18 Sep 2000, 12:04 UTC
RE: IMPORTANT -- Letter to Governor Davis
- From
- Robin Larson rlarson@caiso.com
- To
-
Tony Braun, Robin Larson, Karen Edson, Delaney Hunter, athomas@newenergy.com (Aaron Thomas), alippin@mail.arco.com, cohnap@sce.com, anw@cpuc.ca.gov, anna.ferrera@sen.ca.gov, debinorton@aol.com, moravekj@sce.com, BRBarkovich
and 80 more
bakilbourne@calpx.com, William Booth, cra@calretailers.com, wkeese@energy.state.ca.us, bzobel@mail.arco.com, fosterrg@sce.com, houstgrp@pacbell.net, cmcintyre@sempra.com, carolyn.veal-hunter@asm.ca.gov, hacknece@sce.com, charles.bacchi@asm.ca.gov, brownc@epenergy.com, Dan Carroll, dcazalet@apx.com, priced@epenergy.com, dsam@chevron.com, Dominic DiMare, Dorothy Rothrock, ed@clfp.com, egarcia@ka-pow.com, Evelyn Kahl Elsesser, gheath@eob.ca.gov, gordon.mcdonald@pacificorp.com, jackflanigan@flaniganlaw.com, jackson_gualco@gualcogroup.com, jstewart@cmta.net, jim@resources.ca.gov, smutny@iepa.com, jdasovic@enron.com, Jerry Jordan, jcassie@sempra.com, gronijn@texaco.com, joseph.lyons@asm.ca.gov, Joe Ronan, bridgesj@epenergy.com, fieldejr@sce.com, johnf@ncpa.com, jgl@cpuc.ca.gov, john.rozsa@sen.ca.gov, V. John White, jalamo@enron.com, Julia Wright, kjarrell@smurfit.com, kykoyano@calpx.com, karen@klindh.com, Mills Karen, klc@aelaw.com, katherinebrandenburg@flaniganlaw.com, kgrosulak@sppc.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, kevin.lynch@pacificorp.com, kevins@ncpa.com, lawrence.lingbloom@sen.ca.gov, Lenny Goldberg, szablyal@epenergy.com, Marc D. Joseph, mmasri@energy.state.ca.us, memcdonald@calpx.com, mpa@aelaw.com, Mike Florio, mikahl@ka-pow.com, mpetroch@enron.com, pcaceo@pacbell.net, phil.nails@asm.ca.gov, pstohr@dbsr.com, RCavanagh@nrdc.org (Ralph Cavanagh), randy.chinn@sen.ca.gov, ray.thompson@sen.ca.gov, Rick Counihan, berry@apx.com, scarter@nrdc.org, pikes@epenergy.com, swilson@cmua.org, smara@enron.com, sreeder@sppc.com, twinter@caiso.com, tdinkel@retx.com, tschmelz@energy.state.ca.us, rosst@sce.com, schaefvl@sce.com - Date
- Mon, 18 Sep 2000 05:04:00 -0700 (PDT)
I wouldn't say that it is fair to state that this issue was discussed "at length." Again, I am not saying ISO is wanting to avoid discussing any potential for getting any new generation into the market. It is not necessary to flag this issue--which has not been flushed out and fully discussed in this particular letter to the Governor. It was my understanding that this letter was to contain items of consensus. Perhaps I am incorrect in this assumption.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Tony Braun [mailto:braun@cmua.org] Sent: Monday, September 18, 2000 11:59 AM To: 'Larson, Robin'; 'Karen Edson'; dhunter@smithandkempton.com; 'Aaron Thomas (E-mail)'; 'Allan Lippincott'; 'Ann Cohn (E-mail)'; 'Ann Watson'; 'Anna Ferrera (E-mail)'; 'Art Carter'; 'assistant for John Fielder'; Barkovich, Barbara; Kilbourne, Becky; 'Bill Booth (E-mail)'; 'Bill Dombrowski'; 'Bill Keese (E-mail)'; 'Bill Zobel (E-mail)'; 'Bob Foster'; 'Bob Houston'; 'Carolyn McIntyre (E-mail)'; 'Carolyn Veal-Hunter (E-mail)'; 'Catherine Hackney (E-mail)'; 'Charles Bacchi (E-mail)'; 'Craig Brown'; 'Dan Carroll (E-mail)'; Cazalet, Denise; 'Dennis Price (E-mail)'; 'Denny Samuel'; 'Dominic DiMare'; 'Dorothy Rothrock (E-mail)'; 'Ed Yates'; 'Eloy Garcia (E-mail)'; Elsesser, Evelyn; Heath, Gary; 'Gordon McDonald'; 'Jack Flanigan'; 'Jack Gualco (E-mail)'; 'Jack Stewart'; 'James Boyd'; 'Jan Smutny-Jones (E-mail)'; 'Jeff Dasovich (E-mail)'; Jerry Jordan; 'Jim Cassie (E-mail)'; 'Jim Groniger (E-mail)'; 'Joe Lyons (E-mail)'; Ronan, Joe; 'John Bridges (E-mail)'; 'John Fielder'; 'John Fistolera (E-mail)'; 'John Larrea (E-mail)'; 'John Rozsa (E-mail)'; 'John White (E-mail)'; 'Joseph Alamo'; 'Julia Wright'; 'Karen Jarrell (E-mail)'; Koyano, Karen; Lindh, Karen; 'Karen Mills (E-mail)'; 'Kari Harteloo'; 'Kathy Brandenburg'; 'Kay Grosulak (E-mail)'; 'Keith McCrea (E-mail)'; 'Kevin Lynch (E-mail)'; Smith, Kevin; 'Lawrence Lingbloom (E-mail)'; 'Lenny Goldberg (E-mail)'; 'Louis Szablya (E-mail)'; 'Marc Joseph (E-mail)'; 'Marwan Masri (E-mail)'; 'Mary McDonald (E-mail)'; Alcantar, Michael; Florio, Mike; 'Mike Kahl'; 'Mona Petrochko (E-mail)'; 'Pete Conaty (E-mail)'; 'Phil Nails'; 'Phil Stohr (E-mail)'; 'Ralph Cavanagh (E-mail)'; 'Randy Chinn (E-mail)'; 'Ray Thompson (E-mail)'; 'Rick Counihan'; Berry, Robert; 'Sheryl Carter (E-mail)'; 'Steve Pike (E-mail)'; Stu Wilson; Mara, Sue; 'Susan Reeder (E-mail)'; Winter, Terry; Dinkel, Tom; 'Tim Schmelzer (E-mail)'; 'Tommy Ross'; Tony Braun; 'Victoria Schaefer (E-mail)' Cc: Winter, Terry Subject: RE: IMPORTANT -- Letter to Governor Davis AB 1890 Group: A response to the ISO's recent message regarding CMUA's proposed language is necessary. First, CMUA proposed its language to the Group on participation of municipal System Units during the week of August 21st, and discussed the matter at length with the Group when ISO representatives were in attendance and commenting on various drafting suggestions. Any implication that there is an element of surprise associated with the CMUA language is unfounded. If anything, it is the ISO's latest suggestion to remove the language that is tardy. The Letter underwent several iterative changes, during which time the ISO had an opportunity to make constructive suggestions to modify the language (preferably), or at a minimum explain its position so that the Group could consider the issue. Second, the ISO indicates that "there is ongoing and longstanding litigation over how to bring MUNIs into the ISO system," as a reason for not including the language in the proposed Letter. Certainly, the fact that an issue is being litigated is not a distinguishing characteristic. What issue hasn't been litigated, including Load participation in ISO Ancillary Service markets?! As we fully discussed with the Group, there are a host of issues associated with municipal/ISO discussions, including ISO cost allocation to Load. CMUA's specific proposal is to uncouple issues of transmission and Load cost allocation from the issue of getting generation capacity into the markets. It is unfortunate that, when we all recognize that we need more capacity in the ISO markets to deepen supply, the ISO is taking a position to hold on to "chits" in an effort to strengthen its hand on transmission and Load cost allocation issues. The end result is that generation is not in the ISO markets (whatever the exact number, it is far in excess of several of the other recommendations made in the letter) because the issue is being held hostage for negotiating purposes on issues that have nothing to do with supply. At this point, it appears we will not have agreement on this matter. In the past, the Group has acted as a consensus organization. CMUA would like the group to consider how the letter is characterized to the Governor, or anyone else, if one or more members have remaining concerns. Tony Braun Braun & Associates, P.C. 915 L Street Suite 1460 Sacramento, California 95814 (916) 441-1733 (916) 441-4053 (facsimile) braun@braunlegal.com Counsel to CMUA -----Original Message----- From: Larson, Robin [mailto:RLarson@caiso.com] Sent: Monday, September 18, 2000 10:42 AM To: 'Karen Edson'; dhunter@smithandkempton.com; 'Aaron Thomas (E-mail)'; 'Allan Lippincott'; 'Ann Cohn (E-mail)'; 'Ann Watson'; 'Anna Ferrera (E-mail)'; 'Art Carter'; 'assistant for John Fielder'; Barkovich, Barbara; Kilbourne, Becky; 'Bill Booth (E-mail)'; 'Bill Dombrowski'; 'Bill Keese (E-mail)'; 'Bill Zobel (E-mail)'; 'Bob Foster'; 'Bob Houston'; 'Carolyn McIntyre (E-mail)'; 'Carolyn Veal-Hunter (E-mail)'; 'Catherine Hackney (E-mail)'; 'Charles Bacchi (E-mail)'; 'Craig Brown'; 'Dan Carroll (E-mail)'; Cazalet, Denise; 'Dennis Price (E-mail)'; 'Denny Samuel'; 'Dominic DiMare'; 'Dorothy Rothrock (E-mail)'; 'Ed Yates'; 'Eloy Garcia (E-mail)'; Elsesser, Evelyn; Heath, Gary; 'Gordon McDonald'; 'Jack Flanigan'; 'Jack Gualco (E-mail)'; 'Jack Stewart'; 'James Boyd'; 'Jan Smutny-Jones (E-mail)'; 'Jeff Dasovich (E-mail)'; Jordan, Jerry; 'Jim Cassie (E-mail)'; 'Jim Groniger (E-mail)'; 'Joe Lyons (E-mail)'; Ronan, Joe; 'John Bridges (E-mail)'; 'John Fielder'; 'John Fistolera (E-mail)'; 'John Larrea (E-mail)'; 'John Rozsa (E-mail)'; 'John White (E-mail)'; 'Joseph Alamo'; 'Julia Wright'; 'Karen Jarrell (E-mail)'; Koyano, Karen; Lindh, Karen; 'Karen Mills (E-mail)'; 'Kari Harteloo'; 'Kathy Brandenburg'; 'Kay Grosulak (E-mail)'; 'Keith McCrea (E-mail)'; 'Kevin Lynch (E-mail)'; Smith, Kevin; 'Lawrence Lingbloom (E-mail)'; 'Lenny Goldberg (E-mail)'; 'Louis Szablya (E-mail)'; 'Marc Joseph (E-mail)'; 'Marwan Masri (E-mail)'; 'Mary McDonald (E-mail)'; Alcantar, Michael; Florio, Mike; 'Mike Kahl'; 'Mona Petrochko (E-mail)'; 'Pete Conaty (E-mail)'; 'Phil Nails'; 'Phil Stohr (E-mail)'; 'Ralph Cavanagh (E-mail)'; 'Randy Chinn (E-mail)'; 'Ray Thompson (E-mail)'; 'Rick Counihan'; Berry, Robert; Larson, Robin; 'Sheryl Carter (E-mail)'; 'Steve Pike (E-mail)'; 'Stu Wilson (E-mail)'; Mara, Sue; 'Susan Reeder (E-mail)'; Winter, Terry; Dinkel, Tom; 'Tim Schmelzer (E-mail)'; 'Tommy Ross'; 'Tony Braun'; 'Victoria Schaefer (E-mail)' Cc: Winter, Terry Subject: RE: IMPORTANT -- Letter to Governor Davis I do not have a comment on Karen's edit, but I wanted to email the entire group about CMUA's insistence on keeping Proposal 8 under the generation section. (This is the section referencing potential MUNI units that could be bid into the ISO A/S market if we can figure out a way to avoid having them join formally). I had mentioned when this was first brought up--which was frankly rather late in the drafting game--that I thought this would be very controversial at ISO. Not only does ISO not concur with the notion that there would be "over 1000 MW of addiitonal supply into A/S markets" but placing this language in a letter to the Governor makes it look like ISO is the obstacle to having these units available. There is ongoing and longstanding litigation over how to bring MUNIs into the ISO system. I am not uncomfortable with discussing this issue at any AB 1890 meeting, but forcing the issue in this Governor's letter is not placing the issue on a level playing field in my opinion. If CMUA decides not to sign the letter without this controversial piece that will be unfortunate. -----Original Message----- From: Karen Edson [mailto:kedson@ns.net] Sent: Thursday, September 14, 2000 1:19 PM To: dhunter@smithandkempton.com; 'Aaron Thomas (E-mail)'; 'Allan Lippincott'; 'Ann Cohn (E-mail)'; 'Ann Watson'; 'Anna Ferrera (E-mail)'; 'Art Carter'; 'assistant for John Fielder'; 'Barbara Barkovich (E-mail)'; 'Becky Kilbourne'; 'Bill Booth (E-mail)'; 'Bill Dombrowski'; 'Bill Keese (E-mail)'; 'Bill Zobel (E-mail)'; 'Bob Foster'; 'Bob Houston'; 'Carolyn McIntyre (E-mail)'; 'Carolyn Veal-Hunter (E-mail)'; 'Catherine Hackney (E-mail)'; 'Charles Bacchi (E-mail)'; 'Craig Brown'; 'Dan Carroll (E-mail)'; 'Denice Cazalet'; 'Dennis Price (E-mail)'; 'Denny Samuel'; 'Dominic DiMare'; 'Dorothy Rothrock (E-mail)'; 'Ed Yates'; 'Eloy Garcia (E-mail)'; 'Evelyn Elsesser (E-mail)'; 'Gary Heath (E-mail)'; 'Gordon McDonald'; 'Jack Flanigan'; 'Jack Gualco (E-mail)'; 'Jack Stewart'; 'James Boyd'; 'Jan Smutny-Jones (E-mail)'; 'Jeff Dasovich (E-mail)'; 'Jerry Jordan'; 'Jim Cassie (E-mail)'; 'Jim Groniger (E-mail)'; 'Joe Lyons (E-mail)'; 'Joe Ronan'; 'John Bridges (E-mail)'; 'John Fielder'; 'John Fistolera (E-mail)'; 'John Larrea (E-mail)'; 'John Rozsa (E-mail)'; 'John White (E-mail)'; 'Joseph Alamo'; 'Julia Wright'; 'Karen Jarrell (E-mail)'; 'Karen Koyano (E-mail)'; 'Karen Lindh'; 'Karen Mills (E-mail)'; 'Kari Harteloo'; 'Kathy Brandenburg'; 'Kay Grosulak (E-mail)'; 'Keith McCrea (E-mail)'; 'Kevin Lynch (E-mail)'; 'Kevin Smith (E-mail)'; 'Lawrence Lingbloom (E-mail)'; 'Lenny Goldberg (E-mail)'; 'Louis Szablya (E-mail)'; 'Marc Joseph (E-mail)'; 'Marwan Masri (E-mail)'; 'Mary McDonald (E-mail)'; 'Michael Alcantar (E-mail)'; 'Mike Florio (E-mail)'; 'Mike Kahl'; 'Mona Petrochko (E-mail)'; 'Pete Conaty (E-mail)'; 'Phil Nails'; 'Phil Stohr (E-mail)'; 'Ralph Cavanagh (E-mail)'; 'Randy Chinn (E-mail)'; 'Ray Thompson (E-mail)'; 'Rick Counihan'; 'Robert Berry (E-mail)'; 'Robin Larson (E-mail)'; 'Sheryl Carter (E-mail)'; 'Steve Pike (E-mail)'; 'Stu Wilson (E-mail)'; 'Sue Mara'; 'Susan Reeder (E-mail)'; 'Terry Winter (E-mail)'; 'Thomas Dinkel (E-mail)'; 'Tim Schmelzer (E-mail)'; 'Tommy Ross'; 'Tony Braun'; 'Victoria Schaefer (E-mail)' Subject: RE: IMPORTANT -- Letter to Governor Davis Delaney - IEP has one minor edit to the draft letter and three edits to the recommendations. Three of our four suggestions are driven by legislation sent to the Governor in the last days of session. A redlined version is attached. I hope this is helpful. (1) We propose to eliminate one proposed solution that is part of AB 970. Our edits move to the description of AB 970 the recommendation for allowing plants expected to come on line in 2 or 3 years to come on line earlier as single cycle facilities from the list of solutions. (2) We propose to move the proposal to expedite renewable generation to a comment that signing AB 995/SB 1194 will expedite more than 500 MW of new renewable generation by next summer. (This number is based on a CEC letter.) (3) We propose to consolidate solutions 4 and 5 since both involve changes or additions to existing plants. (4) Finally, we propose to modify the description of the CEC's expedited siting process to reflect AB 970 more accurately. If you have any questions, please call. Karen Edson kedson@ns.net -----Original Message----- From: Delaney Hunter [mailto:dhunter@smithandkempton.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 12, 2000 5:03 PM To: Aaron Thomas (E-mail); 'Allan Lippincott'; Ann Cohn (E-mail); 'Ann Watson'; Anna Ferrera (E-mail); 'Art Carter'; 'assistant for John Fielder'; Barbara Barkovich (E-mail); 'Becky Kilbourne'; Bill Booth (E-mail); 'Bill Dombrowski'; Bill Keese (E-mail); Bill Zobel (E-mail); 'Bob Foster'; 'Bob Houston'; Carolyn McIntyre (E-mail); Carolyn Veal-Hunter (E-mail); Catherine Hackney (E-mail); Charles Bacchi (E-mail); 'Craig Brown'; Dan Carroll (E-mail); 'Denice Cazalet'; Dennis Price (E-mail); 'Denny Samuel'; 'Dominic DiMare'; Dorothy Rothrock (E-mail); 'Ed Yates'; Eloy Garcia (E-mail); Evelyn Elsesser (E-mail); Gary Heath (E-mail); 'Gordon McDonald'; 'Jack Flanigan'; Jack Gualco (E-mail); 'Jack Stewart'; 'James Boyd'; Jan Smutny-Jones (E-mail); Jeff Dasovich (E-mail); 'Jerry Jordan'; Jim Cassie (E-mail); Jim Groniger (E-mail); Joe Lyons (E-mail); 'Joe Ronan'; John Bridges (E-mail); 'John Fielder'; John Fistolera (E-mail); John Larrea (E-mail); John Rozsa (E-mail); John White (E-mail); 'Joseph Alamo'; 'Julia Wright'; Karen Edson (E-mail); Karen Jarrell (E-mail); Karen Koyano (E-mail); 'Karen Lindh'; Karen Mills (E-mail); 'Kari Harteloo'; 'Kathy Brandenburg'; Kay Grosulak (E-mail); Keith McCrea (E-mail); Kevin Lynch (E-mail); Kevin Smith (E-mail); Lawrence Lingbloom (E-mail); Lenny Goldberg (E-mail); Louis Szablya (E-mail); Marc Joseph (E-mail); Marwan Masri (E-mail); Mary McDonald (E-mail); Michael Alcantar (E-mail); Mike Florio (E-mail); 'Mike Kahl'; Mona Petrochko (E-mail); Pete Conaty (E-mail); 'Phil Nails'; Phil Stohr (E-mail); Ralph Cavanagh (E-mail); Randy Chinn (E-mail); Ray Thompson (E-mail); 'Rick Counihan'; Robert Berry (E-mail); Robin Larson (E-mail); Sheryl Carter (E-mail); Steve Pike (E-mail); Stu Wilson (E-mail); 'Sue Mara'; Susan Reeder (E-mail); Terry Winter (E-mail); Thomas Dinkel (E-mail); Tim Schmelzer (E-mail); 'Tommy Ross'; 'Tony Braun'; Victoria Schaefer (E-mail) Subject: IMPORTANT -- Letter to Governor Davis Folks- At today's meeting, those Group members who attended agreed that we should indeed send the letter with changes reflecting the new legislation. Attached is the newest draft of such a letter. We need to send this letter out FRIDAY so in order to do that please look over the letter carefully and let me know if your organization wishes to be included as a signatory. I need every set of eyes out there to look this letter over for spelling, grammar and content -- my eyes have seen it too many times and are apt to miss things. So, here is the process --- Let me know of any minor changes ASAP. If there are content changes please email them to the ENTIRE group for sign off. Please understand that we want to send this FRIDAY so we do not have a lot of time to make changes. When I have a final draft I will ask people to fax signatures or send originals to me by Friday.Thank you all for your help with this letter. We could not have done it with out you. We will be scheduling our next general meeting for mid October. Also, we have finalized the dates for the Annual Retreat and will be sending out packets with all the details next week. DJ and I are working on the agenda so if you have a specific topic you would like covered please let us know. As always, please send me an email or give me a call if you have any concerns or questions about the letter or any other matter. Thanks, Delaney