27 Jul 2000, 14:04 UTC
URE Statement on Criteria for Lifting Tariff Approval Requirements
- From
- Philip Davies philip.davies@enron.com
- Bcc
- Mark Schroeder
- Date
- Thu, 27 Jul 2000 07:04:00 -0700 (PDT)
As requested by Mark.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Philip Davies/LON/ECT on 27/07/2000 14:05 --------------------------- Philip Davies 25/07/2000 17:49 To: Poland cc: Subject: URE Statement on Criteria for Lifting Tariff Approval Requirements The President of the Regulatory Authority has recently issued a 3-page statement, outlining the criteria he will take into account in assessing whether to release companies (ie, generators and trading companies) from the tariff approval requirements in the Polish Energy Law. We may arrive at a situation later this year where we have signed the necessary transmission, balancing and settlement contract(s) with PSE so that we can do wholesale trades -but are still subject to the requirement to get our trades (sales, not purchases) "approved" by URE before we can conclude them. The URE statement and recent press comments by the regulator do not give us any grounds to believe that traders such as Enron are going to be released soon from this requirement (in the press he has talked about possibly releasing some generators from the requirement in early 2001). We may therefore need to investigate getting an "approved tariff". However, unless we can get a framework agreement in place (so we don't need to get each and every transaction separately approved), this does not appear to be a workable solution. The attached statement is unhelpful in that it appears to be simply a list of every conceivable reason that URE could want to use at some point to justify continuing with the current restrictions. While some (but far from all) of the issues raised are genuine concerns, it does not of course follow that requiring tariffs to be approved for all generators and traders is the right response. (In October 1999 we presented to URE the reasons why we believe that these requirements make no sense for a new entrant supplier such as Enron.) However, since this issue is unlikely to go away, Jarek D. and I plan to use this statement to develop a dialogue with URE and see if we can find a workable way forward. Regards, Philip URE definition of "competitive market" which must exist before he can consider lifiting the requirements: "The Authority,s President defines the competitive market as a market where the transaction price is determined as a result of free interplay between supply and demand, and the customer has the right to choose the supplier without restraint, and to change it without excessive costs to himself, as well as being able to decide the quantity of purchases. Each of the subjects on the competitive market functions within similar external conditions. The transactions concluded on this market are subject to civil and legal regulations, or customary ones, and the information regarding the prices of goods on offer are generally accessible. The President of the URE estimates that as far as electric power is concerned, a supplier,s market rather than a competitive market is still in operation, because the customers are not able to exert economic pressure where their preferences are taken into account."