3 Dec 2001, 22:58 UTC
Proposal Issues List
- From
- Steven Curlee stevenc@pandaenergy.com
- Date
- Mon, 3 Dec 2001 14:58:02 -0800 (PST)
Kevin, as we discussed last Wednesday, following is a listing of the issues addressed during our conversation concerning the Proposed Transaction Between Panda and Transwestern. I have also included some additional questions which I thought of later. Although I think I have covered most of the issues, I am certain there will be more as we continue our discussions. As I currently understand, we are going to try and continue our conversation on Wednesday. Hopefully you will have time to complete your hydraulic study and answer these questions/issues by that time. If you have questions concerning the following, please feel free to contact me at (972) 361-1332 and I will try to help clarify. Maximum Hourly Quantity - Panda will require the minimum capability to burn the Maximum Daily Quantity in a 16 hour period with the potential flexibility to burn the plants complete hourly capability over a shorter time frame. Your voice message to Jim on Thursday, regarding a scaled burn window based on notification timing, should address this issue. Although there may be instances where the actual burn will be over 24 hours, the assumption should be that under even the shortest notification timing, 16 hours would be needed. Something to consider would be how to incorporate this schedule into the contract. Consideration would also need to be given in how this, and in general the operations and requirements of a power plant, would potentially deviate from the standard GISB nomination cycles and corresponding gas flows and how to incorporate that into the contract. Contract Rate - Although approximately $0.45/MMBtu has already been mentioned, it should suffice to say that the lowest possible cost of our gas supply, transportation and storage services is the goal. There are, however, a couple of points that could use some clarification. First, would the rates in the proposal be maximum rates as defined by a tariff filing or would these be negotiated? The current assumption is that they are negotiated because of the increase for years 6 through 10 and the escalator for the remaining 20 years. The preference would be for negotiated rates in order to eliminate any rate risk the project would hold if they were tariff based. If they are negotiated, a better understanding of how the rate is broken into its various components would be helpful. If they are tariff based, a better understanding of the anticipated increase and the escalator would be needed. Fuel Rate - A better understanding of the reasoning and numbers behind this rate would be beneficial. Also, how does Transwestern track and adjust for actual fuel percentages? Delivery Term - A shorter term would be required, somewhere in the 10 to 20 year range. Services - Although 500 psi may not be quite enough pressure at the facility, the hydraulic study should give a better indication of the actual pressures at the plant and should be discussed further after the study is complete. It should be noted that Transwestern's interconnect with the facility could still be some distance from the plant, therefore, increasing the pressure requirement at the interconnection point to be greater than the plant's requirements. Other Questions - What is the planned capacity of the lateral from Copper Eagle to the TW/EPNG interconnect? Would alternative receipt and delivery combinations be charged based on the tariff commodity and fuel for the particular path? Since there is already alternate receipt and delivery point capabilities, is the 50,000 MMBtu/day backhaul a guarantee? Although storage is planned at Copper Eagle, how can Transwestern help manage daily imbalances and short notice start up and shut downs in order to minimize penalty exposure? Thanks for your help in trying to address these issues. I look forward to talking with you on Wednesday if not sooner. Steve