5 Oct 2000, 13:23 UTC
Energy Finance critiques
- From
- V Charles Weldon v.weldon@enron.com
- To
- David Haug
- Date
- Thu, 5 Oct 2000 06:23:00 -0700 (PDT)
David, Here are the reviews of the UT Energy Finance program that you requested: From Jennifer Martinez (MBA class of 1999, Energy Finance taken fall of 1998): The Energy Finance Program 2 years ago was very good, especially considering it was the first year of the program. There were a lot of guest speakers from various energy companies who gave us a lot of practical knowledge about the energy industry through case studies, lectures, etc. Basically, we learned all the same finance concepts and tools as in the regular finance classes, but all the cases and examples were energy-related. The professors were good for the most part but didn't have a great deal of practical industry experience. If I had to guess the reason for decreased participation in the program, I would probably say it is the professors. Ronn and Titman are great but known as being very technical and quantitative. Some students prefer less technical professors and classes that aren't limiting to the energy industry. Also, the fact that the class meets for 3 hours twice a week may not be so appealing. Other than those things, I can't imagine why there has been such a drop in enrollment. I especially don't understand why every single person didn't drop for Enron. I wonder if it has something to do with international status.??? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------------- From John Massey (MBA class of 1999, Energy Finance taken fall of 1998): Bottom Line - UT Business Schools is great - Investment Fund - Best Activity available to students Energy Finance program - Fairly Weak - It was a watered down version of the futures options class crossed with a weak finance appendage - The Finance teacher was pathetic - both a poor teacher, ignorant about industry specific analysis, devoid of industry experience, rude to outside lectures (from industry) Keith Brown was the only educator that was any good and he only had a small portion of the class time - Way to make Better: Get teachers with practical industry experience - Make it a seminar Class - Focus on Case studies, lectures - given by people from industry - Promote the class within the business school - I felt like UT did a poor job of internally (to students) promoting the class - ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------- From Ross Mesquita (MBA class of 1999, Energy Finance taken fall of 1998): To be honest, a great majority of the coursework was not energy specific. When energy applications were presented, it seemed more like general finance questions were reworded to include energy lingo. We had some very good speakers, but for the most part, I did not feel like the 6 hours of class had enough energy focus. I assumed that this would get better as the program progressed. One reason that may account for the decline in enrollment is that Energy Finance is a very specific focus. I would have probably not enrolled in the Energy Finance program had it been available in my first year. I did not know enough about energy at that time and I had returned to B-school to consider several career options -- i.e., investment banking, corporate finance, entrepreneurship, marketing, etc. As a new MBA student, I would not want to narrow my window of opportunities to only energy companies. Here is my perspective and probably something that is true of many MBAs-- My interest in Enron brought me to the energy industry and not vice versa. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------- From Billy Braddock (MBA class of 1999, Energy Finance taken fall of 1998): I was a participant in the inaugural Energy Finance program in the Fall of 1998. The primary positives to the class revolved around outside panels/instruction. For example, Enron sent representatives on 2 separate occasions to discuss particular topics (Vince Kaminski and Gary Hickerson). Other notable speakers were Jeff Sandefer (independent business consultant and E&P professional), the Beacon Group, and Encap Investments. Another good speaker was a professor from UT's school of engineering. He brought a good perspective as to the "basics" of the energy business. The class was structured via a team-based instruction approach, with 3 professors team-teaching a 6-hour credit course. None of the 3 professors had any product knowledge of the energy business. Of the 3 professors, 2 were research focussed/tenured with little credibility in "teaching." One of the professors primary focus of research was fixed income, while the other 2 were investments and corporate finance, respectively. As is the case for UT's finance program in general, and energy finance in particular, UT is in dire need of teaching professors (as opposed to research professors) that have the ability to convey finance with practical examples and at a level that can be more easily be understood by students without a finance background. Particular to the energy program, UT needs to have more instruction from energy professionals (such as the instructors used for Enron's internal learning programs (ie. Derivatives classes, etc.). ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------- From Bryan Williams (MBA class of 1999, Energy Finance taken fall of 1998): I participated in the first Energy Finance class offered in Fall of 1998, at the University of Texas. The curriculum was understandably &rough around the edges8 as 1998 was the first year the Energy Finance course was offered. However, the instruction also suffered as none of the instructors had any energy background to speak of (The 6-credit hour class was team taught by three tenured professors). Two of the three professors have co-authored textbooks, and the third professor,s claim to fame is fixed income. As a group, the three professors are research-heavy (as opposed to industry focused), and the team-teaching format did not incent any one of the profs to be personably accountable for the success of the class. That said, the instructors did a good job attracting some top notch outside speakers. Among them: Vince Kaminski & Gary Hickerson, both of Enron. They also dedicated one class period to a video conference call with the Beacon Group, an energy consulting group that I believe was recently acquired by Goldman. Jeff Sandefer, an independent businessman, an entreprenuership instructor, and one of the foremost experts in the E&P sector, also spoke to the class. Jeff was joined by some of the executives from Houston-based Encap. The woes of the Energy Finance could be easily remedied by injecting some instruction from someone from industry. The class is too academic/theoretical with too few relevant examples excerpted from the energy sector. The instructors Enron uses for the Derivatives courses taught internally are good examples of people who can package very relevant information and successfully articulate it in a couple of days. Perhaps a similar approach would bode well for the Energy Finance program at UT. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------- From Yuan Tian (MBA class of 2000, Energy Finance taken fall of 1999): Here are my thoughts on the UT Energy Finance Program: Pros: - more focused on the Finance studies in the Energy Industry which is right now in a transition period from regulation to deregulation and thus is exposed to different financial perspectives from the other industries; - there are some experienced, brand-name professors (e.g. Sheridan Titman) teaching in the program; Cons: - the program should give the students more exposures to energy companies such as Enron. Specifically, it might need to help students link to the interview oppurtunites from these energy companies such as Enron; ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------------------- From George Huan (MBA class of 2000, Energy Finance taken fall of 1999): Companies expect MBA students to have both general management (new ideas) and analytic (quantative) skills. Energy industry is no exception. Energy Finance Program offers Financial Strategy and Risk Managements courses which fit in the insudtry need. However, these two courses are far from enough to help students understand the dynemic of industrial transformation and excitements and opportunities in this industry. Other management and quantitive courses are needed to complete this program. My suggestions: 1) Seminars or lectures about energy industry and energy companies. Before students make their decisions, let them know: What's happening and what's going to happen in this industry; What the companies are doing now; Who they are looking for. 2) Management and/or analytical courses should be included. Such as: Strategy, Financial enginering and Real Option. 3) More industry connections. Presentations and discussions. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------- From Charlie Weldon (MBA Class of 2000, Energy Finance taken in fall of 1999) My experience in the Energy Finance program overall was a positive experience. The most rewarding part of the class was the guest speakers brought in during Dr. Titman's portion of the class. This part of the course is taught in the second half of the semester and consisted of ~10 case classes all focusing on the Energy industry. Two of the cases were based on Enron, and overall the case selection in my opinion was very appropriate and well thought out. Value added by the professor was less than from the speakers and cases. The first eight weeks of the course covered futures and options. Nearly all of the examples and problems discussed pertained directly to the energy industry and special emphasis was placed on increasing the student's understanding of the supply and demand dynamics in the power market. The use of options and futures for speculating and/or hedging was stressed on numerous occasions and a decent attempt at explaining how to value a power plant project. I believe that the University Energy Finance faculty are trying to continuously make improvements to the program. However, I do not believe that they are moving fast enough or necessarily down the right path to improvement. There is a strong need for more practical based training on energy derivatives similar to the course taught by Paradigm here at Enron. The focus of the University teachers is quite theoretical, due in large part to their background. While the theoretical basis is crucial to understanding the basics, the real value of such a program in my opinion is the effective bridging of the theoretical with the practical all in one course. Until measures are taken to inject practicality from someone with extensive industry experience, I believe the Energy Finance program will continue to underdeliver on its objectives. Additionally, I believe that the course structure should be changed to eliminate the need of having 3 consecutive hours of classroom instruction.