5 Dec 2000, 14:51 UTC
Telecom Services: Broadband Services: FCC'S 5TH SET OF OPEN ACCESS COMMENTS LOOKS FAMILIAR
- From
- Margo Reyna margo.reyna@enron.com
- To
-
Sue Nord, Scott Bolton, Tracy Cooper, Lara Leibman, Donald Lassere, Mona L Petrochko, Barbara A Hueter, Jeff Dasovich, Susan M Landwehr, Marchris Robinson, Ricardo Charvel, Stephen D Burns
and 1 more
Xi Xi - Date
- Tue, 5 Dec 2000 06:51:00 -0800 (PST)
Margo Reyna Regulatory Analyst Enron Corp., Government Affairs Phone: 713-853-9191
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Margo Reyna/NA/Enron on 12/05/2000 02:51 PM ----- djcustomclips@djinteractive.com 12/05/2000 10:09 AM Please respond to nobody To: 123363@WCTOPICS.djnr.com cc: Subject: Telecom Services: Broadband Services: FCC'S 5TH SET OF OPEN ACCESS COMMENTS LOOKS FAMILIAR FCC'S 5TH SET OF OPEN ACCESS COMMENTS LOOKS FAMILIAR 12/04/2000 Communications Daily (c) Copyright 2000 Warren Communications News, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Familiar lines were drawn in comments on FCC's inquiry into broadband access (00-185). "Four times in two years the Commission has investigated the questions of whether or how it should regulate cable operators that offer cable Internet services," AT&T began its filing, and many participants appeared to have drawn liberally from their previous remarks. AT&T and Comcast were joined by predictable group including Competition Policy Institute and Information Technology Industry Council in opposing access rules, citing growing competition from other broadband providers and existing access agreements with ISPs. Consumer groups and OpenNet Coalition took other side, questioning commitments cable has made so far. In war that has featured creative semantics for years, CompTel rolled out new weapon, calling for "minimum cable open access rules" that would require full unbundling of cable transmission platforms for telecom as well as ISP service. In filing that chided FCC for its inaction and "inadequate" step in ordering inquiry rather than rulemaking, consumer groups led by Consumers Union asked FCC to ignore recent federal court decision in Broward County, Fla., which struck down local access ordinance. Groups said ruling was "fundamentally flawed and does not bind the Commissions's First Amendment analysis. It is not supported by law or fact, and unlikely to be adopted by other courts." They said absence of open access has already allowed "harm" to set in as corporate actors make business plans and cement technology decisions through purchase and installation of equipment and infrastructure. Open access plans that have been announced have "not occurred because the marketplace is forcing that outcome," the groups said, but because various regulatory agencies "have been involved in unnecessary and time-consuming proceedings while the FCC remained on the sidelines." Opponents of open access warned of consequences should FCC begin access rulemaking. Comcast said rulemaking "would enmesh the Commission in extraordinarily complex matters that would require years of rulemaking and a mis-allocation of govt. resources that should be deployed in true competition-enhancing efforts." AT&T said enhanced regulation of broadband services isn't necessary because of competitive alternatives to cable broadband, including DSL, wireless services and satellite services. It also highlighted Canada's efforts to require open access to broadband cable, which AT&T said have been "mired in complex proceedings ever since, and despite these proceedings, Canada is no closer than is the United States to the development of the arrangements required for multiple ISPs to access customers over cable systems." Both operators celebrated cable's foray's into open access. Noting its recent agreement with Juno, Comcast said it "expects to forge business relationships with other Internet service providers, and is already taking steps necessary to prepare for such developments." Meanwhile, cable companies dismissed lightly USTA's petition to require them to pay into telephone universal service fund on revenue from cable Internet services. FCC "ought not to concern itself with the petition," Comcast said, devoting less than page to topic in its 45-page filing. It said USTA's petition is based on assessment that cable Internet is telecom service, which is far from settled: "That, of course, is the open question." Even if cable Internet is telecom, Comcast said, there would be "no universal service issue that requires Commission clarification." It said FCC's policy has been not to apply universal service requirements to ISPs that "self-provide" underlying telecom service. OPASTCO disagreed, saying requiring universal service contributions would "be consistent with the Commission's commitment to competitive and technological neutrality." It said allowing cable companies to escape contributing increases burden on other industries. -- Terry Lane, Sasha Samberg-Champion Folder Name: Telecom Services: Broadband Services Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 89 ______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClips or contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.com or by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved