18 Oct 2000, 14:56 UTC
San Diego Union Tribune
- From
- Richard B Sanders richard.sanders@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 18 Oct 2000 07:56:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Richard B Sanders/HOU/ECT on 10/18/2000 02:56 PM ----- Eric Thode@ENRON 10/18/2000 02:54 PM To: Richard B Sanders/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Subject: San Diego Union Tribune ---------------------- Forwarded by Eric Thode/Corp/Enron on 10/18/2000 02:55 PM --------------------------- Eric Thode 10/18/2000 02:41 PM To: Mark Palmer/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Subject: San Diego Union Tribune Have you seen this? Eric Power-company profits climb along with prices By Craig D. Rose UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER October 18, 2000 A power company executive yesterday boiled California's ongoing electricity crisis down to the bottom line. "Prices are rising, and I know that's hurting consumers ) but it certainly has been beneficial for Enron," said Jeffrey Skilling, president and chief operating officer of the Houston-based energy and trading company. Enron declined to specify how much it earned from California during the past summer, when the state's deregulated electricity market sent power prices soaring. But the Texas company did say that profits of its sales and services unit ) which trades California electricity and o ther commodities ) increased 135 percent to $404 million. Dynegy Inc., also based in Houston, reported that income from its marketing and trade unit soared more than 300 percent to $142 million. Steve Bergstrom, president of Dynegy, said California was perhaps only the third-biggest contributor to that surge. But industry analysts said the earnings reports are the first indication of a pattern expected in coming weeks. "California clearly drove the positive momentum at both of these companies," said Carol Coale, senior analyst of Prudential Securities. "And you probably just saw the beginning of a string of strong reports (from the power industry)." She and others say they suspect that power companies derived billions in profits from the state, where tight supplies set the stage for huge price increases. Companies did not necessarily have to own generating plants to profit from the deregulated market. Enron produces no electricity in California but is the nation's largest electricity trader, buying and selling the output of power plants owned by other companies. Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-El Cajon, said the big profits should be seen in something other than a business context. "These massive profits by the energy companies translate directly into thousands of San Diegans losing savings that were planned for education, mortgage payments, health care and other . . . necessities," Hunter said. When the state power exchange saw dramatic price increases within a matter of hours, "it was clear that predatory pricing was producing massive profits for someone," Hunter said. Hunter insists that recent power prices violate federal law mandating that rates be "just and reasonable." He is calling for the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to order refunds. FERC is scheduled to issue a report on the California market by Nov. 1. The political fallout from the price increases, meanwhile, appears to weigh heavily on power companies, which are reluctant to tout successes in California for fear of being singled out for profiteering. After noting that Dynegy's recent acquisitions in Illinois contributed strongly to the company's success last quarter, Bergstrom was reminded that he had omitted mention of California. "Illinois is not as politically volatile as California," Bergstrom said. He acknowledged that Dynegy did "pretty well" in California because its power plants produced far more electricity this year than last. Bergstrom also sought to correct an earlier report that Dynegy had quickly recouped the cost of power plants it recently acquired in the state. He said that was true only of the plants it owns in Long Beach and El Segundo, which it bought in 1998. Bergstrom said the cost of Dynegy's half interest in the former San Diego Gas & Electric Encina power plant in Carlsbad ) acquired at the end of 1998 ) had not been recovered. Typically, plant operators assume that it will take as long as 20 years to recoup such costs. In comments to financial analysts, Skilling, of Enron, suggested that power companies could help provide a solution to California's power problems. "Supply constraints and the resulting price pressures in California and other locations have demonstrated the need for skilled marketers like Enron to provide reliable power and stable prices," Skilling said. He predicted that California's utility companies ) which now buy much of their power from other companies ) would sign long-term contracts to stabilize prices, following an approach suggested by many power generators and traders. "If they were willing to extend the terms of their purchases to 10-year contracts, then they could get contracts for $50 a megawatt, which is not much different than they were paying two or three years ago," Skilling said. But consumer advocates have noted that long-term contracts at those levels would lock consumers into price increases and leave them with little choice about suppliers. Advocates of electrical deregulation had predicted that introducing competition would lead to reductions in power costs and to greater consumer choice. Harry Snyder, senior advocate for Consumers Union in San Francisco, said he was skeptical of solutions proposed by the power industry. "Any proposal from the industry has to be suspect because they have engaged in faking out the California public and price gouging when there are shortages," said Snyder, who advocates an end to deregulation. "They do not have consumer interests at heart."