26 Jul 2000, 12:22 UTC
00-19
- From
- Ryan Siurek ryan.siurek@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 26 Jul 2000 05:22:00 -0700 (PDT)
fyi
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Ryan Siurek/Corp/Enron on 07/26/2000
12:22 PM ---------------------------
Kimberly Scardino
07/25/2000 08:35 PM
To: Ryan Siurek/Corp/Enron@ENRON
cc:
Subject: 00-19
I assume you have the huge EITF write-up (53 paragraphs of background). Here
is AA's (should we set up a time to talk about game plan on this - I know you
guys had a flurry of activity last quarter):
AA - Arthur Andersen
Hot Topics
EITF Action on Derivatives on a Company's Own Shares
EITF Action on Derivatives on a Company's Own Shares
July 21, 2000
At its July 19, 2000 meeting, the Emerging Issues Task Force (EITF)
tentatively resolved how certain settlement features affect accounting for
equity derivative contracts entered into by a company on its own stock.
Specifically, the EITF sketched out a model governing how such features
affect whether the contract should be treated as (a) an equity instrument and
reported in stockholders, equity or (b) an asset or liability at fair value
with changes in fair value reported currently in earnings.
EITF Issue No. 00-19, "Determination of Whether Share Settlement is Within
the Control of the Issuer for Purposes of Applying Issue No. 96-13 ," was
taken up to address implementation of the EITF's March 16, 2000, consensus on
EITF Issue No. 00-7, "Application of EITF Issue No. 96-13 to Equity
Derivative Transactions That Contain Certain Provisions That Require Cash
Settlement If Certain Events Occur ." The final consensus in Issue 00-7
generally stated that equity derivative contracts that contained provisions
that implicitly or explicitly required net cash settlement outside of the
control of the company must be treated as assets and liabilities and carried
at fair value rather than equity instruments carried at original cost and
reported as part of permanent equity as provided for in EITF Issue No. 96-13,
"Accounting for Derivative Financial Instruments Indexed to, and Potentially
Settled in, a Company's Own Stock ."
The Task Force also tentatively provided an extended transition period for
existing contracts and contracts entered into before a final consensus is
reached. The goal is to reach a final consensus at the September 2000 EITF
meeting.
The Model
The model,s governing concept is that, for a contract to be accounted as
permanent equity, the contract's provisions should put the company,s
counterparty in no better position than the company,s common shareholders.
Specifically, the EITF tentatively concluded that contracts in a company,s
own stock, such as written puts or forward purchase contracts, that come
under the scope of Issue 96-13 and have net share settlement provisions that
keep a contract from being classified as an asset or liability must have the
following characteristics * otherwise the contract must be treated as an
asset or liability at fair value with changes in fair value reported
currently in earnings.
The contract must permit the company to settle net in shares, at its option,
in either registered or unregistered shares. (It was determined that the
ability to deliver registered shares was outside of the control of a company.)
The contract must contain an explicit cap on the number of shares to be
delivered in a net share settlement. This cap must exist even if the contract
terminates when the stock price reaches a stated price trigger. (The need for
a cap was determined to be critical in determining whether a company had
sufficient authorized and unissued shares to settle the contract.)
At contract inception and on an ongoing basis, the company must have
sufficient authorized but unissued shares available to settle the contract
considering all other claims on authorized shares for stock options,
convertibles, and other transactions that may require the issuance of stock.
(This requirement was deemed critical as the ability to have a request for
additional authorized shares approved by the shareholders was deemed outside
of the control of the company. In this context, "the company" is defined as
the company's management rather than its management and shareholders.)
There is no requirement in the contract to post collateral at any point in
the contract or for any reason.
There are no required cash payments to the counterparty (true-ups) if the net
shares initially delivered are insufficient to provide the counterparty with
full satisfaction of the amount due. However, true-ups may be included in the
contract if the company only, not the counterparty, can choose whether to
satisfy the true-up in shares or cash and the true-up is subject to the
explicit cap discussed in item 2.
There is no economic penalty in the contract for net share settlement that
would economically compel the company to settle in net cash. (The right to
increase the number of shares delivered based on the fair value differential
between registered shares and unregistered shares was not deemed to be a
penalty.)
There are no provisions in the contract that would indicate the counterparty
had creditor rights, or would otherwise contravene the objective of this
model that the counterparty,s rights would rank no higher than those of a
common shareholder. (Subject to future EITF discussions, it may be possible
to meet this criterion by having a legal letter addressing the issue or a
specific statement of this concept in the contract.)
Related Issues
There was also discussion of the provisions relating to termination and
settlement in the event of a merger or change in control. There was general
support for a position that, as long as the counterparty received the same
choice of compensation as other shareholders (for example, stock for stock,
stock and cash for stock, cash for stock), the fact that the counterparty
might receive cash in such circumstances would not preclude equity treatment
for the contract.
Similarly, in the event of nationalization or liquidation, a net cash
settlement of the same type afforded a common shareholder would not preclude
equity treatment for the contract.
In addition, counterparty rights that did not exceed rights of common
shareholders should be acceptable, for example, rights to sue for damages in
the event of misrepresentations or a breach of warrranties or if a company
simply refused to perform under the contract, as long as a common shareholder
would also have those rights.
With respect to events that would cause a contract that was compliant with
the model at inception to later become noncompliant (for example, because an
acquisition consumed enough authorized shares that otherwise were needed to
satisfy the contract), the EITF concluded that, at the time the contract is
no longer compliant, the fair value of the contract should be transferred
from equity to an asset or liability at fair value with prospective changes
in fair value reported currently in earnings. There would be no immediate
earnings effect at the time of this transfer.
Further, if, at a later date, sufficient shares were authorized to again
satisfy the contract, the carrying amount of the contract (that is, its fair
value) would be transferred back to equity and the contract treated as equity
prospectively to the extent the contract continues to comply with the model.
(The company would not be permitted to reverse the gains and losses in fair
value recognized in earnings during the period the contract was treated as an
asset or liability.)
Transition
The EITF tentatively concluded that all contracts entered into after the date
of a final consensus will have to comply with the model at contract inception
to achieve equity treatment. (The goal is to reach a final consensus at the
September 2000 EITF meeting.) For contracts entered into before the date of a
final consensus, a company will have until June 30, 2001, to modify the
contract to comply with the final consensus.
For example, if a company entered into a contract before the date of the
final consensus, the company will have until June 30, 2001, to obtain any
shareholder authorization of shares needed to satisfy the criteria or to
modify their contract for the other criteria or any EITF changes to the
tentative model.
Since a variety of viewpoints are discussed at Emerging Issues Task Force
(EITF) meetings and it is often difficult to characterize the conclusions,
the following minutes may differ in some respects from the final minutes
available from the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB).