19 Oct 2001, 22:00 UTC
OSBA Report Online HTML Version Volume 74 Issue 43
- From
- osbareport@ohiobar.org osbareport@ohiobar.org
- Date
- Fri, 19 Oct 2001 15:00:29 -0700 (PDT)
Goto Online Report Homepage></a> </td> </tr> <!--========================================= END TR SECTION 1 =============================--> <!--========================================= BEGIN TR SECTION 2 =============================--> <tr> <td width=Curving GraphicHand on Mouse GraphicOctober 22, 2001Vol. 74 # 43 Click to view Legis-Letter Click to view Classifieds Click to view Breaking News CLE Courses Unsubscribe [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Click to Visit Click to Visit Click to Visit Supreme Court Attorneys-Continuing Legal Education-Carryover Credit Attorney with 40.75 continuing legal education (CLE) hours during reporting period brought mandamus action against CLE commission to require it to apply 12 excess credit hours to next reporting period and prohibition action to prevent commission from disallowing the carryover. Since Gov. Bar R. X(3)(B)(2) entitles attorney who completes more than the required CLE in a reporting period to a maximum of 12 carryover credit hours, commission is not authorized by Gov. Bar R. X or its own regulations to deny such carryover because of attorney's failure to timely file report. Because of nature of hearing, commission did not exercise quasi-judicial authority in denying carryover, and prohibition is denied. State ex rel. Potts v. Comm. on Continuing Legal Edn. 93 Ohio St.3d 452 Attorneys-Discipline-Multiple Violations-Suspension Attorney is indefinitely suspended where she accepted retainer but failed to act on domestic relations matter, delayed repayment, and failed to cooperate in investigation. Cleveland Bar Assn. v. Demore-Ford 93 Ohio St.3d 417 Criminal Law-Association-Intrastate Travel Defendant was convicted of drug offense and subsequently of trespass in a drug exclusion zone. Although ordinance is justified by a compelling state interest in allowing public use and enjoyment within zones free from illegal drug abuse, it infringes on the fundamental right of freedom of intrastate travel and violates the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Because exclusion of defendant from drug exclusion zone was imposed by the executive branch, it added a criminal penalty for his drug offense neither imposed by a court nor authorized by state criminal statute, in violation of Ohio Const., Art. XVIII, ?3. Also discussed: ordinance prohibiting access only, not human relationships or associations; Supremacy Clause. State v. Burnett 93 Ohio St.3d 419 Criminal Law-Habeas Corpus-Parole Hearing-Guidelines-Due Process Defendant was sentenced for involuntary manslaughter and aggravated burglary and was denied parole, with his next hearing scheduled to be held in 10 years. Court of appeals did not err in dismissing petition for habeas corpus. Adult parole authority's alleged failure to follow its guidelines does not entitle defendant to release; he has no due process right to have alleged errors expunged from parole determination records; his parole was never revoked so as to trigger due process hearing rights; and his petition was defective because he did not attach all pertinent commitment papers, ORC ?2725.04(D). State ex rel. Bray v. Brigano 93 Ohio St.3d 458 Criminal Law-Habeas Corpus-Release-Good Time Credit Defendant was convicted of felonious assault and filed habeas corpus petition for release on grounds that his accumulated "good time" credits under ORC ?2967.193 and former ORC ?2967.19 entitled him to release. Court of appeals did not err in dismissing petition since statutory provisions do not reduce the maximum term of his indeterminate sentence and do not entitle him to release before serving the maximum. Hanes v. Haviland 93 Ohio St.3d 465 Practice and Procedure-Final Order-Attorney-Admission Pro Hac Vice Judgment of court of appeals reversed on authority of ORC ?2505.02 and Guccione v. Hustler Magazine, Inc. (1985), 17 Ohio St.3d 88. Klein v. Streicher 93 Ohio St.3d 446 Practice and Procedure-Judgment-Notice In a foreclosure action, trial court denied defendant's Civ. R. 60(B) and other pending motions, and defendant appealed. Writ of prohibition is granted where court of appeals erred in denying plaintiff's motion to dismiss appeal as untimely since bailiff mailed notice to parties' last known address within three days of entry of judgment, which complied with Civ. R. 58(B), and appeal should have been filed within 30 days, App.R. 4(A). State ex rel. Pheils v. Pietrykowski 93 Ohio St.3d 460 Public Records-Community General Hospital Association-ORC ?149.011(A) In original mandamus action by taxpayers and residents under ORC ?149.43 to inspect, inter alia, minutes of board of trustees of community general hospital association, writ is denied. Association was not subject to Public Records Act because it was not a "public office" or a "public institution" under ORC ?149.011(A). The municipalities had no control over hospital's operation and no board member acted in representational capacity for them, and provision of hospital care is not a uniquely governmental service. The initial issuance of bonds by municipalities for hospital's construction, without provision of funds for other equipment or operations, coupled with lease of building at arguably less than fair market rate, does not constitute support by public taxation. State ex rel. Stys v. Parma Community Gen. Hosp. 93 Ohio St.3d 438 Schools-Administrator-Termination-Notice-Mandamus-Appeal-Moot Relator did not receive written notice from school board of termination of his employment as an administrative officer as required by ORC ?3319.02(C), and court of appeals granted mandamus to compel school board to issue an "other administrator's" employment contract and to pay him back pay and benefits, but denied attorney fees. Since board awarded relator the extraordinary relief ordered by court of appeals, board's appeal is dismissed as moot. Also discussed: attorney fees as damages under ORC ?2731.11. State ex rel. Chapnick v. E. Cleveland City School Dist. Bd. of Edn. 93 Ohio St.3d 449 Workers' Compensation-Average Weekly Wage Claim for industrial injury in 1976 was allowed, and in 1996 claimant moved Industrial Commission to reset her allowed average weekly wage, which was denied. Court of appeals did not err in granting writ of mandamus limited to consideration of readjustment for two years preceding the motion. State ex rel. Lunsford v. Indus. Comm. 93 Ohio St.3d 448 Court of Appeals Opinions Children-Custody-Modification-Best Interests-Alcoholism After custody of minor children and residential parent status were granted father in divorce action, trial court did not err in modifying custody to mother who was moving out of Ohio and granting visitation rights to father. There was some competent evidence to support trial court's determination under ORC ?3109.04(F)(1), where father, an admitted alcoholic, was involved in several drinking incidents, one in front of the children, he had not seen an alcoholism counselor in six months, and the children were tardy to or absent from school many times. Sallee v. Sallee (12th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 366 Criminal Law-Plea Withdrawal-Right to Counsel Defendant, without counsel, entered no contest plea to driving without a license and was sentenced to a jail term and fine, and he moved two days later to withdraw his plea. Trial court erred in denying motion because the state failed to meet its burden in proving that right to counsel was properly waived under criminal rules where there was only mere written waiver of right to counsel. Also discussed: statement of facts and issues in absence of opposing brief. State v. Caynor (7th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 424 Criminal Law-Search and Seizure-Sobriety Checkpoint Defendant was indicted for possession of crack cocaine and criminal tools arising out of a stop and search after he made a U-turn on approaching a sobriety checkpoint. Trial court did not err in granting motion to suppress drugs and crack pipes where defendant had not entered funnel of checkpoint before executing legal U-turn into driveway and officer's view was not optimal. Where defendant committed no traffic violation, police had insufficient cause to stop him based solely on his turning around prior to entering the checkpoint. State v. Bryson (8th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 397 Criminal Law-Sexual Classification-Sexual Predator-Evidence-Recidivism In 1985, defendant was convicted of felonious assault after being indicted for kidnapping, rape, robbery and felonious assault, each with an aggravated felony specification of an earlier attempted rape conviction. Trial court did not err in classifying defendant a sexual predator 15 years after his felonious assault conviction. Under ORC ?2950.01(E), court properly received into evidence victim's statement and testimony that defendant's felonious assault was for the purpose of gratifying his sexual needs and desires. Victim's statement and testimony, defendant's lengthy criminal record and prior convictions and arrests, age of victim and violent nature of crime were probative of defendant's likelihood of recidivism. State v. Childs (8th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 389 Dentists-License Examination-Standing-Public Action Exception Trial court did not err in dismissing for lack of standing dentists' mandamus action against state dental board to compel promulgation of administrative regulation designating acceptable dental licensure examinations. Duty sought to be compelled is not for the benefit of the public sufficient to supply standing under the public action exception to general standing rules, and dentist who was awarded judgment in prior action remanding denial of licensure to board did not have standing because his license application did not depend on alleged invalidity of the rule adopted, OAC ?4715-5-03, or the rule he sought to compel by mandamus. Bowers v. Ohio State Dental Bd. (10th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 376 Negligence-Medical Malpractice-Res Ipsa Loquitur-Jury Instructions-Jury Interrogatories In medical malpractice action against hospital, doctors and practice arising out of patient's death after heart surgery from complications involving alleged puncture of trachea, jury returned verdict for all defendants. Trial court did not err in not instructing jury on breach of fiduciary duty and bailment since no fiduciary duty claim is necessary under medical malpractice and patient is not bailed property; in giving an interrogatory that allowed jury to find negligence without determining the cause because this did not nullify instruction on res ipsa loquitur; and in instructing jury on issue of res ipsa loquitur where court immediately corrected a slip of the tongue, and plaintiff failed to object at trial. Martin v. St. Vincent Med. Ctr. (6th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 347 Negligence-Slip and Fall-Hazardous Condition-Expert Testimony In negligence action for slip and fall in restaurant, jury returned verdict for restaurant. Trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying mistrial where plaintiff did not bear her burden of proof that restaurant created hazardous condition, and any error by trial court in failing to conduct evidentiary analysis after defense counsel referred to plaintiff's litigation history was harmless; in excluding testimony of plaintiff's expert regarding slipperiness of tile floor where he did not visit scene or perform tile experiments, and his opinion was based on deductive reasoning and the elimination of all other causes of the slip. Also discussed: trial court's comments not prejudicial. Eller v. Wendy's Internatl. (10th Dist.-2000) 142 Ohio App.3d 321 Nuisance-Municipal Corporations-Park Roadway-Recreational Use Immunity In nuisance action against city by bicyclist injured in fall after striking traffic control bump on roadway in city park, trial court erred in granting summary judgment to city on basis of recreational use immunity. Roadway is available to general public for travel by vehicles and bicycles for recreational and nonrecreational use. ORC ?1533.181, which affords recreational use immunity only, is inapplicable. Vinar v. Bexley (10th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 341 Practice and Procedure-Notice Dismissals-Double Dismissal Rule-Civ. R. 41(A)(1) Employee was discharged allegedly in retaliation for disclosing safety violations to Federal Aviation Administration and filed and then voluntarily dismissed federal court False Claims Act complaint and separate state court Whistleblower Act action, and then commenced a third similar action in state court. Trial court did not err in dismissing third action with prejudice under Civ. R. 41(A)(1) double dismissal rule because the three actions constituted the same claim under Civ. R. 41(A)(1). The actions arose out of employee's termination following his report of safety violations, even though the claims were based on different theories of recovery. Also discussed: dismissal of United States in action that included private claims; statutory ORC ?4113.52 and public policy Whistleblower claims. Forshey v. Airborne Freight Corp. (12th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 404 Torts-Defamation-Public Figure-Limited-Purpose-Actual Malice In defamation action by businessman against magazine publisher and author referring, inter alia, to his federal indictment, trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to defendants on grounds of plaintiff's being a limited-purpose public figure and lack of actual malice and fair-report privilege. Plaintiff is a limited-purpose public figure to whom the actual malice element of proof applies because over 100 newspaper articles concerning him and his business had been published over a 14-year span. Also discussed: federal indictment fell within fair-report privilege. Kassouf v. Cleveland Magazine City Magazines (11th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 413 Torts-Evidence-Spoliation-Bailment Employee was injured while driving vehicle owned by his employer and brought action for spoliation of evidence and on bailment theory against insurer based on its sale of vehicle for salvage. Trial court did not err in granting summary judgment to insurer since sale was not "willful" destruction of evidence where there was dialogue between plaintiff's attorney and insurer's representative concerning the status of the vehicle. There was no bailment where employee did not transfer a possessory interest in the vehicle to the insurer because insurer had already purchased it from employer. Also discussed: negligent spoliation of evidence. White v. Ford Motor Co. (10th Dist.-2001) 142 Ohio App.3d 384 Misc Court Practice and Procedure-Venue-Contracts-Place of Breach In action by employee for breach of commissions contract against employer, evidence showed that decision not to pay was made in county of employer's principal place of business, and employer's motion is granted to transfer venue to that county from county in which employer merely maintained sales office. Also discussed: county of breach controls for venue purposes, not county of contract's formation. Budzik v. Reynold's Mach., Inc. (Medina Cty. Ct. Com. Pls.-1999) 113 Ohio Misc.2d 17 [IMAGE] rounding corner graphic Opinion summaries prepared by Anadem, Inc., Columbus, Ohio. [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Ohio unreported appellate opinions Ohio Attorney General opinions U.S. Supreme Court opinions U.S. 6th Circuit opinions Ohio ethics opinions Ohio Revised Code Click here to visit Casemaker! [IMAGE] Docket Announcements Rules Announcements Calendar Click here to read more! [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Contributions to OHIO LAWPAC: A good investment for good government Participate in OHIO LAWPAC, the Ohio State Bar Association's political action fund. LAWPAC works on issues affecting your practice in the Ohio General Assembly and the administration of justice. Click to read more! OSBA sponsors Bench/Bar Conference Attend the first-ever meeting of the U.S. District Courts for the Northern and Southern Districts of Ohio. Click to read more! OSBA Report Online subscriber survey We hope you are enjoying the OSBA Report Online, but we want to make sure! Look for a future e-mail that will link you to our online user survey. This is your chance to let the OSBA know how you feel about this e-mail publication, as well as provide suggestions for its improvement. Your feedback is important and the survey will take just a few minutes to complete. More Association News... [IMAGE] [IMAGE] OSBA Logo - Justice is Hard Work Editor: Kathleen Maloney Technology Director: Fred Engel IT Engineer: Shane Zatezalo Membership, Public and Media Relations, & Publications Committee: William J. Davis, East Liverpool, chair Colleen E. Cook, Marietta Louis A. DiFabio, Geneva Michael H. Mearan, Portsmouth Kraig E. Noble, St. Marys Heather G. Sowald, Columbus [IMAGE] [IMAGE] To unsubscribe from this newsletter click here . To subscribe to the text-only version click here . For the online issue archives click here . To utilize the links to the caselaw in the OSBA Report Online you will need a version 5.x or higher web browser. [IMAGE] [IMAGE] Copyright ? 1997-2001 Ohio State Bar Association. All rights reserved. To submit comments or suggestions, send to OSBAreport@ohiobar.org [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE]