5 Sep 2000, 17:55 UTC
Re: WIO Bylaws - Feedback Requested
- From
- Steve Walton steve.walton@enron.com
- Cc
- Paul Kaufman, Mary Hain, Richard Ingersoll, Mona L Petrochko, Jeff Dasovich, susan_j_mara@enron.com, Bruno Gaillard
- Bcc
- Paul Kaufman, Mary Hain, Richard Ingersoll, Mona L Petrochko, Jeff Dasovich, susan_j_mara@enron.com, Bruno Gaillard
- Date
- Tue, 5 Sep 2000 10:55:00 -0700 (PDT)
Marcie, In my view, the Planning issue is more of a matter for an RTO tariff than for the WIO agreement. When we created the RTGs (WRTA, SWRTA, NRTA) we put that kind of language into the agreement because there were no open access tariffs. We no have Order No. 888 OATTs except for a few parties, so I am not sure that we need to retain the transmission access language in WIO. The specific language could create a conflict because the RTO tariff may have different provisions which don 't match based on a division of responsiblity for lines between those on congested paths and lines within local areas. On ADR, I have heard all the old arguments an believe the WRTA/NRTA approach is better. They both lead to quick resolution and have been show in NRTA's case to have resolved real disputes relatively quickly. The approach advocated by SWRTA tries to avoid using FERC as the final decision maker in matters of transmission access. The SWRTA process takes months before you can complain and then you get a mandatory outcome, even if the arbitrator fails to understand FERC requirements. This could put you between a rock and a hard place, if there is a conflict. We should resist the SWRTA approach, and vote for a short mediation, followed by either party being able to go to arbitration, the "last best offer first" style of arbitration and an appealable arbitration decision to the FERC. Steve From: Marcie Milner@ENRON on 09/05/2000 03:20 PM To: Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, Mary Hain/HOU/ECT@ECT, Richard Ingersoll/HOU/ECT@ECT, Steve Walton/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, Susan_J_Mara@enron.com, Bruno Gaillard/SFO/EES@EES Subject: WIO Bylaws - Feedback Requested Following are two issues that are currently being debated to which I am requesting feedback in order to submit an Enron position prior to the Steering Committee being held this week. Planning: Parties are lobbying language to disclose all planning projects permitting anyone to join provided the interested party pays the incremental cost i.e. TO #1 wants to build a 2000 MW Kv line and maintain rights to all 2000 MW, TO #2 wants to increase the lines capability by 400 MW and retain rights to all 400 MW. In this scenario, TO #2 would have to pay all costs associated with upgrading the line. The argument is that in an RTO world this scenario is irrelevant, however, I see this as a potential seams issue. ADR: Parties are lobbying to change language from mandatory binding arbitration with limited appeal to FERC TO mandatory binding arbitration only if both parties agree with the ability to bypass and go directly to FERC. (All entities with the exception of SWRTA currently enforce the former. SWRTA additionally has a provision that calls for a pre-arbitration peer review.) FYI: Class definitions are such that WAPA qualifies for membership in only one class and the regions do not fit the affiliate definition. Therefore, if each region wants to join and have one vote per region in said class, they must each pay $5000 and the larger entity must pay the net energy to load ratio of total load with the larger region collecting pro rata compensation from the other regions. Any comments you have are appreciated. Marcie