1 Dec 2000, 12:51 UTC
Re: Max rate issue on TW
- From
- Steven Harris steven.harris@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 1 Dec 2000 04:51:00 -0800 (PST)
I am in an all day PRC meeting on Tuesday. Thanks.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Susan Scott
11/30/2000 10:24 AM
To: Steven Harris/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Lindy Donoho/ET&S/Enron@ENRON
cc: Drew Fossum@ENRON
Subject: Max rate issue on TW
Steve and Lindy, as I mentioned in our staff meeting, it is probably not
going to be possible to solve our max rate cap dilemma by making a tariff
filing unless we can 1) get FERC to change its mind about its policy that
recourse rates always be available as an alternative to negotiated rates or
2) prove that Transwestern lacks market power and should therefore be allowed
to charge market based rates.
The following is a very brief outline of what would be required to prove lack
of market power. A warning: lack of market power is very difficult to
prove. Koch, a pipeline that most in the industry would agree does lack
market power, tried and failed. The deck is already stacked against us in
TW's case given the withholding of capacity by El Paso's affiliate and the
price conditions in California. However, we do need to analyze the
possibilities for TW, if not to the Cal. border, then on other parts of our
system. Additionally, we need to discuss acceptable incentives for shippers
to pay negotiated rates if we do not end up changing our tariff.
Would you be availabile on Tuesday to discuss this? Please let me know. In
the meantime, here is a summary of FERC's policy on market based rates.
***
To obtain authority to charge market based rates, TW would first have to
request a declaratory order, and in its application provide information
showing it meets the requirements outlined below. If the Commission finds
all requirements have been met, it will issue an order and TW would then make
the appropriate tariff filing to put market based rates into effect.
Application for declaratory order must include:
1. Detailed description of the services proposed for market-based rate
treatment. I assume in our case it would be firm transportation service.
2. A statement defining the relevant product and geographic markets
necessary for establishing the applicant lacks market power with respect to
the services at issue. The Commission requires a narrow definition of the
market("firm transportation" is probably narrow enough, but for our purposes
we might want to narrow it down more (i.e., firm transportation East of
Thoreau). We have to define substitute services available to shippers(other
pipelines are a "good substitute" only if shippers can obtain the same
quality of service on a timely basis, and if the other pipelines offer such
service at a price that would deter TW from raising its prices more than
10%. All relevant "origin markets" must be defined (Panhandle; West Texas)
as well as "destination markets," and alternatives for shippers in those
markets identified. Transportation alternatives are only good alternatives
if they provide a netback to shippers that is roughly the same as if they
used TW. Note that the Commission has rejected capacity release as a good
alternative since it does not guarantee a shipper its desired contract
quantity.
3. Market share and HHI calculations; discussion of other relevant
competitive factors. Commission looks at size of market share, mitigating
factors such as ease of entry, and market concentration as measured by HHI.
Market concentration has to be calculated for each relevant receipt point and
delivery point. HHI is calculated by adding up the total market share and
squaring it. There is a presumption of no ease of entry for transportation
services because of the expense involved in constructing facilities.
4. Proposal for accounting for costs and revenues.