28 Nov 2000, 10:44 UTC
DJ FERC To Lower Price Cap In Calif PwrOrder-Commissioners
- From
- Mary Hain mary.hain@enron.com
- To
- Tim Belden, Robert Badeer, Jeff Richter, Lester Rawson, John M Forney, Mike Swerzbin, Matt Motley, Tom Alonso, Chris H Foster, Sean Crandall, Diana Scholtes, Mark Fischer
- Date
- Tue, 28 Nov 2000 02:44:00 -0800 (PST)
The attached article (based upon another FERC leak) states that in its upcoming order, FERC will lower the cap to $100 but will not (cannot) order refunds.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> By JASON LEOPOLD > Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES > >LOS ANGELES (Dow Jones)--The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission will >likely lower its proposed $150 per megawatt-hour "soft cap" on California's >wholesale power prices to $100/MWh in its final order to repair the state's >troubled electricity market, commissioners said Monday. >But the commissioners told Dow Jones Newswires they won't order generators >to refund billions of dollars in windfall profits earned last summer as a >result of spiking power prices in the state, despite pleas from state >lawmakers and Gov. Gray Davis, because they lack the authority to do so. >"We still believe we cannot order refunds," one FERC commissioner said. "If >there was an inch in the (Federal Power Act) that gave us the authority, we >would take it. But that would destroy the future of deregulation." >FERC released a report earlier this month that largely pinned California's >ongoing power crisis on the structure of the state's wholesale electricity >markets. The commission also issued a proposed order requiring changes >needed to make the market workably competitive. >The order found that electricity prices in the state rose to "unjust and >unreasonable" levels last summer. But FERC fell short of ordering refunds, >saying it lacked the legal authority to do so. >Instead, FERC proposed changes to the governing boards of the state's two >wholesale-market operators - the Independent System Operator and Power >Exchange - said the state's three investor-owned utilities should no longer >be required to buy a majority of their power from the CalPX, and proposed >penalties for utilities that put off buying the power they need until the >last minute. >FERC also proposed capping the price paid to all bidders in California's >power auctions at $150/MWh. Individual bidders could still get higher >prices, but would have to justify their claims to FERC. >FERC may issue its final order as early as Dec. 13, and commissioners said >California shouldn't expect it to differ from the proposed changes >recommended by FERC earlier this month. >The comment period for FERC's draft order closed Nov. 22. >(MORE) Dow Jones Newswires 27-11-00 >2305GMT >Final Order Won't Order Refunds >Davis warned FERC commissioners at a public hearing in San Diego two weeks >ago that a failure to order refunds would produce a "ratepayer revolt." >"Your proposed solution to our energy crisis does nothing to lower prices >for California consumers," the Democratic governor told FERC on Nov. 13 at a >meeting in San Diego. "Quite to the contrary, it is designed to bring our >economy and our consumers to their knees." >California's power regulators and utilities also pressed for refunds. >The state's Public Utilities Commission said it has evidence of market abuse >by generators and that consumers were overcharged $4 billion last summer for >electricity. >Edison International unit (EIX) Southern California Edison, in its response >to the FERC order, attached a study by a Massachusetts Institute of >Technology economist, who found "considerable evidence" generators and power >marketers deliberately withheld supply from California from June through >September - when power usage is at its peak - to drive up wholesale prices. >But despite the allegations, FERC commissioners said they will not order >refunds, though they said the state could legally return to cost-based >rates. >One commissioner also warned a lower "soft cap" of $100/MWh would likely >deter generators from building new power plants in the state, even as it >limited price spikes. >"The truth of the matter is there is no painless or easy way for California >to change its electricity market," the FERC commissioner said. > > Consumer Groups Push Ballot Measure To Re-regulate > >Davis will file the changes the state wants made to the proposed order with >FERC on Friday, but FERC commissioners said they don't expect to be swayed >by the governor's filing. >Meanwhile, Californians are steaming ahead with their own solutions. >On Tuesday, the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights, a Southern >California consumer advocacy group, will hold a news conference announcing >its own sweeping changes to the state's power market, which it will try to >implement through a proposed ballot measure, the details of which have not >been disclosed. >Furthermore, state lawmakers plan on rewriting parts of AB1890, California's >landmark restructuring law when the state Legislature convenes next year. >There is already heated debate within the Legislature to reauthorize >utilities to build power plants and to create a public utility system like >Nebraska's, where there are no investor-owned utilities, in an effort to >control power prices. >"California lawmakers want to be re-elected in 2002," one key lawmaker close >to the electricity issue said. >And Davis is in meetings to replace the Cal-ISO and CalPX with a new entity >to manage the power grid and the state's two wholesale power markets, said >Steve Maviglio, Davis' press secretary. >-By Jason Leopold, Dow Jones Newswires; 323-658-3874; >jason.leopold@dowjones.com >-0- >Last week, FERC received hundreds of pages of comments to its proposed order >for California's power market. >(MORE) Dow Jones Newswires 27-11-00 >G_nther A. Pergher >Senior Analyst >Dow Jones & Company Inc. >Tel. 609.520.7067 >Fax. 609.452.3531 > >The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to >which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged >material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or >taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or >entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received >this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any >computer. > > <<Pergher, Gunther.vcf>> > >------_=_NextPart_000_01C05946.A1460FC0 >Content-Type: application/octet-stream; > name="Pergher, Gunther.vcf" >Content-Disposition: attachment; > filename="Pergher, Gunther.vcf" > >BEGIN:VCARD >VERSION:2.1 >N:Pergher;Gunther >FN:Pergher, Gunther >ORG:Dow Jones Newswires;News Gathering & Pdn >TITLE:Sr Research Analyst >TEL;WORK;VOICE:609-520-7067 >ADR;WORK:;South Brunswick NJ >LABEL;WORK:South Brunswick NJ >EMAIL;PREF;INTERNET:Gunther.Pergher@dowjones.com >REV:20001121T161855Z >END:VCARD > >------_=_NextPart_000_01C05946.A1460FC0-- > Carol Close Opatrny Opatrny Consulting, Inc. 18509 N. E. Cedar Drive Battle Ground, Washington 98604 360.666.8509 (fax) 360.666.8510 (phone) e-mail: ccopat@e-z.net