Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

4 May 2000, 13:38 UTC

RE: Next Draft of EG Testimony in Support of the Comprehensive Se ttlement Agreement

From
Craig Chancellor craigc@calpine.com
To
Tom Beach, Michael Rochman, Brian - TPBKC Cherry, Michael S Alexander, Paul Amirault, david.bayless@utility.com, John Burkholder, Craig Chancellor, Rick Counihan, jdasovic@enron.com, MDay, bdingwall@unitedgas.com
and 49 more Daniel Douglass, Evelyn Kahl Elsesser, jfawcet@enron.com, rfoss@coral-energy.com, plg@cpuc.ca.gov, John Jimison, johnson_pamela@lacoe.edu, karpjos@sf.whitecase.com, John Leslie, kmccrea@sablaw.com, jmpa@dynegy.com, Robert M. Pocta, porterdk@sce.com, Susan M Scott, rbeamish@sempra.com, Betonte, Robert - TP2RSB, tbrill@sempra.com, gcotton@sdge.com, redavis@sempra.com, sdavis@sdge.com, pfair@sdge.com, dfollett@sempra.com, efong@sdge.com, kfreeman@sempra.com, mgaines@socalgas.com, jharrigan@socalgas.com, jhay@sempra.com, ljhubbard@sempra.com, Lad - TPLPL Lorenz, nmcvay@socalgas.com, rmorrow@socalgas.com, rpurves@sdge.com, wreed@sempra.com, wsakarias@sdge.com, lschavrien@sempra.com, asmith@sempra.com, Glen J. Sullivan, tsurak@socalgas.com, J.- TPJUS Suwara, etakemura@socalgas.com, jteeter@sdge.com, tp2jxv@socalgas.com, Watson, Steven - TP2SAW, gwright@sempra.com, dbarker@socalgas.com, lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com, Christine Jun, bsl@cpuc.ca.gov, Amie C. King
Cc
ddyck@mail.arco.com, tlu1@mail.arco.com
Bcc
ddyck@mail.arco.com, tlu1@mail.arco.com
Date
Thu, 4 May 2000 06:38:00 -0700 (PDT)
Tom,

The testimony looks good.  I agree with your position on the rates.  It will
be raised so it is best to hit it head-on.  I am assuming you have IEP
approval on the use of your earlier study.  If not Calpine, Enron and Dynegy
can help get IEP to react.

Thanks

Craig
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Tom Beach [SMTP:tomb@crossborderenergy.com]
> Sent: Thursday, May 04, 2000 12:21 PM
> To: Michael Rochman; 'Cherry, Brian - TPBKC'; AlexanMS@sce.com;
> paulamirault@aec.ca; david.bayless@utility.com; Burkee@cts.com;
> Craigc@calpine.com; Rick.Counihan@greenmountain.com; Jdasovic@enron.com;
> Mday@gmssr.com; bdingwall@unitedgas.com; Douglass@arterhadden.com;
> eke@aelaw.com; Jfawcet@enron.com; rfoss@coral-energy.com; plg@cpuc.ca.gov;
> johnj@bcjlaw.com; Johnson_Pamela@lacoe.edu; karpjos@sf.whitecase.com;
> jleslie@luce.com; kmccrea@sablaw.com; jmpa@dynegy.com; rmp@cpuc.ca.gov;
> porterdk@sce.com; susan.scott@enron.com; 'Beamish, Richard - TPRMB';
> 'Betonte, Robert - TP2RSB'; 'Brill, Thomas R.'; 'Cotton, Gary'; 'Davis,
> Robert E.'; 'Davis, Steven D.'; 'Fair, Pam'; 'Follett, B. David - TPDBF';
> 'Fong, Ed'; 'Freeman, Kimberly'; 'Gaines, Mark - TPMFG'; 'Harrigan, James
> P. - TP1JPH'; 'Hay, James E.'; 'Hubbard, Lisa J.'; 'Lorenz, Lad - TPLPL';
> 'McVay, Nancy W - TPNWM'; 'Morrow, Rick - TP3RMM'; 'Purves, Ralph A.';
> 'Reed, William'; 'Sakarias, Wayne P.'; 'Schavrien, Lee'; 'Smith, Anne S. -
> TPASS'; 'Sullivan, Glen J.'; 'Surak, Thomas M. - TP1TMS'; 'Suwara, J.-
> TPJUS'; 'Takemura, Earl - TPEKT'; 'Teeter, James S.'; 'Van Lierop, Jan -
> TP2JXV'; 'Watson, Steven - TP2SAW'; 'Wright, Gillian - TP1GXW'; 'Barker,
> David - TPDTB'; 'How-Downing, Lindsey'; 'Jun, Christine'; 'Khoury,
> Dexter'; ack@aelaw.com
> Cc: David Dyck; Tom Lu
> Subject: Next Draft of EG Testimony in Support of the Comprehensive
> Settlement Agreement
>
> Attached is (hopefully) the final draft of my testimony on behalf of
> electric generators in support of the Comprehensive Settlement Agreement
> for SoCalGas.  I have incorporated comments from Edison, Dynegy, CCC, IP,
> and SoCalGas.  Please let me know if you have any further concerns, by
> e-mail or at 510-649-9790.
>
> With respect to Glen Sullivan's concerns about discussing the rate impacts
> on EGs, I have the following comments.  Certainly, it is difficult at this
> point to project how much backbone capacity will be subscribed, and at
> what cost.  However, it is a fact that every end user on the SoCalGas
> system will need to acquire and pay for backbone capacity in order to move
> gas to their facility.  Lad and Gillian made, in my view, a reasonable
> estimate that, on average, end users would pay $0.07 per Dth for backbone
> service, based on total backbone costs divided by BCAP throughput.  Some
> may use interruptible service and pay 120% of this rate; others may obtain
> backbone service at a discount.  On average, Lad and Gillian's numbers are
> a reasonable projection and very defensible.  Moreover, in my view, we
> need to try to seize the high ground on the issue of rate impacts on EGs;
> otherwise SCGC will do so, and our settlement could face a real problem.
>
> Tom Beach << File: EG Testimony.doc >>