30 May 2001, 19:19 UTC
Reliant Pushes for "Negawatt" Plan
- From
- Ozzie Pagan ozzie.pagan@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 30 May 2001 12:19:00 -0700 (PDT)
Rick, Here's what I mentioned. Thanks for the v-mail, let me know what I can do. Regards, Ozzie
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Ozzie Pagan/HOU/EES on 05/30/2001 07:18 PM --------------------------- Elizabeth Howley 05/29/2001 12:45 PM To: Ozzie Pagan/HOU/EES@EES cc: Subject: Reliant Pushes for "Negawatt" Plan Ozzie - Here is an article talking about Reliant's effort to do what we were discussing last week, regarding negawatts - getting wholesalers to pay for them like they were actual generated power instead of the absence of. ---------------------- Forwarded by Elizabeth Howley/HOU/EES on 05/29/2001 12:37 PM --------------------------- STACEY BOLTON@ENRON 05/29/2001 12:14 PM To: Jeff A. Brown/HOU/EES@EES cc: Heather Mitchell/HOU/EES@EES, Elizabeth Howley/HOU/EES@EES, Mary Schoen/NA/Enron@Enron Subject: Reliant Pushes for "Negawatt" Plan This is the Reliant program I mentioned in our meeting. ----- Forwarded by Stacey Bolton/NA/Enron on 05/29/2001 12:13 PM ----- Lynnette Barnes 05/29/2001 11:58 AM To: Tom Chapman/HOU/ECT@ECT, Marchris Robinson/NA/Enron@Enron, Bill Moore/NA/Enron@Enron, Howard Fromer/NA/Enron@Enron, Frank Rishe/NA/Enron@Enron, Steve Montovano/NA/Enron@Enron, Daniel Allegretti/NA/Enron@Enron, Jeff Ader/HOU/EES@EES, Mark Bernstein/HOU/EES@EES, Pearce W Hammond/HOU/EES@EES, Brad J Snyder/HOU/EES@EES, Gloria Ogenyi/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Robert Frank/NA/Enron@Enron, Mary Schoen/NA/Enron@Enron, Ron McNamara/NA/Enron@Enron, Harry Kingerski/NA/Enron@Enron, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Stacey Bolton/NA/Enron@Enron, Patrick Keene/NA/Enron@Enron, Leslie Lawner/NA/Enron@Enron, Stella Chan/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Robert Neustaedter/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Kevin Kuykendall/Enron@EnronXGate, Roy Boston/HOU/EES@EES, Barbara A Hueter/NA/Enron@Enron, Becky Merola/HOU/NewPower@NewPower, Susan M Landwehr/NA/Enron@Enron, Janine Migden/NA/Enron@Enron, Kerry Stroup/NA/Enron@Enron, Donald Lassere/NA/Enron@Enron, bmerola@newpower.com, Geoff Duda/HOU/NewPower@NewPower, kathleen.magruder@newpower.com, pbray@newpower.com, sbertin@newpower.com, scovino@newpower.com, treichel@newpower.com, cynthia.sandherr@newpower.com, Kathleen Sullivan/NA/Enron@ENRON cc: Subject: Reliant Pushes for "Negawatt" Plan FT Energy Article By Rick Stouffer rstouffer@ftenergy.com The electricity supply-demand equation is simple: Match supply to demand and things are dandy. Demand overwhelms supply: build more supply. Throughout the country, but particularly in California, there is no question more supply is mandated*NIMBY (not in my backyard) be hanged. But what about the demand side of the issue? What about getting customers involved in the solution by allowing them to sell their excess power back into the system? 'Negawatts' nothing new Granted, the concept of negawatts is nothing new; it was coined roughly a quarter-century ago by the founder of the Boulder-based consulting firm E Source: Amory Lovins. Many utilities today use customer curtailment to get them through wattage rough spots from time to time. All the existing independent system operators have actively considered demand-side bids at one time or another, according to Richard Rudden, president of the consulting firm R.J. Rudden Associates in Hauppauge, N.Y. But what about a negawatt program serving the entire Western Interconnection? Rather than a supply exchange, aka an independent system operator, put in place a "demand exchange" where customers could make a choice: Do I produce widgets, run my milling machines, build product or take the power I would have used, bid it out and see what happens? Just such a demand exchange within the Western Interconnection is being championed by an unlikely proponent: Reliant Energy Inc. The Houston-based energy giant already has testified in Washington, D.C., concerning the proposal, has had meetings with key Western state government leadership and pitched its idea to trade associations and environmental groups. The scorecard: Thus far, no one has laughed, no one has walked away from the conversations*no one has said "no," according to Reliant's John H. Stout, senior vice president of asset commercialization. "You're taking forced, rotating outages and prioritizing the interruption, with the customer (that) can take the outage doing so," said Stout. Much of what Reliant proposes is included in Texas Republican Congressman Joe Barton's Electricity Emergency Assistance bill, but no big generator is pushing from the industry side like Reliant. A demand exchange Like generators, including Reliant, bidding load into the independent system operator pool, a demand exchange allows retail customers to determine what they could spare and bid in a specific load and acceptable price. The negawatt dispatch clearinghouse would develop a bid stack and make it available throughout the Western Systems Coordinating Council (WSCC). If a particular system needed more power, it would contact the clearinghouse, which would match the least cost set of bids that could be shipped, keeping in mind additional transmission charges. Once the bids were identified, the clearinghouse would contact the customer and its local control area. The customer would interrupt and the host utility would move the curtailed megawatts onto an export schedule. One key to the program's success is that no one loses money. The customer that gave up its designated electrons would continue to pay its retail supplier for what it didn't actually use, and the customer would receive its bid price, times the megawatts curtailed, minus its regular retail charges, plus any payment to the transmission provider. "The key is it gets the incentives right at the margin," said William Hogan, a professor at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government. Another key to the Reliant-championed negawatt program is that it is not seasonal; it doesn't lock a potential megawatt-shedder into a long-term contract. "You can bid into the market every day," said Stout. "It offers a tremendous advantage in that it allows distributive decisions to be made, how much a customer is willing to take for an energy entitlement," said Richard Tabors, president of the Cambridge, Mass.-based energy consulting firm Tabors, Carmanis & Associates. As Tabors points out, customers who sell back into the market obviously are doing so to play the margin, to make money. But their efforts also will have a serious impact on the spot market price. "Every megawatt not consumed is a megawatt which doesn't have to be produced," Tabors reasoned. "That lowers the marginal cost, the spot market cost. It really comes down to what (specific megawatts) are worth to someone and not worth to me." Heavy users thrilled Heavy industrial users already are thrilled with the regional negawatt proposal. "We think it is a well thought-out program. We feel customers have the right to buy power, they should have the right to sell power and ought to be compensated like the generators," said John Anderson, executive director of ELCON, the Electricity Consumers Resource Council, which represents large industrial users from nearly every manufacturing sector. Anderson favors this particular plan because it gives the customer choice* sound familiar?*allowing it to determine when it shuts down or gives up its power. "This is voluntary. You know when you will be shut down and thus you won't incur any damages," said Anderson. "Many proposals tell the customer to cut usage, but it costs money for industrial users to just shut down. Command and control proposals treat everyone alike*and they're not." Stout said at least two vendors have expressed interest in taking part in the Reliant proposal, with discussions already taking place with Automated Power Exchange Inc. (APX). "We have had discussions with Reliant; we're in the business of working with generators," said John Melby, vice president for North American marketing for Santa Clara, Calif.-based APX. According to Melby, APX represents more than half the demand response in the California ISO. He said the company could utilize key computer programs and systems previously developed to get the region-wide negawatt program up and running. The down side There could be a number of problems in moving forward with such a large plan. Consultant Tabors, for example, pointed to the White House and the Bush administration's seeming preoccupation with supply. Harvard's Hogan said having the power available when needed was key, while Reliant's Stout said the biggest hurdle was that many states prohibit retail customers from selling load back into the wholesale market. An obvious solution to that would be passage of the Barton bill; however, nothing is certain in such a divided Congress. Thus, Stout continues to travel the West pushing the negawatt program. California Gov. Gray Davis was briefed on the plan some two weeks ago when he called a meeting of all California's generators. "We thought he (Davis) generally liked the idea," Stout said. Next up on Reliant's hit list is S. David Freeman, former head of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and now Davis' California energy conservation "czar." "We've already raised the issue with him (Freeman), but we're looking to plug him in," Stout said.