Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

8 Jan 2001, 11:12 UTC

Proposed Tarl Agenda - Meeting for 9 am Thursday, January 11 (location/call-in to be announced)

From
Wayne Gardner wayne.gardner@enron.com
To
alisa.christensen@enron.com, beth.wapner@enron.com, Cynthia Harkness, david.degabriele@enron.com, David Merrill, derenda.plunkett@enron.com, Donald Lassere, Gerry Willis, James Ginty, Jan Haizmann, Jane Wilson, Jeff Dasovich
and 10 more Lara Leibman, malini.mallikarjun@enron.com, Michael Norris, Michelle Hicks, Mike Dahlke, Rajen Shah, Richard Anderson, Robbi Rossi, Sue Nord, Xi Xi
Cc
Angie Buis
Bcc
Angie Buis
Date
Mon, 8 Jan 2001 03:12:00 -0800 (PST)
I propose a 1 hour meeting to try to regroup from the holidays and hopefully 
come up with a framework that will allow us to pick up the pace for future 
meetings.  Below is a proposed agenda:

1.  Establish what we have learned to date:
Trading of private line and lambda service terminating in Japan unavoidably 
requires a local license held by local entity
-  therefore, trading of private line and lambda service terminating in Japan 
must be done by a local entity
-  exposure to high Japanese tax and potential double tax reduced if Japan 
only has half-circuit
-  but this requires having multiple EBS parties to a trade
-  and trading half-circuits may not even be a commercial alternative
-  a Master and a confirm must be bilateral, i.e., there can be only be one 
counterparty on each side of the agreement
-  thus, a customer that wishes to trade an entire segment (e.g., Tokyo to 
San Jose) will have to execute two Masters and two confirms if the 
half-circuit alternative is used
US tax guidelines to avoid double tax on Japanese trading
Trading of Australian bandwidth entails no license requirements
Trading of Western European bandwidth entails no license requirements 
provided that no physical fiber is owned
Trading US telecom capacity requires an FCC 214 license
-  EBS, Inc. has an FCC 214 license
-  No other affiliate of EBS, Inc. needs to acquire an FCC 214 license IF 
that affiliate is directly or indirectly wholly-owned by EBS, Inc.
With regard to any IP transport deal, we must have the counterparty enter 
into a separate Master agreement and confirm with each EBS entity involved in 
the transaction.
-  Thus, in an IP transport deal involving numerous countries that require 
licensed local entities to provide local IP services, the counterparty will 
be required to execute a Master with each of the local entities
-  This is the ONLY feasible way from a legal standpoint to structure an IP 
transport deal, but is not a very good solution.
None of the foregoing points raise significant accounting issues.
Other?

2.  What are the important near term questions that remain to be answered and 
how long will it take to answer them:
Does private line and lambda trading of segments terminating in Hong Kong, 
Singapore, and India unavoidably require local license held by local entity?
-  If so, is there any way to limit the problem?
Does IP transport constitute a telecommunications service that requires a 
license in Sao Paulo, Tel Aviv, Japan, Singapore, Hong Kong, and India?
-  If so, must that license be held by a local entity?
Does IP transit constitute a telecommunications service that requires a 
license in Sao Paulo, Tel Aviv, Japan, Singapore, Hong Kong, and India?
-  If so, must that license be held by a local entity?
What is the legal relationship of parties to peering arrangements?
What is the regulatory analysis of peering arrangments?
What is the tax analysis of peering arrangments?
Other?

3.  Update on Singapore Pioneer Status application

4.  Are there things should we be doing to try to get ahead of the curve?

I encourage questions and comments on the agenda.

W. Wayne Gardner
Enron Broadband Services
1400 Smith Street
Houston, TX  77002-7361
Phone:  713 853 3547
Fax:  713 646 2532