18 May 2001, 10:45 UTC
RE: Updated Core/Non-Core Analysis
- From
- Michael Tribolet michael.tribolet@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 18 May 2001 03:45:00 -0700 (PDT)
I agree that the plug T&D figures look too high. Chip Schneider and I were looking at another way, and they look too high. Here is a revised chart (to include looking at the relative ratio of core/non core cost). I took the SDGE one up slightly (102%, from 100%) to reflect the mid-point of Core/non core %. Robert, let me know if you want to adjust this. I have attached a revised file. Note also that at the bottom I took the 10-K revenue and kwh, and subtracted the gen portion (per kwh) showing in the MOU literature as yet another cut. As per usual there is a difference. PGE SCE SDGE Core Rate T&D (cents) 4.888 5.250 6.379 Non Core T&D (cents) 2.213 1.783 2.477 All T&D (cents) 3.910 4.200 6.230 Total dollars T&D $ 3,206 $ 3,519 $ 1,072 Core T&D/non core T&D 221% 294% 258% Core T&D/ All T&D 125% 125% 102%
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: Neustaedter, Robert
Sent: Friday, May 18, 2001 9:10 AM
To: Tribolet, Michael
Cc: Kingerski, Harry; Steffes, James; Dasovich, Jeff; Soo, Jeffrey A.; Brown,
Kortney
Subject: RE: Updated Core/Non-Core Analysis
I would like to step back to the plug number for T&D and suggest another
method. The plug, as I understand it, is calculated by building up
generation cost from the MOU presentation and substracting that number from
the total utility revenues reflected in the Lynch decision. Unless the
generation component reflected in the MOU and Lynch's decision are the same
(and I don't think they are), this won't result in a proper number.
For PGE, I am very confident that their non-generation costs are equal to
$.0391 per kWh based upon PGE data filed in the rate design hearing. That
rate multiplied by 81,991 results T&D cost of $3,206. I think this is the
number that should be used for PGE. I don't think you should tie to the
$11,400 number. The T&D number would need to be adjusted for the
core/non-core adjustment factor (core = 125% of average).
For SCE, assuming that the system average generation rate is $.073 and that
the existing total system average rate is $.1132, that leaves a
non-generation system average rate of $.042 which equates to total T&D cost
of $3,519. Because the PGE and SCE systems have a similar per unit rate for
T&D (4.02 v 3.91) and the mix between core and non-core are similar I think
using the 125% factor is reasonable for SCE.
Going through similar calculations and assumptions I come up with a T&D per
unit cost of $.0623 for SDGE. Because their mix of core and non-core is
heavily tilted toward core the above factor would not be applicable.
Perhaps, not adjusting it at all would not be too far off.
Call me if you have questions.
Michael Tribolet/ENRON@enronXgate 05/18/2001 08:27 AM To: Kortney
Brown/ENRON@enronXgate, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Robert
Neustaedter/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Harry
Kingerski/NA/Enron@Enron, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Jeffrey A
Soo/ENRON@enronXgate Subject: RE: Updated Core/Non-Core Analysis
I re-set the Core to Non Core T&D (in cents) ratio (see the bottom of the
spreedsheet for relative cost and attached the spreadsheet) to 200%. As you
can see the analysis is very sensative to this apportionment. Robert and
Harry, any additional ideas about apportioning this would improve the model's
accuracy.
PGE SCE SDGE
Core Rate T&D 5.721 7.240 7.616
Non Core T&D 2.867 3.620 3.809
Total $ 3,836 $ 5,147 $ 1,285
Core T&D/Non Core T&D 200% 200% 200%
By taking PGE's FYE 2000 10-K, I find the following:
Consumer Rev $3008
All Other $3658
Total $6666
Estimated T&D $3836
Gen portion $2830
Consumer Kwh 28,753
Other 53,170
Total 81,923
If 45.1% of revenue is from consumer, and the T&D is estimated at $3836, you
can apportion T&D if you assume gen is apportioned pro-rata:
Consumer Other Total
Gen 993 1837 2830
T&D 2015 1821 3836
Total 3008 3658 6666
T&D (cents)/kwh 7.01 3.42 4.68
<< File: m010508b.xls >>
-----Original Message-----
From: Brown, Kortney
Sent: Thursday, May 17, 2001 6:31 PM
To: Dasovich, Jeff; Neustaedter, Robert; Kingerski, Harry
Cc: Tribolet, Michael; Soo, Jeffrey A.
Subject: Updated Core/Non-Core Analysis
Attached is the revised Core/Non-Core Analysis per our discussion. We have
updated to include the new CPUC rate schedules for PGE and SCE and a toggle
switch 20- year bond scenario to cover the past utility debt that is the
burden of Non-Core. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Kortney
<< File: CoreNonCoreAnalysiswoDWRNewRates.xls >>