24 Apr 2000, 20:48 UTC
Re: Revised Australian Services Agreement
- From
- Susan Musch susan.musch@enron.com
- To
- David Minns
- Cc
- Heidi Mason
- Bcc
- Heidi Mason
- Date
- Mon, 24 Apr 2000 13:48:00 -0700 (PDT)
David and Heidi, Hope you enjoyed your Easter holiday and your Anzac holiday! With respect to your question of whether the financial trader services can be charged at cost or must have a 7.5% mark-up, I received advice from Chris Catt at PWC-Sydney last summer that there needed to be a mark-up for these services. Given the skills required by the financial trader and the risk associated with the transactions, Chris advised that there needed to be a mark-up over cost based on a recent ruling by the ATO. The ATO issued TR 1999/1 in January 1999, which provides a safe-harbor for de minimis services that are provided by an Australian company and meet certain monetary limitations. Under the de miminis safe harbor, where the costs associated with all services provided by Enron Australia Pty Limited to offshore affiliates do not exceed A$500,000 in a year, the safe harbor mark-up of 7.5% may be available. Paragraph 86 of the ruling sets forth the requirements as follows: "As mentioned in paragraph 77, the Commissioner will apply a similar administrative practice in de minimis cases where the total direct and indirect costs of supplying services to Australian or foreign associated enterprises, as appropriate, is not more than $500,000 in a year. The practice applies to all intra-group services supplied or acquired where the relevant cost limit is not exceeded. Therefore, in some cases, it might be applicable to all intra-groups services both supplied and acquired. The transfer prices that must be used, and the conditions for their use, are the same as those specified in paragraphs 82 to 84. As for the practice in relation to non-core services, all taxpayers in a group must use the same mark-up, for incoming and outgoing services, in respect of each foreign jurisdiction, but the mark-up may vary from country to country, within the limits described above. Example An Australian subsidiary of a foreign based multinational group receives marketing and technical assistance from a foreign associate. No other services are acquired by any Australian member of the group from its foreign associated enterprises. The total direct and indirect costs of providing the services to the Australian subsidiary for the year are $200,000. As long as the amount actually charged for the services is not more than $215,000 (or $220,000 in the circumstances outlined in paragraph 83), the Commissioner would not require the taxpayer to establish an arm,s length price for the services." Based on discussions we had late last summer, we thought that the A$500,000 threshold could be met. To my knowledge, the recent changes and proposed changes to the Australian tax rules would not affect TR 1999/1. Please let me know if you have seen anything to the contrary. Consequently, to my knowledge, we are still under these guidelines. I,m not sure, David, what you mean by 100% being current practice as stated in your April 18th e-mail. I am guessing that you are referring to the services provided under the cost sharing agreement. Under that agreement, office costs are being shared by Enron Australia Pty Limited and 3 other Australian entities. Here, services are being provided to an off-shore affiliate. As a result, it appears that TR 1999/1 would require a mark-up. I will be happy to discuss this with you both at your convenience. Best regards, Susan
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
David Minns 04/18/2000 12:22 AM To: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Shari Stack@ECT Subject: Re: Revised Australian Services Agreement I've checked my notes and spoken to Heidi and it appears the delay was settling the mark up (107.5%) in the Agreement. Heidi believes that this figure can be reduced to 100% (which is current practice). If everyone is agreeable I will arrange execution. David Minns 04/18/2000 02:35 PM To: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT Subject: Re: Revised Australian Services Agreement Susan this is the latest version of the Services re ENA/EAPL. There is a note on my file that the percentage uplift. Shari Stack@ECT 09/18/99 06:32 AM To: Susan Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Alan Aronowitz@ECT, Gary Hickerson@ECT, Harry Arora@ECT, Colin Jackson@ECT, Paul Quilkey/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, David Minns/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Barbara Lewis/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: Revised Australian Services Agreement Attached please find my mark-up of the Australian Services Agreement. I have attached a blacklined version for ease of reference. Apart from changing the name from ECT to ENA, I have modified clause 1 in Schedule 1 to more accurately reflect the intended products. Please call me if any questions. Many thanks, Shari ---------------------- Forwarded by Shari Stack/HOU/ECT on 09/17/99 02:25 PM --------------------------- Susan Musch@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 09/15/99 07:30 PM To: Shari Stack@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Alan Aronowitz@ECT, Gary Hickerson@ECT, Harry Arora@ECT, Colin Jackson@ECT, Paul Quilkey/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, David Minns/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Subject: Draft of Australian Services Agreement Attached is a draft of the services agreement for the financial trading services to be provided by the Australian trading office for ECT-Houston. Please review the agreement and let me know if you have any questions, comments or revisions. Best regards, Susan