15 Mar 2001, 17:58 UTC
Which technology resolves disputes best?
- From
- Rahil Jafry rahil.jafry@enron.com
- To
- Mark Taylor, Marcus Nettelton, faisal.kajani@chamberlainlaw.com, k.walji@chamberlainlaw.com, Jason Peters, Paul Goddard, ajafry@hotmail.com, hrjafry@mtholyoke.edu, jafry@hotmail.com, hamida_jafry@hotmail.com, miraaz@peerbhai.com
- Date
- Thu, 15 Mar 2001 09:58:00 -0800 (PST)
http://www.business2.com/content/magazine/ebusiness/2001/03/12/27491# Settle This Which technology resolves disputes best? March 20, 2001 issue Michael Grebb St. Louis retiree David Hubert couldn't have been happier to score a replica of a $3,000 Charles Eames leather chair on eBay -for only $450. When it arrived, he tore open the box, pulled away the bubble wrap, and immediately sunk into the chair to ease his bad back. "As soon as I sat in it, I could tell...whoa, this isn't right," he says. "It had a bad mildew smell-I mean, a really bad mildew smell." Distraught, Hubert emailed the seller to demand that he either pay to clean the chair or take it back. The seller refused. "He basically stonewalled me," Hubert says. So Hubert filed a grievance with SquareTrade, a San Francisco-based startup that helps resolve disputes on eBay. A SquareTrade online mediator-a real person who corresponds with both parties via email-immediately began negotiations. After a week of back-and-forth, the seller finally agreed to send Hubert $150 to have the chair cleaned. Hubert and the seller never were in contact. "I think it went really smoothly," Hubert says. Mediation has been a popular alternative to lawsuits to resolve disputes, especially those involving small amounts of money. For businesses, conflicts between state and international laws have made dispute resolution costly, no matter how big the transaction. With $657 billion changing hands through Internet transactions worldwide, it comes as little surprise that a raft of new dot-coms plans to move the mediation process further online. Everyone expects online mediation to grow as the number of transactions conducted online continues to grow. "Regardless of the market fluctuations and a fair amount of blood on the street, ecommerce is here to stay and is growing at a steady pace," says Steven Abernethy, president and CEO of SquareTrade. "There is wealth of commerce online to keep us and others busy for a while." The American Arbitration Association estimates that dispute resolution is a $200 million-a-year industry, but there's no way to know how much of that would migrate online. "I'm not sure it would necessarily shift," says association spokesperson Toni Griffin. "Online transactions may simply generate more disputes, which would grow the whole market." American Arbitration-the largest dispute resolution company with 140,000 cases per year as of 1999 and $65 million in annual revenue-recently announced its own online mediation business. Online mediators agree that easier dispute resolution will drive faster adoption of ecommerce by businesses and consumers, many of whom may now avoid online transactions for fear of getting hosed. According to Forrester Research, two-thirds of businesses say they would not conduct an online transaction with a party they don't already know. What they can't agree on is how to use technology to resolve disputes. Some companies, such as SquareTrade, eResolution, or Online Resolution, have had experience resolving disputes. They are mediating disputes online simply by substituting an online chat session or email for the conference table or telephone. But a few upstarts say these companies aren't harnessing new technologies that allow mediation to be automated. "This is not as simple as slapping up a Website," sniffs Charles Brofman, president and CEO of Mount Kisco, N.Y.-based Cybersettle.com. He doesn't mediate disputes but offers an automated blind bid system to negotiate settlements when liability has already been established. Here's how it works: The aggrieved party enters a demand; the liable party enters the most it will pay (Neither side sees the other's entry, hence the term blind bid.) If the numbers are within 30 percent of each other, the software automatically splits it down the middle and settles the claim. For each dispute, the parties get three tries, after which they must start over if their entries still haven't come within 30 percent. The company says the site can handle as many as 10,000 simultaneous sessions per second. Brofman says he has signed insurance companies to flat-rate subscription plans in which Cybersettle offers discounts for a certain number of claims per year. "This system just takes all of the ego and personality and whittles it down to what it should have been-settling the claim," he says. That's especially important, he says, for international disputes in which cultural differences can muddy an otherwise objective claims process. Rival clickNsettle.com offers a service similar to Cybersettle's, but doesn't limit parties to three bids per cycle. Instead, it uses a monetary disincentive to stop parties from gaming the process. ClickNsettle doesn't set a bid limit, but charges a small fee for every settlement offer made. CEO Roy Israel says the fees are just annoying enough to keep parties from wasting bids on outlandish demands. "It eliminates the ridiculous," he says. "It keeps someone from asking for millions of dollars. It causes people to get real-real quick. No one wants to waste $100 on bids that don't go anywhere." Israel criticizes Cybersettle's three-bid process, calling it inflexible because it "artificially terminates" the process even when parties haven't settled. And as you might expect, Brofman is equally skeptical of clickNsettle's unlimited bid system. "If you go to infinity, people just try to game the system," he says. "And once insurance companies realize you can game the system, they're not going to use it." His clickNsettle.com was called National Arbitration and Mediation for eight years before adopting a dot-com moniker last year. "We're not just an Internet startup trying to capitalize on dot-com hysteria," Israel says. "We're a mediation business evolving into a Web-enabled business." In fact, its existing mediation infrastructure allows the company to give users the option of moving disputes offline if necessary. The question is whether either Cybersettle or clickNsettle-or any of the other mediation sites-will catch on. "I'm skeptical of these automated mechanisms," says Forrester analyst Charles Rutstein. "It's a little too 'Let's-let-the-machines-do-it.'" He wonders whether all the messaging back-and-forth makes sense for many disputes that could be easily settled using traditional means. "Just pick up the friggin' phone," he says. Web Judges clickNsettle.com , Great Neck, N.Y. Specialty: Traditional claims process goes online Selling point: Allows each side to bid until settlement is reached (with a 60-day time limit) Size: About 8,000 law firms as clients, as well as 500 members using its online component pricing: The first party pays a $15 registration fee, each subsequent offer costs $10 for the first 20 days, $15 for the next 20 days, and $20 for the final 20 days Cybersettle.com , Mount Kisco, N.Y. Specialty: Automated blind-bid mediation service Selling point: Future plans include an "online small claims court" to handle minor disputes Size: 90 employees; claims more than 16,000 registered users pricing: Fee scaled to size of settlement. If plaintiff receives up to $5,000, there is a $100 "success fee"; $5,000 to $10,000 costs $150; defendants' fees start at $100 for a settlement up to $5,000; more than $10,000, a $200 fee. eResolution , Montreal Specialty: Is also an applications service provider, licensing its software to other dispute resolution companies Selling point: Honed experience settling domain name disputes Size: About 30 employees pricing: A sliding scale ranging from 1 percent for the biggest cases ($150,000 or more) to more than 20 percent for small potatoes ($500 or less). iCourthouse , Lafayette, Calif. Specialty: Online jurors judge the case Selling point: "At this point, we're doing this for entertainment," says CEO Clyde Long. Size: 10 employees pricing: Free. Another service, JurySmart, costs $189 per case. Online Resolution , Cambridge, Mass. Specialty: Disputes of more than $2,000 involving insurance, employment, and B-to-B commerce. Selling point: Tailored for common B-to-B disputes Size: 13 employees; 500 mediators pricing: For disputes of less than $10,000, each party pays $50 per hour; for disputes $10,000-$50,000, each pays $75 per hour; disputes of more than $50,000 cost $100 per hour; organizations that sign up for packages receive major discounts per case. SquareTrade , San Francisco Specialty: Mediation for the masses Selling point: Offers mom-and-pop online merchants a "Square Deal" certificate-a seal of approval-for as much as $6,400 Size: More than 250 mediators and arbitrators on contract; claims to have processed more than 35,000 disputes pricing: $20 per dispute for mediation; if the transaction is valued at more than $1,000, it also takes a 1 percent fee. Mediators are paid on a per-dispute basis. WebMediate , headquarters: Boston Specialty: Focused exclusively on business-to- business exchanges and marketplaces Selling point: Brainiac board includes several Harvard and MIT law and management professors. Size: 8 employees and 100 online mediators under contract pricing: Will charge clients an hourly rate for mediators; will take a cut of the mediator's fee or a percentage of monetary disputes when the automated system is used. Michael Grebb (cablegrebb@aol.com) is a Washington, D.C.*based contributor for Business 2.0.