13 Nov 2000, 18:37 UTC
ARM met w/ Mike Florio
- From
- Mona.L.Petrochko@enron.com mona.l.petrochko@enron.com
- To
- Mara, Susan" @ENRON, enron.com@enron.com, Sandra McCubbin, Joseph Alamo, Marcie Milner, Paul Kaufman, Lysa Akin, Mary Hain, Alan Comnes, Roger Yang, Harry Kingerski
- Date
- Mon, 13 Nov 2000 10:37:00 -0800 (PST)
ARM had a good meeting with Mike Florio, TURN, on Friday on defining the utilities default role and more rationale to the forward contracting. My walk away was as follows: 1. TURN agrees with the big guys out first, and the utilities default role defined to residential and small commercial customers. Where you draw the line (20 kW, 50 kW or 100 kW) is probably debatable. TURN thinks SDG&E will be receptive, PG&E is thinking along similar lines and that SCE is most resistant, but could be coaxed. He thinks that CMTA/CLECA probably don't like it, but they will be in the minority. He met w/ John Stevenson, Governor's staff, who was receptive, as was Carl Wood. 2. He agreed that you need definition of the utilities default role to provide direction on forward contracting. Although, we all recognized that the rules around reasonable behavior were preventing utilities from entering into contracts. We discussed up-front reasonableness. Mike seemed to be warming to the virtues of a competitive bid process in determining a reasonable price. 3. The idea of competitive default provider may need some proving. He felt SDG&E was the best place to start. Michael Shames, UCAN, seems interested in the idea. 4. An important component of default service, at least initially, is certainty of price for small consumers. We discussed different ways of providing certainty. The utility could set a price, up front, and have to manage its costs to meet that price. No balancing account. Utilities at risk/reward. We also discussed ways to keep the utilities honest on the price. One way is competitive default provider. Another way is competitive bid for portions of its portfolio. 5. Discussed three components of utility procurement: existing generation, forward contracts and spot purchases. Existing generation would be valued. Question about whether market prices would establish price of output or some interim revenue requirement, as proposed by SCE on its hydro resources. Mike also seems to have softened over future divestitures so long as there is some kind of interim buy-back contract with the utility. Will be at AB 1890 Implementation Group Meeting Tuesday and Wednesday talking to other parties.