???"On a promotional basis, once in a while, yeah, a day game is maybe fine," said Joe Gagliardi, president of the California League, which has 10 Class A (low minor league) teams affiliated with major-league clubs. "But if we had to switch to all day games, it would put at least 60 percent of our ballclubs out of business." ???That's because some of those teams play in the high desert Southern California towns of Lancaster and Adelanto and Central Valley cities like Stockton and Modesto, where summertime temperatures often soar well over 100 degrees. ???Teams without hot-weather problems won't be changing their schedules, either. ???GIANTS LIMITED TO 13 DAY GAMES ???The San Francisco Giants have a lease with the city limiting them to 13 weekday games a year because of the disruption to nearby businesses and commuters, said Giants executive vice president Larry Baer. The team is playing nine weekday games this year. ???"The schedules are put out a year in advance," Baer said. "I think it's unrealistic that we'd change after the season started." ???Fans who couldn't get to the park for day games wouldn't be the only ones who would be upset. ???Through yesterday's game, Giants second baseman Jeff Kent was hitting .343 during the day and .230 at night. But improving his overall numbers isn't worth giving up his free time with his three young children. ???"I'd hate to play day games every day," Kent said last week. "I'm a big family man, and if you play day games, your day is just burned. With all due respect to people who work 9 to 5 -- I guess that's what people in the real world do -- that would make it really hard to spend time with my children." ???State Sen. John Burton, D-San Francisco, toyed with the idea of introducing a resolution calling for more day games before deciding he had to review the legal ramifications of player and TV contracts along with season ticket sales. ???Roger Salazar, a spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis, said Davis has wanted to minimize disruptions to businesses. ???One of the things to consider, Salazar said, is whether the power saved by playing in the daytime "outweighs the fact that many of those people aren't at home (using energy)." ???ECONOMIES OF SCALE ???In fact, that's an argument some major-league clubs make. ???"It's actually more economical for more people to come to a ballgame during a crisis because it takes them away from their homes and brings them to one place," said David Rinetti, vice president of stadium operations for the Oakland A's. "It's kind of like a bus scenario. The economies of scale are much better." ???And teams say playing all day games could create new energy demands. ???"It takes eight hours to clean the ballpark," said Tim Mead, a spokesman for the Anaheim Angels. "If you play day games, you'd be cleaning the ballpark at night," with the lights on. ???The Angels, who play at Edison Field, are particularly sensitive about the energy issue. Mead pointed out that the park is actually served by the city of Anaheim's power company, not Southern California Edison, and that the stadium voluntarily turned off its Big A electric sign in December despite the fact that it's one of their primary means of advertising. ???TEAMS PITCHING IN ???Baseball teams say they are doing what they can to conserve energy. Rinetti said concourse lighting has been dimmed at the Network Associates Coliseum in Oakland, and field lights are not turned on during batting practice anymore. The lights used to be turned off a half-hour after the game ended, but now they're turned off seven minutes after the final out. ???The San Diego Padres added day games to their schedule and will play 39 this year, said spokesman Glenn Geffner, who pointed out that that's the fifth-highest number in the majors. ???In Vacaville, where the Solano Steelheads of the independent Western Baseball League play at Travis Credit Union Park at the Nut Tree, owner Bruce Portner is being even more parsimonious about power. ???"Any profit I had in mind this year is going to PG&E," Portner complained. ???At one game this season, Portner argued with an umpire who wanted the lights turned on at dusk. ???"The umps aren't paying the bill," Portner said. "I am."Chronicle Staff Writer Henry Schulman contributed to this report. / E-mail Erin Hallissy at ehallissy@sfchronicle.com. GRAPHIC: PHOTO (2), (1) Seven-year-old Truman Purnell, from Piedmont, was ready for a foul ball while sitting in the lap of his father, Dan, at Friday night's A's game., (2) Baseball is being criticized during the energy crisis for having so many of its games at night, like Friday's A's game in Oakland. / Photos by Kim Komenich/The Chronicle LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????15 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ?????????????????????JUNE 4, 2001, MONDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: EDITORIAL; Pg. A19; WASHINGTON INSIGHT LENGTH: 682 words HEADLINE: Gloom today, glut tomorrow BYLINE: Carolyn Lochhead BODY: WHAT GOES UP usually comes down. And few industries are more prone to boom and bust than energy. ???Imagine the news stories a few years from now: "Crisis hangover -- energy stocks sink as prices plunge; But California consumers still stuck with high bills." ???"The energy industry is suffering its worst downturn since the supply glut of the 1990s, as dozens of big new power plants come on line, and the just-completed Alaskan gas pipeline sends natural gas prices to their lowest levels in six years. ???"The one bright spot for Texas generators is California, where consumers are locked into long-term contracts for wholesale electricity that the state signed at the peak of its blackouts in the summer of 2001. ???"Sacramento lawmakers have appealed to President Daschle to help get the state off the hook, arguing that California will never claw its way out of its economic slump if businesses continue to flee to states where energy is cheap. ???"But top Enron lobbyist Gray Davis, a former governor of California, warned Daschle that suppliers would have little choice but to go to court to enforce the contracts the state signed." ???Washington and Sacramento are agog with the energy crisis and bursting at the seams with plans to fix it. But the one thing no one -- even environmentalists -- suggests is letting high energy prices discourage energy consumption or encourage new supplies. ???"To economists, letting the price rise is the solution," said Paul Portney, president of Resources for the Future, a Washington think tank. "To elected representatives, having the price go up is the problem." ???Political memories tend to be selective and short. But it was the energy glut of the 1990s that contributed to California's blackouts, $3 gasoline and $ 400-a-month heating bills. Likewise, high prices are now laying the seeds of their own destruction. ???As a story in the New York Times noted, an energy investment boom "promises a cyclical increase in supplies that is expected to stabilize or reduce prices in coming months, many industry executives and private analysts say." ???Through much of the 1990s, there was a glut of energy. Fuel of all kinds was really cheap. ???How cheap? Adjusted for inflation, as cheap as in 1949, economists calculate. ???Energy is the oxygen of the economy, and rock-bottom prices contributed to the long economic boom. But low prices also caused energy production to slump and consumption to soar. ???People ditched their economy cars for SUVs. Houses got bigger, ceilings got higher and kitchens sprouted industrial stoves with enough BTUs to melt aluminum. Stores, offices and homes turned into summertime refrigerators. ???Low prices discouraged energy development. ???"Oil was so cheap for so long, that people were selling their refineries," Portney said. "You had virtually no exploration for new natural gas when prices were at $2 a BTU." ???As demand soared and supply fell, prices rose. Profits have grown so robust that green fuels, such as biomass and wind, are becoming economically viable. The oil industry is booming. Refineries are expanding. The long-delayed construction of a natural gas pipeline from Alaska now looks likely. So many power plants are under construction that the market may be flooded with as much as 200,000 new megawatts by 2004. ???Investments in energy efficiency -- from new-age superconducting transmission wires to better light bulbs -- are suddenly looking attractive for the first time in decades. ???"High prices will dampen demand, high prices will encourage supply, and will encourage people to make better use of what they've got," said Robert Ebel, director of energy for the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "So we're starting on the down slope. We're not very far down. When prices start to decline, I can't say how far they will go. But they will decline, because that's just the law of supply and demand. Prices decline, demand starts to creep up again, there's less incentive to add to supply, and here we go again."E-mail Carolyn Lochhead at clochhead@sfchronicle.com LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????18 of 143 DOCUMENTS ????????????????Copyright 2001 News World Communications, Inc. ?????????????????????????????The Washington Times ?????????????????????June 04, 2001, Monday, Final Edition SECTION: PART A; COMMENTARY; Pg. A14 LENGTH: 805 words HEADLINE: Shedding light on Bush's energy plan BYLINE: Charli Coon BODY: ??If the opponents of President Bush's energy policy were as quick and creative about finding solutions to our energy woes as they are about criticizing the policy, we'd be exporting kilowatts to every corner of the globe by now. ??Depending on whom you talk to, the president is: pandering to the oil lobby, masquerading as a conservationist, focusing too much on long-term solutions, destroying the environment or creating an artificial crisis. ??They're wrong. ?The plan makes a good deal of sense largely because the president understands basic economics. ?His plan takes a giant step toward allowing the market to correct the current imbalance between supply and demand. ??Some people urge more conservation. ?That's fine, and conservation should be encouraged on a personal level (no need to run the home air conditioner on a 74-degree day). But conservation can't solve the problem by itself. ??The other 49 states can learn a lot from California, where the recipe for blackouts has been perfected. ?Just add excessive federal regulations that boost the cost of electrical production and discourage new production to a flawed deregulation plan. ?Mix in price controls, and you've got a market for flashlights. ??But it's not just California. ?Bad energy policies have affected the whole country, with consumers elsewhere experiencing higher gasoline prices and rising utility bills. ?Failing to deal with these problems will threaten America's prosperity. ??President Bush's energy plan is designed to increase supply through a variety of measures, including improvements to the nation's aging energy infrastructure. While not perfect, his plan would move America past an energy policy based on crisis management to one that can meet the needs of future generations. Consider some highlights. ??More Electricity: Since 1973, U.S. ?energy consumption has increased by about 30 percent - roughly the same as our population growth. ?Simply put, there are more people using energy to power their homes, cars, air conditioners, televisions and computers. ?But the number of power plants and lines hasn't increased in proportion to the population surge, so prices have risen. ??President Bush wants to increase the energy supply by building new power plants, opening a tiny portion of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil and gas development (a move supported by trade unions such as the Teamsters), and developing new technologies for alternative fuels. ?The president supports this because he knows price controls don't work. ?They encourage consumption and impede investment. ??Nuclear power now: President Bush also would increase the energy supply through nuclear power. ?Opponents are quick to raise the specter of Three Mile Island or even Chernobyl. ?But the Three Mile Island accident involved only a tiny amount of leakage in the first place and no loss of life or widespread increase in disease. ?As for Chernobyl, no plant in this country ever has or will operate with so little regard for safety. ??Besides, nuclear power plants already supply about 20 percent of U.S. electricity, and hardly anyone complains. ?Yes, more nuclear power means more nuclear waste - which is why the president urges the use of a centralized waste site far from population centers. ??More trade for oil: President Bush wants to trade with more nations for oil, and his proposal couldn't come at a better time. ?About 56 percent of the oil the United States uses is imported, mostly from the Middle East. In contrast, when we had our first energy crisis in 1973, only 35 percent of our oil came from foreign sources. ??The president would expand oil and gas trade agreements with Canada and Mexico, and he wants to trade more with oil-producing countries other than those in the Middle East, such as countries in Africa, the Caspian Sea region and South America. ?In short, oil is a global - not a regional - commodity, and we should shop accordingly. ??The president's plan has its weak spots. ?For example, it would throw even more federal money at alternative fuel sources, such as clean coal technology, wind, solar, hybrid gas-electric cars and organic waste. ?But despite the billions of taxpayer dollars that have been spent so far on alternative energy, we've developed enough affordable power from those sources to meet only 3 percent of our energy demands. ??For the most part, though, the president's plan represents a responsible approach to the energy crisis. ?Let's hope Congress gives it the serious consideration it deserves. ?To do otherwise could carry long-term consequences. Any response that isn't market-based can't help but leave everyone in the dark. ??Charli Coon is an energy policy analyst at the Heritage Foundation. ?A longer version of this article recently appeared in the San Diego Calif. ?Union Tribune. LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????20 of 143 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????The Associated Press State & Local Wire The materials in the AP file were compiled by The Associated Press. ?These materials may not be republished without the express written consent of The Associated Press. ????????????????????????June 4, 2001, Monday, BC cycle ????????????????????????????12:09 AM Eastern Time SECTION: State and Regional LENGTH: 745 words HEADLINE: Developments in California's energy crisis BODY: ??Developments in California's energy crisis: ??SUNDAY: ??- The state energy commission announces that Californians sliced their electricity use in May by 11 percent compared to the same month last year. Residents and businesses cut their electricity demand by 3,595 megawatts in May compared to last year. One megawatt is enough to power about 750 homes. Energy use during peak demand hours decreased in May by about 10 percent over the same period last year. In April this year, monthly electricity use was down by 7 percent over the previous year. ??- More than 6,500 businesses - from pet cemeteries to bakeries to tattoo parlors - have applied with the state Public Utilities Commission in hopes of being spared during rolling blackouts. The high demand prompted the PUC to extend the deadline from Friday to Monday. Thousands of institutions, such as fire and police stations, military bases and hospitals, are already exempted from rolling blackouts because the PUC considers their services essential to public health and safety. ??- The federal agency in charge of monitoring and policing California's power system was warned by experts both inside the agency and out of potential deregulation flaws such as the price gouging that now fuels the state's power crisis, the Los Angeles Times and the San Jose Mercury News both report. ??Though the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is charged with ensuring the price of energy is "just and reasonable," just three months into the 1998 launch of California's deregulation experiment, energy traders tested their ability to manipulate the market by offering a megawatt-hour of electricity for $9,999 - the highest price they thought trading computers could accept. Electricity had been trading below $100 per megawatt-hour. ??- California will blow through most of the $12.5 billion Gov. Gray Davis hopes to borrow to head off summer blackouts over the next two months, the Orange County Register reports. The state currently spends $66.9 million a day on electricity. If it continues at this pace, it will have spent $10.4 billion - or 83 percent - of what it plans to borrow through a bond sale by mid-August. That leaves only $2.1 billion to buy future energy. The state estimates it needs at least $2.7 billion to pay for such contracts just through June 2002. Davis' energy team says dropping energy prices and long-term contracts will help stretch the money. ??WHAT'S NEXT: ??- Davis' representatives continue negotiating with Sempra, the parent company of San Diego Gas and Electric Co., to buy the utility's transmission lines. ??-In federal bankruptcy court Monday, Calpine Corp. asks U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali to order Pacific Gas and Electric to free Calpine's small power plants from contracts to provide the bankrupt utility with electricity or else let them stop producing electricity. PG&E will also ask Montali to stop the manager of the state's power grid from buying future electricity for PG&E or charging it for any electricity bought after the utility filed for bankruptcy April 6. ??THE PROBLEM: ??High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. ??Edison and PG&E say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. ??Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the two companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power costs. ??The Public Utilities Commission has approved average rate increases of 37 percent for the heaviest residential customers and 38 percent for commercial customers, and hikes of up to 49 percent for industrial customers and 15 percent or 20 percent for agricultural customers to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????23 of 143 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????The Associated Press State & Local Wire The materials in the AP file were compiled by The Associated Press. ?These materials may not be republished without the express written consent of The Associated Press. ????????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday, BC cycle SECTION: State and Regional LENGTH: 839 words HEADLINE: Critics say FERC ignored California's deregulation flaws DATELINE: FOLSOM, Calif. BODY: ??The federal agency in charge of monitoring and policing California's power system was warned by experts both inside the agency and out of potential deregulation flaws such as the price gouging that now fuels the state's power crisis. ??The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has a legal obligation to ensure "just and reasonable" prices, and is meant to operate as an oversight agency, similar to the Federal Securities Commission that oversees Wall Street. ??However, just three months into the 1998 launch California's deregulation experiment, energy traders tested their ability to manipulate the market by offering a megawatt-hour of electricity for $9,999 - the highest price they thought trading computers could accept. Electricity had been trading below $100 per megawatt-hour. ??FERC may have set itself up for problems by eagerly promoting deregulation, despite red flags from one of the nation's top deregulation experts and the agency's own staff members, including its economists, according to interviews and a review of hundreds of documents published Sunday by the San Jose Mercury News and the Los Angeles Times. ??"There were a lot of issues that got swept under the rug," said economist Carolyn A. Berry, who headed FERC's analysis of the California plan. "We were trying to point out the ugly warts, but it wasn't our job to set policy." ??But Curtis Hebert Jr., who took over as FERC's chairman in January, insists the agency isn't failing to investigate the energy industry. FERC's job is to make the market competitive, which will bring lower prices, he said. ??"We do have enough resources, and we are handling it in a way that's appropriate," Hebert said of California's energy crisis. ??Before deregulation began, FERC commissioners, generating companies, utilities and politicians argued that a deregulated market for electricity - as was done with natural gas - would reduce prices and increase competition. In 1992, Congress passed a law encouraging open access, and in the mid-1990s, a draft plan was started for the California Public Utilities Commission. ??Bill Hogan, a deregulation expert from Harvard University, said he was hired to analyze the state's plan for San Diego Gas & Electric Co. He wrote a 71-page report citing potential price spikes and other problems to be presented at FERC's deregulation hearings in the summer of 1996. ??That report was eventually withdrawn after the utility was pressured to join the deregulation bandwagon if it wanted to have a say in the final plan, said Bill Reed, chief regulatory officer for the utility's parent company. ??Once the California Legislature passed the bill in 1996, it essentially gave FERC the sole authority to intervene when wholesale power prices soar. ??But FERC also had the final say on each part of the plan before it was implemented. Some say the agency did not promote internal debate, and add that the plan was already charging forward and would have been politically difficult to stop. ??"There was great resistance on the part of many people at the commission to undo the process that California sent in," Berry said. "There was a reluctance to start pulling at the threads for fear that the whole package might fall apart." ??At that same time, FERC officials also were working on a $12.7 million plan reorganize the agency's staff and upgrade computers. ??Then came the hot July day in 1998 when energy traders charged nearly $10,000 for a megawatt-hour of electricity to test the waters. The Independent System Operator, manager of California's power grid, was forced to buy the power to keep the grid from crashing. ??The ISO then requested that FERC grant an emergency price cap, which it did. But ISO officials continued to warn the federal agency that this was just the beginning. ??"I don't think they had any thought of what the potential was," said Anjali Sheffrin, the ISO's market surveillance director who visited the agency twice in the fall of 1999 in an effort to convince FERC officials of potential dangers. ??James Hoecker, who served as FERC's chairman during the transition to deregulation, now disagrees with the way in which deregulation was pushed through in California. He says more attention should have been given to critical analysis. ??"I would have liked for the commission to be more prepared for California," he said. ??FERC has approved deregulation plans in New England, New York and the mid-Atlantic states. But FERC officials point out they only oversee wholesale energy prices, while state officials are responsible for the local utilities and other retailers selling power to customers. ??Over the past few months, FERC has ordered a dozen companies to justify their high prices or pay $124.5 million to California utilities for January and February. Williams Cos. of Tulsa, Okla., also settled for $8 million after being accused of shutting down power plants last spring to spike prices. ??--- ??On the Net: ??http://www.ferc.gov ??http://www.caiso.com LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????25 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ???????????????????????Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ????????????????????????????The Charlotte Observer ?????????????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday SECTION: STATE AND REGIONAL NEWS KR-ACC-NO: ?K1149 LENGTH: 1806 words HEADLINE: Duke Energy rates spike in emergency BYLINE: By Stella M. Hopkins and Peter Wallsten BODY: ??SACRAMENTO, Calif. _ As Duke Energy faces accusations of price gouging in California's escalating energy crisis, the Charlotte, N.C., company acknowledges it has sold power to one wholesale customer for more than twice the highest previously reported price. ??For several days in January, Duke Energy charged the California Independent System Operator $3,880 per megawatt hour. That's about as much electricity as the average Duke Power residential customer in the Carolinas uses in one month. That average Duke Power customer pays about $73 a month. ??Duke's $3,880 charge is twice the $1,900 rate that brought another power generator harsh criticism in May from California Gov. Gray Davis, who is battling President Bush to impose caps on the state's skyrocketing wholesale energy prices. ??The ISO sale came to light during a Knight Ridder analysis of federal documents that provide a rare public look at closely guarded pricing in California's convoluted energy market. After that analysis, Duke also gave pricing data it has previously refused to release. ??Duke says its average wholesale price in California last year was $76 per megawatt hour. ??For the first three months this year, which includes the high ISO sale, Duke said its average sales price was $136 a megawatt hour. ??"On average, Duke's prices are not 'gouging prices,'" said Nancy DeSchane, a vice president with Duke Energy's trading arm in Salt Lake City. ??Wildly gyrating energy prices are the product of California's effort to deregulate its electric industry. Legislators intended the move to foster competition and lower prices. Instead, prices soared _ sometimes to unheard-of extremes. Duke Energy, whose Duke Power unit is the largest Carolinas utility, is a key player in California, where it is one of five generators accounting for 30 percent of power production. ??In the past year, Duke's highest-priced sales seesawed, then rose sharply. Last spring, Duke's top charge was $1,100 per megawatt hour. ??During the summer, the high dropped to $554, then rose to $1,021 last winter and topped out at $3,880 during the first three months of this year. ??Duke said its rate for the ISO sale reflected higher fuel costs, the cost of running an extremely inefficient unit of one plant and a poor-credit surcharge representing up to 80 percent of the total charge to a buyer that hadn't paid its bills. The sales came during times of extreme power shortages, including two days when the ISO called blackouts, Duke said. ??Duke's total sale to the ISO at $3,880 was 5,000 megawatt hours _ $19.4 million. The sale represented less than 1 percent of the 10 million megawatt hours Duke sold in California during the first three months of the year. ??Most wholesale rate increases hadn't been passed on to Californians, but starting today, residential consumers begin receiving bills reflecting the largest rate increase in California history. Depending on use levels, consumers will pay two to three times the rate Duke Power charges its Carolinas customers. ??The analysis of Duke's quarterly reports filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission led the company to identify significant errors in reports. The reports, for example, listed one sale late last year for $4,845. Duke said the actual charge was $758. The company volunteered the $3,880 transaction, which had been reported as $250. ??Duke will file amended reports. ??"We have a number of erroneous items," DeSchane said. "It was not intentional." ??The commission is required by federal law to assure "just and reasonable" prices, and the reports are one mechanism for monitoring prices. ??Despite errors, the reports remain the best publicly available source of pricing information that Duke and other generators have fought to keep confidential. ??The demands for pricing data come as the generators face lawsuits and state and federal investigations into claims of profiteering and price manipulation. The companies are resisting subpoenas from a state Senate committee investigating their business practices. The companies say price disclosure hurts their ability to compete. ??"The fact that they are so insistent on confidentiality is very disturbing to me," said state Sen. Joe Dunn, the Orange County Democrat chairing the committee. "If (the allegation of market manipulation) isn't true, then why are they insisting on secrecy?" ??In its quarterly federal reports, Duke lists the total power sold and the lowest and highest price for each customer. But Duke doesn't have to say how much power was sold at what price, so there's no way to calculate Duke's total California sales from the report. ??The documents also show about 10 percent of Duke's sales volume came in what's called the spot market, a highly volatile, daily trading market. ??The ISO sale at $3,880 was a last-minute sale, similar to those on the spot market, driven by heavy demand. The $1,900 charge that angered the California governor was a last-minute sale by Houston generator Reliant to avert blackouts. ??In releasing the confidential pricing, Davis called Reliant's price "obscene." ??He has called generators "the biggest snakes" and warned plant seizures could be the ultimate penalty. ??For January and February trades _ which includes Duke's $3,880 sale to the ISO _ the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has ordered generators to refund $124 million in overcharges, including $20 million from Duke. The company has said it will gladly refund those fees _ if it ever gets paid. ??Duke stands by the credit surcharge policy it developed as cash-strapped utilities stopped paying mounting bills. When the utilities stopped paying the ISO, that agency couldn't pay traders such as Duke. ??The ISO, created under deregulation, oversees the state's electrical transmission system and is charged with ensuring the system has enough power to meet demand. ??When the system runs short, the ISO buys power at what are typically high, last-minute prices. If there is no power to buy, the ISO calls for blackouts. Generators must sell available power to the ISO. ??"We were forced to sell (to the ISO) and had an obligation to our shareholders to assess the risks," Duke's DeSchane said of the decision to levy a credit surcharge. "Nobody has paid bills yet." ??The company has set aside $110 million to cover anticipated refunds and unpaid bills. ??The federal reports also show Duke sold 90 percent of its power this year and 70 percent last year on contracts ranging from a few days to more than a month. ??Duke says most of these contracts actually range from one to four years. ??Pre-selling power means Duke forgoes the chance to make potentially larger profits selling that power on the spot market. If a plant shutdown or other problem prevented the company from producing power, Duke could be forced to buy on the spot market to fulfill the contract. ??Duke says it wants the stability of long-term contracts. When Duke agrees to sell power, it also buys fuel to produce that energy. That means Duke locks in sales and its largest cost. ??Return on investment ??Duke entered the California market in 1998 by buying three power plants for $ 501 million. In 1999, the company signed a 10-year lease on a fourth plant. ??The company expected tight supplies, which likely meant strong prices, because California hadn't seen a major power plant built in 10 years. But, like much of California's leadership, Duke didn't forecast the severe shortages that have led to blackouts. ??The result is a market in which sellers can charge prices far higher than elsewhere in the country. ??Duke readily admits California profits have exceeded its expectations, although the company won't say how much money it has made in California. ??This year, profits quadrupled in the unit that includes Duke's California plants as well as plants outside its regulated Duke Power territory in the Carolinas. ??Duke calls the unit's earnings rise to $348 million from $82 million "stellar." ??The unit accounted for 27 percent of the Fortune 100 company's pre-tax earnings, compared with 10 percent a year ago. Critics say generators' profits come on the backs of Californians. ??Some economists and California politicians say generators' prices violate federal requirements that electricity prices be "just and reasonable." ??"The generators are charging whatever they can get in the market," said Frank Wolak, a Stanford University economist with access to confidential pricing data. ??"In economics, when there is a financial incentive for something to happen, it usually does." ??The criticism haunts Duke veterans, sent from the Carolinas to make a go of the company's California gamble. ??"We're out here on the new frontier, where they don't know Duke from Adam," said Randy Vigor, who helped build Duke's nuclear plants on Lake Wylie and Lake Norman and now heads a $500 million expansion at one of Duke's California plants. "We're getting blamed for a lot of things that aren't Duke's fault." ??In July _ before the big run-up in prices _ Duke offered Davis the chance to buy enough electricity to power 2 million homes at $50 a megawatt hour. Davis did not act on the offer. ??"At that point, prices were still lower than that," said Steve Maviglio, Davis' press secretary. "No one in a million years expected prices to rise as much as they have since then. ??"Where is that offer today is the better question." ??The answer, Duke says, is that the power has been sold. ??"We feverishly attempted to provide a set of solutions to all the California folks," said Duke Chief Executive Rick Priory. ??He includes in those attempts the offer Duke lawyers sent this spring to Davis, saying it would forgive millions in utility debts in exchange for an end to investigations. The move backfired when the offer became public May 2, dragging Duke into a harsh spotlight. ??"They were clearly trying to call off the dogs," Maviglio said. "They realize this a public relations nightmare." ??In similar past exchanges, Duke has said the "dogs won't find anything." ??Priory says he doesn't regret making the offer, that it was an attempt to settle disputes and get on with building desperately needed power plants. ??He says California remains important _ and welcome _ in Duke's portfolio. ??"Our experiences in California have generally been positive. The one negative is the political rhetoric, but we know this problem will be solved, and that will be toned down," Priory said. ??Meanwhile, he added: "We're just focused on producing every kilowatt of electricity we can." ??KRT CALIFORNIA is a premium service of Knight Ridder/Tribune ??(c) 2001, The Charlotte Observer (Charlotte, N.C.). ??Visit The Charlotte Observer on the World Wide Web at http://www.charlotte.com/ JOURNAL-CODE: CH LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????26 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ???????????????????????Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ??????????????????????????????Contra Costa Times ?????????????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday SECTION: STATE AND REGIONAL NEWS KR-ACC-NO: ?K1314 LENGTH: 653 words HEADLINE: Judge refuses to override PUC over PG&E bankruptcy BYLINE: By Matt Sebastian BODY: ??SAN FRANCISCO _ Fearing "jurisdictional chaos," the federal judge overseeing Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy has refused to override the California Public Utilities Commission, a decision that could keep the utility's electricity rates capped for another year. ??U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali, in a 30-page written ruling issued late Friday afternoon, declined to block state regulators from adopting new bookkeeping rules that effectively cap PG&E's consumer rates through March 31. ??The judge found that the PUC may perform its regulatory duties even while the utility is in the midst of a Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization. PG&E had sought an injunction against the commission, saying it will lose $4 billion over the next year if rates remain capped. ??In plain language, Montali addressed those who saw the proceeding as a precursor to action by the court to raise consumer electricity rates as part of any future reorganization plan. ??The ruling "is not about a power struggle between a federal bankruptcy court and an agency of the executive branch of California government nor is it about setting retail electricity rates," Montali wrote. ??PG&E officials vowed to pursue other legal challenges to the commission's new accounting rules, including petitions before the PUC itself, and in state and federal court. ??"Pacific Gas & Electric Co. is disappointed that the court did not grant immediate relief from the unlawful and retroactive CPUC order," the company said in a written statement. "However, today's decision was not on the overall merits of the CPUC action." ??Commission President Loretta Lynch, also in a written statement, lauded the ruling as a "ringing affirmation of our position that the CPUC will continue to require PG&E to serve its customers." ??Under California's deregulation of the energy market, PG&E's customer rates have been fixed since 1998 to allow the utility to pay down "stranded costs" _ money spent on unprofitable investments like nuclear power. ??The statutory rate freeze is scheduled to end March31, although PG&E can apply to lift the cap if it recoups its $7 billion in stranded costs before that date. The utility, in fact, applied to end the rate freeze last fall. ??For the first year and a half of deregulation, low wholesale costs meant PG&E recovered billions of dollars more from its ratepayers than it was paying for their energy. ??But when wholesale prices exploded last summer, PG&E quickly found itself spending far more for energy than it could legally charge its ratepayers. In less than a year, the utility says it has been unable to pass on $8.9 billion in energy costs. ??The new accounting rules, adopted March 27, will force PG&E to hold its profits from the first half of the deregulation to its losses in the last year, thereby quashing the utility's claims it has already met the threshold to end the rate freeze. ??The PUC had argued that, as a state agency, it enjoys sovereign immunity from prosecution. The judge ruled that the commission isn't entirely immune, but he found that the one exemption _ in cases where federal law is violated _ didn't apply. ??Also Friday, Montali refused to free a group of alternative energy generators from their contracts with PG&E. The power producers, known as qualifying facilities, had sought to sell their electricity on the open market, where they could command much higher prices. ??Instead, the judge ordered PG&E to pay the generators up to 20 percent of the tens of millions of dollars they're owed. ??"We're pleased the judge moved up the time frame under which our generators get paid," said attorney Bruce Leaverton, who represents four cogeneration plants in the San Joaquin Valley. ??KRT CALIFORNIA is a premium service of Knight Ridder/Tribune ??(c) 2001, Contra Costa Times (Walnut Creek, Calif.). ??Visit the Contra Costa Times on the Web at http://www.cctimes.com/ JOURNAL-CODE: CC LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????27 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ???????????????????????Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ??????????????????????????????Contra Costa Times ?????????????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday SECTION: STATE AND REGIONAL NEWS KR-ACC-NO: ?K1316 LENGTH: 731 words HEADLINE: Gloomy electricity supply forecast in June may have been optimistic BYLINE: By Mike Taugher and Rick Jurgens BODY: ??WALNUT CREEK, Calif. _ An electricity supply forecast for gloom in June was based on overly optimistic assumptions about how many plants would be off-line. ??The gloomy prediction was based on an historic average of 2,500 megawatts from power plants being unavailable for maintenance or breakdowns. ??In fact, plants producing 8,500 megawatts were off-line Friday and that figure is not expected to get down to 3,000 megawatts until the end of June. ??Whether the 5,500 megawatt difference will translate into more blackouts will depend on the weather and the availability of power from other states. ??State grid managers in March predicted that California would be short enough power to serve about 3 million homes during the hottest afternoons this month. ??Still, the Independent System Operator, originator of the March forecast, said Friday that it does not expect the conclusions to change by all that much in a revised forecast next week. The bottom line: California faces a shortage of up to 3,600 megawatts this month. ??"Things right now are extremely tight and will be through June," said ISO vice president for grid operations, Jim Detmers. ??In the push-pull of good and bad news, some brighter elements appeared: An 1,100 megawatt nuclear powered unit in Southern California forced off-line by fire in February was ramping up Friday, several weeks ahead of schedule. ??Despite record temperatures in Northern California _ heat that also melted snow and temporarily increased the supply of power from electricity-generating dams _ no rolling blackouts occurred. ??"The imports were up because of the water coming down, and the mild weather down south, that's what made the difference," Detmers said. ??In a related development, the ISO _ under protest _ met a Friday deadline from federal regulators to submit a plan for greater cooperation with grid operators in neighboring states. ??But the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's deadline was illegal and improper, ISO General Counsel Charlie Robinson said in a conference call. The FERC made submission of a "regional transmission organization" plan a condition for activating measures to rein in illegally high prices in the California wholesale electricity market. ??Gov. Gray Davis reiterated his complaint that the FERC plan falls short. ??"There are more loopholes than Swiss cheese in FERC's order," Davis said in a written statement issued late Friday. ??The ISO's plan ceded no control of the transmission grid and preserved "the limited price mitigation offered by FERC," Davis said. ??The FERC, committed to promoting competition in the electricity industry, has prioritized consolidation of the regulation and operation of the high-voltage transmission lines that carry electricity thousands of miles from generating plants to users. ??Merging the California grid into a broader network is "something we're not prepared to even worry about" until California's electricity market has stabilized and its utilities restored to financial health, said ISO Chairman Michael Kahn. ??In any case, the federal agency can not create "regional institutions by regulatory fiat," the ISO said in its filing, which also asserted that the ISO itself already meets the FERC's criteria for such regional grids. ??Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric, which own transmission lines operated by the ISO, signed onto its filing. ??Pacific Gas & Electric Co., the owner of a majority of the transmission lines in the ISO operation, dissented. In a separate filing PG&E urged federal regulators to put more pressure on the ISO to join a regional grid. ??PG&E, which has repeatedly locked horns with Davis during the state's energy crisis, noted that he had appointed the current ISO board and urged the FERC to seek "adequate assurances that the decision-making process at the California ISO will be truly independent." The current five-member board includes two members of the Davis administration. ??FERC has yet to sign off on the ISO's current governance structure, which came through legislation passed in January after FERC ruled the previous board was "comprised of stakeholders who are perceived as being susceptible to influence." ??KRT CALIFORNIA is a premium service of Knight Ridder/Tribune ??(c) 2001, Contra Costa Times (Walnut Creek, Calif.). ??Visit the Contra Costa Times on the Web at http://www.cctimes.com/ JOURNAL-CODE: CC LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????31 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????June 3, 2001 Sunday ?Home Edition SECTION: California; Part 2; Page 3; Metro Desk LENGTH: 915 words HEADLINE: Los Angeles; ; Key Figures Trade Views of Energy Picture; Forum: Most of the 12 discussing crisis agree only on blaming federal regulators. They find no consensus on a solution. BYLINE: JOE MOZINGO, TIMES STAFF WRITER BODY: ??Some of the major players in the state's energy crisis met in a Hollywood studio Saturday for a sometimes contentious panel discussion in which they resoundingly criticized federal regulators and disagreed over possible solutions. ??Although there was no clear consensus on strategy, Gov. Gray Davis' chief energy advisor, S. David Freeman, echoed sentiments the governor has expressed in saying the end of the electricity shortage is in sight. ??A combination of new power plants and increased conservation, along with long-term, lower-rate contracts between the state and energy providers, should create a 15% power surplus within several years, he said. ??"The same companies that are charging an arm and a leg now are negotiating five- and 10-year contracts at prices that are reasonable," Freeman said, though not specifying which producers. "By 2003, I'm certain we will have this problem behind us." ??Critics have widely disputed this claim. And some of Saturday's other panelists--including the president of Southern California Edison, the president of Sempra Energy, a state utilities commissioner and the speaker of the state Assembly--said they were not as confident about the future, especially if the federal government doesn't step in with price caps. ??During last week's visit to California, President Bush reiterated his opposition to such intervention. ??The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission "is on a sit-down strike," said Carl Wood, of the state Public Utilities Commission. "They should start regulating or just announce they are out of the business." ??Several of the 12 panelists also complained that the federal agency is not regulating the cost of transporting natural gas through pipelines--a price that has skyrocketed by a factor of 30 in recent years. ??Natural gas is the primary fuel for most new power plants. ??John Stout, senior vice president of Texas-based Reliant Energy, blamed those exorbitant fuel costs for the high prices his company has been charging on the spot market in California. ??Half-jokingly introduced by the moderator as the "bad guy," Stout said the company's rates--if the cost of natural gas were factored out--would be lower than those the investor-owned utilities like Edison had charged before deregulation. ??"Two-thirds of every dollar we get goes to natural gas," he said. ??Stout was the sole panelist to also defend the federal regulators, saying they audit Reliant every time its prices go up. ??Freeman disputed Stout's assertions and math, saying there is no proportional correlation between high electricity prices and the increase in costs of natural gas--a business, he noted, Reliant is also involved in. ??"You're in the gas business and the gas people are ripping us off as bad as the electrical people," he said. ??Loretta Lynch, president of the Public Utilities Commission, found evidence that power generators scaled back electricity production and then benefited from the resulting high prices. Documents uncovered by The Times in April showed Freeman's own agency at the time, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, may also have engaged in driving the electricity prices skyward. ??As a municipal utility, the DWP has so far avoided the perils of deregulation, and managed to profit from it by selling its excess power on the market. Now, Freeman is in the ironic position of pushing his former agency to sell its surplus power this summer to the state, instead of on the open market where it could generate larger profits. ??The current assistant general manager of DWP said he is negotiating such a contract, but there are risks. "We are purchasing on the spot market the gas we need to produce the power," he said. ??Freeman sounded more confident about the contract. "We want one and we're going to get one." ??Asked afterward if he would have made such an agreement if he were still at the DWP, Freeman said, "Of course." ??Saturday's KFWB (AM-980) Energy Summit was held in the CBS studio that most recently housed the sitcom "Two Guys and a Girl" and consisted of two panels of six speakers each. Freeman gave the keynote address and joined the first discussion. ??The second forum dealt with a wider range of ideas on how to cope with the crisis, but was noticeably short on concrete plans. One speaker said "two guys and a girl" could do a better job finding a solution, while actor and conservationist Ed Begley Jr. discussed the potential of solar and wind power and recounted a drive he took across the country in a hybrid car recently, which cost him $72 in gasoline. ??Assembly Speaker Bob Hertzberg (D-Sherman Oaks) proposed a plan in which large power consumers would negotiate their own contracts with energy suppliers, while residents and small business owners would still get their electricity from the utilities. ??And a UCLA economist claimed that speculation of major economic fallout from the rate increases is overstated. "Even if you pay higher rates, the average consumer is going to pay less overall than the consumer in Arizona and Nevada," said Chris Thornberg. "It's not going to have the economic impact that some people think." ??The president of the California Chamber of Commerce, Allan Zaremberg, disagreed. He said companies that use lots of power--drywall manufacturers and food processors, for example--would be compelled to leave the state, creating a vacuum that could have dire economic effects. ??"Nobody has got an endgame here," he said. LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????32 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????June 3, 2001 Sunday ?Home Edition SECTION: California; Part 2; Page 1; Metro Desk LENGTH: 828 words HEADLINE: Thanks for Your Concern, Wall Street BYLINE: PETER H. KING DATELINE: SAN FRANCISCO BODY: ??A few odds and ends, mostly odds, from the energy front: ??The first comes via Bloomberg News, the financial information service. In a dispatch filed Thursday--a day that saw California slide to within minutes of yet another round of rolling blackouts--Bloomberg offered, without a whit of irony, an upbeat near-term analysis of the U.S. energy industry. ??Profits among energy traders and generators, a Wall Street analyst told Bloomberg, could rise by as much as 30% this year. The reason, the dispatch explained, was that "electricity and natural-gas traders are profiting from deregulation. . . ." What's more, "many benefited last quarter as increased demand sent prices surging in California and other parts of the U.S." ??This belaboring of the obvious was followed by a quote from the Merrill Lynch & Co. analyst. Looking ahead to the summer, Steven Fleishman could hardly contain his enthusiasm: "Hot weather," he chirped, "could be the cream on the top." ??So there it is, Californians. ??Our crisis is their cream. ??Wall Street loves us. ??The energy companies love us. ??We are making so many wonderful people so wonderfully rich. ??Last Friday was the deadline for Californians seeking exemptions from blackouts to file their case with the state Public Utilities Commission. Among the applicants is John Lee Hooker's Boom Boom Room, a blues club in San Francisco's Fillmore district. Because exemptions will be granted only to those who provide "essential" services--who can demonstrate, for example, that a power cutoff might cost lives--the Boom Boom Room's case is hardly a dunk by Shaq. ??Still, Boom Boom owner Alex Andreas gamely gave it a shot. ??"If the lights went out during a show," he told a San Francisco Chronicle reporter, "there would be a huge panic, and people would freak out." ??As it happens, a similar stampede of exemption-seekers occurred during California's power crisis of 1948. (Yes, we are living a rerun, even down to the absurdities.) In a study conducted for the Institute of Government Studies at UC Berkeley, researcher Stuart A. Ross found that the 1948 roll call of those seeking to avoid service interruptions included: ??The California Bakers' Assn., which noted that "bread was essential to community health" . . . ??Union Ice Co., which argued that its ice was "used almost entirely for the preservation of food and hence was essential to the public health and safety" . . . ??The California Brewers Institute, which fretted about what might happen to "its vast quantities of beer in fermentation" . . . ??And the Market Street Assn. of retailers, which sent a representative to argue that lighted store-window displays deserved the same consideration as agricultural irrigation pumps: "Both bring sustenance and both depend on electricity." ??About a week ago, the idea of switching to regular, planned power outages--as opposed to unpredictable rolling blackouts--appeared to be gaining momentum. Alas, the governor and the energy bureaucrats instead have settled, at least for now, on a system in which warnings will be issued an hour or so in advance of any potential blackouts. In its debut Thursday, this approach seemed only to add to the general confusion, as the alarm turned out to be false. ??"It's a crapshoot," a state Chamber of Commerce official said afterward. "We're not going to get the level of precision that would be optimal, that would allow you to make a decision that would be foolproof." ??Let me make once again, briefly but with feeling, the case for scheduled outages. These outages would last, say, three or four hours and would unfold, on schedule, one or two workdays a week, whether they were needed or not--same days, same times for each customer. Just like garbage pickup day. ??In a single stroke, such a system--if properly calibrated and coordinated--could undermine any peak-hour manipulations by generators, saving truckloads of money, and spare Californians the inconvenience and even fear that comes from not knowing if the power will stay on through any given day. ??Factories, shops, agricultural concerns and the like could make plans. Backup generators could be rented rather than purchased. Shifts could be split. Retail store jewelry could be locked away safely in anticipation of the outage hours. Traffic officers could be dispatched in advance, not on the fly, to affected intersections. Invalids needing electricity for medical devices could be moved elsewhere. And so on. ??It requires no great feat of intellect to build a list of ways in which scheduled blackouts would be superior to rolling ones, even with one-hour warnings. A more difficult riddle is this: Why don't they want to do it? Every expert seems to agree that blackouts in some form are inevitable, so why not plan them out, beat the generators to the punch, seize control of the situation? What's to be gained by keeping Californians on edge through a long, hot summer? Just curious. LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????33 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????June 3, 2001 Sunday ?Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 1; National Desk LENGTH: 4230 words HEADLINE: The Nation; THE ENERGY CRISIS; Watchdogs Take a Hit in State's Power Ills; Energy: Ex-federal officials say oversight of California's deregulation suffered due to a push for free-market competition. BYLINE: JUDY PASTERNAK, ALAN C. MILLER, TIMES STAFF WRITERS DATELINE: WASHINGTON BODY: ??California was the first test, and right from the start economists at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission saw trouble coming. Their bosses were worried too. In hindsight, some admit they could have done better. ??But five years ago, when California officials were rushing to deregulate electricity, the federal watchdog charged by law with overseeing the process and guarding against runaway prices decided not to bark. ??In their zeal for free-market competition and their ideological commitment to shifting authority away from Washington to the states, FERC's commissioners brushed aside their qualms and let the process roll forward. ??"There were a lot of issues that got swept under the rug," said economist Carolyn A. Berry, who headed FERC's analysis of the California plan. "We were trying to point out the ugly warts, but it wasn't our job to set policy." ??Former FERC Chairman James J. Hoecker, who presided over the approval, said the agency "should have been far less deferential." John Rozsa, a state legislative analyst who played a key role in the deregulation law, laughed when he heard that. "FERC wanted it badly," he said. ??Today, FERC stands accused of failing to exercise its oversight, enforcement and political muscle just when they were needed most. The agency, critics on the inside and outside agree, helped launch a radical economics experiment without sufficient preparation, adequate staff or a clear sense of how to carry out its mission. ??With fully half the states considering deregulation, the story of what a previously obscure federal agency did not do has become more than a case study in regulatory shortcomings. It has become a warning shot across the bow of the whole country. ??FERC has approved deregulation plans in New England, New York and the mid-Atlantic states. At stake is a reliable supply of a commodity that fuels virtually every home and workplace in America. California's example is hardly encouraging: months of blackouts and an electric bill that has rocketed from $7 billion in 1999 to as much as $50 billion this year. ??Now the commission is caught in what some see as an identity crisis, divided and uncertain as politicians in California and Washington call for mutually contradictory action. ??"I think the commission needs to decide what it wants to do when it grows up," said Hoecker, who headed the agency during a critical period ending in January. His own leadership, he concedes, was not always all it might have been. ??Without question, there is ample blame for everyone, not just FERC. Certainly in California, state officials devised a flawed deregulation scheme and then insisted on carrying it out. Some power company executives have extracted windfall profits. Politicians have wilted when things went awry. ??And, as FERC officials continually point out, its authority is limited to wholesale markets. State officials are responsible for the local utilities and other retailers selling power to consumers. ??Nonetheless, it is FERC that Congress charged with overseeing electricity markets and assuring "just and reasonable" prices. ??How did FERC choose the course it took? What factors influenced its decisions? ??Certainly energy companies, consumer advocates, lawmakers and others lobbied the agency. ??Yet even FERC critics say such influence was not dominant. FERC is not insulated from lobbying, but David Nemtzow, president of the Alliance to Save Energy, a coalition of business, consumer and environmental leaders, said: "They are less sensitive to those forces than a lot of other players." ??Rather, this seems to have been a case of government decisions driven by ideology. The commissioners, both Republicans and Democrats, were wedded to the idea that deregulation at the wholesale level would lead to lower retail bills. The market, they believed, would inexorably produce greater competition, greater efficiency and falling prices. ??To Mark Cooper of the Consumer Federation of America, the primary problem was "their excessive faith in the market." ??Even after price spikes occurred across the Midwest and in California as early as 1998, FERC officials dismissed suggestions the surges might reflect market instability or manipulation. ??And as California's situation worsened, FERC's response was shaped by a continuing commitment to market forces with a minimum of government intervention--witness its April order allowing temporary price caps but only in narrowly defined emergencies. ??In the last few months, under enormous pressure, FERC has ordered a dozen companies to justify high prices or refund $124.5 million to California utilities for January and February. It won an $8-million settlement from Williams Cos. of Tulsa, Okla., which it had accused of shutting power plants last spring to drive up prices. Williams did not admit guilt. ??Detractors, including California officials, howl that FERC's actions are too little too late. They have called for a range of solutions, from flat-out price caps, as in the old days of full regulation, to much higher rebates from generators caught price-gouging, to retractions of individual firms' permission to charge market-based rates. ??If the agency chose to wield all of its authority, it also could force witnesses to testify under oath and subpoena tapes of phone calls among power traders, and even force the state to change the way the market operates. ??Curtis L. Hebert Jr., the free-market champion who succeeded Hoecker as chairman, insisted "FERC is being vigilant in its efforts to ensure just and reasonable rates, while at the same time ensuring" that it fosters new energy supplies. ??"I would vehemently disagree with anyone who says otherwise," he added, noting he transferred 75 attorneys--half of the agency's litigators--into market oversight. ??Still, a consensus that it's time for aggressive action seems to be forming among commissioners, including two nominees confirmed by the Senate last month: Patrick H. Wood III and Nora M. Brownell. ??Wood, a Texas utility regulator nominated by Bush and probably FERC's next chairman, said the agency needs to evolve into a "market cop with a great big old stick," adding: "There is a role that only the federal government can take. . . . The free market ain't a free and full market yet." ??Already named FERC's special liaison for California, Wood remains dedicated to market principles but vows to take a fresh look. ??Commissioner Linda Breathitt, a Democrat, also talks of change. And commissioner William L. Massey describes agency officials as naive in their past actions, in contrast to what he calls the "very sophisticated players" on the industry side. ??If some commissioners are starting to sound more like watchdogs, that's partly because they feel the tug of two conflicting ideas in their mandate to open markets while assuring fair prices. ??Americans have always loved the way capitalism gives opportunities to the shrewd and energetic. At the same time, the country has repeatedly turned to government regulation when it thought particular industries, such as the railroads, waxed too powerful. ??How well FERC deals with this intrinsic conflict and meets its challenges may have a sizable effect on the country's energy future. ??Frightened by events on the West Coast, some states have slowed their progress toward deregulation. Others have decided not to try at all, at least for now. ??"If the commission wants to have competitive markets," Hoecker said, "it's going to have to pull the bacon out of the fire." ??Though it traces roots back to the Federal Power Commission and development of hydroelectric power in the 1920s, FERC began its present incarnation in the 1980s, with the Reagan administration's deregulation campaign. ??FERC undertook to deregulate natural gas, then, spurred by a Democratic Congress and the first President Bush, it moved on to electricity. ??The problem is that electricity and its markets differ significantly from natural gas. Electric power cannot be stored to meet future shortages, as gas can. Its markets are more volatile. And the effect of shortages or price spikes cascades through the economy much faster. ??Without anyone quite realizing it, FERC was sailing into uncharted waters. ??Moreover, as FERC's staff took up the original California deregulation plan, it faced a significant constraint: The commissioners had made a conscious call to let the state have its way most of the time. ??As state officials saw it, so much power was available for the Western electrical grid that prices would surely come down. FERC economists, on the other hand, saw myriad problems. ??For example, the state's scheme called for generators to submit blind bids with a separate quote for each hour of the coming day. With any power plant, the unit cost is highest when a generator is started up and declines as it runs. So the price charged for later hours should be lower than for the first--but only if the operator can sell both the beginning and the later hours. ??Under the California blueprint, though, bidders could not be sure which hours the purchaser might buy. That meant bidders would have to load the higher start-up costs into each hour throughout the cycle to make sure those costs were recovered. By contrast, the mid-Atlantic market requires the power purchaser to add separate payments to cover start-up costs. ??Other issues were deferred rather than solved before FERC granted approval, including such questions as how to manage congestion on the grid and what the transmission rights should be for municipalities that generated and sold power. ??State legislative aide Rozsa argues that such matters were not crucial and that the biggest flaw in the plan--the insistence that the system operator not have any generators of its own--was conceived with FERC guidance. Both FERC and the state, he said, had "an exaggerated sense of their knowledge and ability." ??As the California launch, originally scheduled for January 1998, drew near, FERC's nervousness increased. As late as the Christmas holidays, the state was still tinkering. The agency ordered the state to provide two weeks' written notice before taking the final step, even though FERC had already approved the plan. ??When California finally "went to market," FERC analysts snickered at the timing: The first electricity auction was held March 31 for power to be delivered the next day--April Fool's Day. ??As for the commissioners, "We were somewhat naive," Massey said. "The commission believed there was so much inefficiency built into the old-fashioned . . . regime that any new market would be better." ??With the nation's largest state deregulating, FERC began blessing plans on the East Coast. Hundreds of companies lined up for permission to charge market rates in various open trade zones. ??FERC, according to its rules, was supposed to reject any firm that held a big enough share in a market--generally defined as about 20%--to influence prices for a sustained period. But doing the necessary market analyses proved impractical. ??For one thing, the rising workload was overwhelming the staff, which had shrunk by more than 25% from its 1980 high of 1,600 employees. The agency, as critics see it, simply buckled. ??"Once it got going, it took over," Berry said of the momentum behind deregulation. "FERC was handing out [permission] to anybody who walked in." ??FERC economist Steven A. Stoft was infuriated. He wanted to start cautiously, opening one small market, testing before expanding nationally. ??"To put in markets everywhere, to affect a lot of people, to just wait and see how it turns out, that's completely irresponsible," said Stoft, who now lives in California and is writing a book for regulators about how to design markets. ??At first, the staff Cassandras seemed wrong. Prices generally headed down. ??But during the summer of 1998, prices spiked twice--once in the Midwest, once in California. ??In the Midwest, several aging nuclear plants shut down for maintenance just as a heat wave sent air conditioners into overdrive. Wholesale electricity rose past $7,000 per megawatt-hour, 100 times normal. Consumers and politicians screamed. ??The weather cooled and new supply came in fast. Prices ebbed. ??To consumer groups and several FERC economists, the sudden increase suggested the worst can happen. Hoecker and FERC member Vicky Bailey drew a different lesson, as did a staff investigation: The market worked to correct an unusual confluence of events that was unlikely to recur. ??About the same time, a strange thing happened in California's reserve market, where the state's independent system operator pays generators with extra capacity to stand ready to meet unexpected surges in demand. ??So few companies offered to sign such contracts that the ISO sometimes had little choice but to accept whatever bid came in. It was just a matter of time before someone took advantage. One day in that summer of 1998 someone did: The only offer to provide reserve power was an astronomical $9,999 per megawatt-hour. ??To some, it was proof that the California market could--and would--be manipulated. "I was horrified," Berry said. ??FERC quickly granted California's request for permission to cap prices in the reserve. The authority quietly expired in November. There was no outcry about this spike because reserve costs are spread around to the states' utilities, thus diffusing their effect. ??"Of course, it should have been a warning that the sellers were several steps ahead of us," commissioner Massey says. ??In a memo last June, Ron Rattey, a senior FERC economist who has been with FERC since 1975, complained that the staff was "impotent in our ability to monitor, foster and ensure competitive electric power markets." He added in an interview: "FERC doesn't want todiscover that the policy changes it's making aren't working." ??Commissioners at the quasi-judicial agency are forbidden by law from privately discussing pending cases. So companies and Congress must officially content themselves with filing briefs, writing letters and testifying at hearings. ??No such restraints apply to the issue of who sits on the commission. There, the jockeying for influence can be intense. ??Commissioners are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate to staggered five-year terms, with a limit of three members of a political party on the panel. The president can also designate at any time which commissioner serves as chairman, a position that bestows broad authority over the FERC's agenda and staff. ??When Bush took office, he picked Hebert, then the lone Republican on the commission, to the chairmanship and named his choices for the two vacancies. It was unclear whether Hebert would keep the chair once Bush's nominees were confirmed. ??Soon afterward, Hebert talked by telephone with Kenneth L. Lay, who heads Enron Corp., a Houston-based energy marketing giant that recently saw its profits triple in a year. FERC policy decisions could have a huge influence on its future. ??Enron spokesman Mark Palmer says Lay, whose friendship with Bush is well known, was returning a call from Hebert. Palmer says Hebert wanted Lay's support for remaining chairman. ??Hebert told a FERC official, who heard the new chairman's end of the conversation, that Lay offered support but only if the chairman changed his views in ways that would aid Enron. The official says he heard Hebert decline and characterizes him as offended. The discussion was first reported in the New York Times. ??Lay has never been shy about offering advice, nor about courting political access. He golfed with President Clinton, and Palmer wrote a letter to Clinton's personnel chief touting Hoecker for chairman. The Enron executive's ties with Bush bind especially tight; Lay raised and donated hundreds of thousands of dollars to Bush's campaigns and related efforts. ??Power companies also scouted candidates for the two slots. Enron went so far as to send the White House a list of a dozen people Lay considered qualified (the two new commissioners were on it). ??In the end, however, the evidence suggests that such lobbying mattered less than the faith in free markets and less federal intervention shared by two presidents and just about every recent FERC member. "FERC is filled with true believers," Rozsa said. ??The agency's recent California orders underline the point. In December, FERC concluded the market was dysfunctional and ordered a limited version of the price caps that free marketers abhor. ??Still, prices remained above $300 a megawatt-hour--10 times the pre-crisis average. So in April, FERC concluded it had to take further action. ??But the new version of price caps, approved 2 to 1, actually narrowed the circumstances under which they could be imposed, though it gave the state more flexibility. Even temporarily, the commission would not abandon its market principles. ??"I was reluctant to stop in my tracks," said Breathitt, the swing vote. She didn't want "to go back to a form of regulation that this commission and I had departed from five or six years ago." ??FERC at a Glance ??1920: The Federal Power Commission created to oversee development of hydroelectric power. ??1977: Power Commission replaced by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to oversee interstate transmission of natural gas, oil and electricity and regulate wholesale electric rates. ??1992: Congress gives FERC authority on electricity, opens door to full-scale deregulation. ??1996: FERC approves California deregulation plan. ??1998: Prices spike briefly; FERC puts temporary price caps on California's emergency reserve. ??2000: FERC orders staff investigation of market conditions nationwide, declares California market seriously flawed in November; in December, a form of price caps introduced. ??2001: Rolling blackouts hit California. FERC orders $124.5 million in refunds from power companies alleged to have overcharged utilities. Agency says California price caps can apply in narrowly defined circumstances ??* ??Source: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission; Times reports ??Federal Energy Regulatory Commission ??FERC Members Chosen by Bush ??* ??Patrick H. Wood III, GOP ??Nominated by Bush, March 27; confirmed by Senate May 31. ??Age: 38 ??Term: Expires June 30, 2005 ??Career: Chairman of the Public Utility Commission of Texas, 1995-2001. Attorney for the law firm Baker & Botts in Washington, 1989-1991. Legal advisor to FERC member Jerry Langdon, 1991 to 1993. ??Personal: Native of Port Arthur, Texas. ??Education: Texas A&M University, B.S., 1985. Harvard Law School, J.D., 1989. * ??* ??Nora M. Brownell, GOP ??Nominated by Bush, March 27; confirmed by Senate May 31. ??Age: 53 ??Term: Expires June 30, 2006 ??Career: Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, 1997 to 2001. Senior vice president at Meridian Bancorp, 1992-1996. Current president of the National Assn. of Regulatory Utility Commissioners. ??Personal: Native of Erie, Pa. ??Education: Attended Syracuse University, 1966-1969. ??* ??FERC Members Chosen by Clinton ??Curtis L. Hebert Jr., GOP ??Nominated by Clinton, 1997. Named chairman by Bush in January. ??Age: 38 ??Term: Expires June 30, 2004 ??Professional career: Chairman of the Southern District of the Mississippi Public Service Commission, 1994 to 1996. Member of the Mississippi House of Representatives, 1988-1992. ??Personal: Native of Pascagoula, Miss. ??Education: University of Southern Mississippi, B.S., 1985; Mississippi College School of Law, J.D., 1990. ??* ??Linda Breathitt, Democrat ??Nominated by Clinton, 1997. ??Age: 49 ??Term: Expires June 30, 2002 ??Professional career: Chairwoman of the Kentucky Public Service Commission, 1995-1997. Past president of the Southeastern Assn. of Regulatory Utility Commissioners. Executive director of Kentucky's Washington office, 1980-1993. ??Personal: Native of Lexington, Ky. ??Education: University of Kentucky, B.A., 1975. ??* ??William L. Massey, Democrat ??Nominated by Clinton, 1993, 1998 ??Age: 52 ??Term: Expires June 30, 2003 ??Career: Practiced law in Washington, 1989 to 1993. Served on the presidential transition team for the Department of Energy, December 1992. Served as chief counsel to Sen. Dale Bumpers (D-Ark.), 1981 to 1989. ??Personal: Native of Little Rock, Ark. ??Education: University of Arkansas School of Law, JD, 1973; Georgetown University Law Center, master of laws, 1985. ??*Compiled by SUNNY KAPLAN/Los Angeles Times ??Q&A ??Differences in the approaches of the three most senior members of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission were apparent during recent interviews with The Times. Following are excerpts: ??* ??How do you define FERC's role as a regulator of wholesale electricity? ??HEBERT: "What the commission has attempted to do here since I've been chairman is to provide a balance--making certain that we have just and reasonable rates and, at the same time, making certain that we have given proper opportunity to build out infrastructure and to add much-needed supply so as to correct the flawed market that California has put in place." ??BREATHITT: "It is being an effective referee. It's being a cop on the beat. It's being a nurturer of competition. It's being an arbiter of disputes. And it's overseeing a level playing field. And, also, its role--more than we've seen in the past--is going to be a place to listen to the energy consumer." ??* ??Is FERC effectively monitoring wholesale electric markets and enforcing "just and reasonable" rates? ??HEBERT: "I think FERC is using any and all tools available to it to adequately monitor the markets, continue to look 24 hours, seven days a week for market manipulation, and ensure just and reasonable rates. I would vehemently disagree with anyone who says otherwise." ??MASSEY: "We need more people dealing with the monitoring function. The monitoring function requires skills that are precise. I think we need more people involved in hard-nosed investigation work . . . everyone here realizes we still have to do better in that regard." ??BREATHITT: "This is new to us. We've been monitoring markets in an old way. We have to get better at monitoring markets within the current framework." ??* ??Should FERC revise the test it uses to determine whether a power generator has "market power"? ??HEBERT: "Obviously, if I thought we needed to change it, we would have." ??MASSEY: "We have this old horse-and-buggy methodology for determining whether generators have market power. Everybody passes, nobody ever fails. If we've learned nothing else, it's that the screen is not sensitive enough to pick up the exercise of market power in California. . . . I don't know how you can say you see no reason for change." ??* ??Have wholesale power generators exercised market power to manipulate rates in California? ??HEBERT: "I know there are several people in the state of California that continually make remarks, some of them that are completely unnecessary [about manipulation of markets]. If they have information and real evidence, this commission wants to know about it . . . But this anecdotal evidence that they bring forward and is not real is not helpful." ??MASSEY: "In a capacity-short market where they need all the generation, even a small company can exercise market power. I'm not talking about some kind of conspiracy. I'm talking about the kind of conduct you would expect from a tough, hard-nosed, profit-maximizing company that owns generation." ??* ??Did FERC's April 26 order imposing price caps in California during emergency hours go far enough? ??HEBERT: "I embrace the order; I think it will make a real difference. And I wish there was some way to take California through the experience without the price mitigation and show the proof that the price mitigation is going to bear in trying to level out prices while at the same time giving signals to build out infrastructure and needed supply." ??MASSEY: "I don't think we've moved quickly enough. Generally, our solutions have been too little too late. We've been hoping the market will settle down, and it just hasn't . . . we should have imposed a timeout . . . on that market to cool it off." ??BREATHITT: "I wanted it to mitigate against high prices. I wanted it to have a market orientation. And I wanted it to be effective in controlling what I thought would be high prices this summer. . . . We did control prices on April 26." ??* ??Has FERC resolved the question of "just and reasonable" rates in California? ??HEBERT: "When it comes to just and reasonable rates, you cannot just pick a price at which no one should pay over, or be allowed to pay over, because you have to give the proper opportunity for infrastructure and supply. . . . We are addressing it and we will fully address all the legal arguments on it in these rehearings pending on recent California orders." ??BREATHITT: "This order, I think, will produce just and reasonable rates given the shortage of supply in California." ??MASSEY: "We haven't really defined it. I would define it as cost-of-service regulation or price disciplined by a well-functioning market. We don't have either of those." ??* ??MORE INSIDE ??Jury still out: No smoking gun yet in natural gas rate hearing. A23 GRAPHIC: PHOTO: Patrick H. Wood III PHOTO: Nora M. Brownell PHOTO: Curtis L. Hebert Jr. PHOTO: Linda Breathitt PHOTO: William L. Massey LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????35 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company ??????????????????????????????The New York Times ??????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final SECTION: Section 4; Page 18; Column 5; Week in Review Desk LENGTH: 788 words HEADLINE: The Nation; Econ 101: It's Right and It's Wrong BYLINE: ?By MICHAEL M. WEINSTEIN; Michael M. Weinstein is a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. BODY: ??ELECTRICITY deregulation -- allowing power companies to set wholesale prices on their own -- has gone seriously awry in California. Severe shortages have led to rolling blackouts and soaring prices, with wholesale prices rising about 700 percent in a year, jolting the state's economy. Last week, Gov. Gray Davis grabbed for instant relief. When President Bush visited his state, Mr. Davis lobbied hard for federal regulators to impose a price cap on power companies -- a maximum price that wholesalers would be permitted to charge. ??The president dismissed the governor's demand, offering an economics lecture instead. "I oppose price caps," he explained, because, "price caps do nothing to reduce demand and they do nothing to increase supply." ???That's a pretty sound argument, based on Economics 101. If price caps don't increase supply, they cannot relieve shortages. Besides, economics professors tirelessly preach about the evils of price controls. Applied to a competitive market, caps threaten to reduce output -- the opposite of what California needs -- by driving out companies that can't make a profit selling at the lower prices set by the government. Indeed, economics students who persist in thinking that price caps are pro-consumer risk being taken aside by their college advisors and urged to switch to another major. ??Yet while Mr. Bush's lecture would sit well in most introductory Econ classes, it did not sit well with some of the nation's leading authorities on regulation. Ten prominent economists -- including Paul Joskow of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Severin Borenstein of the University of California at Berkeley and Alfred Kahn, the architect of airline deregulation under President Carter -- have sent a letter to the president calling for the federal government to clamp down on wholesale energy prices. Nostrums suitable to the textbook world of perfect competition, they argue, do not fit the messy facts of electricity markets. ??It might seem like a man-bites-dog story, but the idea of economists calling for price controls isn't nearly as zany as it appears. ??Electricity prices skyrocketed in California in part for standard supply-and-demand reasons. The supply of power fell as rising prices for natural gas, used to produce electricity, drove up its cost of production. Supplies dwindled further as power companies in neighboring states exported less electricity to California. And demand rose swiftly along with the increasing use of computers and other electricity-guzzling hardware. ??The most contentious question is whether another factor has also been at play: manipulation by power companies of the rules set up by the state to enforce deregulation. Specifically, have the companies withheld supply in order to jack up the price that authorities pay for power? ??In truly competitive markets, attempts to withhold supply to raise prices are fruitless. If Farmer Brown withholds her 10 bushels of corn from a market of billions of bushels, corn prices would not rise one cent. But the market for electricity, California style, is different. The complex rules have provided an unintended incentive for power companies to fool regulatory officials. By withholding electricity at the price offered in the morning of a typical day, the power companies can count on the officials to come back later in the day and plead for power at a substantially higher price. ??This is not just a theoretical possibility. Mr. Joskow says he has found evidence. There is probably nothing illegal going on; the power companies do not appear to have conspired to withhold supply. Each acted alone. ??If the 10 economists are right, Mr. Bush needs a refresher course in economics. Price caps, they say, can indeed increase supply. Once they are in place, prices can no longer rise. So power companies would have nothing to gain by withholding supply. They would sell more electricity, easing the shortage. The economists warn against setting price caps so low that power companies quit the industry. Instead, they call for setting caps somewhat above the actual costs of production -- which would allow companies to make a profit. ??The gang of 10 have not taken leave of their professional senses. The economists don't advise adopting price caps indefinitely. Left in place, the controls would discourage investors from building new power plants -- which, along with fixing perverse incentives under deregulation, is the best near-term solution to California's energy crisis. Fortunately, price caps won't be needed very long because enough power plants are under construction to ease the shortage in 18 months or so. Then, the lessons of Econ 101 might start making sense again. ??http://www.nytimes.com GRAPHIC: Photo: President Bush looking at the grid in California. (Agence France-Presse) LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????36 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company ??????????????????????????????The New York Times ??????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final SECTION: Section 4; Page 17; Column 1; Editorial Desk LENGTH: 739 words HEADLINE: Reckonings; Watt Price Ideology? BYLINE: ?By PAUL KRUGMAN BODY: ??I once had a math teacher who responded to student errors by saying "Save that answer -- I may ask that question someday." I thought of him after George W. Bush's apparently pointless trip to California. ???During that trip, Gov. Gray Davis asked for a temporary cap on wholesale electricity prices -- a request that gained extra force because it was backed by economists with strong pro-market credentials, including Alfred Kahn, who oversaw the deregulation of airlines, trucking and other industries in the 1970's. Mr. Bush, however, was unmoved. Again and again he declared that a price cap would do nothing either to increase supply or to reduce demand. ??Save that answer, Mr. Bush. We might ask that question someday. ??Actually, Mr. Bush's assertion may have been wrong even on its own terms. I'll come back to that in a minute. But the most striking thing about his declaration was that it had nothing to do with the actual problem. ??For the issue facing California right now is not how to increase supply and reduce demand. It's too late for that; summer is almost upon us, and it is simply a fact of life that there will be power shortages in the months ahead. It is important that the state build power plants as quickly as possible, so that this shortage is only temporary. But not to worry: power plants are being built at a furious rate, in California and in the nation at large. Indeed, last week the credit agency Standard & Poor's expressed concern that electric generating capacity is being added so quickly that the industry will soon face a glut. ??Meanwhile, however, the temporary lack of capacity has led to incredibly high wholesale electricity prices, which are a huge financial burden on the state, over and above any disruption that may be caused by physical shortages of power. Nobody knows exactly how much California will pay for power this year, but reasonable estimates suggest that it will pay at least $50 billion more than two years ago -- an increase of more than $1,500 for every resident. The great bulk of that represents not an increased cost of production but windfall profits for a handful of generating companies. ??The main purpose of a temporary price cap would be to reduce -- though by no means eliminate -- this transfer of wealth away from California residents. That is, we're talking about dollars, not megawatts. And Mr. Bush's response is therefore almost surrealistically beside the point. ??You could argue that any financial benefit from price caps would be more than offset by a worsened physical shortage. But that's a hard case to make. Nobody has proposed capping prices at a level that would prevent power producers from making extraordinarily high profits; why should this reduce the supply of power? ??It's true that Econ 101 teaches that price controls tend to produce shortages. But this would be a minor effect in this case, since neither production nor consumption would be much affected. And anyway, students who go beyond Econ 101 learn that strictly speaking the standard argument against price controls applies only to a competitive industry. A price ceiling imposed on a monopolist need not cause a shortage, if it is set high enough; indeed, price controls on a monopolist can actually lead to higher output. That's not an argument you want to use too often, but given the extraordinary prices now being charged for electricity, and the considerable evidence that producers are exercising monopoly power, if ever there was a case for a temporary price ceiling, California's electricity market is the place. ??I am actually somewhat surprised by Mr. Bush's obtuseness on this whole subject. No doubt his determination to answer the wrong question is deliberate: misrepresenting policy issues is, after all, standard operating procedure for this administration. But even on a cynical political calculation, Mr. Bush's remarks seem to be foolish, only reinforcing the sense that he neither understands nor cares about California's problems. ??Maybe Mr. Bush's advisers are knee-jerk ideologues who believe that the market is always right, even when textbook economics says it is wrong. Or maybe they are so close personally to energy industry executives that they believe that whatever is good for Enron is good for America. ??Whatever the real story, it's clear that this administration not only has no answers for California, it won't even listen to the question. ??http://www.nytimes.com LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????37 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company ??????????????????????????????The New York Times ??????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final SECTION: Section 1; Page 37; Column 1; Metropolitan Desk LENGTH: 1065 words HEADLINE: One Developer's Power Solution: Build a Plant at the Office BYLINE: ?By CHARLES V. BAGLI BODY: ??With state officials scrambling to stave off power shortages this summer, a New York developer has come up with his own solution: building a sophisticated power plant, complete with gas turbines and smoke stacks, inside his planned West Side office complex. ??Power experts and real estate brokers said the project might be the first privately owned one to generate the kind of high-quality, reliable power needed for computer operations. ???Gas turbines are among the cleanest power generators. The heat exhaust from the turbines would be used to drive steam generators for the building's air-conditioning system. Any surplus steam would be sold to Consolidated Edison. ??The developer, Douglas Durst, is proposing to build a 47-megawatt generating station, with six gas turbines and enough power to light 40,000 homes a year. The power plant would serve his planned $200 million NYCyberCenter, a six-story building on a block bound by 11th and 12th Avenues between 57th and 58th Streets. ??The complex would be for tenants needing huge, air-conditioned spaces for computers and electronic equipment used for the Internet or data storage. ??But these kind of buildings, known variously as telecom hotels, server farms and data centers, require enormous amounts of electricity to power the computers and air-conditioning systems, typically 10 times as much as a comparable office tower. ??Given the current concerns about power shortages, Mr. Durst, whose family owns 10 Manhattan skyscrapers, said he decided to build his own cogeneration plant rather than rely primarily on Con Ed. He has brought in the Trigen Energy Corporation of White Plains to build, own and operate the turbines. ??"It's the most innovative and exciting project we have worked on," Mr. Durst said, "but it's also the most difficult. It has taken an effort by more than 40 people to come up with a solution that will enable companies with dense power requirements to secure premium power with unparalleled reliability." ??Mr. Durst still needs permits from the state and the city, but government officials say they are intrigued by the proposal. ??"It's a novel program," Deputy Mayor Anthony P. Coles said. "It seems to bring with it a number of benefits, but the city has to complete its due diligence before reaching a final decision." ??Kevin Corbett, chief operating officer of the Empire State Development Corporation, said, "Anything that can help reduce emissions and provide energy more efficiently is certainly worth looking at." ??Mr. Durst said he planned to begin demolition on the site in August for the first phase of the project, a 420,000-square-foot building. He will add office space and possibly a residential tower in two successive stages, he said. If the project is successful, experts said, other Internet data centers might quickly use the same technology, especially with tightening power supplies in California and the Northeast. ??"With California facing a white-knuckle summer of up to 200 hours of rolling blackouts, every kilowatt of energy reduction is critical," said Dr. William M. Smith, a manager of the Electric Power Research Institute, a nonprofit development organization for the electricity industry. "This cogeneration facility may be a forerunner of things to come as the digital economy tries to keep the lights on." ??Demand for electricity has soared in recent years in New York as well, but private power companies have been slow to build new power plants since the deregulation of the electricity industry in the mid-1990's. ??The first two of 21 proposed large and medium-size plants around the state will not begin operating until at least late 2003. Meanwhile, the state is spending $510 million to build six small gas turbine plants in the city and one on Long Island this year, some of which have encountered opposition. ??The administration of Gov. George E. Pataki has also encouraged hospitals, factories and colleges that have their own backup generators to run them when demand for electricity is high and there is a threat of power shortages. But environmentalists have criticized the effort because most of those power plants are diesel generators, which would create more pollution, and most of them are in New York City, which already violates federal clean air standards. ??That is what makes Mr. Durst's use of energy-efficient gas turbines and steam generators as his primary source of power attractive to environmentalists who oppose diesel generators and nuclear power plants. ??"They're demonstrating that you can have high-quality, reliable power and do it in a very clean way," said Ashok Gupta, senior energy economist for the Natural Resources Defense Council. "We'd support expediting the permits if they met clean air standards." ??According to Con Ed, Mr. Durst's project is one of 22 proposals it has received for telecom hotels or Internet data centers. But the other projects rely chiefly on Con Ed for their power, requiring 60 to 120 watts per square foot, compared with 7 to 10 watts for an office building. In addition, the tenants typically have a series of diesel generators and battery systems for backup power in the event of a breakdown. ??Tenants at the telecom hotel at 75 Broad Street, for instance, have 44 diesel generators, each of which can cost millions of dollars to build and maintain and take up as much as 30 percent of each company's space. ??Mr. Durst said that tenants in his building would save money because they would not need to rent the extra space or buy backup systems. His power plant would have backup turbines and in the event of a breakdown would immediately switch to Con Ed power. The electricity in his building, he said, would cost no more than what Con Ed charges. ??"Customers won't have to worry about storms, lightning or Con Ed," said Richard A. Ubaldi, a vice president of Trigen Energy. ??Still, there are risks in Mr. Durst's plans. Many Internet-related companies have collapsed over the past year, while those that survive are finding it hard to get financing for new projects. Real estate brokers said that few tenants were now willing to sign leases for space that has yet to be built. ??That is one reason the developer has expanded his list of potential occupants to corporate data centers. Mr. Durst said he expected the market to recover in the 18 to 24 months it took to build his complex. ??http://www.nytimes.com GRAPHIC: Photo: A rendering shows a proposed office complex that would include a 47-megawatt power plant between 11th and 12th Avenues at 57th Street. LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????38 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ???????????????????????Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ??????????????????????????The Orange County Register ?????????????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday SECTION: DOMESTIC NEWS KR-ACC-NO: ?K1495 LENGTH: 757 words HEADLINE: California may have already spent energy money it plans to borrow BYLINE: By Hanh Kim Quach BODY: ??SACRAMENTO, Calif. _ Almost all of the $12.5 billion California hopes to borrow this summer to buy cheap power for the future will be spent before the state sees the first dime, according to a projection of the state's numbers by The Orange County Register. ??If California continues to spend money on high-priced emergency electricity at the current pace _ $66.9 million a day _ it will have spent $10.4 billion, or 83.2 percent, of what it plans to borrow through a bond sale by mid-August, the time it hopes to have the cash in hand. That $10.4 billion would be immediately repaid to the state treasury. ??That leaves only $2.1 billion left to buy future energy. But according to the state's own estimates, its needs at least $2.7 billion to pay for such contracts just through June 2002. The state estimates, it actually needs enough new money to secure such power through at least 2003. ??That means, to meet Gov. Gray Davis' energy goals, the state would have to either raise taxes, cut programs funded by the general state budget or borrow more money on the bond market _ which would mean yet another hike in electricity rates for all customers of Southern California Edison, San Diego Gas & Electric and Pacific Gas & Electric. Those customers will already face an increase to pay back the $12.5 billion in bond borrowing. ??"It's like the emperor's new clothes," said consumer advocate Doug Heller. "Everybody's saying we have to protect schools, law enforcement and infrastructure, when the reality is the (general fund) will be used to buy energy, yet again." ??In response to The Register's projection, Davis' energy team says it is wrong to assume that spending for emergency energy will continue at the same pace into the summer. ??The administration says the outlook is brightening for the energy supply because of new energy contracts _ some taking effect this month _ continued conservation and new power plants. The increased supply should drive down prices, thus reducing the average amount the state is spending each day on energy. ??"We'll have room to spare," said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio. ??According to the Davis administration, it will need to repay itself only $7.9 billion of the bonds it plans to issue Aug. 14 _ $2.5 billion less than The Register's projection. That would leave $4.6 billion, presumably enough to buy an adequate supply of relatively cheap electricity on long-term contracts. ??But Davis' predictions have been criticized as too rosy. ??"There's certainly a vulnerability to these assumptions," said Brad Williams, chief economist in the non-partisan Legislative Analyst's Office. "The administration assumption that prices will fall is very risky." ??One of Davis' assumptions, for example, is that spot-market prices will be cut in half, from $346 a megawatt-hour in the spring to $195 a megawatt-hour during the summer. The state reasons that this is because it will have secured more power under long-term contracts, under which prices are cheaper. ??But if there is only a finite amount of power in California, and the state has secured a good portion of it under contract, the law of economics says that intense demand could push the price of the remaining un-contracted power up. And summer power has traditionally been more expensive, not less. ??State Controller Kathleen Connell, a Democrat like Davis, has her doubts. ??"We don't know whether the governor's estimates are correct. They haven't been correct to date. ... I have always argued that $12.5 billion is not going to be enough." ??Assembly Speaker Robert Hertzberg, D-Van Nuys, speaks plaintively about the future. He's hoping the state won't have to dig too deep into its treasury to keep lights on, putting extra emphasis on hope. ??"Look, who in a million years thought the prices would be $1,900 a megawatt-hour?" Hertzberg asked, touching on the unpredictability of the crisis. The state paid that then-unprecedented price for power for six hours over May 9 and 10. ??Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, believes that power generators have been manipulating the market since the beginning of the crisis _ and continue to _ and that could keep prices artificially high this summer. ??"Some of us were saying back in January that you can't go that route" and sell bonds because " the bonds will be eaten up before they're even sold," Dunn said. ??(c) 2001, The Orange County Register (Santa Ana, Calif.). ??Visit the Register on the World Wide Web at http://www.ocregister.com/ JOURNAL-CODE: OC LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????39 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 McClatchy Newspapers, Inc. ????????????????????????????????Sacramento Bee ???????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday METRO FINAL EDITION SECTION: MAIN NEWS; Pg. A3; CAPITOL & CALIFORNIA POWER CRUNCH LENGTH: 491 words HEADLINE: State heeds call to conserve energy Californians trimmed their use of electricity by 11 percent in May. BYLINE: Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau BODY: ??Californians used 11 percent less electricity in May than they did during the same month last year, giving Gov. Gray Davis hope for a summer of continued conservation and limited blackouts throughout the state. ??In a news conference scheduled for today, Davis administration officials are expected to release the latest California Energy Commission figures, which show state residents used 11 percent less electricity overall and 10.4 percent less energy during peak times last month than in May 2000. ??Throughout the energy crisis, Davis has implored Californians to save energy, particularly during daytime hours when demand for electricity is at its highest. ??"Clearly conservation is making a difference," Davis said of the May figures. "We are getting the job done." ??This summer, the state could face a shortfall of several thousand megawatts, depending on summer temperatures. One megawatt is enough to power about 1,000 homes. ??Though the state has begun entering into long-term contracts for electricity and several power plants are in the process of being built, not all of the power from either source will be available this summer. ??To make up the difference, the Democratic governor has asked Californians to reduce their electricity use by 10 percent, even though he is factoring a more conservative figure - 7 percent - into his financial forecasts. ??"Until we get the generation that's in the works online, conservation is our only way out of this to avoid blackouts and disruptions," said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio. "So far Californians are heeding the call, and then some." ??Californians were more successful at reducing demand last month than they were any other point this year. ??For example, Californians conserved the least in January, using 5.4 percent less electricity overall than they did in January 2000 and 6.2 percent less during peak times. In April, state residents reduced their overall usage by 6.9 percent and their peak usage by 9 percent. ??Their 10.4 percent peak reduction in May translates to saving 3,595 megawatts over the year-ago period, adjusted for weather and growth. ??Michael Shames, executive director of Utility Consumers' Action Network, called the May numbers "promising," particularly because some conservation programs had yet to fully kick in. ??For instance, the governor's 20/20 program - which will give some Californians a one-time, 20 percent rebate off their summer bill if they cut their electricity use by at least 20 percent during the hottest summer months - did not begin until this month. ??Shames cautioned, however, that Californians need to conserve more in order to avoid blackouts and to significantly reduce the cost of the state's power purchases. He also encouraged some skepticism of the Energy Commission's numbers until its analysis can be reviewed by peers in the industry. ??* * * ??The Bee's Emily Bazar can be reached at (916) 326-5540 or ebazar@sacbee.com . LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????40 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 McClatchy Newspapers, Inc. ????????????????????????????????Sacramento Bee ???????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday METRO FINAL EDITION SECTION: FORUM; Pg. L4; OUR VIEWS LENGTH: 625 words HEADLINE: Lone shining light State power authority a future market tool BODY: ??"One only can speculate what the cost of electricity would be were it not for these public power system yardsticks. It can be understood why the power companies want to get rid of public power." ??Bee editorial Jan. 8, 1959 ??Years from now, when California looks back on this expensive failure of electricity competition, one bright light will shine from this dark moment in history. That was the decision by the California Legislature and Gov. Gray Davis to create a California public power authority. ??Recycling the rhetoric of decades past, when utility monopolies and holding companies fought the creation of municipal utilities, critics today see public power as an unwelcome, inefficient intruder into the free market system. ??But public power's role isn't to replace that market. It is to make sure that it behaves. Californians can adjust to price gyrations for things such as airline tickets and cherries. Electricity, however, is too vital a commodity, and without regulation and competitive policy, the electricity market, as Californians have so painfully learned, is too easily gamed. ??There is now a brief window to contemplate how this state public power authority can stay one step ahead of market manipulation. The governor has signed the authorizing legislation, but the authority won't officially exist for another two months. Once in operation, its potential is enormous. ??As financial capital, the Legislature has authorized it to sell up to $5 billion worth of bonds to build new power plants to create electricity to be sold at cost. As human capital, the governor will likely tap the wisest old owl in the public power trade, David Freeman. Having already run the public power agencies of the Tennessee Valley, the state of New York, Sacramento and Los Angeles, Freeman brings experience that likely will never be duplicated. ??Freeman's strategy is to ensure that California races to turn a shortage of electricity into a surplus of about 15 percent. Private generators are busy building new plants and applying to build others. Yet at some point these companies may conclude it is not in their interests to compete so vigorously against each other. They feast on shortage and volatility. That's where a vigilant public authority can provide supply to keep the market balanced. ??An ideal partner in generating ventures would be the existing cities that run their own power authorities. The Sacramento Municipal Utility District, for example, is looking to build a generating plant fired by natural gas at the site of the former nuclear plant, Rancho Seco. By partnering with the state authority, SMUD could build a larger plant. The state could sell the surplus at cost. SMUD could get even more reliable power. ??With its surplus, the state may wish to direct some to new municipal districts. Customers in several communities are mulling whether to create their own municipal power agencies as a way to avoid the volatility of the deregulated world. Davis, San Francisco, Fresno and other communities are in various stages of this exploration. This very threat of competition keeps down the charges of both the private utilities and the generators. ??The cheapest power of all is that which California doesn't have to buy. The power authority's greatest contribution to California may end up being on the demand side of the electricity equation. It is ideally suited to lead future conservation and efficiency initiatives. Lowering demand lowers the price for the power that Californians do have to buy, whether their utility is public or private. ??"We will be masters of our own destiny," says Freeman. The history of public power's vital role in the market place suggests that Freeman is right about the future. LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????41 of 143 DOCUMENTS ??????????????Copyright 2001 Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ???????????????????????Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service ????????????????????????????San Jose Mercury News ?????????????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday SECTION: DOMESTIC NEWS KR-ACC-NO: ?K1534 LENGTH: 2242 words HEADLINE: U.S. approved California's power-deregulation plan despite flaws BYLINE: By Eric Nalder and Mark Gladstone BODY: ??SAN JOSE, Calif. _ The federal agency charged with ensuring the stability of the nation's power system gave California the go-ahead to deregulate its electric utilities despite critical flaws evident to its own experts. And once deregulation was under way in 1998, the agency did little to police the state's market, even though it has a legal obligation to ensure that prices are "just and reasonable." ??Far from being the innocent bystander that top federal officials portray, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has played a central role in California's deregulation disaster, weighing in more than 80 separate times with orders approving, revising or rejecting parts of the plan. ??To examine the role this small agency has played in California's deregulation, the San Jose Mercury News reviewed hundreds of documents and interviewed energy experts and FERC employees, some of whom talked publicly for the first time. ??The review found that FERC, eager to promote deregulation and reluctant to cross California politicians, generating companies and utilities pushing the state's groundbreaking plan, ignored detailed criticism from one of the nation's top deregulation experts and its own staff members, including its chief economist. ??More important, the review reveals the most critical mistake federal regulators made in ushering in electricity deregulation: They set the stage for a new energy-trading market every bit as complicated as Wall Street but failed to monitor it. With California ceding its regulatory role, FERC had the critical responsibility to stop market abuses, but it failed to hire enough experts, obtain the data or install the computers needed to keep the market honest. ??In contrast to the Securities and Exchange Commission, which frequently takes aggressive action to enforce stock-market rules, FERC almost never uses subpoenas in staff investigations to acquire data on electricity trading that could include evidence of anti-competitive practices that boost prices. ??Curtis Hebert Jr., a confident 38-year-old Mississippi lawyer who became FERC's chairman in January, dismisses claims that the agency does not gather enough data on prices or investigate the energy industry thoroughly. ??"We do have enough resources, and we are handling it in a way that's appropriate," he said of the agency's role in California's crisis. An ardent supporter of free markets, he said FERC's primary job is to create a competitive market for electricity and keep the lights on. Low prices will follow, he promised. ??But James Hoecker, FERC's chairman when California adopted its plan, has become more critical of the decisions the agency made under his leadership and now says FERC should have more aggressively scrutinized the plan rather than moving it along. ??"I would very much have liked for the commission to be more prepared for California," he said. ??FERC has a responsibility to rule on deregulation plans because, under a 66-year-old federal law, it regulates wholesale electricity. The law says the agency must ensure that wholesale prices are "just and reasonable," though neither Congress nor the courts have made clear what that means in a deregulated market. ??For decades, FERC's responsibilities were much simpler. The agency set rates for wholesale electricity using a formula based on generating costs plus a fair profit. ??But the agency took steps to change its role in the early '80s, when it helped set into motion the forces that would lead to California's deregulation. In 1982, two years after President Reagan's election, a FERC lawyer named Robert Angyal wrote an internal memo assuring commissioners that the ambiguity of "just and reasonable" gave them ample room to experiment with free-market sales of electricity. ??"We thought we were the good guys then," said Steve Greenleaf, who joined the agency in 1986 as a regulatory specialist. Greenleaf, who now works for California's power grid operator, said recent events "certainly make me go back and consider what we did." ??What he and others did was clear a path for the deregulation bandwagon. FERC commissioners, generating companies, utilities and politicians _ both Democrats and Republicans _ all argued that competition could both reduce rates and boost profits, just as it had for natural gas, airlines and other markets. ??In 1992, Congress passed a law encouraging open access. FERC took the next key step when Chairwoman Betsy Moler, a free-market Democrat, sat down at her kitchen table one morning to begin drafting Order 888, named after the agency's address in Washington. ??The order, finalized in April 1996, encouraged the emergence of free markets by requiring utilities to open their transmission lines to competing power companies, but it did little to prepare the agency to monitor the markets and make sure companies competed fairly. ??Daniel Fessler, a former University of California-Davis law professor appointed to the state Public Utilities Commission by Republican Gov. Pete Wilson, drafted California's deregulation plan in the mid-'90s. In a brief and reluctant interview _ the first he has granted since the energy crisis began _ Fessler said that he consulted with FERC officials while he worked on the plan and testified several times before the commission. ??"Our dialogue was extremely public," he said. ??But FERC officials say the agency took a hands-off approach, despite conducting hearings and receiving thousands of documents. ??Hoecker, who took over from Moler in June 1997, said the agency viewed California's plan as an experiment that raised questions that could not be answered until it was in place. "Fundamentally, the commission took the stance that no one had experience in the United States anyway with this comprehensive restructuring," he said. ??At several crucial junctures, the agency's commissioners passed on the chance to explore the advice of critics, both academic and in-house, that could have helped shape California's plan. ??One of the nation's top experts on electricity deregulation, Bill Hogan of Harvard University, witnessed how commissioners let a detailed critique of California's plan slip by them at FERC's summer 1996 hearings. ??San Diego Gas & Electric, California's third-largest investor-owned utility, had hired Hogan to analyze the plan, which the utility opposed. His 71-page report offers a blueprint for some of what eventually would go wrong. ??Hogan did not predict the disaster _ nobody did _ but he criticized key aspects of the plan: a market structure that made it possible for companies to boost prices, and a complex power auction that opened the door for gaming. ??At a hearing, the San Diego utility's chairman presented Hogan's paper to the commission. San Diego's opposition was the last major obstacle the plan faced, and the utility says it came under pressure to get in line so California could meet a start-up date of January 1998. ??State lawmakers and other energy executives told San Diego to get on board if it wanted to have a "meaningful role" when the Legislature wrote the final plan, said Bill Reed, chief regulatory officer for the utility's parent company. ??"I believed, naively as it turned out, that FERC would exercise the ultimate judgment as to what needed to be done," Reed said. "Unfortunately, FERC has taken deference to an extreme that I never considered." ??The San Diego utility withdrew Hogan's report, and the commissioners signed off on the deregulation plan. ??"San Diego stopped talking," Hogan said. "I wasn't invited to speak." ??After the San Diego utility dropped its opposition, Steve Peace, a loquacious Democrat from San Diego, led legislators on 18 days of hearings to craft the final details of California's plan. ??The Legislature passed the bill unanimously, and Wilson signed it Sept. 23, 1996, hailing it as "a major step in our efforts to guarantee lower rates." ??To a degree that few seemed to grasp at the time, it was an unprecedented transfer of power from the state to the federal government. Prior to the bill's passage, state regulators had control over most of the power generated in California, setting prices and making sure enough electricity was available. Now much of the power is generated by private companies _ not state-regulated utilities _ and only FERC has the authority to step in when wholesale prices climb. ??FERC also continued to rule on each additional step in the state's complicated deregulation plan as it was implemented. Again, the agency missed chances to overhaul the plan, this time based on flaws pointed out by its own experts. ??FERC's chief economist, Richard O'Neill, openly called the California plan a Rube Goldberg contraption in conversations with colleagues and California officials, according to sources inside and outside the agency. ??Carolyn Berry, a FERC economist who has since left the agency, also reviewed the plan. She, too, saw flaws _ and worried especially that the odd market structure might encourage companies to manipulate prices. ??"There was great resistance on the part of many people at the commission to undo the process that California sent in," Berry said. "There was a reluctance to start pulling at the threads for fear that the whole package might fall apart." ??The flaws the two cited, including some of the same ones Hogan flagged, are now widely acknowledged as contributing to the collapse of California's scheme. ??The deep concerns of the staff members, however, were never impressed on the commissioners. FERC does not foster a culture of internal debate, insiders say. ??Hoecker said the agency made few changes in the plan because "the commission was too highly deferential" to California's industry leaders and politicians. ??In addition, he said, the agency simply did not have the clout to stop a plan hurtling along on a political fast track. ??FERC, like other agencies in Washington, is highly political and, acutely aware of what industry leaders want, often delivers. As far back as 1960, a presidential commission labeled the agency's predecessor "a virtual Chamber of Commerce for the oil and gas companies." ??Corporate executives have considerable sway over the agency, to the point of helping the White House decide who is appointed to the five-member commission and who becomes chairman. ??And there is an active revolving door. Hoecker was an industry lawyer before he was a commissioner, and now he is again. Former Chairwoman Moler consulted for Enron and other energy companies after leaving the agency, and now she is a utility executive. ??Industry leaders wanted deregulation, and they pressed hard for California's plan, which they thought would open the door for unfettered markets nationwide. ??Several other factors kept FERC from playing a stronger oversight role. While the California plan was being put into effect, many FERC officials were focused on a $12.7 million plan to reorganize their staff and upgrade computers. Hoecker was so proud of the result, he spent $100,000 to have a historian write a book about it. ??But key employees say they were distracted by the reorganization for months. More important, a half-dozen employees who were versed in deregulation issues left, leaving FERC handicapped in its ability to police the new market it had created. ??Some staff members sought a single, larger enforcement division resembling the one at the Securities and Exchange Commission, where 900 people, half of the agency, handle market investigations and enforcement. But FERC decided to keep its enforcement split between two offices that had a total of about 75 employees at the time _ a fraction of its 1,200 employees. ??The agency was confronted with its first clear warning of the coming disaster soon after California's deregulation took effect. ??On a hot day in July 1998, three months after the market opened, energy traders whose names state officials have refused to release decided to test whether the new market could be manipulated. Although electricity had been trading well below $100 a megawatt-hour, they offered a megawatt-hour at $9,999 _ the highest number the traders thought the computer system would accept, they later told regulators. ??Desperate for power to keep the grid from crashing, the Independent System Operator _ which monitors the system and buys some power _ paid it. The ISO then made an emergency request for a price cap, and FERC granted it. ??Worried that federal regulators were not alert to the potential for market shenanigans, the grid operator repeatedly warned FERC that trouble was ahead. The ISO's market surveillance director, Anjali Sheffrin, was so concerned that she visited the agency twice in the fall of 1999 to try to explain to FERC officials that California's fledgling market needed the protection. "I don't think they had any thought of what the potential was," Sheffrin said. ??But at least one FERC economist did. ??Ron Rattey, one of the agency's most experienced analysts, made a presentation to his colleagues in March 2000, shortly before the California crisis began. He noted an increase in price spikes nationwide from 1997 through 1999. Among other factors, he blamed regulatory policies and market abuses. ??His conclusion: "We should expect another tumultuous summer in 2000." ??(c) 2001, San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.). ??Visit Mercury Center, the World Wide Web site of the Mercury News, at http://www.sjmercury.com/ JOURNAL-CODE: SJ LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????44 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ?????????????????????JUNE 3, 2001, SUNDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: NEWS; Pg. A1 LENGTH: 2344 words HEADLINE: Cutting a deal on the environment; Activists accused of favoring cash over mission at Moss Landing SOURCE: Chronicle Staff Writers BYLINE: Scott Winokur, Christian Berthelsen BODY: Eager to placate environmentalists, the Duke Energy Corp. agreed to pay more than $12 million to Monterey Bay area groups whose objections could have scuttled the controversial expansion of its Moss Landing power plant, destined to be the state's largest. ???Most of the groups are now being accused of taking financial advantage of the situation and betraying their mission as environmentalists to defend the Monterey Bay area's fragile harbors, sloughs and wetlands. The environmental groups protested until Duke put up money, then dropped their opposition. ???The result, opponents say, is that the very things the groups originally protested, including the discharge of heated water into fragile aquatic environments, will still happen. ???Donna Solomon, co-owner of Solomon Live Fish in Moss Landing, fears that the heated exhaust water will shrink catches of two commercially important fish, cabezon and bolina. ???"They say they are environmentalists, but they are not -- they are frauds," Solomon said of the groups. ???The funds include $8 million for "monitoring" environmental quality and for land acquisition -- an amount dwarfing the nonprofit groups' budgets, in some cases. ???The fighting that broke out at the local level over Moss Landing, energy-industry critics say, is an inevitable consequence of authorities' failure to establish a broad, coherent energy policy and their desperate search for quick fixes to the crisis. ???The deals, critics add, were a predictable corporate response to a situation that invited financial exploitation. ???"Local groups quickly succumb to corporate money," said Doug Heller, a consumer advocate with the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica. "When we become dependent on them to take up statewide issues, the corporation is given the upper hand." ???Two prominent Monterey County politicians took part in behind-the-scenes negotiations involving the 239-acre plant, sources who participated in the talks told The Chronicle. ???Assemblyman Fred Keeley, D-Boulder Creek (Santa Cruz County), brokered a $1 million deal between Duke and the four environmental groups. Keeley, who plans to run for the state Senate in 2004, has accepted donations from the energy industry in the past, but says he stopped accepting the industry's contributions in January, after assuming a leadership role in dealing with the crisis. ???County Supervisor Louis Calcagno pressed regulators to approve the power plant and held a meeting called to devise a way to transfer $3.4 million from Duke to the Moss Landing Chamber of Commerce. Calcagno is a Moss Landing dairyman with substantial agricultural, commercial and residential properties. He acknowledges that those holdings could grow in value as a result of Duke -funded projects in the area. ???"There was money all around," said Gary Shallcross, chairman of the Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board. ???Environmentalists who negotiated with Duke say they made the best of a bad situation. Rather than fight a project they believed likely to get speedy approval regardless of what they did, they accepted money from Duke. They contend that the funds will be used to benefit the environment. ???"The bottom line is, we were looking at a locomotive coming down the track," said Steve Shimek of the Otter Project in Marina, one of the groups that negotiated with Duke. "We made the decision to do the best we could. Do I wonder if we did the right thing? I question myself." ???The three other groups that opposed Duke, then made a deal with the energy company, are Save Our Shores and the Center for Marine Conservation, both in Santa Cruz, and Friends of the Sea Otter in Pacific Grove. ???GROUPS WAIVE RIGHT TO SUE ???Although fierce initially, key opposition to Duke vanished between the late summer and Nov. 6 -- when a document laying out the company's agreement to pay for "monitoring" and additional "mitigation" was finalized. ???The environmental groups agreed by that date that they would "not participate in any lawsuit, regulatory challenge, regulatory appeal or any other action . . . that might obstruct, delay, or prevent Duke's construction" of the plant. ???This contrasted with a Sept. 22 letter to the Regional Water Quality Control Board in which they said they were "deeply concerned" about impacts; had "serious reservations" about the amount of money Duke agreed to put up, to that point, to offset damage; and "strongly" believed the company should do more. ???The Moss Landing plant will be the state's largest after its completion next summer. With an output of 2,538 megawatts, it's expected to account for 30 percent of all new electricity generated in California next year, serving about 2.5 million households in the Monterey, Santa Cruz and southern Santa Clara County areas, including San Jose. ???At issue for the environmentalists is Duke's intention to use a relatively cheap "once-through" cooling system as part of the modernization and expansion project. ???The cooling system would suck up to 1.2 billion gallons of salt water a day out of Moss Landing Harbor and two of the state's ecological gems, Elkhorn Slough and Monterey Bay. This amount would cover nearly 3,700 acres of land to a one-foot depth. ???Duke contends that "once-through" is cleaner than lower-impact alternatives costing tens of millions of dollars more. The company also says studies show its impact on marine organisms won't be unacceptably high. Environmentalists uniformly disagreed. ???About two things, however, there has been no dispute. ???The "once-through" process will exterminate a substantial portion of the aquatic food chain, chiefly the smallest organisms, before the slightly chlorinated water is returned to Elkhorn Slough, nearby Moro Cojo Slough, Moss Landing Harbor and Monterey Bay. ???Moreover, the process will allow the discharge of large amounts of water 600 feet offshore in Monterey Bay at temperatures up to 20 degrees warmer than natural water temperatures. ???For some of the delicate organisms that survive the previous stages of the process, this may mean the equivalent of death by boiling. As one environmentalist told regulators, " 'Cooling water' is a euphemism . . . 'Heated exhaust water' is a more accurate description." ???Duke spokesman Tom Williams said the company did nothing wrong and contended that the expanded plant will be better for the environment than the current one. He said Duke had gone "the extra mile" to address community concerns. ???Madeleine Clark, a Prunedale environmentalist, disagrees. "In Monterey County, Duke can waltz in and buy everybody off, and everyone looks the other way," she said. ???A last-ditch challenge to the project by Clark and other protesting environmentalists will be heard by the State Water Resources Control Board in Sacramento on Wednesday. ???DUKE'S DEALS ???Duke acquired the 30-year-old, 1,478-megawatt gas-fired plant from Pacific Gas and Electric Co. in July 1998 as part of a half-billion dollar package, including plants in Oakland and Morro Bay (San Luis Obispo County). ???Five months later, the Charlotte, N.C., energy company announced plans to spend $475 million modernizing Moss Landing, a figure that would rise to $525 million. This was followed by an application to the California Energy Commission for permission to add 1,060 megawatts. ???Despite environmentalist opposition, the project generally had an easy time of it in hearings before the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the state Energy Commission. When Duke broke ground on Nov. 16, about three weeks after the commission gave its final approval, the company had made the following side arrangements, totaling $12,435,000: ???-- $1 million, in five annual installments, to the Monterey Bay Sanctuary Foundation "to monitor water quality in the Elkhorn Slough." ???This is the deal that sparked the controversy. The funds were obtained for the foundation by the four environmental groups that opposed Duke, then dropped their opposition when the company put up the money. ???An additional $425,000, in three annual installments, will be given to the foundation "to monitor the power plant's heated seawater discharge in the ocean." Most of the money will be used, the groups say, to pay experts to take water and marine-life tissue samplings for five years. ???-- $610,000 to local agencies for air-pollution control, marine mammal care and trail building. ???-- $7 million to the Elkhorn Slough Foundation for land acquisition and management. ???Foundation Director Mark Silberstein said the money would be partly used to add to the 1,700 acres under the foundation's control and to pay for conservation chores such as removing weeds and planting native grasses. ???Some environmentalists don't consider Silberstein's plan genuine mitigation. Carolyn Nielson of Aptos, a foundation docent, quit in September after the $7 million deal was announced. ???"The groups made a cynical decision that never again would there be an opportunity for such financial benefit," Nielson said. ???Supervisor Calcagno also could benefit from the Elkhorn Slough deal by selling property or property easements to the newly enriched foundation. ???He owns MoonGlow Dairy, a 110-acre farm adjoining the slough and the power plant. The farm includes a 22-acre pond frequented by bird-watchers. ???As chairman of the Monterey County Board of Supervisors last year, Calcagno went on record in state hearings supporting Duke. He also said he had confidence in the Elkhorn Slough Foundation's ability to use the company's money to benefit the environment (Calcagno had been one of the organization's founders). ???There's no indication that a transaction involving Calcagno and the foundation is imminent. But Silberstein didn't deny the possibility of an eventual deal. ???"You need a willing seller, and Lou Calcagno owns that property," he said. "The door is open." ???Calcagno said he would consider a transaction. ???"That will probably be in a long-range plan. There is no doubt about that," he said. ???-- $3.4 million to the Moss Landing Chamber of Commerce, in 20 annual installments, for "infrastructure improvements," including power-line undergrounding, storm drains and street lighting. ???Here, too, Calcagno could benefit. ???Since the late 1980s, he has been planning a large commercial project on Highway 1, not far from Elkhorn Slough. The project has been dropped, but Calcagno still owns the land on which it would have been built, as well as stores and apartments nearby. ???Calcagno held a meeting at his office in Castroville last July to discuss how Moss Landing businesses would deal with the money Duke was offering, according to Jim Stillwell, harbormaster of the Moss Landing Harbor District. ???Stillwell -- who opposes the plant and contends that it will increase toxic sedimentation in the harbor -- said at the meeting that he believed the district was best suited to handle the money because it is authorized to undertake public works. ???He offered the district's services. He was rebuffed. ???"We proposed this," Stillwell said. "Next thing I know, they give it to the chamber." ???Calcagno confirmed the meeting and acknowledged that his properties could grow in value as a result of the Duke-funded projects chosen by the chamber, to which he belongs. He said, however, that he didn't care about the potential gains. ???"The Duke project in no way benefits me," he said. "I can't get out of my driveway when the traffic is coming in the morning." ???ASSEMBLYMAN BROKERS DEAL ???The four groups that made the deal with Duke insist they won't benefit. But the Monterey Bay Sanctuary Foundation, which will benefit, has connections to at least two of the groups. ???Sanctuary Foundation President Warner Chabot of San Francisco is also regional director of the Center for Marine Conservation, which led the way in making the Duke deal. The Sanctuary Foundation, additionally, has accepted cash grants from both the Center for Marine Conservation and another party to the Duke accord, Friends of the Sea Otter, tax records show. Chabot said the links are of no significance. ???"The great conspiracy does not exist," he said. ???Vicki Nichols of Save Our Shores and Kaitilin Gaffney, Central Coast program director for the Center for Marine Conservation -- both parties to the Duke accord -- echoed Chabot. ???But Gaffney admitted that there had, in fact, been much coordination between the groups before reaching an agreement with Duke. Gaffney's group and the Otter Project demanded $3.75 million -- $750,000 a year for five years -- within a week of each other in late October. Gaffney said this had been planned. ???Duke countered with offers no higher than a few hundred thousand dollars, according to people who participated in the talks. As negotiations between Duke and the groups bogged down in early November, Assemblyman Keeley was asked to intervene. ???"Fred prevented what could have been a bloody negotiation," Nichols of Save Our Shores said. "When he came in on behalf of the environmental community, Duke listened." ???Keeley was no stranger to the energy industry. As speaker pro tem of the Assembly, he has been prominent in attempts to deal with the energy crisis. And state records show that he has received nearly $50,000 in campaign contributions from energy companies since 1998, including $5,500 from the Duke subsidiary running the company's power plant in San Luis Obispo County, Duke Energy Morro Bay. According to Keeley, the total amounted to less than 10 percent of all the political contributions he received. ???"The things that drive me as a legislator are environmental protection, higher education and social justice," Keeley said, "and so when I get a call from two well-established environmental organizations saying we need help to get a better deal for the environment, I'm pleased to help."E-mail Scott Winokur at swinokur@sfchronicle.com and Christian Berthelsen at cberthelsen@sfchronicle.com. GRAPHIC: PHOTO, MAP, PHOTO: The expanded Moss Landing power plant is expected to account for 30 percent of all new electricity generated in California next year. / Associated Press 2000, MAP: Chronicle Graphic LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????45 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ?????????????????????JUNE 3, 2001, SUNDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: EDITORIAL; Pg. C6; DEBRA J. SAUNDERS LENGTH: 554 words HEADLINE: Draw a line in the sand BYLINE: Debra J. Saunders BODY: The irony is that while Gov. Gray Davis keeps demanding that President Bush impose wholesale price caps to save his state, Davis has made it easier for Dubya not to. ???By the time Davis was ready to take action on the electricity crisis, the only solution he could come up with was to spend his way out of a hole. At his behest, Sacramento started spending the budget surplus -- your tax dollars -- on power. As a result, while big power bills may squeeze some people, TV news broadcasts are not saturated with stories about California businesses receiving business-busting electricity bills and laying off workers to pay PG&E, which makes it easier for Bush to say no to price caps. ???Bush is right to say no to price caps. Even if the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission were to set price caps, the price caps would apply to less than half the electric market. Municipal utilities, federal power plants and Canadian outfits would be exempt. The Los Angeles Department of Water could still ask $ 1,400 for a megawatt hour that cost $30 two years before. ???So, when the Dems demand price fixing, know that they're not trying to fix the problem. They are trying to shift the blame onto Bushdom. ???Too bad Bush had made himself such an easy target. More Californians might get behind him on price caps if they believed that the administration would do something about price gouging. ???But Bush can't even look miffed about it. When I asked Veep Dick Cheney in March if there was price gouging, he answered, "There's no way for me to make a judgment." ???With such tepid rhetoric, it's hard to believe that the administration is doing much about the problem, even though Bush/FERC saw gouging when it ordered suppliers to pay $124.5 million in refunds for overcharging -- which Clinton/FERC never did. ???Asked what the administration was doing about gouging, White House spokesman Ken Lisaius recited the litany we've heard before: Tax cuts, $150 million more in assistance for low-income energy consumers, the need to increase supply. Also, Bush told FERC to get tough on "illegal price gouging." ???They don't get it. FERC should get tough on legal price gouging too. As Davis electricity czar S. David Freeman noted, "Even if the action is not criminal, what's happening is a crime." Let FERC use its regulatory arsenal to make life difficult for the high rollers. ???There's a little thing here called fundamental fairness. As FERC Commissioner William L. Massey noted, when cabbage spikes to $50 per head, people don't buy it and prices drop. That's the market at work. But an economy can't do without electricity, and there is no free market when the state is buying juice for utilities. ???Bushdom says the Davis price caps aren't the answer because they don't increase supply. Nonetheless, FERC has ordered very modest price controls to kick in during shortages. This is supposed to stop price spiking. ???Freeman says it won't help. If he's right -- hell, even if he isn't -- the president should invite key natural gas providers and other electricity biggies to Washington for a powwow. Let them know that there are limits. Let them know that regulation can be more onerous for bad guys. Draw a line in the sand.E-mail Debra J. Saunders at E-mail Debra J. Saunders at dsaunders@sfchronicle.com. LOAD-DATE: June 3, 2001 ?????????????????????????????47 of 143 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????Copyright 2001 The Seattle Times Company ??????????????????????????????The Seattle Times ?????????????????????June 3, 2001, Sunday Sunday Edition SECTION: ROP ZONE; News; Pg. A1 LENGTH: 1633 words HEADLINE: the energy crisis: ground zero In Stockton, Calif., where a long, hot summer looms, keeping the power on seems an easy trade for saving the salmon in the Northwest BYLINE: Lynda V. Mapes; Seattle Times staff reporter DATELINE: Stockton, Calif. BODY: ??STOCKTON, Calif.--It's the time everyone here has been dreading: the hot time, the dark time--summertime in California. ??This is ground zero in the West Coast energy crunch. Washington's concerns over salmon and increased electric rates--still among the cheapest in the country--seem pale by comparison to people worried about sewage backing up into streets when pumps won't run. ??But California's problems hit home in Washington. ??When California botched its experiment in electricity deregulation, Northwest ratepayers also felt the effects of the high wholesale power prices. Seattle City Light borrowed $250 million to pay its debt for power purchases and has increased residential rates 37 percent since January to help pay it off. ??The Bonneville Power Administration--which supplies about 46 percent of the region's power and is also planning a rate increase in the fall--is still owed about $90 million for power it sold to California utilities last winter. ??And when California temperatures soar and power demand jumps by as much as 40 percent in summer, it's typical for the Northwest to send as much as 1,000 megawatts of power southward every hour. That's nearly enough to light Seattle at any given time. ??BPA also is selling about 725 megawatts of power to California, even in this time of shortage, under long-term contracts. ??With the Northwest facing the second-driest year in its history, using water to generate power to send south this summer could also hurt salmon, which need enough water to aid their migration to the sea. ??But to some living at ground zero, fish seem an easy trade for power. ??"I'm not too much on the salmon," said Carl Swanson, an $8-an-hour security guard in Stockton, a town of about 250,000 on the San Joaquin River, 45 miles south of Sacramento. ??Swanson is facing up to an 80 percent increase retroactive to March in his power rate, already about double what the average Seattle City Light ratepayer is charged. ??"If they could give us some power to help people out I'd say go with it," he said of the Northwest. "It's getting ready to get hot. I believe human beings have to come first; the Lord put salmon here to eat. If you are a human, you have to feel for the next person." ??California, hit six times since January by rolling blackouts, has become a place where pets and people are panting at the veterinary clinic and the vet worries about losing power during surgery; where retirees on fixed incomes don't dare turn on the oven. ??Where the director of the municipal waste-water plant fears sewage backing up in the streets when the pumps stop running. ??Where workers at the city's port are scaring the crickets out of moribund World War II-era generators to keep its cargo cranes working. ??Where no one knows quite how all this happened, but where they are sure of one thing: Summer is about to roast some 32 million souls at the mercy of utilities that couldn't even keep the lights on in the lower-demand seasons of winter and spring. ??Long, hot summer ahead ??Hector Dominguez's restaurant, with its dozen tables and scuffed vinyl banquettes, is dim and stuffy. Half the lights are out and the thermostat is set at 80. Dominguez has unplugged the icemaker. He buys cubes these days to save on his power bill. ??His is a typical small business in Stockton. He has been paying $350 more a month for power this year than last, and that was before rates went up. He's wondering if the restaurant, in the family 17 years, can stay in business. ??Dominguez is the little guy: too small to be notified by the utilities when the power is about to go out, and operating on margins too thin to absorb the loss from a blackout. Like many, he's aghast to find himself so vulnerable. ??"At least in Mexico you kind of expect this. One day you have power, one day you don't. But not here. I expect them to be able to keep the electricity on." ??Capt. Allen Anton, assistant director of Stockton's emergency services, pulls a thick notebook off his shelf, the city's emergency plan. But it's not much use in a rolling blackout. Like everywhere else in the state, city and county managers are outgunned by uncertainty. ??Blackouts are triggered when operators of California's power grid see reserves dip below 1-1/2 percent of total statewide supply. ??When the power goes out, water pressure in the city's system can drop by half, depending on how long the power stays off and how much water residents use. "From a fire standpoint, your response is nil," Anton said. ??City police are outnumbered by the number of signaled intersections, and officials think staffing some and not others could be a liability problem. Motorists go it alone when the traffic lights blink out. ??The power company, Pacific Gas & Electric, has promised a 15-minute warning before shutting off the electricity. It doesn't always happen. ??"We get very little warning," said Ronald Baldwin, director of emergency operations for San Joaquin County. ??Baldwin doesn't fear brief rolling outages. He figures any community can handle those. But an extended breakdown of the power grid in 105-degree summer temperatures isn't something he rules out, or something he can really plan for. ??Just staying informed is a challenge. Some California legislators are proposing an electrical-supply forecast on the radio along with the weather and pollen count. ??Officials say they have been told to expect outages as short as 90 minutes and as long as six hours. They're bracing for a statewide total of anywhere from 300 hours to more than 1,000 hours of blackouts this summer, depending on whether they listen to utility officials, independent watchdogs or legislative analysts. ??Morris Allen, director of the city's water and waste-water-treatment services, faces the summer armed with nothing more than an 800 number to reach an electric-company recording if the power goes out. ??But he doesn't think California should rely on Washington's power to ease the crisis this summer. ??"Why should people in the Northwest pay for the fact that we haven't planned well for our growth here?" Allen said. ??"If it were a natural disaster, that would be one thing. But it isn't." ??At Sumiden Wire Products the power will stay on, because the company is on the same circuit as a hospital, one of the facilities exempt from blackouts in California. ??But while the power is reliable, the company can't afford it. ??One of the largest power users in San Joaquin County, the company has turned its shifts upside down to avoid costly peak power times. Workers now run the plant on weekends, at night, and in the morning. The plant shuts down at midday. ??CEO Bob Olson's contract won't be renewed come July. After 22 years at the plant, he's philosophical about the need to cut costs. Last year the plant just broke even; this year it will lose millions. Energy costs are the nail in a coffin of overseas competition. ??Dairy owners Mario and Ann Silva had just finished milking 750 cows when the power went out last month. ??"We have a generator but it blew up on us," Mario Silva said. When the milk truck came, they couldn't pump their milk into it. ??Their generator is being fixed, so a loaner is parked at the ready. Suddenly, in a state known for high-tech, a diesel generator is a necessity. ??Asked whether the Northwest should send power to California, Ann Silva doesn't hesitate. "Oregon and Washington, screw the fish. We can't conserve our way out of this. If that is the plan, we are dead ducks. We have to generate more power." ??For some, the question of survival is visceral. At Sheba's Liquors and Groceries, an unsteady parade of folks comes in for the bottles they'll sip from brown paper sacks as owner Nageb Algazali considers his summer ahead. ??When the power goes out, Algazali worries not about his ice cream melting--he's worried about getting robbed. "How will you protect yourself? The alarm will not go off." ??Lois Bond, 58, has stopped baking. She's stopped using the air conditioner that used to run from May until October. Now it's on 10 minutes in the morning and 10 minutes at night. ??She helps wrap her housemate with freezer packs to combat the heat. ??Bond unplugs every appliance in the house before she goes to work. She's replaced her electric clocks with battery operated ones; put compact fluorescent light bulbs in every fixture they fit, and cleaned out and unplugged the freezer in the garage. ??Across town, Victoria Garcia and her husband, Jose, loaded up their trunk with sacks of groceries from the Greater Stockton Emergency Food Bank. It is assistance that helps feed their family of seven on Jose's $14-an-hour welding job. ??A charity picked up $435 of the $1,000 they owed to the power company, but they still face monthly bills of $235 to whittle down the back payment, on top of current charges. ??Food-bank staff member Michael Mueller said three out of four people he interviews in line for eligibility these days need help in part because of their power bills. ??For the Garcias, blackouts and cutting back power use are frightening. Their 2-year-old son has asthma and requires treatments on an electrically powered nebulizer. His attacks are more frequent in hot weather. ??"I must give him treatments twice or four times a day, and with rolling blackouts, what if he has an attack? What am I supposed to do then?" Victoria Garcia said. ??"I'm a mom, I have to think of everything. And with five kids it's hard not to use power." ??She is looking for help anywhere she can find it to get through this summer, including Northwest reservoirs. ??"People," she says, "are more important than fish." ??Lynda V. Mapes can be reached at 206-464-2736 or lmapes@seattletimes.com. GRAPHIC: map; The Seattle Times: Stockton, Calif. (map not available electronically).: the energy crisis: ground zero (map not available electronically) LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001 ?????????????????????????????48 of 143 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????????????????The Associated Press The materials in the AP file were compiled by The Associated Press. ?These materials may not be republished without the express written consent of The Associated Press. ???????????????????????June 2, 2001, Saturday, BC cycle SECTION: Washington Dateline LENGTH: 249 words HEADLINE: Democrat calls on Bush to cap energy prices in radio address DATELINE: WASHINGTON BODY: ??Democrats are pressing their demand that President Bush set price limits on gas and electricity to help Californians deal with the energy crunch. ??In the weekly Democratic radio address Saturday, Rep. Anna Eshoo of California blasted Bush's speech during his recent trip to the state. ??"Californians were deeply disappointed about what President Bush didn't say," Eshoo said. "We were hoping that he would announce that he is taking immediate action and that price relief is on the way right now. ??"Westerners would immediately see relief from generators who are gouging and gaming the system by withholding power we have available right now to drive up prices five, 10, even 20 times its market value." ??Bush has rejected California Gov. Gray Davis' plea for federal caps on soaring electricity bills. Instead he has offered federal money to stimulate the building of more electrical lines running north and south through the state. ??"Price caps do nothing to reduce demand, and they do nothing to increase supply," the president told business leaders in California. ??But Eshoo said Bush's plans won't stop electric companies from raising prices to capitalize on the energy shortage. ??"All Americans are shouldering runaway prices at the gas pump," Eshoo said. "In the Midwest, people are paying as much as $2 a gallon for gas and some people are predicting prices could go as high as $3 a gallon before the end of summer. Please Mr. President, stand by consumers." LOAD-DATE: June 4, 2001