8 May 2001, 13:01 UTC
Fw: Cal-Tax e-Alert: Windfall Profits Tax
- From
- Chris Micheli cmicheli@carpentersnodgrass.com
- To
-
Susan McCabe, smara@enron.com, Steven Kelly, steve_ponder@fpl.com, stephanie-newell@reliantenergy.com, sadlersa@earthlink.net, Scott Govenar, smccubbi@enron.com, rtom@govadv.com, Roger Pelote, robbiz@cwo.com, rventurini@teamgsi.net
and 41 more
rwhyde@duke-energy.com, rachel.king@elpaso.com, Phil Isenberg, mrmonagan@aol.com, oharen@hmot.com, mmoretti@mccabeandcompany.net, lale@dynegy.com, kent.palmerton@williams.com, Katie Kaplan, Kassandra Gough, Julee Malinowski-Ball, john_h_stout@reliantenergy.com, john.g.larrea@williams.com, Joe Ronan, Jeff Dasovich, Jean Munoz, smutny@iepa.com, jackp@calpine.com, Hedy Govenar, GTBL@dynegy.com, fred_pownall@ka-pow.com, Delaney Hunter, Chuck Cole, Bev Hansen, Anne Kelly, Andy Brown, janorwood@norped.com, pcaceo@pacbell.net, matt.kilroy@pge-corp.com, cjrudman@softcom.net, cmcintyre@sempra.com, blevake@syix.com, psoos@covantaenergy.com, ppape@calpine.com, mohammeda@calpine.com, kentr@calpine.com, katherip@calpine.com, juanr@calpine.com, eileenk@calpine.com, highlander@calpine.com, aymeer@calpine.com - Date
- Tue, 8 May 2001 06:01:00 -0700 (PDT)
For those who have not seen this yet - ?
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Original Message ----- From: Lisa Martin To: lisa@caltax.org Sent: Tuesday, May 08, 2001 11:48 AM Subject: Cal-Tax e-Alert: Windfall Profits Tax [IMAGE] Cal-Tax e-Alerts keep you informed on key tax and public policy issues?related to your industry as they develop.? We invite you to visit Cal-Tax Online (http://www.caltax.org) for more information on this and other Cal-Tax activities.? If you wish more information about Cal-Tax's e-Alerts or Cal-Tax Online, please contact Greg Turner at greg@caltax.org? If you wish not to be included on future Cal-Tax e-Alerts, please contact Betty Rickard at betty@caltax.org and your address will be removed from our distribution list. May 8, 2001? To:????????????Cal-Tax?Board of Directors and?Interested?Parties??? From:????????Ron Roach, Communications Director?? Subject:????Update of Windfall Profits Tax Legislation? The following is advance Caltaxletter coverage of the May 7 California Legislature's actions on two bills that would impose "windfall profits" taxes on producers of electricity:?? ? SENATE APPROVES &WINDFALL PROFITS8 TAX AS ROLLING BLACKOUTS HIT?????? Nearly coinciding with rolling blackouts plaguing California for the first time since mid-March, the Senate on Monday approved a &windfall profits8 tax on energy producers (SB 1X, Soto). Critics said the measure establishes a perverse tax incentive not to sell power in California and will reduce electricity supply even further, increasing prospects of future blackouts.?? Twenty-five Democrats voted &aye8 on SB 1X, while 12 Republicans voted against it. Because the bill did not pass with 27 votes, or two-thirds of the Senate as required by Proposition 13, there will likely be a court challenge on this point. Meanwhile, just hours earlier, the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee approved a slightly different version of a &windfall profits8 tax (AB 128X, Corbett), despite the fact that the bill was substantially amended at the hearing. SB 1X imposes a 100 percent excise tax on sales of electricity at a price above $80 per megawatt-hour. It also establishes a refundable tax credit equal to the amount of revenue generated by the tax. AB 128X establishes a retroactive (to January 1, 2001) sliding-scale tax of 50 percent of gross receipts on electricity sales over $60 per megawatt-hour; 70 percent of the gross receipts of sales over $90 per megawatt-hour, and 90 percent of gross receipts of sales over $120 per megawatt-hour. The rate of tax can be changed &from time to time8 by the California Public Utilities Commission. ?The bill will likely tax sales not made in California, because it defines &sales of electricity to a retailer8 in California to be the higher of the ratio of sales in California to the total sales or percentage of total electricity sales everywhere, using a ratio of total sales everywhere in the year 2000 to sales in California in the year 2000.? Debate in the Senate was hotter than the 95-degree temperature outside. Democrat Senator Steve Peace, who is generally given credit for pushing the electricity deregulation bill through the Legislature in 1996, became highly emotional in denouncing energy producers.? Continuing to blame the California crisis on the Federal Energy Regulation Commission (FERC), as well as Harvey Rosenfield,s Proposition 9, which sought to unravel deregulation in 1998 and caused a two-year delay in construction of additional power plants, Senator Peace called SB 1X the &only reasonable alternative.8? He said it will bring competition to the market with rules and &a referee who will blow the whistle.8 He described FERC as &the proverbial cop in the donut shop who refuses to enforce the law8 and limit what wholesalers can charge.? Republican Senator Ray Haynes said the tax would not bring additional electricity to Californians. &We are going to make sure by passing this bill that the lights will go out,8 he said.?? Democrat Senator Debra Bowen said the prospect of taxing excess profits &will grab (energy producers) by the horns and their hearts and minds will follow.8? Republican Senator Tom McClintock said the tax would cut supplies of electricity, noting that other states, such as Texas and Nevada, are building, or will build, power plants to serve California with investments that benefit those states, economies, not California,s. &To make electricity cheap, we have to make it plentiful. This is a very wrong step in a very wrong direction,8 he said.? At the Assembly committee hearing, numerous speakers sought to testify for and against the bill. However, Democrat Assembly Member Helen Thomson (chosen by Committee Chair Ellen Corbett to preside instead of the Republican vice-chair, which in itself was unusual) limited testimony to two witnesses on each side.? Speaking for the tax were Jean Ross, executive director of the California Budget Project, and Lenny Goldberg, of the California Tax Reform Association, organizations funded largely by public employee unions or liberal-leaning foundations that generally oppose tax relief and support increased government spending. Ms. Ross urged immediate action, saying consumers will be paying 1.5 percent of their income on power purchases in the next year. Mr. Goldberg called the proposal a viable and realistic solution, which he said he hopes is constitutional.?? Providing opposition testimony were Carrie-Lee Coke, representing the California Manufacturers and Technology Association, and Steven Kelly of the Independent Energy Producers.? Ms. Coke said the bill is a disincentive to more supply and will make the current crisis worse. She said it also applies to the cogeneration operations of California manufacturers. Mr. Kelly told the committee that the bill jeopardizes plans for as much as $10 billion in private capital investment in new California power plants.?? A number of others were allowed to state their affiliations and their positions on the bill. Among supporters were the California Labor Federation and the California Public Interest Research Group. Opposition included the California Chamber of Commerce, InterGen, and BP?Amoco.? Committee Member Elaine Alquist asked to be a co-author of the bill, saying it is about time &we did something.8??AB 128X was approved by a 5-0 vote, with Republicans abstaining. Assembly Member Mark Wyland said he abstained because he believes that while California is being gouged by high energy prices, the bill is anti-free market and incentives are needed to develop more power to avoid blackouts.? Meanwhile, Governor Gray Davis &is open to the idea8 of such a tax, but has not endorsed either bill, said his press secretary, Steve Maviglio. &It just depends on the bill.8?????? ? - e-alert3.gif