13 Jul 2001, 19:58 UTC
FW: POWER POINTS:Generators, Here's To Better Luck In Brazil
- From
- Lester Rawson lester.rawson@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 13 Jul 2001 12:58:33 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Foster, Chris H. Sent: Friday, July 13, 2001 12:48 PM To: Rawson, Lester Subject: FW: POWER POINTS:Generators, Here's To Better Luck In Brazil -----Original Message----- From: "Onukogu, Ernest" <Ernest.Onukogu@dowjones.com>@ENRON [mailto:IMCEANOTES-+22Onukogu+2C+20Ernest+22+20+3CErnest+2EOnukogu+40dowjones+2Ecom+3E+40ENRON@ENRON.com] Sent: Friday, July 13, 2001 12:23 PM To: undisclosed-recipients:;@ENRON Subject: POWER POINTS:Generators, Here's To Better Luck In Brazil > NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--Less than a month after the Federal Energy > Regulatory > Commission shot the messenger, it's looking for new volunteers. > On June 19, the FERC totally trashed U.S. wholesale electricity markets > with > price controls and an order for refunds dating back to October or to May > 2000 or > to whenever they later decide. What is the FERC price cap on electricity > throughout the western U.S.? Well, it's whatever the California > Independent > System Operator decides it is. > Nevertheless, on Wednesday the FERC made a sharp U-turn in the direction > of > free markets for power. With unquestioning confidence, it ordered all U.S. > utilities to consolidate their transmission lines into a few independent > transmission operators in order to foster free trade and movement of > electricity. > Surely, some might say, the FERC didn't give the California ISO total > price > discretion over the western U.S., did it? After all, the ISO is simply the > administrator of the FERC's very precise formulas, like this one for > non-emergencies: the cost of burning natural gas (assuming a power plant > is > located both in northern California and southern California) at the least > efficient generator that was called on in the most expensive hour of the > most > recent Stage 1 emergency that wasn't a Stage 2 at any point during the > hour, > plus $6 for operation and maintenance multiplied by 0.85 (then add 10% if > the > buyer is the California Department of Water Resources). > What could be more clear? More "market-based," as the FERC trumpeted its > own > ingenuity? How could the ISO possibly manipulate that? > The ISO's initial cap of $92 a megawatt-hour was based on a gas price of > $9. > After inputting the other elements, that cap turns out to be based on a > quite > efficient heat rate of 11.4. Surely, the heat rate of the least efficient > unit > used in the most recent emergency, etc., was 20 or higher. > But the ISO decided it didn't want to pay more than $100/MWh. Who > confirms > that the ISO really used the correct heat rate? Nobody. > Now, after gas prices crashed to $4, the ISO had full discretion - based > on a > technicality - to avoid resetting the cap. At all four opportunities, the > ISO > declined to reset the cap because the ISO staff know they can't get the > power > California needs for $43, which is where the cap would have come out using > the > old 11.4 heat rate. That's way below the costs of the marginal generators > needed > when things get even a little tight. > Sierra Pacific Resources' (SRP) Nevada Power couldn't get all the power > it > needed July 2 for $92 even. > So, what is the FERC price cap on western power? Whatever the California > ISO says it > is. > Not surprisingly, Nevada Power and others western utilities are furious > with > California for successfully using its political muscle to export its > problem to > the rest of the West. > "Before the FERC price caps, the market definitely was working. When you > had > prices of $300 a megawatt-hour, people were mortgaging their restaurants > to buy > a diesel generator to sell power into the grid," said Chelan County Public > Utility District's Chuck Berrie, one of a handful of utility veterans in > the > U.S. who thrived in the deregulated wholesale market. Unlike those of most > other > western utilities, Chelan's customers haven't seen a rate increase and > won't for > the next five years, because Berrie and his coworkers have maximized the > utility's assets and market opportunities. > "People were coming out of the woodwork to get generators on line. I've > never > seen anything like it. But the FERC order killed them," Berrie said. > Orders for hundreds of small diesel-fired generators that could have > helped > get the West through the next 18 months or so were canceled immediately > after > the FERC order, because the generators cost more than $92/MWh to operate. > They > are expensive to run, but could have patched over the shortage until big, > permanent power plants are finished in 2003. But who wanted to bet in late > June > that the California ISO would pass up the opportunity for a $44 price cap? > So > the orders were canceled. > In fact, even with the cap stuck at $92, at least 100 megawatts of > installed > generators are being taken off line and sent back to the rental companies. > When > the blackouts come, hundreds of thousands of homes and businesses will be > without power that the generators could have provided. > The biggest manufacturer of such generators, Caterpillar Inc. (CAT), > said it > is redirecting the units to Brazil, which like the western U.S. is highly > dependent on hydroelectricity. And Brazil, like the West, is enduring a > drought > this year. Brazil, however, isn't under FERC jurisdiction. > But surely the generators must not be needed if we are sending them down > to > poor old Brazil. > Not so, according to utility employees like Berrie, as well as the > quasi-governmental Northwest Power Planning Council. The chances of > blackouts > this summer and winter is still much higher than acceptable, and, of > course, > higher still without those temporary generators. > Price controls kill the messenger. High prices say that supply should be > increased and usage reduced. Really high prices, like those the West has > endured > for the past year, say "Hurry!" > But the administration of George W. Bush, after getting a good ol' > political > whuppin' at the hands of California Gov. Gray Davis, agreed to shoot the > messenger. > "Why would anybody get into this industry with all the uncertainty of > this > ridiculousness? It's the price caps, as well as the rebates. Or you're > going to > get sued. Regular people were practically turning over their couches to > get the > nickels together to invest in a generator, and they have lost their > investment," > Berrie says. > "I think the horse is dead. Even if you removed the regulations and > prices did > come back up, people still won't come back. What certainty would you have > that > they won't change the rules again? Who can take that risk?" he added. > Yet the FERC just ordered the restructuring of many billions of dollars > of > transmission lines as the foundation of a free market. > In the East, they must be wondering what that messenger said before the > FERC > shot him. Apparently it was: "Brazil's economy can afford to pay more for > electricity than the U.S. economy can." > -By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604; > mark.golden@dowjones.com > > (END) Dow Jones Newswires 13-07-01 > 1821GMT(AP-DJ-07-13-01 1821GMT) >