5 Jul 2001, 09:47 UTC
PG&E Files Emergency Motion re URG Valuation
- From
- Dan Douglass douglass@energyattorney.com
- To
- tjohnso8@enron.com, berry@apx.com, dpurdum@apx.com, ed@cazalet.com, billr@calpine.com, bob_anderson@apses.com, Carolyn A Baker, camiessn@newwestenergy.com, jcgardin@newwestenergy.com, curt.hatton@neg.pge.com, curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com, Gary Ackerman
- Date
- Thu, 5 Jul 2001 02:47:00 -0700 (PDT)
???????????? PG&E has?filed the attached, &Motion to Establish Final Market Valuation of Non-Nuclear Generating Assets Pursuant to Public Utilities Code Section 367.8? The motion requests that the Commission consolidate in the docket used for the recent rate stabilization decision the existing record of PG&E,s remaining major non-nuclear generating asset market valuation proceedings and immediately adopt a final market valuation for all of PG&E,s remaining non-nuclear generating assets.? The market valuation dockets that would be consolidated in this proceeding include A.99-09-053 (hydroelectric assets); A.00-05-031 (Kern); and A.00-05-034 (Humboldt Bay). ??? ??? ??? The utility requests that this be done?prior to establishing the revenue requirements and rates for PG&E,s retained generating assets pursuant to the June 15 Chief ALJ,s Ruling.? That ruling set a hearing schedule for determining the revenue requirements of the three utilities related to retained generation,?QFs, bilateral contracts, and ancillary services.? PG&E asks that the?Commission rule on its Motion as soon as possible and no later than July 19, so that PG&E and interested parties have the benefit of the ruling prior to the beginning of hearings on July 23, 2001. PG&E argues that since the Commission has not completed market valuations for PG&E,s generating assets,?it therefore may not legally determine the value of those assets for ratemaking purposes until such time as those market valuations are complete.? In fact, there has been no action whatsoever in?PG&E,s hydroelectric market valuation proceeding since January 22,?when the Chief ALJ issued a ruling canceling a prehearing conference and public participation hearings, and extending the comment period on the draft environmental impact report. The utility stresses that Section 367(b) of the PU Code?requires the Commission to market value the utilities, generation assets ¬ later than December 31, 2001,8 and that it has to be, &based on appraisal, sale or other divestiture.8? They also note that AB 6 from the Legislature,s First Extraordinary Session modified Section 377 to?prohibit PG&E from selling any of its existing generating assets until at least January 1, 2006, and requires that those assets be dedicated for the benefit of California ratepayers.? Since AB 6X precludes the Commission from valuing PG&E,s generating assets by sale or divestiture, appraisal is the only lawful method. PG&E concludes that effective January 1, 2002, its non-nuclear retained generation must be reflected in utility rates on the same basis as the market value determined for purposes of AB 1890 stranded cost computations.? Therefore, the?market valuations adopted by the Commission will have to be included in the consideration of URG ratemaking in this proceeding.? The motion says that the?valuations are also essential prerequisites to the determination of any amounts that might be made available under the current rate structure for payment to the DWR as provided for in AB1X.? PG&E concludes that market valuation of its retained generating assets is an essential prerequisite to establishing their revenue requirement, which is hardly illogical. Dan Law Offices of Daniel W. Douglass 5959 Topanga Canyon Blvd.? Suite 244 Woodland Hills, CA 91367 Tel:?? (818) 596-2201 Fax:? (818) 346-6502 douglass@energyattorney.com - 7-3-01 PG&E URG Motion.doc