23 Aug 2000, 16:56 UTC
Re: Edited Draft of FERC Presentation
- From
- Tim Belden tim.belden@enron.com
- To
- Ellen Wolfe
- Cc
- james.d.steffes@enron.com, Mary Hain, Joe Hartsoe, Sarah Novosel, Jeff Dasovich, Paul Kaufman, Mara, Susan" @ENRON
- Bcc
- james.d.steffes@enron.com, Mary Hain, Joe Hartsoe, Sarah Novosel, Jeff Dasovich, Paul Kaufman, Mara, Susan" @ENRON
- Date
- Wed, 23 Aug 2000 09:56:00 -0700 (PDT)
I have made a number of edits of the presentation today. There are many more to go. I think that we can get it shaped up by Friday. It will require a lot of coordination to shape it up by Thursday. In the event that it can't be whipped into shape by Thursday, I think that we need to boil it down to a few themes that we present at the group meeting. We then can finish the presentation and get it to FERC Friday AM before the call. Who is making the final call on this? How are we going to coordinate? Enron Capital & Trade Resources Corp. From: Ellen Wolfe <ellen@tca-us.com> 08/23/2000 02:29 PM Please respond to ellen@tca-us.com To: James D Steffes <James.D.Steffes@enron.com> cc: Mary Hain <Mary.Hain@enron.com>, Joe Hartsoe <Joe.Hartsoe@enron.com>, Sarah Novosel <Sarah.Novosel@enron.com>, Jeff Dasovich <Jeff.Dasovich@enron.com>, Paul Kaufman <Paul.Kaufman@enron.com>, Tim Belden <Tim.Belden@enron.com>, Susan J Mara <Susan.J.Mara@enron.com> Subject: Re: Edited Draft of FERC Presentation Jim and others, I think we are suffering from not enough time to fully iterate this, as well as little information on what others are going present. The basic messages as I see them (and not having trued this up with Mary or others) are: 1. The markets are working consistent with physics and economics; demand is up, supplies are down and higher prices are resulting. 2. Characteristics of the retail markets have resulted in risks being passed to end users. Are such issues impeding wholesale markets? If so, perhaps FERC can influence movement in this area. 3. We shouldn't equate outcomes at the retail level with bad structure at wholesale level. The key is to distinguish the retail issues so that FERC can focus on the wholesale issues. 4. Any remaining concerns should be studied further rather than simply receiving blame for the outcomes we've seen: Whether there is market power? Whether rather it's a matter of scarcity rents? What are appropriate scarcity rents? Is monopsony power on the buyers' side (utilities) causing undesirable economic and reliability outcomes. (And out of this should be consideration of whether an across-the-board $250 cap is the right one, especially given that the ISO staff itself recognizes that this is a poor proxy for what buyers are willing to pay as scarcity rents.) That's my 2 cents. I don't know what Mary's additional thoughts are, nor how what other parties will say may affect what we should emphasize. Certainly, though, your feedback is invaluable. If you reply with feedback I'll do what I can to see that Enron's message reflects your preferences. Regards, Ellen. James D Steffes wrote:
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> Mary & Joe -- > > Given the time frame for our response (2 - 4 minutes), we need to prepare not > only our "leave behind" but also our "oral message". > > I want to make sure that everyone agrees with the theme and content of our > verbal discussions. Can you please put out an outline of the message and > details and then make sure the Trading desk and CA Govt Affairs agree with the > form and delivery (set up a conference call if necessary)? > > This is a very complicated issue and very short time frame to deliver. The more > we prepare I think the better we'll do. > > Thanks, > > Jim > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > Name: August 24 presentation to FERC1.ppt > August 24 presentation to FERC1.ppt Type: Microsoft PowerPoint Show (application/vnd.ms-powerpoint) > Encoding: base64 > Description: Microsoft PowerPoint 97 - ellen.vcf