6 Nov 2000, 11:56 UTC
FYI
- From
- Daniel Douglass douglass@arterhadden.com
- To
- barbara_klemstine@apsc.com, bob_anderson@apses.com, dcazalet@apx.com, billr@calpine.com, jackp@calpine.com, glwaas@calpx.com, ken_czarnecki@calpx.com, Carolyn A Baker, rjhickok@duke-energy.com, GTBL@dynegy.com, kewh@dynegy.com, rpelote@energy.twc.com
- Date
- Mon, 6 Nov 2000 03:56:00 -0800 (PST)
From today's Electricity Daily re last week's FERC action: ? Commentary: Price Caps Cap Capacity, Not Prices "We should have learned the lesson by now. Price caps don't cap prices. Price caps cap capacity. We've seen that in California this summer, where, the investigation by the staff of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission demonstrates, price caps had the perverse, and predictable, effect of driving supply out of the state, pushing up local prices even further. The same phenomena cropped up in the 1970s with oil price controls and in the 1980s with natural gas price controls. FERC's actions last week on the California electricity "marketplace meltdown," as Chairman Jim Hoecker put it, were about right. The major slippery slope in the FERC California plan is its "price mitigation" approach. It is not really a price cap, not even a "soft cap" as advertised by some. Under the FERC approach, bids under $150/MWh will work as before, with the highest bid setting the market clearing price. But for bids above $150, a bidder would get what it bid (if dispatched), but the high bid would not set the clearing price for other bidders. So it's not a price cap. But it's a fiddle, and bidding above the $150 level would trigger some "market monitoring" requirements that would give FERC access to confidential company data in order to determine whether anybody was cooking the books. Commissioner Curt Hebert says he fears that having the prospect of FERC looking over their shoulders, and the possibility of refunds in the future, would scare some capacity out of the market. He may be right. More to the point, the whole thing may be unnecessary. The other steps FERC is taking are probably sufficient to kick-start to competitive marketplace. Particularly salutary are ending the mandatory buy-sell provision, enabling forward contracting and hedging, and fining companies for under-scheduling. Also welcome is FERC's order to the California Power Exchange and the California Independent System Operator to shut down their highly politicized stakeholder boards and replace them with independent, business-oriented directors, including the institution's management. Nothing has screwed up the California process more completely than the board shenanigans, particularly the political food fights at the ISO board meetings. As a journalist, I'm sorry to see them go. But as a businessman and a devotee of good public policymaking, I say good riddance. Indeed, FERC should have gone farther and ordered the merger of the PX and the ISO. Separating the two was another case of where California allowed politics to overcome sound reason, Californicating the restructuring. Among other things, the separate institutions, with separate staff and separate procedures, drive up transaction costs. A much sounder model comes in PJM, where one-stop shopping prevails. But, taken together and acknowledging that FERC's California action plan is only the beginning, I have to give the FERC staff and the commission high marks. Unfortunately, in typical FERC fashion, they have managed to launch a major undertaking during the coming holiday season. Coal in the stockings for that one, folks."