14 Sep 2000, 14:11 UTC
Fwd: [Tech] Enron {01}
- From
- Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
- To
- Mark Palmer
- Date
- Thu, 14 Sep 2000 07:11:00 -0700 (PDT)
What "polluting" Enron plant is he speaking of?
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Susan J Mara/SFO/EES on 09/14/2000 12:08
PM ---------------------------
"Robert Weisenmiller" <rbw@mrwassoc.com> on 09/14/2000 01:28:09 PM
To: Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, Mona L
Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES
cc:
Subject: Fwd: [Tech] Enron {01}
FYI
Bob
>Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2000 11:05:55 -0700
>From: "Holly A. Senn" <has@mrwassoc.com>
>X-Mailer: Mozilla 4.7 [en]C-DIAL (Win95; I)
>X-Accept-Language: en
>To: <rbw@mrwassoc.com>
>Subject: [Tech] Enron {01}
>X-MDRcpt-To: tech@mrwassoc.com
>X-MDRemoteIP: 192.168.1.41
>Sender: BadMsgQ@mrwassoc.com
>X-Return-Path:
>X-MDMailing-List: Tech@mrwassoc.com
>X-MDSend-Notifications-To: [trash]
>X-MDaemon-Deliver-To: rbw@mrwassoc.com
>
>Bay Guardian article featuring ENRON , 9/6/2000
>
>Slick oil: George W. Bush's toxic money pipeline.
>
> By Pratap Chatterjee
>
> EARLY LAST OCTOBER, every member of a ninth
>grade girls
> track team and the freshman the football
>team at suburban
> Houston's Deer Park High School's north
>campus returned from
> practice reporting severe breathing
>problems. That day Deer Park
> registered 251 parts of ozone per billion,
>more than twice the
> federal standard, and Houston surpassed Los
>Angeles as the
> smoggiest city in the United States.
>
> One of the biggest sources of Deer Park's
>pollution is a plant
> owned by Enron, Houston's wealthiest company
>d and the single
> largest contributor ($555,000 and counting)
>to the political
> ambitions of Texas Governor and Republican
>presidential
> nominee George W. Bush. Kenneth Lay, the
>chief executive of
> Enron, has personally given over $100,000 to
>Bush's political
> campaigns, more than any other individual.
>He is one of Bush's
> "Pioneers" d elite fund-raisers who have
>collected at least
> $100,000 in direct contributions of $1,000
>or less for "Dubya."
>
> Enron is best known as the largest buyer and
>seller of natural gas
> in the country. Its 1999 revenues of $40
>billion make it the 18th
> largest company in the United States. Enron
>is invested in energy
> projects around the world including the UK,
>Argentina, Bolivia,
> Brazil, the Philippines, Indonesia, China,
>India and Mozambique.
>
> The company has recently expanded from
>energy to "bandwidth"
> capacity for the Internet, making it one of
>the world's largest
> Internet-based trading companies, buying and
>selling a dizzying
> array of products ranging from pulp and
>paper to petrochemicals
> and plastics, as well as esoteric products
>like clean air credits that
> utilities purchase to meet emission limits.
>
> Texas activists say that this tight
>connection between Bush and
> Lay bodes ill for the country, if Bush is
>elected. Andrew Wheat,
> from Texans for Public Justice, a campaign
>finance advocacy
> group in Austin, compared the symbiotic
>relationship between
> Enron and the Governor to "cogeneration"-a
>process used by
> utilities to harness waste heat vented by
>their generators to
> produce more power. "In a more sinister form
>of cogeneration,
> corporations are converting economic into
>political power," Wheat
> explained. "A Bush election fueled by Enron
>dollars could fill the
> White House with dangerous levels of Enron
>gas. When that gas
> ignites in the public-policy arena,
>consumers will get burned." .
>
> Indeed Bush campaign spokesman Ray Sullivan
>said that, if
> elected president, the governor is keen to
>promote the kind of
> policies that he has crafted with companies
>like Enron for the state
> of Texas. "The governor believes in
>competition, free enterprise,
> better service and technology improvements.
>He has promoted
> sweeping and effective reforms in education
>and has been the first
> governor in Texas to seriously address
>limits on emissions. He will
> carry his agenda to Washington to do what he
>believes is best for
> the country."
>
> But is what Bush believes is good for Texas,
>good for the United
> States Of America? Texas has one of the
>worst environmental
> records in the country, particularly in air
>pollution. Unfortunately, the
> Bush platform for the country is very
>similar to the kinds of
> programs that he has worked on with Enron d
>cutting corporate
> taxes, deregulating industry and replacing
>social programs with
> private sector volunteerism.
>
> In addition Enron is invested in energy
>projects around the
> globe-some of which have been tainted by
>charges of human
> rights abuses. In India construction of
>Enron's controversial Dhabol
> power plant has brought charges by
>international groups like
> Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International
>of complicity with
> police brutality in rural communities. And
>according to
> California-based Amazon watch, Enron is
>charged with human
> rights violations in Bolivia, where it is
>building a major gas pipeline
> threatening indigenous communities and the
>rainforest
> environment.
>
> Special deals
>
> The Enron Methanol plant in Pasadena, Texas
>lies in the Houston
> Ship Channel area, the nation's largest
>concentration of
> petrochemical plants just east of the city.
>The Enron Methanol plant
> has won special concessions from Governor
>Bush allowing the
> company to pollute without a permit, as well
>as giving the company
> immunity from prosecution for violating the
>law. Indeed, plants like
> this in Texas actually emit twice as many
>nitrogen oxides, a key
> ingredient of smog, as do all the nine
>million cars in Texas put
> together.
>
> Only seven percent of the more than 3,500
>tons of nitrogen oxide
> emitted by the Enron Methanol plant in 1997
>were permitted.
> Enron got away with this under the
>"grandfather clause" of the
> 1971 Texas Clean Air Act which allows plants
>built before 1971 to
> continue their polluting practices. Governor
>Bush extended this
> clause under the 1999 Clean Air
>Responsibility Enterprise
> (CARE) program that his office drew up in a
>series of secret
> meetings with representatives of the top
>polluters in the state.
> CARE waives permit requirements for plants
>that volunteer to cut
> emissions.
>
> The CARE program is backed up by an act that
>Bush signed in
> May 1995 giving sweeping protections to
>polluters who perform
> internal environmental or safety audits. The
>law makes these audit
> documents confidential from the public and
>allows polluters to
> escape responsibility for environmental
>violations. To date Enron
> has conducted five such audits and filed for
>immunity from
> prosecution for violations of the law,
>according to the Texas
> Natural Resources Conservation Commission
>(TNRCC), the state
> equivalent of the Environmental Protection
>Agency.
>
> Tamara Maschini, who lives about five miles
>from the Enron plant
> is one of the founders of a local
>environmental group called Clean
> Air Clear Lake. "Whole families in this
>neighborhood have asthma
> because of the pollution from plants like
>Enron," she says. "It's
> gotten so bad that NASA has a problem
>recruiting people to work
> here at Mission Control which is just down
>the road. Houston is in
> trouble and George Bush is the reason d he
>has allowed the
> situation to deteriorate over the past
>several years," according to
> Maschini.
>
> Mark Palmer, head of public relations for
>Enron, says that the
> company's contribution to local pollution is
>minimal. "If the
> grandfather clause was canceled right now,
>we would benefit the
> most of any of the companies in Texas
>because our nitrogen oxide
> emissions add up to less than half a percent
>of the total," he said.
>
> Neil Carman, a former employee of the Texas
>Air Control Board,
> who now works for the Sierra Club, agrees
>that Enron's
> grandfathered nitrogen emissions add up to
>less than one percent
> of the total for all of Texas. However, he
>points out that Enron
> Methanol plant alone contributes 3.6% of the
>nitrogen oxide
> emissions from the nearly 250 stationary
>sources of pollution for
> the city of Houston d the equivalent of
>152,500 cars.
>
> What's more, he says that Enron is simply
>paying lip service to the
> Bush proposal to cut pollution at grand
>fathered plants. "Enron
> showed up at the governor's press conference
>to volunteer for the
> CARE program but they have been missing in
>action ever since.
> They haven't even bothered to file their
>voluntary plan."
>
> Giving and receiving
>
> If environmental regulators wanted to speak
>to Enron's senior
> officials about the missing voluntary
>program, they would be well
> advised to follow the presidential candidate
>around as he is often
> chaperoned by Enron officials.
>
> On April 7, 2000, Ken Lay, Enron's chief
>executive, played host to
> Bush junior and his father, former president
>George Bush, at the
> Houston Astros' first home game of the
>season at the baseball
> team's brand new stadium d Enron Field d
>which was built with the
> help of a $100 million donation from Enron.
>(The company got free
> advertising, a tax break and a $200 million
>dollar contract to
> supply power to the stadium in return.) Less
>than three weeks later
> Lay joined Bush in Washington DC for a
>Republican fund-raiser
> that topped all previous records by bringing
>in a staggering $21.3
> million, easily the biggest one-night haul
>for any political party in
> history.
>
> That's not all. Lay makes sure that the Bush
>presidential campaign
> has access to other Enron facilities. Last
>year the Bush campaign
> borrowed Enron's corporate jets eight times
>to fly aides around the
> country, more times than any of the 34 other
>companies that made
> their company aircraft available to the
>presidential hopeful. (Under
> federal law, campaigns must reimburse
>companies for
> transportation, typically at the cost of a
>first-class ticket so Enron
> received $25,000 from the Bush campaign for
>this favor).
>
> Lay's ties to Bush junior begin with his
>father, former President
> George Bush, who was also a recipient of
>Enron/Lay's financial
> largesse. Like his son now, Bush senior was
>also happy to return
> the favor, appointing Lay to the President's
>Export Council from
> 1991 to 1993.
>
> When asked about the relationship between
>the two men, Ray
> Sullivan, a spokesman for the Bush campaign,
>chose his words
> carefully. "Ken Lay is a noted business
>leader in Texas who has
> long been active in Republican politics. He
>is chair of the
> Governor's Business Council. But the
>governor has his own
> agenda based on what he believes is best for
>Texas and for the
> country."
>
> Lay toed a similar line when recently
>interviewed by the New York
> Times. "When I make contributions to a
>candidate, it is not for
> some special favor, it's not even for access
>d although I'll be the
> first to admit it probably helps access. It
>is because I'm supporting
> candidates I strongly believe in
>personally." Indeed both Lay and
> Enron are generous contributors to local and
>national politicians
> wherever they do business, often following
>the long standing
> corporate practice of funding candidates on
>both sides of the
> election.
>
> According to campaign records, Enron and Lay
>have contributed
> to Democrats as diverse as Texas Land
>Commissioner Garry
> Mauro, U.S. Rep. Richard Gephardt of
>Missouri and Texas House
> Speaker Gib Lewis. In 1984, Lay was Harris
>County chairman of a
> $1,000-a-plate Reagan-Bush fund-raiser,
>while at the same time
> co-chairing a fund-raiser for U.S. Sen.
>Lloyd Bentsen, the vice
> presidential candidate on the opposing
>ticket.
>
> Bush delivers just the kind of results that
>Lay wants. Candidate
> Bush says he will "work with local
>jurisdictions using market-based
> solutions and not try to sue our way or
>regulate our way to clean air
> and water." He proposes allowing industries
>to voluntarily police
> themselves, just like he did for Enron and
>the other polluters in
> Texas.
>
> Texas has regularly ranked as the most
>environmentally polluted
> states in this country for years. According
>to the Environmental
> Defense Fund, Texas has the worst record of
>all 50 states in air
> pollution, water pollution, overall toxic
>releases, recognized
> carcinogens in the air, suspected
>carcinogens in the air,
> developmental toxins in the air (affecting
>brain and
> nervous-system development in children) and
>cancer risk.
>
> While it is true that Texas was the most
>polluted state in the
> country before George W. Bush became
>governor, the reason it
> has stayed that way is simple: Bush's
>policies have effectively
> allowed these industries to continue to
>pollute through a system of
> voluntary compliance.
>
> Read the fine print
>
> Ken Lay and Enron's political beliefs
>overlap with candidate Bush
> in other arenas such as education. For
>example on August 20,
> 2000 the Houston Astros will host a book
>drive at Enron Field to
> promote one of George W Bush and Enron's
>favorite charities d
> the Reach Out And Read (ROAR) literacy
>program.
>
> Launched in 1998, by Laura Welch Bush, the
>governor's wife, the
> program calls for physicians and nurse
>practitioners to give free
> culturally appropriate books to their
>pre-school age patients at
> every checkup. Enron also regularly
>volunteers its employees to
> read to children in area clinics and
>conducts book drives. The cost
> to Enron for this five year publicity
>program was $400,000.
>
> Susan Cooley, the director of Texas ROAR,
>was gushing in her
> support for the company, the governor and
>his wife. "I've been a
> nurse for 25 years. I don't know anything
>about sponsorship or
> advertising. But at Enron they have whole
>departments to do this,
> so finding a corporate sponsor has been a
>godsend," she said.
>
> However Enron is less than supportive of
>schools that do not
> provide similar public relations
>opportunities. And its political
> reach goes beyond the governor's mansion.
>Some 20 miles north
> of the company's headquarters in Houston
>Enron has effectively
> cut approximately $225,000 from the annual
>budget of the Spring
> school district, one of Houston's ethnically
>diverse, poorer
> suburbs. Spring, Texas, sits on top of
>Bammel Field, a huge
> underground salt cave, which Enron uses to
>store large quantities
> of natural gas. As the largest business in
>Spring, Enron was
> required to pay taxes based on the value of
>its property and
> mineral holdings on January 1st of each
>year.
>
> But under a special 1989 provision Enron and
>other large
> business property owners were allowed to
>choose September 1st
> as their tax assessment date, when the
>company has less gas
> stored in Bammel field. Enron was able to
>reduce its property
> taxes by $15 million in 1990, blowing a hole
>in the school districts
> budget, according to Katherine Trumbull, a
>tax accountant with the
> school district .
>
> The Spring school district went to court to
>challenge the new tax
> provision as unconstitutional and won at the
>appeals court level.
> Enron appealed this decision to the Texas
>Supreme Court. While
> the case was pending Enron's Political
>Action Committee (PAC)
> and senior executives contributed heavily to
>the election
> campaigns of every Republican judges vying
>for seats (all the
> members of the Texas Supreme Court are
>elected and may take
> money from contributors for the campaign
>expenses). Enron's
> employees and PAC doled out $78,700 between
>the seven of the
> winning justices in the 1996 campaign
>including more than
> $24,000 from Ken Lay personally. The Supreme
>Court justices
> ruled unanimously in Enron's favor on May 6,
>1996, a month after
> Lay gave Chief Justice Thomas Phillips
>$5,000 for his campaign.
>
> "I have nothing against Enron, after all
>they are our biggest
> taxpayer. They can afford to pay for good
>lawyers and lobbyists
> and we can't," says Trumbull simply. Enron's
>Palmer had no
> comment about the tax lawsuit brought by the
>Spring Independent
> School District.
>
> Enron's global muscle
>
> Enron has also courted Bush's help for its
>business abroad. In
> March 1997 Lay wrote a letter to Bush, that
>was subsequently
> released to the press under Texas open
>records laws, asking him
> to contact every member of the Texas
>delegation to explain how
> "export credit agencies of the United States
>are critical to U.S.
> developers like Enron, who are pursuing
>international projects in
> developing countries."
>
> These agencies include the Overseas Private
>Investment
> Corporation (OPIC), a federal agency which
>provides political risk
> coverage and financial support to United
>States companies
> investing abroad d including hundreds of
>millions of dollars for
> Enron projects in countries from Brazil to
>India. Unfortunately for
> communities in these countries Enron's
>investments have had
> devastating impact.
>
> In India where Enron received $200 million
>in political risk
> insurance for the Dabhol offshore oil and
>gas development project
> in 1996, the company has been blamed by both
>Human Rights
> Watch as well as Amnesty International, for
>financing local police
> brutality.
>
> Just before dawn on June 3, 1997, police
>stormed the home of
> several women in Veldur, a fishing village
>in western state of
> Maharashtra, India. "The policemen forcibly
>opened the door and
> dragged me out of the house into the police
>van parked on the
> road. (While dragging me) the police kept
>beating me on my back
> with batons," says Sugandha Vasudev
>Bhalekar, a 24 year old
> housewife who was three months pregnant at
>the time of her
> arrest, according to Amnesty International.
>"The humiliation meted
> out to the other members of my family was
>similar to the way I was
> humiliated... my one and a half year old
>daughter held on to me but
> the police kicked her away."
>
> The only "crime" committed by these women
>was to lead a
> peaceful protest against a massive new Enron
>natural gas plant.
> An investigative team from Amnesty
>International found that a
> number of the women subsequently sustained
>injuries, including
> bruising, abrasions and lacerations on arms
>and legs. Several
> hundred other peaceful protestors have been
>arrested and
> temporarily detained by Indian police since
>December 1996,
> according to the report. Meanwhile, a
>January 1999 investigation
> by Human Rights Watch revealed that the
>police were directly on
> the Enron payroll.
>
> Likewise, Enron has been severely criticized
>for the Cuiab?
> Integrated Energy Project in Bolivia and
>Brazil, for which it
> received US$200 million in insurance from
>OPIC in 1999.
>
> On February 4, 2000 an oil pipeline operated
>by Transredes, a
> joint venture between Enron and Shell in the
>Cuiab? Integrated
> Energy Project, erupted in the Bolivian
>altiplano and dumped an
> estimated 10,000 barrels of refined crude
>oil and gasoline into the
> Desaguadero River, which supports indigenous
>communities like
> the Uru Moratos. Facing starvation from the
>loss of their life-
> sustaining waterfowl and fish, the Uru
>Moratos left their ancestral
> lands at the southern shores of Lake Poopo
>in April and marched
> 85 miles to the city of Oruro to ask for
>government help. TK result...
>
> 'Mutual self-interest'
>
> In January 1999 Enron pitched in $50,000 to
>help pay for Bush's
> inaugural bash in Austin, Texas, when he won
>the reelection for
> governor. If George W. wins this November,
>it is very likely Ken
> Lay will be on hand when Bush is inaugurated
>as the next
> president of the United States, hoping that
>in return for Lay's
> generous campaign Support, Bush will be
>equally generous in his
> support for Enron's businesses at home and
>abroad in the future.
>
> Craig McDonald, director of Texans for
>Public Justice, says that
> the relationship is bound to pay off. "Those
>two have a mutual
> self-interest in being buddies. Bush has
>always delivered on Ken
> Lay's political pitches. Enron depends upon
>government policies
> to enhance their bottom line in lots of
>ways. The company relies
> upon this kind of access to government," he
>recently told an
> Associated Press reporter.
>
> It is people from the Uru Moratas of Bolivia
>to the school children
> of Deer Park and Spring, Texas, who will
>ultimately pay the price
> through the continued destruction of their
>communities and
> environment.
>
> This story was made possible by the
>Corporate Watch Fund
> for Investigative Journalism.
>
>--
>Holly A. Senn
>Senior Information Specialist
>MRW & Associates
>1999 Harrison St., Ste. 1440
>Oakland, CA 94612
>p: 510.834.1999
>f: 510.834.0918
>e: has@mrwassoc.com