12 Dec 2001, 22:24 UTC
FW: Calpine
- From
- Alan Comnes alan.comnes@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 12 Dec 2001 14:24:40 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Comnes, Alan Sent: Wednesday, December 12, 2001 9:11 AM To: Buerkle, Jim; Foster, Chris H. Subject: Calpine Good detail ... -----Original Message----- From: Robert Weisenmiller [mailto:rbw@mrwassoc.com] Sent: Tuesday, December 11, 2001 6:19 PM To: Comnes, Alan Subject: fyi <x-flowed> > > > Calpine's Credibility Crumbles > >By Peter Eavis >Senior Columnist >12/11/2001 06:49 PM EST > > >Calpine (CPN:NYSE - news - commentary - research - analysis) talks and the >market walks. > >The fast-growing power producer received a ton of flak Monday for taking >no questions on a conference call designed at rebutting a critical article >by The New York Times. Calpine held another call Tuesday -- with the >stated aim of discussing talks to renegotiate power sale contracts with >the state of California -- and spent more than three hours responding to a >range of issues raised by concerned holders and snarky critics. > > > >But soon after this marathon gabfest got under way, Calpine stock, already >down for the day, plummeted after a series of remarks by executives that >the market didn't like. It ended the day down 13% at $15.50, a 52-week low. > >If Detox had to make a list of why the market biffed Calpine during the >call, these would be the reasons: > >1. Dilution. Calpine executives said they would be willing to issue stock >at a low price if cash were needed, and if debt couldn't be issued because >it would push the leverage ratio above acceptable levels. (Leverage is >here defined as debt to total capital, while capital is debt plus equity >and equitylike securities.) The executives didn't say an equity issue was >imminent or probable. However, the fact that an offering could be done at >a low stock price would make it dilutive for existing shareholders. A big >negative. To raise $1 billion at Tuesday's stock price, Calpine would have >to issue about 65 million shares, equivalent to 20% of its shares >outstanding at the end of the third quarter. Notably, Calpine executives >said that they probably wouldn't use an equity issue to pay back a $1 >billion convertible bond that may need refinancing in April. > >2. Natural gas assets. Calpine said it could, if it had to, raise $1 >billion from "monetizing" its natural gas reserves. That would provide the >company with cash, but it would put an up-to-date price on the assets that >could be well below what Calpine recently paid for them. That might force >the company to do a big writedown to equity, which would, in turn, damage >leverage ratios. On the call, Calpine executives played down the notion >that they may have to do a writedown, saying future gas prices suggest one >isn't necessary. > >Related Stories >Calpine Holders Cringe as Cash Questions Swirl >Calpine Offers Cold Comfort >Calpine Offers Its Side of the Story >How Enron Came Undone >Dynegy Dives as Enron Won't Go Quietly > > >3. Earnings outlook. Not only did the company say it may have to revise >2002 earnings guidance, but it also showed uncertainty about >fourth-quarter 2001 earnings. This looks bad for three reasons. First, it >suggests that Calpine has more of its business unhedged than investors >have believed, leaving the company vulnerable to the slump in power >prices. Second, it will add weight to the argument that a glut of power >generation capacity is building. Third, and critically for investors >looking for a bottom in Calpine stock, a large cut in the 2002 earnings >outlook could make the stock look a lot pricier than it is at multiples >based on current Street estimates. Analysts currently expect Calpine to >make $2.52 a share in 2002, putting the stock on a bargain-basement >price-earnings ratio of 6 to 1. But if earnings were to be half that, the >P/E would obviously double to 12, which would actually be quite expensive >for a company that faces liquidity constraints that could force it to >jettison its growth strategy. If Calpine continues to struggle to clear >its name, a floor for its stock price may be book value, currently $9 a share. > >4. Renegotiating California contracts. Although this was the ostensible >subject of the call, too little was said on this issue. The company gave >no indication of how much business might be at stake and was reluctant to >surmise on how much of a hit it might take from recasting the forward gas >purchases made to fuel the power production. > >5. Accounting issues remain. Calpine revealed on the call that it uses it >own in-house method to calculate its leverage. This unorthodox method, >which adds $700 million paid for a Canadian gas company to equity, makes >the company's leverage ratio look lower than it actually is. At one point >on the call, a Calpine executive couldn't detail what was added to net >income to get to the company's earnings before interest, taxes, >depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) number. This is pertinent because >SEC Insight, a research firm that reviews internal Securities and Exchange >Commission documents, said in a report Tuesday that the SEC had talked >with Calpine about the way it presents its EBITDA number in its SEC-filed >financials. > >6. Bank loans and liquidity. Much time was spent addressing whether >Calpine can increase the size of a corporate revolving loan to $1.5 >billion from $400 million. The company said it thought it could do this in >early January. But banks that have gotten burned by lending to Enron >(ENE:NYSE - news - commentary - research - analysis) may now be scaling >back their energy exposure. What's more, Calpine is trying to raise the >size of a corporate loan, implying that the funds aren't needed primarily >for construction purposes. Could the need for new cash have arisen within >the company's trading operations? Calpine said Tuesday that its >counterparties weren't asking for more collateral. But if the trading desk >is consuming more, then it's even more unlikely that the banks will >increase their credit line, considering the Enron meltdown. </x-flowed>