4 Apr 2001, 00:18 UTC
Littler Texas E-Lert - NOTE: Designed for HTML email systems
- From
- Littler Mendelson littler@swbell.net
- Date
- Tue, 3 Apr 2001 17:18:00 -0700 (PDT)
Littler Mendelson [IMAGE] About Littler Attorneys Offices Publications Seminars Contact Us ? [IMAGE]2001National Employer Conference [IMAGE]2001Texas Employer Conferences ? Dallas?- September 25 Cityplace Conference Center, Dallas For more information contact: Barbara Kuhlke 214.880.8110 ? Houston?- October?30 Four Seasons Hotel,?Houston For more information contact: Lisha Stuckey 713.652.4726? ?[IMAGE] ? [IMAGE] Littler Mendelson Texas Supreme Court Lowers Plaintiff,s Burden of Proof in State Discrimination Law Claims Suggestions for Avoiding Litigation In our previous Littler E-Lert, "Emerging Trends: Less Pretrial Dismissals of Employment Suits and More Trials," we discussed the likelihood that federal courts will be more inclined to let juries decide employment discrimination cases. Based on a recent Texas Supreme Court case, Quantum Chemical Corp. v. Toennies, Texas employers should anticipate the same trend in employment cases arising under the Texas Commission on Human Rights Act (TCHRA) in Texas state courts. Ralf Toennies worked for Quantum Chemical as an engineer. A few months after he began to report to a new supervisor, his performance reviews changed from being satisfactory to "below expectations." After Quantum fired Toennies for poor performance, Toennies sued Quantum, alleging that he was the victim of age discrimination. At trial (where the jury found no discrimination), Toennies did not introduce any direct evidence of age discrimination. Instead, he attempted to prove discrimination by establishing that the employer,s reason for his termination - poor performance - was false or a pretext for discrimination. Some of the co-workers called to testify at trial stated that Toennies was "diligent" and "very competent." The Texas Supreme Court held that this testimony and his prior satisfactory performance appraisals, which contradicted the employer,s explanation that Toennies was a poor performer, was enough to "permit the trier of fact to find that the employer was actually motivated by discrimination." The Court remanded the case for another trial with a new set of jury instructions to assess whether the employer's decision was motivated by Toennies' age. In its analysis of the case, the Court held that the question the jury should answer is whether the plaintiff,s protected status - age, race, sex, etc. - "was a motivating factor" for the employment decision. The plaintiff-employee does not have to prove that his or her protected status was the "sole" factor or the "determining" factor in the decision; instead, if the jury determines that the protected status "was a motivating factor," then the jury may decide that the plaintiff was the victim of illegal discrimination. While this merely may seem to be only a difference in verbiage, the shift is significant. The "motivating factor" standard is much different than proving that "but for" the protected status, the employer would not have fired the employee. The practical effect of the Court's decision is to increase the burden on the employer to show that it would have made the adverse employment decision regardless of the employee's protected status. This decision will make summary judgment in an employment case even more difficult to obtain in state court. Even if a supervisor does not have an illegal motive for the termination, if there is a scintilla of evidence that casts doubt on the reason why the employee was terminated, the employer,s fate may be in the hands of the jury. Accordingly, before making a termination or other adverse employment decision, we recommend that employers?perform an exit interview with two persons (other than the supervisor) present to ascertain if the employee has any discrimination concerns. Consider having the employee sign an acknowledgment documenting the topics discussed in the exit interview. If the employee alleges disparate treatment, the termination should be put on administrative hold until the issues have been investigated. The employee need not be reinstated, but the termination should not be made final until the investigation is completed. Review termination decisions with counsel, if necessary, to assess the litigation risks.? Finally, implement procedures to prevent hasty, unauthorized termination decisions. In addition to preventive measures, employers should also examine all pleadings, affirmative defenses, and jury charges in pending TCHRA cases to be certain that it has raised all defensive theories. For example, an employer may reduce damages if the employer can establish that it would have made the same adverse employment decision regardless of the employee's protected status. Each lawsuit should be reviewed on case-by-case basis to determine whether to raise that defense. *********************?? ?Texas Employment Lawyers of Littler Mendelson, P.C. ????????????Dallas Office?????????????????????Houston Office ??????????? (214) 880-8100????????????????? (713) 951-9400 Littler Texas E-LertTM is published by Littler Mendelson in order to?provide our Texas clients and employers with the latest developments in employment law.? It is designed to provide accurate?information on?developing trends or?events for employers to consider in keeping abreast of changes in the law.??Littler Texas E-LertTM?does not attempt to offer solutions to individual?situations or cases. ,??2001 Littler Mendelson. All rights reserved.? If you have received this electronic notification in error, or no longer wish to?receive further?electronic notifications of?this type from Littler?Mendelson, please notify Suzy?Varner?to have?your name?removed.? ?? - hdr-about.gif - hp-about-on.gif - hp-attorneys-on.gif - hp-offices-on.gif - hp-publications-on.gif - hp-seminars-on.gif - hp-contact-on.gif - Elert Box 1.bmp - button.gif