7 Sep 2000, 16:35 UTC
Re: Gov. Davis Press Release
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Cc
- Bob Hansen, Douglas Condon, James M Wood, martin.wenzel@enron.com, Greg Cordell, Chris Hendrix, Edward Hamb, Jennifer Rudolph, Dennis Benevides, Harry Kingerski, Gary Mirich, Jeff Dasovich
- Bcc
- Bob Hansen, Douglas Condon, James M Wood, martin.wenzel@enron.com, Greg Cordell, Chris Hendrix, Edward Hamb, Jennifer Rudolph, Dennis Benevides, Harry Kingerski, Gary Mirich, Jeff Dasovich
- Date
- Thu, 7 Sep 2000 09:35:00 -0700 (PDT)
I think the implementation plan for the Res and Small Commercial makes good sense. This is good intelligence for preparing our curves and pricing models; however, these customers are not our commercial focus and only tend to show up as a few sites in a portfolio of sites. SDG&E's plan was our preferred plan to the extent that the Legislature or Commission had implemented a mandatory rate cap for all size customers. With respect to the larger opt-in customers, I expect that this is only available to Standard Offer customers. SDG&E should prevent cost shifting to other customers who do not benefit from the cap, i.e. SO customers who do not opt-in and DA customers who do not have the option. Even customers who opt-in will vary by differing degrees in terms of the size of the customer and timeframe. It seems to me, the only equitable implementation plan for the opt-in customers is a customer-specific balancing account, similar to that which is implemented for the balanced payment plan; otherwise too much gaming will ensue which would result in the need for administratively burdensome tracking. To the extent that SDG&E makes all customers, including DA customers, pay for the undercollections, we can switch our customers to Standard Offer without any negative ramifications. (Note: It would be difficult to exercise such a "regulatory switching option" if only those customers who benefit incur a surcharge into the future, because our customers would balk at us exercising the option during our contract term and imposing a future liability on our customer beyond the contract term.) In fact, it might be better if all customers were expected to pay for the undercollections so that we can exercise the regulatory switching option. What do others think? I think we can work with either implementation method. If it is a customer-specific balancing account, we will make customers know that the lower rates is the equivalent to a loan they will need to eventually pay off. If it is all customers who are expected to pay, we will exercise the regulatory switching option. We need to be careful not to share too much of this strategy and insights with the utility, because they will counter by imposing new rules and charges for switching customers between DA and SO. I don't believe that SDG&E's shareholders should be held accountable for a percentage of the shortfalls. This would provide a subsidy to SO service. I believe it is more important that customers realize that the utility's SO service is not the right solution versus trying to drive the utility away from SO service. Either outcome works for us. The last issue I will address is the timing of recovery of the undercollections. Will recovery begin during the period of the cap such that the cap will effectively be implemented as a freeze? Or will the recovery begin after the cap expires, resulting in otherwise higher future rates. Defering cost recovery will always work to our advantage from a book perspective. The key for me is to know asap the details, so that we can properly model our curves for pricing new deals and reflect the changes in our book. However, since these questions largely pertain to the smaller customers in SDG&E's service territory, I do not anticipate a large impact on our book and our marketing efforts. In fact, I think the burdens of the modeling changes would outweigh much of the benefits of this legislation for us. Thanks for the intelligence. Roger
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Mona L Petrochko 09/06/2000 06:26 PM To: Douglas Condon/SFO/EES@EES, James M Wood/HOU/EES@EES, Martin Wenzel/SFO/HOU/EES@EES, Greg Cordell, Chris Hendrix/HOU/EES@EES, Edward Hamb/HOU/EES@EES, Jennifer Rudolph/HOU/EES@EES, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Roger Yang, Harry Kingerski/HOU/EES@EES, Gary Mirich/HOU/EES@EES cc: West GA, James D Steffes/HOU/EES@EES Subject: Gov. Davis Press Release Governor has NOT signed AB 1156, $150 million from the general fund. He HAS signed AB 265 (SDG&E rate cap bill) and AB 970 (expedited siting for non-permanent peaking). I had a conversation today with Wayne Sakarias from SDG&E about implementation. It appears, based on the press release, that the Commission will act tomorrow to adopt an order that will begin the implementation process, although the order is not available for review yet. I asked Wayne how they intended to implement the bill. He believes that the opt-in provision for large C&I customers, and any associated undercollections associated with the customers that opt-in, would be handled separately from the general application of the rate cap for residential and small commercial customers. I asked how they would collect any shortfalls. It didn't sound like they had a plan yet. I suggested balancing account treatment for the customers that benefit from the opt-in with any shortfalls recovered as quickly as possible but no later than 1 year. Relative to Res/Small Commercial: He said that SDG&E will propose, in response to ARM comments, that the cap (for res and small commercial) customers would not disadvantage DA customers. In other words, they are concerned about the appearances that SDG&E's rates would be lower than market prices because of the cap and would make available to DA customers a comparable pricing mechanism, that in effect, would eliminate any pricing advantage by staying w/ SDG&E. For example: If prevailing market prices were 7.5 cents/kWh, SDG&E's res and small commercial customers would only be charged upto 6.5 cents, and DA customers would receive a 1 cent/kWh credit against their T&D charges so that in effect, there is no economic advantage to staying w/ SDG&E. However, when it comes time to pay the piper for undercollections, DA and bundled customers would again be treated comparably. Their BIG concern is that the Commission will hang them out to dry on reasonableness. We agreed to keep the dialogue open. Things will likely happen quickly. If folks have any recommendations or see problems with the above, let me know asap. Thanks. Mona ---------------------- Forwarded by Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES on 09/06/2000 04:03 PM --------------------------- Sandra McCubbin 09/06/2000 03:25 PM To: mpetroch@enron.com, Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, David Parquet/SF/ECT@ECT, Samuel Wehn/HOU/ECT@ECT, James D Steffes/HOU/EES@EES, Steven J Kean/HOU/EES@EES, Richard Shapiro cc: Subject: Gov. Davis Press Release It doesn't look like he is going to sign the bill that takes 150 million out of the general fund for San Diego rate payers ---------------------- Forwarded by Sandra McCubbin/SFO/EES on 09/06/2000 03:22 PM --------------------------- Joseph Alamo 09/06/2000 03:15 PM To: Sandra McCubbin/SFO/EES@EES cc: Subject: Gov. Davis Press Release OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- L00:091 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE September 6, 2000 GOVERNOR DAVIS SIGNS ELECTRICITY CONSUMER RELIEF LEGISLATION SACRAMENTO ) Governor Gray Davis continued his commitment to easing the burden of San Diego ratepayers by signing two major pieces of legislation designed to stabilize the cost of electricity and streamline the siting process for new power plants. "One of the major achievements of this year's legislative session is our aggressive response to California's energy challenge," Governor Davis said. "My Administration did not create this problem, but we are 100-percent committed to solving it. And, now, after a long, hot summer of unconscionably high energy prices, relief is finally on the way." AB 265 by Assemblywoman Susan Davis (D-San Diego) and Senator Deirdre Alpert (D-Coronado) will stabilize the price of electricity for consumers and small business (including schools and hospitals) in San Diego at 6.5 cents per kilowatt-hour. These rates will be retroactive from June 1, 2000 and extend to December 31, 2003. "In the short term, this will ease the uncertainty of San Diego energy prices," Governor Davis said. "When it comes to predicting their electric bills, San Diego consumers have been in the dark long enough. This is an urgency measure. I am signing this bill today so that the PUC can take immediate action at its meeting tomorrow." As a result of this legislation, the average monthly bill for residential customers in San Diego will be reduced to $68. Small businesses (all schools and acute-care hospitals are included) will pay an average monthly bill of $220. Medium businesses (consuming up to 72,000 kilowatt-hours a month) would also have a price cap of 6.5 cents per kilowatt-hour. For large businesses, AB 265 would allow for a negotiated payment plan with SDG&E over a longer period of time. AB 970 by Assemblywoman Denise Ducheny (D-San Diego) and Assemblyman Jim Battin (R-La Quinta) will help California overcome the inadequate supply of energy, one of the biggest obstacles to lower energy prices, by expediting the siting process for new power plants and streamlining permitting for upgrades of old facilities. "Restrictions and red tape have presented a powerful disincentive to those who would build more power generators in California," Governor Davis said. "This bill will benefit consumers by increasing supply to meet growing demand. It will also establish new programs to reduce demand." Over the last three months, Governor Gray Davis' leadership has been demonstrated in his response to the San Diego electricity crisis: On June 14, he called for emergency reduction of electricity use by all state facilities in the San Francisco Bay area in response to electricity emergency and rolling blackouts. On June 15, he called on chairpersons of the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to analyze the conditions that led to electricity shortages in the San Francisco Bay area the previous day, including a statewide perspective on the price and delivery of electricity. Report was completed, submitted to the governor and released on August 2. On July 27, 2000, Governor Davis called on federal and state regulators to take swift action to extend the caps on wholesale electric rates in California and provide San Diego ratepayers with million of dollars in refunds. In letters written by the governor to two state regulatory agencies and two California-based panels charged with overseeing California's power market, he called for a coordinated state effort to urge federal regulators to take strong measures to reduce power rates in both the short- and long-term. On August 2, 2000, Governor Davis issued three Executive Orders designed to reduce energy consumption by state government and speed up the time it takes new power generating facilities to win approval from state agencies. Please go to http://www.governor.ca.gov/briefing/execorder/index.shtm to view copies of Governor Davis' Executive Orders. On August 9, 2000, Governor Davis called on the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to establish a two-year plan that would cut electricity rates by nearly half for residential and business customers of San Diego Gas & Electric. The governor also reached an agreement with the California Grocers Association that will save enough electricity to provide power to between 50,000 and 60,000 homes during periods of peak demand, as grocers agreed to reduce power consumption by 10 percent during Stage One emergencies. On August 10, 2000, Governor Davis wrote a letter to President Clinton urging him to expedite the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's investigation to determine whether current electric rates in San Diego were unjust. On August 22, 2000, Governor Davis called on President Clinton to release emergency funds from the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) to the state to help low-income Californians pay their rapidly-rising electricity bills. On August 23, 2000, President Clinton responded to Governor Davis' request by releasing $2.6 million in emergency funds to help low-income Southern Californians cope with the surge in their electricity bills. The president also asked federal regulators to speed up their investigation into the operation of U.S. power markets and urged the Small Business Administration to use its credit programs to help small firms hurt by the price increases. On August 23, 2000, Governor Davis reached agreement with legislators on legislation to provide relief to San Diego ratepayers. Today's bill signing is the culmination of that agreement. # # # ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- GOVERNOR GRAY DAVIS ? SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA 95814 ? (916) 445-2841