21 Jun 2001, 13:03 UTC
The Southeast RTO: The "Backstory" Behind the Press Release
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Thu, 21 Jun 2001 06:03:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] In an exclusive SCIENTECH PowerHitters interview, Envenergy President and CEO, Ed Richards, describes an option to building owners being "held hostage" to proprietary closed systems. The open platform concept of Envenergy is leveraging IP to connect the complete network of building systems across an enterprise. Read more at: www.scientech.com Did you know that SCIENTECH offers unbiased services for: Strategic I/T Infrastructure Design for Generation, T&D, and Retail Operations I/T Strategic Sourcing Consulting Customer Care Requirements Definition Application Selection Services Product and Service Plans I/T Investment Due Diligence Secure e-mail, web and operations hosting To learn more, please contact Jon Brock at jbrock@scientech.com or call him at 1-505-244-7607, or toll free at 1-888-972-8676. [IMAGE] [IMAGE] June 21, 2001 The Southeast RTO: The "Backstory" Behind the Press Release By Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [IMAGE]Owners of transmission systems across Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, and South Carolina have announced the signing of a memorandum of understanding (MOU) to develop a regional transmission organization (RTO) for the Southeast. A full list of the Southeast RTO members appears at the end of this article. Two of the largest members of this new organization are Southern Company (NYSE: SO) and Santee Cooper. If the transmission owners prove successful in their efforts to develop this transmission entity, the RTO would be one of the nation's largest, covering more than 39,000 miles of transmission with an investment in assets in excess of $6 billion. Analysis: The dynamics behind this announcement create a backstory that is not readily available in the press materials being circulated by Southern Company. However, the development of this much-anticipated RTO illustrates how transmission infrastructure in the Southeast is assimilating, answers questions about how Southern Company will comply with federal directives, and raises speculation about possible impact on the region's already-established RTO, GridSouth. Further, as FERC has encouraged RTOs to form across the country, much of the commission's focus has been placed on the Southeastern United States (along with the West). The Southeast is dominated by large IOUs that control massive transmission assets. Thus, seeing that Southeastern transmission systems are ultimately conjoined has been a key priority for FERC. You may recall that a few months ago Southern Company applied to FERC to form its own RTO (the organization that will manage a transmission network within a particular region). FERC rejected the SeTrans Gridco concept because Southern Company planned to funnel certain rate incentives to companies other than the RTO operator, which violated FERC policy. In addition, it is FERC's general policy to consolidate operating RTOs across the country, and the commission was concerned that Southern Company would remain too autonomous if it was the only utility involved in a transmission entity. Thus, FERC unequivocally told Southern Company to not re-apply for RTO status until it had explored joining forces with neighboring companies. Simultaneously, FERC gave conditional approval to GridSouth, an RTO formed by Carolina Power & Light, Duke Energy and South Carolina Electric & Gas (SCANA), Southern Company's neighbors to the north. The conditional approval came with the instruction that GridSouth should engage in dialogue with the SeTrans Gridco, Santee Cooper and Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) about joining GridSouth. Again, FERC sent the message that it ultimately hopes to see a single, large RTO serving the entire Southeast region. Nevertheless, now Southern Company and Santee Cooper have joined forces with seven other companies to form a new RTO that will be a completely separate entity from GridSouth. I contacted GridSouth for a response regarding what impact (if any) the formation of the new Southeast RTO might have on GridSouth. However, as of press time, representatives for GridSouth had not prepared a public statement regarding the proposed transmission entity. I spoke with John Sell, a Southern Company spokesperson on June 19. Sell informed me that Southern Company had indeed engaged in negotiations with GridSouth upon FERC's directive, but determined that GridSouth was "too far down the road" in terms of its development, and that Southern Company planned on taking a different approach toward its transmission assets. For instance, while both entities are for-profit operations, the new Southeast RTO plans to hire an independent third party to oversee its operations. Further, although the term "Southeast RTO" is being used in the press release, Sell told me that among the companies involved the RTO is actually being referred to as SeTrans (the name of Southern Company's rejected entity). Sell stressed that the name SeTrans was chosen only because it had been previously established by Southern Company and should not be seen as any indication that Southern has majority power over the RTO. In fact, the name will be changed to something else later this year. On a related note, one statement that I found particularly interesting in the press release about the new RTO is that "the companies have also made it clear that the process is not being controlled by any individual transmission owner, but rather all participants will help establish the rules by which they will operate and make decisions." This is clearly a veiled reference to Southern Company, which was criticized by FERC for being too autonomous in its original RTO filing. When I spoke with John Sell, he volunteered that Southern "is not the driver behind this RTO." Santee Cooper's involvement in the SeTrans RTO also came about in a somewhat precarious fashion. As noted, FERC specifically asked GridSouth to find a way to incorporate Santee Cooper, a state-owned utility located in South Carolina, into its RTO. As Santee Cooper controls about 4,200 miles of transmission lines covering 75 percent of South Carolina, it is no wonder that the commission would want to make sure that the public utility was conjoined in some way to developing RTOs. There was just one problem with this plan: the South Carolina constitution prohibits Santee Cooper from joining for-profit enterprises. The case was closely followed throughout the energy industry as other public power agencies across the country are also involved in pending negotiations to join RTOs. New reports indicate that, if the SeTrans RTO is approved by FERC, it will be the largest RTO in the country to include a public power entity. However, it is important to note that Desert Star, an RTO based in Phoenix that connects transmission assets of seven Western states, includes the Western Area Power Administration (WAPA), which owns about one-third of the transmission system that serves Colorado and provides power to 28 of 29 of the state's municipal electric systems. Naturally, as the SeTrans RTO is also classified as a for-profit entity, the question has been raised of how Santee Cooper will be allowed to join as a member given the South Carolina law. I spoke with Stephen Pelcher, associate general counsel of rates and regulations for Santee Cooper, about this conundrum. There is an important distinction that should be understood. GridSouth is a wholly owned company under its three utility parents (Carolina Power & Light, Duke and SCANA). The obstacle facing Santee Cooper's participation in GridSouth was that the company could not be a shareholder in a private corporation. Under the SeTrans RTO, in which Santee Cooper is now a participant, none of the participating companies will have ownership over the transmission entity. As noted, this was one of Southern Company's main interests in forming its own RTO as the company intends to hire an independent third party to oversee its operations. Pelcher told me that the SeTrans RTO is still in a "preliminary stage" and thus it appears at this time that participants in the SeTrans RTO will retain ownership of their transmission assets and only turn over operational control to the independent third party. Interestingly, Pelcher also told me that Santee Cooper (and, by extension, the SeTrans RTO) remains in consultation with GridSouth for a "coordination and implementation service agreement" that would in some way interconnect the two entities. One issue that will continue to impact RTOs throughout the country is how electricity will be transported across independent transmission systems. Specifically, FERC has been concerned about how power will be traded from one RTO to another and the possibility that boundaries between two separate RTOs could become "speed bumps" in the flow of electricity. In fact, the commission met this week on the issue and continues to formulate policy related to these "seam issues." Part of the reason that Southern Company's original, independent RTO plan was rejected was FERC's concern that the utility was resisting efforts to form a cohesive, interconnected system in the region. At this point, it appears that FERC favors standardization in how adjacent RTOs will relate to each other, and thus has instructed developing RTOs to consult with each other on seam agreements. FERC reportedly is planning to have a formal policy on the subject ready by the end of this year. Related to the development of this policy is the debate over whether or not FERC should take a more active role in forcing consolidation among developing RTOs so that only a limited number of separate entities exist. Thus, as the SeTrans RTO continues to grow, it will need to determine how it will be connected to GridSouth and GridFlorida (and any other adjacent RTOs). In addition, Southern Company's John Sell disclosed to me that the SeTrans RTO has formed an MOU with TVA for a seam agreement. At this point, TVA has made no announcement that it is planning to join the new Southeast RTO and in fact, as a federal agency, is under no obligation to join an RTO. The SeTrans RTO plans to file an application with FERC and is preparing for the commission's deadline of being formed by Dec. 15 of this year. If the SeTrans RTO (or whatever it is ultimately called) gains FERC's approval, it will represent a significant part of the Southeast's development into a functionally competitive electric market. If FERC's stated policy of consolidating RTOs is effectively applied, ultimately we could see that GridSouth becomes conjoined to this new RTO, which now includes Southern Company, Santee Cooper and (through a seam agreement) TVA. Moreover, the development of the new Southeastern RTO illustrates the complexities of conjoining companies that transcend federal, state and municipal levels, along with the challenges of ensuring that adjacent RTOs form synergistic policies regarding the flow of power. Members of the Southeast (SeTrans) RTO: Alabama Electric Cooperative-generation and transmission cooperative providing wholesale electricity to 21-member distribution systems*17 in Alabama and four in Florida. City of Dalton (Ga.) Utilities-full-service utility providing electric, water, wastewater, natural gas and telecommunications services to the city of Dalton and portions of Whitfield, Murray, Gordon, Floyd, and Catoosa counties in Georgia. City of Tallahassee (Fla.)—maintains more than 2,200 miles of transmission and distribution lines, serving some 98,000 homes and businesses in the Tallahassee area. Georgia Transmission Corporation-not-for-profit cooperative owned by 39 electric membership corporations in Georgia. GTC owns approximately $910 million in assets, including more than 2,400 miles of transmission lines and 500 substations across the state. JEA—Formerly known as Jacksonville Electric Authority, a municipally owned electric supplier serving 35,000 customers in four-county area in northeast Florida. Municipal Electricity Authority of Georgia-joint-action state authority providing wholesale electric generation and transmission to 48 city- or county-owned electric systems in Georgia. Santee Cooper—South Carolina's state-owned electric and waste water utility and the state's largest seller of power. The utility is the direct and indirect source of power for 1.6 million South Carolinians and maintains 4,223 miles of transmission lines. South Mississippi Electric Power Association-non-profit wholesale electric power cooperative serving the power requirements of the 350,000 retail customers of its 11-member distribution cooperatives in the state of Mississippi. Southern Company-super-regional energy company with more than 32,000 MW of electric generating capacity in the Southeast and 26,000 miles of transmission lines. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.scientech.com [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily e-mail, send a message to Issue Alert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.