15 Dec 2000, 08:54 UTC
Re: FX Product
- From
- Sara Shackleton sara.shackleton@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 15 Dec 2000 00:54:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT on 12/15/2000 08:58 AM ----- Susan Musch@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 12/14/2000 08:18 PM To: Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Subject: Re: FX Product Sara, Given my discussion with Sheila Glover and Darren Delage last night, I think this is the structure we're going to use. We just need to set up the service agreement. Best regards, Susan From: Sara Shackleton@ECT on 12/14/2000 04:40 PM To: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Subject: Re: FX Product Susan: Thanks for the update. Gary Hickerson wants this product available on EOL now (which explains why I am called daily by the trading desk). Do you know when a decision on the Japanese FX principal will be forthcoming? Sara Susan Musch@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 12/14/2000 03:56 PM To: Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Janine Juggins/LON/ECT@ECT, Melba Lozano/HOU/ECT@ECT, William Stuart/HOU/ECT@ECT, Steve Jacobellis/NA/Enron@Enron@ECT, Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT, Rhett Jackson/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: FX Product Sara, Attached are two e-mails that I sent yesterday and today on the Japanese FX trader. In short, we are pursuing the dependent agency approach. The specifics are set forth in the e-mails. Please let me know if you have any questions or need any additional information. Best regards, Susan Susan Musch 12/14/2000 09:46 AM To: Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Jan-Erland Bekeng/AP/Enron@Enron, Sheila Glover@ECT, Darren Delage@Enron, Scott Gilchrist/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Janine Juggins@ECT, Rod Sayers@ECT (bcc: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT) Subject: FX Trader in Tokyo Heidi, In response to your attached e-mail, I am attaching the e-mail message that I sent out yesterday regarding the structure for the FX trader in Tokyo and the EM-Japan traders. (You were already copied on this but I want to make sure that you got it.) In this e-mail, I explain that PWC-Tokyo has recommended following a dependent agent approach for these traders (which is what you reference in your attached e-mail). I recommend this approach saying that it is a pragmatic approach and should be easily implemented. I talked with Sheila Glover and Darren Delage about this approach yesterday evening and they like it as well. (In fact, they were also copied on the e-mail regarding the FX trader and the EM-Japan traders.) The following points should be kept in mind in following the dependent agent approach, which I have already discussed with Sheila and Darren: (1) Agency approach: Enron Japan would be considered to be an agent of ENA. In this role, it would facilitate trades that would be entered into between ENA and the third party counterparties. The trades would be entered into in the name of ENA. Under this approach, Darren is limited in what he is authorized to do, and his trading parameters will need to be reduced to writing. These parameters must restrict his activities so that they constitute activities that have a preparatory or auxiliary character. The advice that we received for the FX trader's activities in Australia should equally apply to our facts here. The following is an excerpt from a memo that I wrote last year summarizing this advice: Guidelines and boundaries must be established on what the financial trader can do (e.g. price parameters, product parameters, etc.). Activities cannot include the negotiation of terms of master contracts, forwards and other derivatives with counterparties. If a master contract must be executed in Australia, then it should be executed by an independent agent (such as a lawyer) having a power of attorney from the hedging party. Confirmations should be issued by the hedging party, rather than by EA Finance in Sydney. The Australian tax advisor recommended that the financial trader say: &My principal will deal with you within these parameters (.8 (2) Darren's employment: Darren must be considered an employee of Enron Japan so as to avoid ENA being treated as having a permanent establishment in Japan. (3) Darren's agency role: Darren should not identify himself as an employee of ENA Houston. He should make it clear that the third parties are entering into the transactions with ENA as principal. (4) Service agreement: A service agreement must be put in place between Enron Japan and ENA (similar to what we did for the FX trader in Sydney). Enron Japan should at least initially be compensated at a cost plus 5% mark-up. Yesterday evening I also forwarded to Sheila and Darren by e-mail the old service agreement that we put in place for the FX trader in Sydney so that they could review what terms have been previously used. (Incidentally, the service agreement we put in place between Enron Australia and ENA was very similar (almost identical) to the one that was put in place between Enron Europe and ENA for the FX trader in London.) (5) Potential issues upon Japanese tax audit: Notwithstanding that this approach is easier to implement, more workable and more pragmatic in approach, we need to be aware that there could be questions upon a Japanese tax audit. In that event, transfer pricing issues could be raised. That is, the auditors could question whether a cost plus 5% mark-up is commensurate with what an unrelated third party would charge for similar services. We would then need to justify that service fee, or if unsuccessful, try to work out a commission fee that would be acceptable to the Japanese tax auditors. Management needs to be aware of this potential. I guess I wasn't clear in my attached e-mail. I am sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused you. I hope this e-mail better explains the recommended structure. Please let me know if you would like to set up a conference call to discuss this further (and let me know who you would like on the call). Best regards, Susan Susan Musch 12/13/2000 06:07 PM To: Jan-Erland Bekeng/AP/Enron@ENRON cc: Jane McBride@Enron, Tina Ward@ECT, Paul Simons@ECT, Alan Aronowitz@ECT, Rod Sayers@ECT, Janine Juggins@ECT, Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Joseph P Hirl/AP/ENRON@ENRON, Sheila Glover@ECT, Darren Delage@Enron (bcc: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT) Subject: Enron Metals & FX Traders in Japan Jan-Erland, I have not yet received the 2001 projections/budget for the Enron Metals trading in Japan. If you have already sent it, could you please re-send it? Also, I talked with PWC-Tokyo late last night about structuring for the FX trader and Japanese Metals traders to confirm Baker & McKenzie's advice on not using a dependent agent structure in Japan. PWC has advised that although Baker & McKenzie's approach is more technically correct, foreign traders usually set up their Japanese trading operations through the use of a dependent agent in Japan. The Japanese dependent agent is usually reimbursed using cost plus 5%, at least initially. Then, if the Japanese tax authorities raise questions upon audit, a commission arrangement is generally used, with the question being what should the profit split be between the agent and the foreign company. Whether the Japanese tax authorities raise questions upon audit is dependent upon the volume of trades and the magnitude of the trades. The PWC Japanese tax partner suggested that we use this arrangement for both the FX trader and the EM Japan trades. I have asked PWC to send this advice in writing by tomorrow. This seems to be a much more pragmatic approach than the one suggested by Baker & McKenzie. And it should be easy to implement by year-end. However, management must be aware of the fact that PWC's approach could raise questions upon a Japanese tax audit. Note that if we follow this approach, we would need to set up a services agreement between Enron Japan (whichever the appropriate entity is) and ENA. Please let me know if you have any questions or need any additional information. Best regards, Susan HEIDI MASON 12/13/2000 08:38 PM To: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Jan-Erland Bekeng/AP/Enron@Enron Subject: Re: Japanese Financial Subsidiary Thanks for the note Susan. Like you, I would love to get the funding resolved before year-end as we have finalised the amounting owing to Houston etc (subject to some invoices etc being received) so it would be a good time to get this done. Re the FX trader, I have been harassing Sheila a bit this week, so I was hoping to hear from you or her on the progress here. At this stage I understand that the deals are still being done in the name of ENA, but there have not been alot, so again if we can get this addressed before the volume grows it would be best for all. I was reviewing this matter with JEB yesterday and he indicated that his preference is for an agency style agreement which avoids the need for the back to back deals. With thanks Heidi Mason Chief Financial Officer Enron Australia From: Sara Shackleton@ECT on 12/14/2000 01:22 PM To: Janine Juggins/LON/ECT@ECT, Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Melba Lozano/HOU/ECT@ECT, William Stuart/HOU/ECT@ECT, Steve Jacobellis/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT, Rhett Jackson/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: FX Product Janine: Thanks for the update. Any word on the Japanese FX desk principal? Sara ----- Forwarded by Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT on 12/14/2000 01:23 PM ----- Janine Juggins 12/13/2000 04:04 PM To: Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT, Rhett Jackson/HOU/ECT@ECT, Melba Lozano/HOU/ECT@ECT, Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT Subject: Re: FX Product Your summary is correct based on information to date (in this regard the agreement between ENA and EEFT still requires amendment in respect of RMT and I undertake to get this done). However, please note that there have been some last minute changes in the Japanese tax advice, received I understand only as of last night. Susan Musch will be following up on these changes at a meeting today with Sheila Glover and Darren Delage, and has undertaken to keep you appraised of the position. The effect of the change would be to permit RMT to be the principal for the Japanese FX desk, with a Japanese entity acting as agent to arrange the transactions. Best regards Janine From: Sara Shackleton on 13/12/2000 13:52 CST To: Janine Juggins/LON/ECT@ECT cc: Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT, Rhett Jackson/HOU/ECT@ECT, Melba Lozano/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: FX Product Janine: With respect to the attached (internal) FX product for EOL, I just wanted to verify with you that internal counterparties should transact on EOL with: (1) RMT (as principal for Houston FX desk) (2) EEFT as agent for RMT (as principal for London FX desk). In this regard, was the services agreement between ENA and EEFT ever extended to include RMT for internal trades? (3) Enron Japan Corp. (as principal for Tokyo FX desk) There appears to be some confusion since our meeting of November 3. Thanks. Sara ----- Forwarded by Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT on 12/13/2000 11:22 AM ----- Melba Lozano 12/11/2000 05:59 PM To: Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Robert B Cass/HOU/ECT@ECT, Steve Jacobellis/NA/Enron@Enron, Kevin Meredith/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Steve Jacobellis/NA/Enron@Enron Subject: FX Product Sara / Mark, I need an approval as soon as possible from you for the FX Description attached. Steve Jacobellis is requesting that this gets out on the web as soon as possible. Thank you, Melba 58986 ---------------------- Forwarded by Melba Lozano/HOU/ECT on 12/11/2000 05:53 PM --------------------------- From: Melba Lozano 11/30/2000 06:41 PM To: Sara Shackleton/HOU/ECT@ECT, William Stuart/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Robert B Cass/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: FX Product Sara: Please approve on the attached language for the FX Product. William: There is a gap between hour ending 3:00 and 4:00 . Do you want to go ahead and set up Central time to trade until Hour Ending 4:00? Please let me know. Thank you, Melba