4 Jun 2001, 12:53 UTC
Bonneville Power Administration: Vulnerable to Western Power Crisis, But Protected by Federal Status
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Mon, 4 Jun 2001 05:53:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] Southeastern Electric Exchange 2001 Utility Odyssey: Engineering & Operation/Accounting, Customer Billing and Finance Conference and Trade Show The Doral Resort Miami, FL Featured speakers include Wall Street Analysts Ed Tirello and Dan Ford and SEE Company Utility Executives Donald Hintz, Entergy Corp., Dennis Wraase, Pepco, and Bill Coley, Duke Power For full details: www.theexchange.org [IMAGE] "Global Power & Western U.S. Coal: Domino Factors at Play in Today's Energy Markets" is the theme of the 2001 Spring Pacific Coal Forum (Coal Forum'2001) to be hosted by the Western Coal Council, June 4-6, 2001 in Park City, Utah. Keynote Speakers include: Honorable Mike Leavitt, Governor, State of Utah; Hitoshi Tagawa, Tokyo Electric Power Company; Eng. Jesus Buentello, Comision Federal de Electricidad; Malcolm Thomas, Kennecott Energy Company; Manfred Raschke, International Strategic Information Services (ISIS). Contact Janet Gellici at (303) 431-1456 or info@westcoal.org www.westerncoalcouncil.org Miss last week? Catch up on the latest deregulation, competition and restructuring developments in the energy industry with SCIENTECH's IssuesWatch [IMAGE] [IMAGE] June 4, 2001 Bonneville Power Administration: Vulnerable to Western Power Crisis, But Protected by Federal Status By Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [IMAGE]Two mainstays of the Northwest's economy—public power and the aluminum industry-waging a war of words over the Bonneville Power Administration's attempts to set rates for the electricity it sells. Both sides have hired public relations companies in their attempts to sway public opinion before the federal power marketing agency sets new electricity rates effective Oct. 1. BPA, which sells power produced at 29 federal hydroelectric dams and a nuclear plant, has signed contracts for about 11,000 MW but has generating capacity for only 8,000 MW. To help make up the 3,000-MW shortfall, BPA is pushing a plan to idle the region's 10 aluminum smelters for two years, until additional generating capacity comes online. Analysis: Given the barrage of media coverage that continues to hang over California's energy problems, the fact that the Pacific Northwest is suffering from its own related maladies is often overlooked. Perhaps the most extreme case that illustrates the severity of problems to the north of California is the BPA, which in addition to attempting to increase its wholesale rates by as much as 250 percent this fall is now unable to fulfill many of its long-term power contracts. Much like Pacific Gas & Electric and Sierra Pacific Resources before it, the BPA now stands among a handful of power firms in the West that have sustained devastating financial blows due to volatility of the region's market. However, unlike investor-owned utilities (IOUs), BPA is owned by the federal government and as such has been criticized for having access to federal funding and protection not extended to other Western power victims. It is important to remember that BPA is a federal organization that was formed in 1937 to market power from the Bonneville Dam. It holds a lock on approximately 46 percent of the Pacific Northwest power market, and is one of the primary providers of power to incumbent utilities in the area such as Tacoma Power and Seattle City Light. In the 1990s, the BPA experienced an excess of power and sought power contracts outside the Pacific Northwest in order to retain a positive cash flow and support various programs to ensure the lives of salmon and steelhead, which populate the Bonneville Dam. The BPA formed contracts with such out-of-region buyers as Enron, Avista Energy and the main California utilities. The BPA signed long-term contracts to sell 1,223 MW of hydropower—enough to light the city of Seattle-utilities outside the Pacific Northwest and to private power marketers, adding to the base of its contracts with Northwest utilities and C_customers (mostly aluminum manufacturers). However, these contracts have aggravated regional power problems in a new era of shortages and soaring prices. For the most part, BPA's troubles have stemmed from weather-related circumstances, unlike California and Nevada (where weather has served to exacerbate fundamental restructuring problems). The Pacific Northwest, which relies heavily on hydropower, has suffered one of its worst droughts in recent history, which has greatly compromised what has typically been a reliable and abundant power source. In fact, the Northwest is reportedly between 1,500 MW and 3,000 MW short of the power it needs. Further, power that the Northwest could typically rely upon from California and the Southwest to supplement any shortage it might encounter in its own territory is no longer available due to power demands in other states. Given its role as the primary power supplier to the region's utilities, the BPA has become increasingly vulnerable to the volatility of the spot market. The end result is that BPA, which clearly overextended itself regarding power contracts formed in the last decade, has been forced to either buy expensive power on the spot market to serve its customers or negotiate buyouts of its power obligations. The BPA also has traditionally sold power directly to industrial customers, and over the last few months has attempted to rescind many of those contracts. For instance, the Columbia Falls Aluminum Company, a Kalispell, Mont.-based aluminum manufacturer, has agreed not to use 167 average MW of the 171 average MW BPA had agreed to sell it from October 2001 to September 2002. Reportedly, the BPA has bought back the power under contract to Columbia Falls for $19.50/MWh. This marked the second industrial customer that has allowed the BPA to terminate a power contract, following a deal with Alcoa (another aluminum producer), in which the BPA bought back about 400 average MW. Typically, the C_customers have agreed to break their contracts with the BPA due to their own halted production schedules that have resulted from soaring power costs. However, aluminum production is a critical part of the Northwest's economy, and several lobbying groups have emerged to block the BPA from negotiating with any additional aluminum manufacturers to cease production. Arguing that the BPA has an obligation to fulfill its power contracts, the advocacy groups—comprised of public power and manufacturing representatives- attempting to secure some form of legal restriction against the BPA before the agency increases rates this fall. Without knowing the terms of the contracts, it is not clear whether BPA has an exit clause that entitles it to stop providing power to the various buyers. Regarding its Northwest customers, which are given priority to BPA power supplies, the BPA has requested that these utilities implement conservation programs to reduce the amount of power that must be purchased on the wholesale market. Nevertheless, the BPA has already disclosed that it will be forced to increase rates by as much as 250 percent this October to cover its spot market power purchases (a condition that echoes similar movements by PGOand Sierra Pacific Resources). BPA reportedly charges its utility customers about $25/MWh for electricity. Wholesale electricity on the spot market is now selling at between $250 to $300/MWh, and wholesale power sold through long-term contracts sells for $75 to $150/MWh. Consequently, the 250-percent increase could be the minimum at which the BPA raises its rates, which would in turn impact the retail rates that Northwest utilities must charge their customers. PacifiCorp recently became the first IOU under contract with the BPA to voluntarily reduce load on the federal agency. Under the agreement, PacifiCorp has released BPA from its commitment to sell the utility an average of 251 MW each year for the next five years. Other IOUs are not acquiescing to the BPA's proposal. For instance, the BPA informed Southern California Edison (SCE) that it would not provide 500 MW of power this summer to the utility, under the terms of a previously reached agreement. The BPA, which unilaterally changed the terms of the contract from a strict sales agreement into an exchange when SCE began to have its own financial problems, has argued that SCE has ceased providing needed power to the BPA. As a result, the BPA will provide no further power to SCE unless it receives financial guarantees in advance. SCE has deemed this threat as a potential breach of contract and is currently pursuing the matter in the 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals. Moreover, the crux of the matter presently is the dichotomy that BPA represents in a deregulated energy market. On one hand, BPA is a federally protected agency with access to federal funding and control over federal lands. On the other hand, BPA—unlike any other federal agency—controls about half of the Northwest's energy supply and in the past has profited from power sales to other regions (mostly California). In addition to the growing resistance from public power and aluminum groups over BPA's plan to increase rates, other groups have raised the claim that BPA is receiving preferential treatment from the federal government. Some critics find it inconsistent that the Bush administration supports free market principles in the West (evidenced by the resistance to put wholesale price caps into place) and increased production, but at the same time might allow BPA to break long-term power contracts. Such critics (mostly clearly represented by the Northeast-Midwest Institute, a nonprofit Washington, D.C. think tank) believe the Bush administration should force BPA to sell its power to anyone who wants it at free-market rates (which of course are consistently higher than its current cost-based rates). In addition to potential rate increases, the BPA is attempting to secure increased funding from the federal government. As a federal agency, the BPA is allowed to borrow from the federal treasury to support infrastructure upgrades such as transmission capacity and maintain federal dams that generate the BPA's power. Recent reports have indicated that the BPA already is spending around $1.3 billion in federal funds to modernize the region's power grid and will request an additional $800 million from the federal treasury for transmission upgrades and to modernize existing power-generating facilities. Yet, at the same time, several regional groups are attempting to block any increase in the BPA's access to federal funds, arguing that the administration has continuously lowered its annual payments into the treasury and therefore should not be entitled to a credit increase. The BPA may not have directly caused the current power problems in the Northwest, but it is clear that the federal agency engaged in overly optimistic power contracts that it now cannot fulfill. Moving forward, the question will be whether or not, in a supposedly deregulated market, the BPA should be governed by any special standards given its status as a federal agency or whether it should be held to the same rules that apply to IOUs. While the for-profit economy of the Northwest is now in jeopardy due to volatile power prices, stakeholders in the region object to the BPA being able to break contracts and increase rates. Once again, this appears to be another matter that will fall under the jurisdiction of the Bush administration to decide as part of the nation's unfolding energy agenda. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.scientech.com [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.