12 Mar 2000, 20:51 UTC
CORRECTED: New Update on PPI Model for Inflation Book
- From
- Anjam Ahmad anjam.ahmad@enron.com
- Date
- Sun, 12 Mar 2000 12:51:00 -0800 (PST)
Dear all, I followed up on the suggestions at the conference call as follows:- 1) USE LESS DATA Unfortunately, kicking out only 1990 makes the overall equation a lot less robust, in fact dramatically so, and so eliminates the possibility of using less data. The model tested was the RPI(month+15) & Deviations from long-term average for Brent Crude. The r-squared and F-statistic collapsed by eliminating the first 12 months of data. 2) DEVIATIONS IN CRUDE VARIABLE Shifting the crude explanatory variable backwards and forward by 3 and 6 months did not alter the model goodness-of-fit parameters dramatically and so my suggestion is that we stick with the following model: PLLU[t] = a.RPI[t] + b.RPI[t+15] + c.BrentCrudeDeviations[t] + Constant 3) TESTING MODEL WITH SINE WAVE To gauge the response of the model to wildly-varying RPI forward curve, a sine wave of period 3 years for RPI was input into the PPI model. The result was as expected; PPI pre-empts the moves in RPI by about 8 months. The magnitude of the oscillations is also reduced. This shows that if we had more detail in our RPI forward curve, then the PPI model would reflect those peaks and humps adequately. CONCLUSION I therefore propose that we use the model that incorporates RPI, RPI[t+15] and deviations of Brent Crude from long-term average. The new model is plotted below in burgundy and can be compared to the old PPI which is depicted in blue. The new model achieves the two main objectives of the PPI curve: it is significantly more robust and stable than the existing one, and it is considerably less sensitive to the input coefficients, which results in us having more confidence in our monthly P&L. Please note that all this analysis only applies to PLLU, and that a separate study will be needed for the DZCV PPI index. Regards, Anjam x35383
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Anjam Ahmad/LON/ECT on 09/03/2000 16:52 --------------------------- Anjam Ahmad 08/03/2000 14:03 To: Martina Angelova/LON/ECT@ECT, Harry Arora/HOU/ECT@ECT, Maureen Raymond/HOU/ECT@ECT, Zimin Lu/HOU/ECT@ECT, Farouk Lalji/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Trena McFarland/LON/ECT@ECT, Dale Surbey/LON/ECT@ECT, Stinson Gibner/HOU/ECT@ECT, Vince J Kaminski/HOU/ECT@ECT, Leandro Ibasco/Corp/Enron@Enron Subject: Update on PPI Model for Inflation Book Dear all, We thought it might be useful to incorporate Brent crude as an explanatory variable for PPI; it was found that deviations of Dated Brent Crude from the long-term average of $18.80 was the best form of the variable to use (for predictions the Brent forward curve produced by the Global Products Group is used). The three new equations developed were:- PLLU(t) = a.RPI(t) + b.RPI(t+N) + c.(DatedBrentCrude - 18.8) + constant, where N is 14,15 or 16 [REDDISH CURVES] r-squared approx 0.49 F-stat approx 32 The chart below shows what our projected PLLU curve would be given this equation, and also the three best relations from before which were based upon current and future RPI: PLLU(t) = a.RPI(t) + b.RPI(t+N) + constant, where N is 14,15 or 16 [GREENISH CURVES] r-squared approx 0.47 F-stat approx 45 COMPARISON OF MODELS As you can see, the two equations differ in the very short-term and very long-term; the inclusion of deviations of Brent Crude leads to short-term predictions of 3.0% to 3.2% over the next six months. The greenish curves predict PLLU in the range of 2.5% to 2.8% over the next six months. The curves are then very similar until 2009, when the models including crude break-away to the upside, relative to the falling RPI curve. The model based purely on RPI hugs the RPI curve much more closely in the longer term. This is only important to the extent that we have large positions beyond 2009 (which we don't). SUGGESTION What could be useful now is a differently-specified model designed to forecast only the next 3 months, using auto-regressive or auto-regressive error terms. This model would be far more accurate in the near-term, and we could include this information onto the front of this long-term model. This may be useful, despite the fact that most of our exposure is in future time buckets. BACK-TESTING All the models give similar visual and statistical performance over the data sample used (based mainly on 1990s "new paradigm" economy). Hopefully we can discuss these and other points later in the tele-conference; your ideas on this would be appreciated. Regards, Anjam x35383